I don’t get it though. If you’re town why would he weakly push you. I always thought weak pushes were indicative of scum pushing scum, but not actually wanting to go through with the lynch.
Mafia TBT Mafia: Renaissance - Game Thread [ENDGAME - Town Wins]
- Thread starter N e s s
- Start date
- Status
glow
not ur aesthetic
he hasn't given me a proper reply after i responded to his.
i made some clarifications and asked further questions, but he stated in his first reply he was not willing to 'wallpost with me" which i interpret as an excuse for a lack of engagement with me.
instead he resorted to intimidation-tactic mode. which hey, if ad hominem is how you want to play, when i really was only presenting my issues with the observations surrounding him/tae, feel free. but it isn't doing anything for me. sorry for scumreading you i guess?
i made some clarifications and asked further questions, but he stated in his first reply he was not willing to 'wallpost with me" which i interpret as an excuse for a lack of engagement with me.
instead he resorted to intimidation-tactic mode. which hey, if ad hominem is how you want to play, when i really was only presenting my issues with the observations surrounding him/tae, feel free. but it isn't doing anything for me. sorry for scumreading you i guess?
PunchyTheCat
Senior Member
voting f11
will b back in an hour i’m eating
will b back in an hour i’m eating
glow
not ur aesthetic
i tried to ignore my reads, and consider whether his reaction towards me was warranted. but it's not like i opened up a briefcase and laid out my scum!geoni files. my post was mainly in refute of a tae/geoni team, and i never explicitly CALLED him mafia just stated issues with him/his reads/his conclusions.
i voted him to see what he'd do.
but all i got from what he said was that he's resentful from that time i SR'd him and we were both town. as if that matters here? or i guess he was just making the point that i'm a bad player / bad at reading him
like aight lol are you trying to say you've never misread anyone....
i voted him to see what he'd do.
but all i got from what he said was that he's resentful from that time i SR'd him and we were both town. as if that matters here? or i guess he was just making the point that i'm a bad player / bad at reading him
like aight lol are you trying to say you've never misread anyone....
PunchyTheCat
Senior Member
why is locker voting me
PandaDarling
Purple People Eater
eh I dunno ..... I think my vote will be for either Harbour or Geoni today.... if its for Harbour and we get mafia great if Harbour is town then ok, no offense, but I don't think we lose much ( other than numbers) and if Geoni is mafia that will be a huge win for us, he is a very strong player and scary as mafia but the same stands if he is town, that could be a big loss for us.... so I dunno maybe Harbour is our safer Lynch for the day ? ( sorry I'm kinda just thinking/typing my way through this) but also theres the point that we learn more from a Geoni Lynch over a Harbour Lynch..... hmmm.... I'm a cautious person by nature so I guess (unless something changes my mind) it will probably be for Harbour.
EpicGamer12
Senior Member
I'm going to vote before this thread gets crazy. Clearly not enough people are pushing for tae so I am going to go ahead and vote Geoni.
hewwo i wanted to make a readslist so i can sort out who to vote for
this list was made with several assumptions
1. Those who were against NL and didnt engage with the idea are more likely to be mafia
2. Shawo is not doing an 100000 iq galax brain play from day 1
3. stuff i know (uwu)
4. stuff i think i know from my observations
f11 - town
Trundle - town
Sheabae - town
Antonio - town
Mogyay - town based on my rule 1 also i feel like mafia mog is a bit more assertive??
PandaDarling - town based on rule one
glow - i wanna say town but I litrally don't know
tae - mafia/town but i can confirm by day 3
Shawo - mafia/town but i can confirm by day 3
I Don't know/haven't been paying enough attention to
DinoTown
7. Locket
8. Oath2Order - lurkey
10. amazonevan19
19. Heyden - that role pm stuff from the beginning again inclines me to think that heyden is probably town
20. Harbour
11. Geoni - Dad said this
PunchyDaHufflepuff - although this seems like an OMGUS its not an omgus. I cant find the quote but I remember Punchy being very against no lynch for some reason? Like He was like "we HAVE to lynch for muh information" and didnt even consider NL as an option. also both today and from day1 they have been distancing themselves from the main wagons in a way that seems like they are trying to avoid implicating themself in a town mislynch. like geoni, dan also townread punchy lol.
this post was dumb but i wanted to explain what Im thinking what rn and why im voting for dad
this list was made with several assumptions
1. Those who were against NL and didnt engage with the idea are more likely to be mafia
2. Shawo is not doing an 100000 iq galax brain play from day 1
3. stuff i know (uwu)
4. stuff i think i know from my observations
f11 - town
Trundle - town
Sheabae - town
Antonio - town
Mogyay - town based on my rule 1 also i feel like mafia mog is a bit more assertive??
