Mafia TBT Mafia V: There and Back Again [Game Over/Town Win]

I don't understand when a behavioral change is evident in someone like Beary, you all have no problem going after her, but when it's in someone like Kayla, God forbid anyone jumps on board.

I agree. There is definitely some influence based on people's opinions of people that may sway people from what they said. If this whole game was anonymous, I doubt either things that we said would really get that much attention.
 
I don't understand when a behavioral change is evident in someone like Beary, you all have no problem going after her, but when it's in someone like Kayla, God forbid anyone jumps on board.

I second this. She usually contributes often, but she is quiet.
Why?
 
I second this. She usually contributes often, but she is quiet.
Why?

Well, she's at work right now so obviously she can't.
I was basically talking about the behavior changes I noted in my original post describing suspicions on her.
 
Well, she's at work right now so obviously she can't.
I was basically talking about the behavior changes I noted in my original post describing suspicions on her.

Ah, I see. I will have to reread that.
Thank you for clarifying.
 
Well, she's at work right now so obviously she can't.
I was basically talking about the behavior changes I noted in my original post describing suspicions on her.

She's always been deceptive, and she herself said so.
I think we had better wait until she is home and more active before we can start pointing fingers, as we have little evidence on her yet.
 
She's always been deceptive, and she herself said so.
I think we had better wait until she is home and more active before we can start pointing fingers, as we have little evidence on her yet.

She is viewing the thread at the moment.
 
She's always been deceptive, and she herself said so.
I think we had better wait until she is home and more active before we can start pointing fingers, as we have little evidence on her yet.

Then why are you so sold on Beary?
It's night and you said you're already sold on her for the next lynch. Take it easy there, tiger.
 
Okay...
Okay.
I think the most I can do is to say, that I am not lying.
I am very suspicious of Trundle. He may also be doing his job. I am just putting this out there in case I die.
I understand that I am not a very skilled player, but I have my mind on other things most of the time. And when has somebody been mafia twice in a row?
I am a very repetitive person. If that bothers you, I am sorry, but I highly advise not lynching me. I am no asset to the town, as I do not post much useful content, but using up a perfectly good lynch on me tomorrow is a horrid idea.

I'm trying my best to come up with a defense, but my life is hard at the moment. I don't have the time to.
I hope you consider what I have said.

Also, iLoveYou has not explained her vote for Blu Rose yet....

This is a perfectly good reason to lynch you and get you out of the way. It sucks that our lynch choices come down to getting rid of those who can't play well or mafia because we pretty much choose the former (look at dolby). Stop doubting yourself and saying you're not useful. Why did you even bother signing up then? Play the game - be logical, strategic, and have confidence in yourself/choices. Make sure each decision you make is because you decide. If you're going to bandwagon at least make sense of whatever argument is thrown around.

Lowkey: Mafia is probably laughing just watching us attack each other. Pull it together people!
 
You're probably on the list for the bad acting with Blu Rose.
If this is true, why am I on the list?

This all needs to stop, this is the exact reason Dolby died. You're all talking **** and you need to stop. Petty little conversations between yourselves are for PM's. You make yourselves look guilty in my eyes.

Um... Correct me if I'm wrong, but that was forever ago? The conversation, I mean. Before the game even started, non?

Now, I want to bring this up.
What were those votes for Blu Rose about?

Y'know, I really think that I would be really surprised if I weren't on anyone's (mild) suspicions list.

Because, in my eyes, everyone is just as suspicious as everyone else, except, of course, a few standout people.

We always talk on chatzy anyways.

Confirmed.
I've also noticed that beary509 has joined the IRC and then left seconds after once or twice today.

I swear I should get on the IRC one of these days...
I am angry, because you guys are making such idiotic assumptions. Following Trundle like dogs.
And Karla.

I am also angry because whenever I try to improve, everybody thinks, oh, somebody is helping her!
I DO have a life, and at the moment, it is very hard. I apoligize if I am bringing it out on everyone.
I am tired or being the shy, un contributing person.
I'm trying, and if that is not good enough for you, go ahead and waste a lynch.

She knows how I feel! I was in her exact same position Game IV, and it drew negative attention because I apparently improved within the span of a few seconds.

Also, I was personally not surprised that Kayla decided to go and vote to lynch me...

I was snow shoeing...
 
This is a perfectly good reason to lynch you and get you out of the way. It sucks that our lynch choices come down to getting rid of those who can't play well or mafia because we pretty much choose the former (look at dolby). Stop doubting yourself and saying you're not useful. Why did you even bother signing up then? Play the game - be logical, strategic, and have confidence in yourself/choices. Make sure each decision you make is because you decide. If you're going to bandwagon at least make sense of whatever argument is thrown around.

Lowkey: Mafia is probably laughing just watching us attack each other. Pull it together people!

I have played mafia since the second game. Isn't this your second time?
I am getting better. I try my best. Honestly, I am 12 years old. I really enjoy mafia when people are not making stupid choices. I'm not a strategist, but that doesn't mean that. I can't play.
I really want to help. I really do.
But these hateful responses, basically telling me to give up, and I should've never played, hurts.
They really do. :c
I highly advise everybody to stop freaking out, and think seriously, and get those reds!
 
Urgh...
I have not posted one liners in a while!
Why does everybody make such a huge deal out of this?!
Ffs, I'm about fed up with this.

Jesus ****ing Christ, calm down gurl! No ones maliciously posting these suspicions. That've all legitimate reasons. Getting this enraged over accusations is just making yourself look more red.

Red flags are being raised. Scrambling to point at other people when you're in spotlight raises red flags even further.
I am very suspicious of Trundle. He may also be doing his job. I am just putting this out there in case I die.

