Mafia TBT Mafia IX: The Apocalypse [Game Over/Town Win]

[EpicGamer12]

Good game! Best of luck to my comrades!

 

[Keen]

Wow x.x

Sucks that Sway is gone, and it sucks that some leaked her blue role to everyone. I hope somebody was watching sway last night, to see if anybody used actions on her.

 

[Cariad]

We really need to pick at everything to get a good hit today. This is becoming more and more evident.

 

[Trent the Paladin]

RIP Sway, Trundle, and Prin.

I'd really like the following people to post something resembling a case against someone:

Lunatic
Justin
MrKisstoefur
Gandalf
ITookYourWaffles
MissNoodle
DarkNightMoon
Feloreena
BlueLeaf
Yui Z
Sataric
MisterNeedleMouse
Kaiaa
BellBringerGreen
Jeremy

You're all pretty quiet, it's not helpful town as you all look incredibly suspicious. Plus Gandalf has lived two nights, he's clearly mafia or horseman! (/s [not really{are you scum}])

Either way I'll try to build up some cases, but I can't guarantee anything as concrete as ProfGallows. Plus I'm trying to piece together what happened during the night, something didn't happen apparently. :/

 

[MrPicklez]

Kaiaa​

These are all quotes from Kaiaa in this game so far. Now, what does this mean? Well, if we look back at her previous games, her play style seems to be much more reserved and safe - she has been posting enough to not be looked at as inactive, but most of her posts are useless filler information and what looks like bad mafia acting. The sentences I've highlighted are prime examples of the kind of speech she is using this game that is different from previous games.

Spoiler: Previous Game Posts

These are from game VII, where she was a townie.


http://www.belltreeforums.com/showt...imal-Crossing-Game-Over&p=2621358#post2621358

In the quotes from the above game, Kaiaa had way more posts. Short posts mostly, and was very involved in helping the town in whatever way she could. Her behavior this game has none of the helpful tendencies and doesn't look like she is helping.
I really can't guarantee she is scum or a horseman, but you are all too lazy and it's the best I can do.

Wait what do you need? PM me with more details as to why you need the identity.

- - - Post Merge - - -




Farobi also had suspicions on Kaiaa, and he ended up dead. A player who was in contact with him informed me of this.

Now that Oath is dead I can tell you that I'm a Baker but unfortunately, I can't really prove I'm town aligned unless inspected twice in a row (in case I'm framed the night of the first inspection), all you have to go off of is my word. Another thing is in that game I could actually do something to help the town and that was to buy things for the town. The mafia only kept me alive because I was announcing what items did publicly to everyone. In this game, Oath is dead and now I'm not able to help besides pick apart what people have said. I'm not very good at picking peoples words apart which is one reason I'm not very good at contributing to either mafia game I played.

I'd like to bring this case up again.

 

[Trent the Paladin]

Anything else you'd like to add to that Kisstoefur or just bringing the case back up again?

 

[MrPicklez]

Anything else you'd like to add to that Kisstoefur or just bringing the case back up again?

I'd like to bring the case back up lol

 

[Alice]

Well, I knew this was coming, since that blue leak, but good show. Good luck town, wish I could have lasted a tiny bit longer.

 

[Sataric]

Me and Trundle communicated quite a bit through PM's yesterday. He seemed to have plenty of people's roles figured out and wanted to compare his notes to mine, but I was not entirely sure I could trust him. We decided to wait until morning would come, and that if we'd both survive the night, we would combine our finds and info, and look for any anomalies in them. Sadly, Trundle perished before we could get to that stage.

I did tell him that he should send all of his information to a confirmed Townie or two before the night was over, just in case something would happen to him. I truly hope he followed that advice, and that his findings are not lost to us. In any case, we did confirm a couple of things together, and I feel like we have at least narrowed the scope down on who could be guilty and who could not.

Trundle's final wishes seemed to be to properly investigate Gandalf. He strongly suspected him to be Mafia due to, and I quote: "his major behavior change and non-death this game, which differs from last." - And I believe that Sway was sent to investigate him last night, though sadly she did not survive for long enough to check him out.

Many of the people on Tom's list I believe are innocent townies - Several of which are more or less confirmed. The fact that Tom does not know this is very alarming to me. Either he has not been talking to the right people behind the scenes, or something's a little off.. But, in any case, we do agree on certain names, and I would name the following people as my primary suspects:

Gandalf. ITookYourWaffles. DarkKnightMoon. BellBringerGreen. Jeremy.

- - - Post Merge - - -

By the way, the current team count should be something along the lines of:
2 Horsemen. 5-6 Servants of Hell. 11-12 Town.

 

[MrPicklez]

Me and Trundle communicated quite a bit through PM's yesterday. He seemed to have plenty of people's roles figured out and wanted to compare his notes to mine, but I was not entirely sure I could trust him. We decided to wait until morning would come, and that if we'd both survive the night, we would combine our finds and info, and look for any anomalies in them. Sadly, Trundle perished before we could get to that stage.

I did tell him that he should send all of his information to a confirmed Townie or two before the night was over, just in case something would happen to him. I truly hope he followed that advice, and that his findings are not lost to us. In any case, we did confirm a couple of things together, and I feel like we have at least narrowed the scope down on who could be guilty and who could not.

Trundle's final wishes seemed to be to properly investigate Gandalf. He strongly suspected him to be Mafia due to, and I quote: "his major behavior change and non-death this game, which differs from last." - And I believe that Sway was sent to investigate him last night, though sadly she did not survive for long enough to check him out.

