Mafia TBT Mafia V: There and Back Again [Game Over/Town Win]

[iLoveYou]

I have concerns.

Players who are likely to slide by (in no particular order):

Tina - Very neutral regardless of her alignment. It's too hard to read her. If anyone is PM'ing with her, then I hope you are gaining ground on her alignment.

Superpenguin - Very aggressive regardless of his alignment. I feel like the only thing that will make people even consider him as Mafia, will be if he ever succeeds to get me lynched. Even then, it can be a Town player making a mistake. Or, his PM circle can be infiltrated by a red player which is influencing him to target me specifically.

LaurinaMN - I know it's still early & stuff, but she is very likely to slide by no matter what. I'm sure soon enough we'll see her start analyzing posts, which will give everyone generally a pro-Town feeling about her. Town had a hard time lynching her in Game 4 and they were even quoting good evidence to get her lynched.

Lauren - She isn't posting a lot or anything that will get her noticed as a "threat". She's playing it safe and posting to comment only about the people we are generally attacking in the thread (Beary509). Also this is the first time me & her have not roleclaimed to eachother. She hasn't shown any interest at all in wanting to know my role & whenever she used to be Town she usually needed to know my role. Not sure if we actually got divided for the first time or not. I mean, it could be that she's not that interested too.

There are other names like: Oath2Order, TheCreeperHugz and Tom. I don't have much to say about them though. I know this is basically just a list at the moment. Two cents, two cents.

I love you all <3. We still friends outside of this thread pweez :{

 

[Chris]

If you want to know why I voted, it's because they told me to vote in IRC and acted as if I was holding up the game. So blame Tom.

Hey now, Tinaa and some of the others wanted you to vote as well. The way Gandalf worded it made it sound like voting was mandatory and those who don't get modkilled.

This is true. At the time we pinged Jeremy there were already 12 or 13 votes for Dolby. I assume that he voted as soon as he saw it.

 

[Blu Rose]

Players who are likely to slide by (in no particular order):

Tina - Very neutral regardless of her alignment. It's too hard to read her. If anyone is PM'ing with her, then I hope you are gaining ground on her alignment.
I agree, as of the moment.

Superpenguin - Very aggressive regardless of his alignment. I feel like the only thing that will make people even consider him as Mafia, will be if he ever succeeds to get me lynched. Even then, it can be a Town player making a mistake. Or, his PM circle can be infiltrated by a red player which is influencing him to target me specifically.
Not true. I don't believe he is necessarily Mafia, but I do believe that he could be hiding some kind of role that us Town do not necessarily like.

LaurinaMN - I know it's still early & stuff, but she is very likely to slide by no matter what. I'm sure soon enough we'll see her start analyzing posts, which will give everyone generally a pro-Town feeling about her. Town had a hard time lynching her in Game 4 and they were even quoting good evidence to get her lynched.

Lauren - She isn't posting a lot or anything that will get her noticed as a "threat". She's playing it safe and posting to comment only about the people we are generally attacking in the thread (Beary509). Also this is the first time me & her have not roleclaimed to eachother. She hasn't shown any interest at all in wanting to know my role & whenever she used to be Town she usually needed to know my role. Not sure if we actually got divided for the first time or not. I mean, it could be that she's not that interested too.
I only roleclaim to twoselect people when I'm blue. Then again, I've only been that once. Oh, and I have done a role-swap with Lynn and Beary, but Lynn was a Goon, and Beary is still undetermined.

There are other names like: Oath2Order, TheCreeperHugz and Tom. I don't have much to say about them though. I know this is basically just a list at the moment. Two cents, two cents.
Four cents? Why?

I love you all <3. We still friends outside of this thread pweez :{

Well...
I'll go do something with my life now.

Spoiler: What I've been doing

View attachment 27110

 

[KarlaKGB]

Not true. I don't believe he is necessarily Mafia, but I do believe that he could be hiding some kind of role that us Town do not necessarily like.

The only role that could match that description is the serial killer, who for all intents and purposes should be considered Mafia.

