Mafia TBT Mafia ~ The Binding of Isaac ~ Town Wins!

[Damniel]

Lucanosa, I would appericate it if you would take off your "Placeholder" vote on me. With all these scattered voting, I'm set to to be lynched I believe.

 

[N e s s]

##Trojan

Soda, explain this.

 

[oath2order]

Lucanosa, I would appericate it if you would take off your "Placeholder" vote on me. With all these scattered voting, I'm set to to be lynched I believe.

You're the first to reach 2, you're still getting lynched at this point.

 

[glow]

Yay, somewhat relevant things

I want you all to remember that in a two faction mafia game it is easy for a mafia member to come off as pro-town as they are actively hunting scum, just like a SK.

Ness and Panda have been arguing over nothing this whole day phase, just different forms of nothing as time passes

PPL who I don't feel are town
Lucanosa(Placeholder vote 3 hours in, sus on Ness bc they consider Ness's comment on the rune joke a defense)
Ayaya(Seems to be avoiding the thread at the moment. They may be busy with irl things, but I don't like the drop in post count and quality)

PPL who I feel are good right now
Panda(I actually feel like Panda is town, unlike quite a few of you, even though I haven't been seen her as scum. Most noob scum try to lay back and be non-confrontational, but panda isn't doing that. Not that certain aspects of her posts and nitpickyness aren't scummy to some people, but it's normal behavior for her)
Oath2order
Sarasakat

*Ninja Vanish and Sleeps*

Nah, I'll be on for another 15 minutes

Your logic for Panda being town is because she is confrontational and scumhunting like she usually is, but your first sentence acknowledges that scumhunting isn't enough to town read someone this game. And correct me if I'm wrong the only person she's suggested for lynch is Daniel. So it's kind of contradicting

her reactions gave me a null reading, saying that my argument is that she's "trying too hard" when I never said that (Daniel did). I said that she's posting too much without saying that much.

That said I'm still not sure about how to feel about Panda, I'm hoping the more substance she posts (quality>quantity) the clearer she'll be so I hope she spends more time bringing up possible lynch candidates rather than defending herself. I've made that mistake myself a couple times lol. She's mentioned Daniel as possible scum, and Ness had a point of him being a bit wishy-washy with his opinions. So I'm hoping to hear more from her about Daniel/who else we should lynch before day ends.

@ Ayaya

your post consists of only town or null reads... who do you think is a good lynch candidate?

 

[Minties]

You're the first to reach 2, you're still getting lynched at this point.

Wot? When did he reach two? Beardo reached two first.

Tbh this game is already a massive headache with a ****load of bickering. Anyone that's new or busy is going to have a hard time sifting through it. I'm already feeling a bit over it.

Ness it'd be nice if you didn't get offended at every single sentence that someone says. I'm honestly sick to death of reading "you don't have to be rudeeee" when they're not even being rude. (You wanna see rude, go look at my posts to Sarasa in Papers please) This is a mafia game, there's emotions and things you won't want to hear if you post stupid things/bad logic. That's not devious play, that's actually playing to win. I play like that and probably have the one of the highest win rates on TBT.

Personally I would be completely satisfied with a Lucanosa lynch today. There's no logic behind voting for Daniel and it reminds me suspiciously of when Rune "didn't read and just placeholder voted" on someone in Papers Please while he was scum. I've already touted how ferociously anti-town this behaviour is because it leads scum to jump on easy bandwagons. I'm putting my vote on Lucanosa.

 

[oath2order]

Wot? When did he reach two? Beardo reached two first.

Tbh this game is already a massive headache with a ****load of bickering. Anyone that's new or busy is going to have a hard time sifting through it. I'm already feeling a bit over it.

Ness it'd be nice if you didn't get offended at every single sentence that someone says. I'm honestly sick to death of reading "you don't have to be rudeeee" when they're not even being rude. (You wanna see rude, go look at my posts to Sarasa in Papers please) This is a mafia game, there's emotions and things you won't want to hear if you post stupid things/bad logic. That's not devious play, that's actually playing to win. I play like that and probably have the one of the highest win rates on TBT.

Personally I would be completely satisfied with a Lucanosa lynch today. There's no logic behind voting for Daniel and it reminds me suspiciously of when Rune "didn't read and just placeholder voted" on someone in Papers Please while he was scum. I've already touted how ferociously anti-town this behaviour is because it leads scum to jump on easy bandwagons. I'm putting my vote on Lucanosa.

whatever he's still lynched first.

I love your point on ness

I play like that and probably have the one of the highest win rates on TBT.

i am going to throw you off a cliff oh my god

 

[Ayaya]

@ Ayaya

your post consists of only town or null reads... who do you think is a good lynch candidate?

If you noticed, Jacob is the only on that list that I didn't null or town read, and I'm waiting for his response.

 

[Damniel]

I'm thinking Lucanosa joked vote me for that "Lynch Dannyboi D2" tag. No one else calls me that but him and he's the one who mentioned that unfunny meme in the past. He realized that if he just said he joked voted me, people would be suspicious and claimed it was as a "placeholder". He was modkilled as scum for not voting, but he could just actually play well and vote on a suspicious person instead of a "random person". Which to pick me out of all people seems off.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Right now,Lucanosa is set to be lynched. As SrirchaKat unvoted beardo.

 

[Minties]

whatever he's still lynched first.

I love your point on ness




i am going to throw you off a cliff oh my god

I'll take you down with me.

Is he? There's still a vote on Beardo first. I don't know have to wait for Sataric to do a tally.