Also, iLoveYou has not explained her vote for Blu Rose yet....

I second this. She usually contributes often, but she is quiet.
Why?

After reading all this through, several times over, your actions seem so very red-oriented.
 
Jesus ****ing Christ, calm down gurl! No ones maliciously posting these suspicions. That've all legitimate reasons. Getting this enraged over accusations is just making yourself look more red.

Red flags are being raised. Scrambling to point at other people when you're in spotlight raises red flags even further.






After reading all this through, several times over, your actions seem so very red-oriented.

I completely understand this, but you guys are making such stupid choices, I want to tear my hear out. I am a very hot headed person in real life, and sometimes on the forums. I am sorry that. I am not sickly sweet, sappy, and girly. I was never that way.
 
Then why are you so sold on Beary?
It's night and you said you're already sold on her for the next lynch. Take it easy there, tiger.

You're right. I actually am a very aggressive player. Quite often too aggressive, as you will have observed.

She is usually pretty laid-back, at least on Chatzy and around the forum. As for Kayla, I cannot pretend to know her at all.
My position for now is strongly leaning towards Beary. I will, of course, take in the following events and may change my position accordingly.
 
I completely understand this, but you guys are making such stupid choices, I want to tear my hear out. I am a very hot headed person in real life, and sometimes on the forums. I am sorry that. I am not sickly sweet, sappy, and girly. I was never that way.

You don't have to take it so emotionally. People are just posting why they think your red. I'm actually younger than you(ya you probably already know), and I'm not sweet,sappy, or girly either. I just don't take it half as hard as you. I do belive you are red, but please don't beat yourself up over it.
 
You don't have to take it so emotionally. People are just posting why they think your red. I'm actually younger than you(ya you probably already know), and I'm not sweet,sappy, or girly either. I just don't take it half as hard as you. I do belive you are red, but please don't beat yourself up over it.

I am just going to **** up now....
I always take things personally. That is one off the reasons that I've considered quitting mafia...

- - - Post Merge - - -

OMFG, shut up. Not ****...o. O
 
Also, iLoveYou has not explained her vote for Blu Rose yet....

I explained it to a couple of people in the IRC. Basically Blu Rose was the easiest target on Day One after all the posts you two made together. So I voted for him in hopes that other people would immediately jump on (potential Mafia players - if Blu Rose was not Mafia). All I got was Prin. This is how we caught Kuma (Mafia) in Mini Mafia 2 so I was hoping it would work here too. That was my only intention with the Blu Rose vote. I didn't necessarily think he was Mafia.

There's a couple of you that seem really anxious to get me out / shift attention onto me whenever you can, with good reason too I guess. Although knowing my alignment, it's definitely raising flags. I hope a couple of you people, in specific, get inspected tonight. It can't be that you're so certain that I am Mafia this early in the game, and just willing to lynch me away. At this point it just seems like you are specifically targeting me. I have a feeling it's because you know my role & the easiest way to get it out is through lynching. Double win because it's actually me who has the role this time.

The biggest reason why I am more quiet is because I've done the strong players / inactives so many times. Superpenguin is pretty much right, everyone knows the lists by now. What else can I talk about here? Half of you have only been appearing the thread to post general stuff (dos & don'ts). It's Day One with no leads. I've been put in the position of having to defend myself and concentrate on that rather than bring forward suspicions. For two reasons: 1) I do not have enough good evidence on them to go hard against them & 2) If I brought them up while I was being attacked, then wouldn't that appear like I was trying to get the attention off myself?

Superpenguin you brought up Oath2Order's name. I was pretty much relying on the fact that YOU had substantial proof to go after him. I never talk to him in these Mafia games, so when you said you were getting a weird vibe from him, I just chose to believe you. I was also busy with the two names I gave you in which I expressed concern to you about.


Behavioural changes:

iTookYourWaffles - died Doctor (Game 4) [ Acting suspicious on purpose ]
BellBringerGreen - died Townie (Mini Mafia 1) [ Suddenly started PM'ing SP for the first time ]
Mary - died Townie / Bodyguard (Game 4) [ Was a huge distraction roleclaiming Townie Day One for no reason ]
Justin - Townie (Game 1) [ very aggressive ] & Townie (Game 4) [ not participating at all ]

You guys can not possibly expect us to play the game the same way every single time we get Town roles. When you get an advantage in the game it makes you relax and not feel pressure to post aggressively. I know people are generally counting on us to contribute but I can only do so much when I am being attacked (a.k.a defend myself).

Also, any player who gets Mafia can equally mimic their behaviour form a previous game when they had a Town role to slide by. It works both ways. Behavioural changes & no change in behaviour.

Tom I found it rather interesting that you left LaurinaMN & Oath2Order off your Detective / Protection list. They're strong players that get by easily & I feel like they should be added to your already long list before we forget about them.
 
I am just going to **** up now....
I always take things personally. That is one off the reasons that I've considered quitting mafia...

- - - Post Merge - - -

OMFG, shut up. Not ****...o. O

Maybe mafia just isn't a game for you then, it says that it's not for the light-hearted. :c

I'm doubting myself already. On one hand, some things you have done are suspicious, on the other, I can totally see where you're coming from-that you're just Beary being Beary.
 
Mary - died Townie / Bodyguard (Game 4) [ Was a huge distraction roleclaiming Townie Day One for no reason ]

This isn't a behavioral change. And if it is, it is kind of obvious why she changed. She was mafia her first games; this was the first time she was town. Obviously she would exhibit a different type of behavior.
 
Back
Top