I only roleclaim to twoselect people when I'm blue. Then again, I've only been that once. Oh, and I have done a role-swap with Lynn and Beary, but Lynn was a Goon, and Beary is still undetermined.

I don't see the relevance in this. In fact I don't even understand what you're talking about. This game or previous games?

 

[Mary]

If you want to know why I voted, it's because they told me to vote in IRC and acted as if I was holding up the game. So blame Tom.

I just want you to die. Is that wrong?


I think it's still too early to tell anything. I want to see how the night actions play out.

 

[Lauren]

Lauren - She isn't posting a lot or anything that will get her noticed as a "threat". She's playing it safe and posting to comment only about the people we are generally attacking in the thread (Beary509). Also this is the first time me & her have not roleclaimed to eachother. She hasn't shown any interest at all in wanting to know my role & whenever she used to be Town she usually needed to know my role. Not sure if we actually got divided for the first time or not. I mean, it could be that she's not that interested too.

There are other names like: Oath2Order, TheCreeperHugz and Tom. I don't have much to say about them though. I know this is basically just a list at the moment. Two cents, two cents.

I love you all <3. We still friends outside of this thread pweez :{

I'm at work so I'll post in 4 hours when I've finished and 2 you told mafia mine and tinas role last game!

- - - Post Merge - - -

When it comes to this game I'm not trusting as much seeing as last games people such as trundle and Kayla have told people my roles. I'm nothing important this game yet id like to stay alive to aid town. Hence why I've said it would be completely pointless checking me.

- - - Post Merge - - -

And I mentioned Beary and Dolby for the reason there isn't anything really going on or suspicious right now and they're the only ones of which have stud out to me right now. You pointing fingers seems to be pretty weird, this early on anyway, maybe you're using your "likability" when in actual fact in previous games where you've been mafia you've led town to believe you were innocent yet you were mafia, with me I won't deny that. Yet people still choose to follow you when you act this way whether or not you're mafia or town aligned. I have role claimed to I believe Han whether he was listening. Like I said I am of no use.

 

[iLoveYou]

I don't see the relevance in this. In fact I don't even understand what you're talking about. This game or previous games?

Neither do I. Blu Rose, I was only talking about Lauren, not you. Why did you choose to reply to that? It had nothing to do with you.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I just want you to die. Is that wrong?


I think it's still too early to tell anything. I want to see how the night actions play out.

Well when the Mafia read this thread I'm sure they know who to kill to make you / him look guilty.

 

[Lauren]

On the other hand Kayla, I could say the same to you, you usually question whether I'm mafia and what not. It works both ways really.

 

[Mary]

Neither do I. Blu Rose, I was only talking about Lauren, not you. Why did you choose to reply to that? It had nothing to do with you.

- - - Post Merge - - -



Well when the Mafia read this thread I'm sure they know who to kill to make you / him look guilty.

If so, I will have no problem making a post in my defense. If Jeremy is innocent, I expect the same.

 

[Superpenguin]

Superpenguin - Very aggressive regardless of his alignment. I feel like the only thing that will make people even consider him as Mafia, will be if he ever succeeds to get me lynched. Even then, it can be a Town player making a mistake. Or, his PM circle can be infiltrated by a red player which is influencing him to target me specifically.

I consider you're lynch/death a crucial point in this game. I would have no problem defending myself if you do ever end up dying as Town as it would've been a mistake on my part. I, of course, have been keeping notes on who has been telling me things in support of your lynch and those who have been against it as well as to the degree they were enforcing their opinion on the matter. If anything, you dying would help town and I don't understand why you don't have that same degree of self-sacrifice like you did in the past games.

 

[Blu Rose]

The only role that could match that description is the serial killer, who for all intents and purposes should be considered Mafia.

I don't see the relevance in this. In fact I don't even understand what you're talking about. This game or previous games?

Precisely.
But, then again, one can never be too sure.

Well, I'm just stating what I would do in that situation.