 

[N e s s]

I'm leaning towards Daniel being scum. More on that in a bit, my glucose levels are low and i'd like to not pass out <3

 

[illunie]

Ok these posts are uncalled for. Cut it out on the personal attacks man.

Sorry if that came out wrong (full stops make it sound serious for some reason) but the first one was a joke and the second was was kinda a joke but also a legit point.

Panda is basically doing the exact same thing she was doing in Arstozka mafia, and as a scum in that game we managed to make town turn against her. I would like to remind town that she was a town in that game. There is basically no change in her playstyle from when she was town. I would not be suprised at all if this is a bw attempt from mafia because of how easy a lynch Panda is.

Sorry if I offended anyone.

 

[N e s s]

Sorry if that came out wrong (full stops make it sound serious for some reason) but the first one was a joke and the second was was kinda a joke but also a legit point.

Panda is basically doing the exact same thing she was doing in Arstozka mafia, and as a scum in that game we managed to make town turn against her. I would like to remind town that she was a town in that game. There is basically no change in her playstyle from when she was town. I would not be suprised at all if this is a bw attempt from mafia because of how easy a lynch Panda is.

Sorry if I offended anyone.

Its a bit scary how much your thoughts reflect mine.

 

[illunie]

PPL who I feel are good right now
Panda(I actually feel like Panda is town, unlike quite a few of you, even though I haven't been seen her as scum. Most noob scum try to lay back and be non-confrontational, but panda isn't doing that. Not that certain aspects of her posts and nitpickyness aren't scummy to some people, but it's normal behavior for her)

Thank you!

- - - Post Merge - - -

IMO Panda is reacting as any town would do if they were accused of scum - example not getting overly defensive. So, my suspicions with her are void. although that could just be her plan all along... >> kidding

Kind of clueless on who to vote for atm, but with time running out I'll have a definite vote soon.

Panda's getting reeeeally defensive, not sure what this is.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Day ends in 14 hours, so that's 5 in the morning for me. Probably should vote before I go to bed, so if anyone wants to scum slip that'd be fantastic.

 

[Chrystina]

Panda's getting reeeeally defensive, not sure what this is.

Hey sorry been sleeping most the day.... hmmm..... im being seen was scum cause im being too town ? thats just lovely.

Meow has her reasons for being suspicious of me and thats fine, its nothing unreasonable she thinks im trying too hard to really be pro town, i assure you, you're wrong but thats fine.

yes Daniel i read it and i don't know what to say really that i haven't said in a pervious post about this situation... i don't feel like i have to 'defend' myself, im being scum read for being TOO TOWN... im trying to do my best and get reads and post and talk about the game im sorry if that makes any other town members suspicious of me. as far as what i said about you and meow i just said that i thought it was weird that you seemed like you just wanted to take a back seat and wait for me to respond and then you just went ahead and voted. no big deal its just weird your words and actions say two different things. thats the 'real' reason... ya i shot you i was suspicious of you last game. i don't see what that has to do with this game ?

really all I need to quote is "I dont feel like I have to 'defend' myself". Lol, how is that being "reeeeeeally defensive"?

 

[mother of all llamas]

Omigosh, I didn't realise the game had started already... I'll start reading today's posts, sorry for the inactivity from me. X.X;;

 

[PandaDarling]

Sorry if that came out wrong (full stops make it sound serious for some reason) but the first one was a joke and the second was was kinda a joke but also a legit point.

Panda is basically doing the exact same thing she was doing in Arstozka mafia, and as a scum in that game we managed to make town turn against her. I would like to remind town that she was a town in that game. There is basically no change in her playstyle from when she was town. I would not be suprised at all if this is a bw attempt from mafia because of how easy a lynch Panda is.

Sorry if I offended anyone.

@Rune that's what I was think, there's definitely scum in there somewhere but I don't think it's Meow as she was the first to come up with it and she made a huge post about it, I think that's too brave of a move for Mafia to do so that's why I was leaning more towards Daniel being scum.

 

[N e s s]

I'm way too sleepy and way too dead to make some kind of case, because I just stayed up until 12:00 PM trying to get this damn homework done.

I think its Daniel.

 

[Jacob]

1. This post seem to indicate he's not reading the thread at all, claimed to read 12 pages back yet didn't see that the convo stopped after doughssant and I pointed out that KP discussion isn't helping much beside getting a discussion going.

2. And why do you think PL and no lynch is favorable when we're not even close to deadline and people have started discussing their suspicions at that time? You haven't even posted your reads or try to question people to justify that conclusion.

1. there were like 120+ replies i needed to catch up on, i was reading fast and i mustve skipped over that
2. it was more of a reaction test, I've suggested no lynch or PL in previous games D1 so my plan was to compare people's thoughts on it.

As for now, I'm a little happy the bickering calmed a little bit, but my top lynch candidate is N e s s because if he continues to be this way i'm not gonna wanna keep playing w him. I get that mafia is intense but fam gettin angry over nothing

i get thats not a good reason so I am like rereading everyone's reads on eachother and posts to try to come up w a better lynch candidate

 

[oath2order]

I'm way too sleepy and way too dead to make some kind of case, because I just stayed up until 12:00 PM trying to get this damn homework done.

I think its Daniel.

Seriously why is it you somehow always have an excuse to get away with not making a case

 

[N e s s]

Seriously why is it you somehow always have an excuse to get away with not making a case

I can take a snapshot of my work for you if you're that disbelieving.

I've already showed some reasons as to why I think its Daniel, i'm too tired to do anything so good night.