Many of the people on Tom's list I believe are innocent townies - Several of which are more or less confirmed. The fact that Tom does not know this is very alarming to me. Either he has not been talking to the right people behind the scenes, or something's a little off.. But, in any case, we do agree on certain names, and I would name the following people as my primary suspects:

Gandalf. ITookYourWaffles. DarkKnightMoon. BellBringerGreen. Jeremy.

- - - Post Merge - - -

By the way, the current team count should be something along the lines of:
2 Horsemen. 5-6 Servants of Hell. 11-12 Town.

Waffles was in contact with Farbobi before he died. And if I remember, Purpl brought her up at some point as well.

 

[Byngo]

I'd really like the following people to post something resembling a case against someone:

Lunatic

You want me to pull a case out of my ass? Because that's what I'd have to do. I don't have anything on anyone and I haven't been posting much because I really don't have much to say. Like at all. I have, however, been communicating a lot via PM this game. c:

But I will point out a few names I feel are a but suspicious... Jeremy and Justin. Both of them are usually vocal players and I haven't seen much from either of them. Post some? c:

 

[Sataric]

Waffles was in contact with Farbobi before he died. And if I remember, Purpl brought her up at some point as well.

Yes, Waffles and Farobi seemed very close and from what I've gathered they even know each other in real life. And despite barely speaking a single word, Farobi died on the first night, even though most of the other deaths all fell on known experienced players who had been significantly more active in the thread. To this date, I am not sure if he was killed by scum or by a trigger-happy vigilante, but I feel like he might have been removed from the game because Waffles is evil and didn't want him to figure it out and tell the rest of us. It's just a suspicion, though.

PS: If YOU (the reader!) are a Vigilante and you killed Farobi, consider telling me in a PM. I know all the Vigs already. Trundle and I discussed those in detail, so you wouldn't be leaking anything. But this piece of information would be important to completing the puzzle.

 

[BellGreen]

RIP all three Town

I'll try and come up with something later, although it won't be much because I'm pretty empty on thoughts after Gallows' death as Horseman. I have come up with some stuff though; I'll post it when I'm done.

 

[Trent the Paladin]

Many of the people on Tom's list I believe are innocent townies - Several of which are more or less confirmed. The fact that Tom does not know this is very alarming to me. Either he has not been talking to the right people behind the scenes, or something's a little off.. But, in any case, we do agree on certain names, and I would name the following people as my primary suspects:

Gandalf. ITookYourWaffles. DarkKnightMoon. BellBringerGreen. Jeremy.

That list wasn't for lynching, no that list was merely a list of names of people who haven't been talking all that much this game. I realize a few of them are town/confirmed, I just want to hear more of their thoughts on some matters.

You want me to pull a case out of my ass? Because that's what I'd have to do. I don't have anything on anyone and I haven't been posting much because I really don't have much to say. Like at all. I have, however, been communicating a lot via PM this game. c:

But I will point out a few names I feel are a but suspicious... Jeremy and Justin. Both of them are usually vocal players and I haven't seen much from either of them. Post some? c:

If it gets the job done. Surely everyone has some suspicion on someone.

 

[BlueLeaf]

I may make somewhat of a case against her, but Pally has been on my mind when I saw the deaths. Prin suspected Pally from the beginning. It may be a frame, but why not just frame Pally on Night 2? It could possibly be an attempt to get Prin off of Pally, while she was quiet and didn't go insane in accusing her. What I find the strangest is that Pally said analyzation won't get us too far. Either this is just a stupid Town post or Scum/Horsemen trying to stop us from analyzing.

- - - Post Merge - - -

*Something has happened through PM's. For now, we should be able to trust Pally, due to some information I have gotten.

 

[BlueLeaf]

I also want to say this: DT('s), please reach out to someone you feel is trustworthy. I assume all of you checked the names brought up in the thread. Contact someone with your inspection, whether Town or Mafia.

 

[Kaiaa]

Has anyone else noticed how we have so many nurses dying yet Pestilence isn't killing anyone? Pestilence is clearly someone who is inactive, someone who hasn't done much posting since the game started. By inactivity, I mean someone who has hardly made any posts, possibly someone like Jeremy who has failed to vote in the last lynch.

 

[Sataric]

Has anyone else noticed how we have so many nurses dying yet Pestilence isn't killing anyone? Pestilence is clearly someone who is inactive, someone who hasn't done much posting since the game started. By inactivity, I mean someone who has hardly made any posts, possibly someone like Jeremy who has failed to vote in the last lynch.

Pestilence can only kill on Even Numbered DAYS - Meaning Day 2, 4, 6, etc - And he did in fact kill PurplPanda on Day 2 which was his only opportunity so far. One kill out of one possible chance is actually a 100% kill ratio, so he is not inactive at all.

 

[Trent the Paladin]

Also to be honest, I'm surprised I haven't been shot/killed yet. :/ Usually by now someone's tried to off me, so unless the Mafia team only plans on keeping me around long enough to rid themselves of the horsemen, I wonder if somebody knows something I don't.

 

[Kaiaa]

Pestilence can only kill on Even Numbered DAYS - Meaning Day 2, 4, 6, etc - And he did in fact kill PurplPanda on Day 2 which was his only opportunity so far. One kill out of one possible chance is actually a 100% kill ratio, so he is not inactive at all.

Oh I didn't realize that was a pestilence kill, I though she let death kill him but now I see that it's not the way it works. Even still though, why didn't Jer vote? He was the only one who failed to vote and who still fails to post more than a couple posts. I'm not one to lead lynches and I certainly don't want to lynch Jer unless there is more substantial evidence but his inactivity on an ODD day leads me to believe that he might only be interested in posting on even days.