PandaDarling - town based on rule one
glow - i wanna say town but I litrally don't know
tae - mafia/town but i can confirm by day 3
Shawo - mafia/town but i can confirm by day 3
I Don't know/haven't been paying enough attention to
DinoTown
7. Locket
8. Oath2Order - lurkey
10. amazonevan19
19. Heyden - that role pm stuff from the beginning again inclines me to think that heyden is probably town
20. Harbour
11. Geoni - Dad said this
and
I could easily see mafia!dad not wanting the no lynch because ofc he knows the top wagons are town. Other people sus dad for other stuff like dumb posts and I agree to a degree but with the qualities of my posts I feel like I can't complain. I think its important to mention that dan actually townread geoni so like thinking from an outsider perspective it wouldn't put any sus on geoni if daniel died (which he did) these are weak reasons yes but something about that last adhom/ate post from dad "im not gonna do mafia here anyore" just makes me feel like dad is scum?? But then again I'm also being a total sheep rn.
PunchyDaHufflepuff - although this seems like an OMGUS its not an omgus. I cant find the quote but I remember Punchy being very against no lynch for some reason? Like He was like "we HAVE to lynch for muh information" and didnt even consider NL as an option. also both today and from day1 they have been distancing themselves from the main wagons in a way that seems like they are trying to avoid implicating themself in a town mislynch. like geoni, dan also townread punchy lol.
this post was dumb but i wanted to explain what Im thinking what rn and why im voting for dad
So I read a lot of the posts and I'll try to get to a lot of things since there's a bit too much for me to respond in a semi-organized matter. But what's important first is that we DON'T split votes too hard. A few people said something about how I voted 10 minutes into D1, and I think that point is pretty invalid because this was the kind of situation I was trying to prevent. Of note, why are people in my case for voting into d1, I think it was probably just Tae but I thought a few more people said it. What are you supposed to do if not read through the night and try to vote for a potential SR?
I guess in particular I'm looking at Punchy/Locket/Evan, who I think are voting people who won't get lynched.
Right now vote patterns look like it's potentially going to end up Harbour/Geoni... but that seems. Weird to me. I'd give it a few more hours before we figure out what the top lynches look like. I'm most likely going to hold my vote until the end of the day, and I'll use it when it matters.
In my opinion though, it seems like Geoni's the one with the weird fixation on harbour, rather than saying I have a weird fixation with Tae.
I guess in particular I'm looking at Punchy/Locket/Evan, who I think are voting people who won't get lynched.
Right now vote patterns look like it's potentially going to end up Harbour/Geoni... but that seems. Weird to me. I'd give it a few more hours before we figure out what the top lynches look like. I'm most likely going to hold my vote until the end of the day, and I'll use it when it matters.
In my opinion though, it seems like Geoni's the one with the weird fixation on harbour, rather than saying I have a weird fixation with Tae.
I mean you're free to vote Locket. I think I need to read Harbours post more but I don't even think they're HERE. But I'm not sure how to check if someone is active on the forum or not.
I actually might be a little tunnel-vision-ey. If Tae's not going to get lynched I think I should take a step back and start analyzing the potential Geoni BW/Counter BW.
Post automatically merged:
I actually might be a little tunnel-vision-ey. If Tae's not going to get lynched I think I should take a step back and start analyzing the potential Geoni BW/Counter BW.
Last edited:
PunchyTheCat
Senior Member
wait so f11 susses me bc i didn’t want no lynch or either of the wagons yesterday?
10/10 sus
10/10 sus
OK but weird thing that has me fixated on Harbour is when she said:
“This thread is so interesting“
As if this game has multiple outlets, for which it shouldn’t unless you’re mafia —thread and quicktopic—. Would you not say this —game— is interesting? I feel like she unconsciously isolated the thread as a separate section idfk.
Maybe I’m nitpicking.
“This thread is so interesting“
As if this game has multiple outlets, for which it shouldn’t unless you’re mafia —thread and quicktopic—. Would you not say this —game— is interesting? I feel like she unconsciously isolated the thread as a separate section idfk.
Maybe I’m nitpicking.
PunchyTheCat
Senior Member
maybe i want information
maybe you want cred in the future for not advocating for the day 1 town lynch canidates
Post automatically merged:
was this @ me?
yeah i voted panda but i have to lay off because antonio
Antonio hasn't been very actively recently either. I wonder what a lot of the people who had a really strong opinion abt Trundle are doing rn.
Also, I'm fairly certain that if Geoni flips mafia Harbour is town confirm. I mean I think that was obvious but no one's said it yet.
Also, I'm fairly certain that if Geoni flips mafia Harbour is town confirm. I mean I think that was obvious but no one's said it yet.
- Status
