Mafia TBT Mafia IV: Red Revolution [Game Over/Mafia Win]

[Farobi]

Woah, everyone's suddenly jumping on Tom? I don't know if I find him suspicious. Tom had kind of pushed for Gandalf to be lynched (he had brought up some new evidence) + he didn't seem to support an ITYW lynch. o:

I do find him suspicious. Not dying the night after he led a lynch of a scum? That was an intentional lynch, bud.

I'm pretty sure I have the Mafia in the bag, I'll make a better post later.

but tl;drs

This lynch was lame. You guys didnt even give her a chance to defend herself.

To the real medic: protect yourself please. I dont know who you really are but I'm pretty sure the Mafia will aim at you.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Aim at you tonight*

 

[Blu Rose]

She was trying to defend herself, Farobi...

 

[Farobi]

:{
Rule #7: Never roleclaim to iLoveYou.

- - - Post Merge - - -

She was trying to defend herself, Farobi...

No what I meant was before the influx of votes for her.

- - - Post Merge - - -

She was offline when she was suspected and lynched.

 

[Dolby]

So right now Blueleaf is either mafia or medic, Tom is pretty much a confirmed mafia, and no one is sure about Farobi at this moment in time

 

[Blu Rose]

- - - Post Merge - - -



No what I meant was before the influx of votes for her.

- - - Post Merge - - -

She was offline when she was suspected and lynched.

Oh, that makes more sense.

 

[Byngo]

I do find him suspicious. Not dying the night after he led a lynch of a scum? That was an intentional lynch, bud.

True, I hadn't even thought of that.

But sacrificing possibly one of their better players doesn't quite seem like a wise thing to do~

 

[Trent the Paladin]

What does that have to do with anything? ITYW directly roleclaimed directly to you and then he got role blocked. Asuming that there are two roleblockers then there was a 20 percent chance of him being selected to be role blocked. Detectives, if Tom turns up mafia threw a rolecheck inform confirmed innocents who you have checked and tell them to post that Tom is a confirmed mafia on the main thread, if he turns up innocent, do not say anything to him or your confirmed innocents. He should be a suspect for tomorrow's lynch.

If Kuma told me about ITookYourWaffles, who is to say she didn't tell someone like Blue Leaf? At first I was going to ignore it because I suspected Waffles of being scum and Blue Leaf was supposedly protecting me Night 2. Night 2 I chose to protect iLoveYou only to be blocked, which I had notified him of. After leading the Gandalf lynch, I very well expected to die and be blocked, so I decided yolo and protect LaurinaMN. Yet imagine my surprise when A) I live and B) LaurinaMN was shot at. I'm sorry, what. A suspected scum shot at and I'm still very much so alive. So I decided to kinda lay low during the day phase and only responded to ITookYourWaffles publicly. So instead, I'd like to return fire on the ones who were so dead set on lynching ITookYourWaffles;

Blu Rose
Dolby
And my new personal suspicion, Blue Leaf.

 

[Blu Rose]

Okay, sincerely sorry for eliminating an Apothecary...

Statistics:
Three fourths of us are currently Mafia.
BlueLeaf, likely to be the other Doctor, is likely to die, as he, well, roleclaimed in the thread.
Gallows is likely to die, as he is a strong player.
Tom is likely a Mafia, as ITookYourWaffles, the Doctor, was roleblocked after roleclaiming to Tom.
Suspicions for me have probably shot through the roof.

My personal suspicions list (which no one should trust after Waffles):
LaurinaMN
Farobi
Tom

@BlueLeaf: You are jumping to conclusions. If you really are the Doctor, then you will likely die tonight anyways.

Yep, my list was correct.
If I were Mafia, would I really have stayed on that argument for so long? I would have dropped it, as I wouldn't want attention on myself, right?

 

[Trent the Paladin]

Yep, my list was correct.
If I were Mafia, would I really have stayed on that argument for so long? I would have dropped it, as I wouldn't want attention on myself, right?

And if I were Mafia, would I seriously try refuting and then pointing fingers? In fact, I'm really only certain about one name on the list I provided and plan to push it should we both survive the night.

 

[Farobi]

True, I hadn't even thought of that.

But sacrificing possibly one of their better players doesn't quite seem like a wise thing to do~

Yeah. But could it be possible that the rest of the Mafia players are even better than him? He was only a Mafia Goon anyway, not a Roleblocker. His death also did arouse suspicion on Waffles (Doc) and I, which could've been something scum intended to do.

 

[Trent the Paladin]

Yeah. But could it be possible that the rest of the Mafia players are even better than him? He was only a Mafia Goon anyway, not a Roleblocker. His death also did arouse suspicion on Waffles (Doc) and I, which could've been something scum intended to do.

If I was scum, why would I push hard for the death of one of my own? The goal for Mafia is to equal or outnumber town, it would make no sense for me to kill him off it just delays the ending even more. Gandalf was an excellent player in Game I and died rather quickly in Games II and III because of it. He survived Night 1, putting him on mine and Kayla's radar but it really showed his true colors when he got incredibly defensive when merely asked a few simple questions by Kayla.

 

[Dolby]

If Kuma told me about ITookYourWaffles, who is to say she didn't tell someone like Blue Leaf? At first I was going to ignore it because I suspected Waffles of being scum and Blue Leaf was supposedly protecting me Night 2. Night 2 I chose to protect iLoveYou only to be blocked, which I had notified him of. After leading the Gandalf lynch, I very well expected to die and be blocked, so I decided yolo and protect LaurinaMN. Yet imagine my surprise when A) I live and B) LaurinaMN was shot at. I'm sorry, what. A suspected scum shot at and I'm still very much so alive. So I decided to kinda lay low during the day phase and only responded to ITookYourWaffles publicly. So instead, I'd like to return fire on the ones who were so dead set on lynching ITookYourWaffles;

Blu Rose
Dolby
And my new personal suspicion, Blue Leaf.

First off, if you think I knew what role waffles was your wrong, second, one of you is lying about being the doctor, waffles implies that he directly told you that he was blue and got role blocked. I personally think that lynching Gandalf was intentional lynch due to the fact that there was probably one goon left and three power mafia roles left providing that Blueleaf is telling the truth about being the doctor. We have laurina as a confirmed mafia

The possibility that you are telling the truth, laurina is innocent, true, you did lead a mafia lynch. There would be the possibility of only one roleblocker. You successfully protected a person making you a great asset to the town.

I honestly thought that waffles was mafia and the most dangerous potential mafia, given that the three of them appeared to defend eachother and Gandalf was mafia, what would you have done in that situation?

 

[Trent the Paladin]

First off, if you think I knew what role waffles was your wrong, second, one of you is lying about being the doctor, waffles implies that he directly told you that he was blue and got role blocked. I personally think that lynching Gandalf was intentional lynch due to the fact that there was probably one goon left and three power mafia roles left providing that Blueleaf is telling the truth about being the doctor. We have laurina as a confirmed mafia

The possibility that you are telling the truth, laurina is innocent, true, you did lead a mafia lynch. There would be the possibility of only one roleblocker. You successfully protected a person making you a great asset to the town.

I honestly thought that waffles was mafia and the most dangerous potential mafia, given that the three of them appeared to defend eachother and Gandalf was mafia, what would you have done in that situation?

Oh? Are you implying there is actually another detective in play who checked Laurina but hid their results? Because I would have greatly loved to have followed up a scum lynch with another scum lynch. Surely they could have PMed someone like Gallows their results and it could have been brought forward.

I would have held off some more. If it wasn't for the fact I was being bugged by A) living players and B) dead players to change my vote to Waffles, I would have kept it for Farobi. Yes, Waffles was incredibly 50/50 and having worked some with Blue Leaf I chose to side with you guys, which only backfired on us.

There's always the incredibly unlikely, terribly awful chance that there is three doctors. After all, look how long I kept you guys guessing whether or not there was a second Bus Driver Game III. I bet Karla is actually laughing at us right now, a town divided by two doctors.

 

[Dolby]

Oh? Are you implying there is actually another detective in play who checked Laurina but hid their results? Because I would have greatly loved to have followed up a scum lynch with another scum lynch. Surely they could have PMed someone like Gallows their results and it could have been brought forward.

There's always the incredibly unlikely, terribly awful chance that there is three doctors. After all, look how long I kept you guys guessing whether or not there was a second Bus Driver Game III. I bet Karla is actually laughing at us right now, a town divided by two doctors.

As for the first paragraph, what I implied was that I would have withheld some kp to vault two mafia to higher positions within the town, it's what I would've done if I were mafia. As for three doctors, I am laughing at all the players including myself if it is true. I was laughing at everybody in game three because I made everyone so confused.

- - - Post Merge - - -

And the only good town role that you could fake-claim if you were town without them killing you is veteren

 

[Prof Gallows]

As for the first paragraph, what I implied was that I would have withheld some kp to vault two mafia to higher positions within the town, it's what I would've done if I were mafia. As for three doctors, I am laughing at all the players including myself if it is true. I was laughing at everybody in game three because I made everyone so confused.

- - - Post Merge - - -

And the only good town role that you could fake-claim if you were town without them killing you is veteren

I'm not sure many of us are laughing. If you're just confusing everyone and you are town, you're just helping the mafia.
It's extremely doubtful there is another detective, or else they would have come forward to someone already.

 

[unravel]

Whoops that post didn't know it was aggressive (I was complaining to be honest)
Yeah tbh I'm more aggressive in online than real life agaaain ...wasn't expecting this, wasn't reply to blu til she is 100% sure im a scum keeps quoting me and getting to cocky (peace yo1)

Hope you guys are happy, bye huehue

 

[Elijo]

I'm not sure many of us are laughing. If you're just confusing everyone and you are town, you're just helping the mafia.
It's extremely doubtful there is another detective, or else they would have come forward to someone already.

Yeah. That person has come forward to me.

 

[KarlaKGB]

Day 5​

There was love in the air, even with the revolution going on. Two young fledgling members of the party had planned a secret rendezvous during the night. When they met up, he could see the passion in her eyes. Pushing open the door to his quarters, he wasn't expecting a booby trap to explode, ripping both of them apart. The first rescuers on the scene saw a poignant sight, Kuma and Hikari's dismembered hands, intertwined even in death.

---

Kuma the Revolutionary was killed.

Hikari the Revolutionary was killed.

---

It's time to vote!

 

[Trent the Paladin]

It was nice playing with you all best of luck town, mafia scum you -

---

Kuma the Revolutionary was killed.

Hikari the Revolutionary was killed.

---

- - - Post Merge - - -

I was roleblocked last night, I guess they didn't want me protecting people. ._.

 

[Elijo]

Two words: Lynch Laurina.

Welp, looks like there is a Kuma X Hikari ship going on. Is Hikari a boy?! So confused.

Good luck town! I'll miss you all.

X X O O

Kuma