And I mentioned Beary and Dolby for the reason there isn't anything really going on or suspicious right now and they're the only ones of which have stud out to me right now. You pointing fingers seems to be pretty weird, this early on anyway, maybe you're using your "likability" when in actual fact in previous games where you've been mafia you've led town to believe you were innocent yet you were mafia, with me I won't deny that. Yet people still choose to follow you when you act this way whether or not you're mafia or town aligned. I have role claimed to I believe Han whether he was listening. Like I said I am of no use.

Just one question...

What else are we supposed to do other than point fingers, anticipating a nervous response from the Mafioso? I don't think that they've left us any real, solid evidence, unless, of course, it is buried deep within their posts...

Also, one question...

Will play continue if the Mafia are all killed, but not the Serial Killer?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also, Karla, Serial Killer could most definitely be used to our advantage, if s/he chooses todo so.

 

[Superpenguin]

Also, Karla, Serial Killer could most definitely be used to our advantage, if s/he chooses todo so.

Serial Killers are against everyone. So if they do reveal themselves to anyone, they should know that they'll just be killed at some point later no matter how much of a "help" they try to be.

 

[Lauren]

Well...
I'll go do something with my life now.

Spoiler: What I've been doing

View attachment 27110

In that case I'll finger waggle you, START MAKING CONSTRUCTIVE POSTS.

 

[iLoveYou]

I consider you're lynch/death a crucial point in this game. I would have no problem defending myself if you do ever end up dying as Town as it would've been a mistake on my part. I, of course, have been keeping notes on who has been telling me things in support of your lynch and those who have been against it as well as to the degree they were enforcing their opinion on the matter. If anything, you dying would help town and I don't understand why you don't have that same degree of self-sacrifice like you did in the past games.

That's simple, it's because I don't have the same role. Neither am I in the same position: securely in a PM circle, where if I die I can just let them know who to target. I don't think you should go around targeting people and using them as bait. The aim isn't to lynch Town players to get information. If you know that people are trying to steer you into the direction of lynching me and you are gathering information, then why aren't you bringing their names forward? Why would you rather sacrifice a Town role than to target those who are actively trying to get me out?

@ Lauren: I can't quote your post because of my phone but, I did accuse you of Mafia like I usually do in the IRC. I said, if you are Mafia you won't be able to take me out Night One. All you did was post that in the thread publicly for everyone who wasn't in the IRC to see. It's just a concern. I'm not accusing anyone on my list of being Mafia, so if you are not Mafia then you should have nothing to worry about.

 

[Lauren]

For me that seemed like you was role claiming within the first hour. I have no grounds to accuse anyone but I'm sure when night ends the **** will hit the fan and land on someone, thus causing the ****e bandwagon we all end up getting involved with.

 

[Superpenguin]

That's simple, it's because I don't have the same role. Neither am I in the same position: securely in a PM circle, where if I die I can just let them know who to target. I don't think you should go around targeting people and using them as bait. The aim isn't to lynch Town players to get information. If you know that people are trying to steer you into the direction of lynching me and you are gathering information, then why aren't you bringing their names forward? Why would you rather sacrifice a Town role than to target those who are actively trying to get me out?

Because I don't know what you are. Several people know who these people are as I do realize that people should know this information. But I won't actively try to lynch them since I don't know what you are. You seem to think everyone believes you are Town. We don't.

 

[Blu Rose]

Serial Killers are against everyone. So if they do reveal themselves to anyone, they should know that they'll just be killed at some point later no matter how much of a "help" they try to be.

I know. But, in the right situation, the Serial Killer can be an aide.

@Lauren: Whatever...

I guess I'll just shut up for now, as I'm still the noob I've always been...

 

[Lauren]

Blu Rose, painful. If you try and pick at me for TRYING to be rational then so be it. You're only doing it because she's not highlighted you. If it was you, it would be a different story. In doing so you've mo laced yourself on the radar in my opinion.

 

[iLoveYou]

Because I don't know what you are. Several people know who these people are as I do realize that people should know this information. But I won't actively try to lynch them since I don't know what you are. You seem to think everyone believes you are Town. We don't.

I truly do believe you are in contact with a red player who is trying to influence you to get me lynched (assuming you are not Mafia). You guys have suddenly decided to target me and I'm pretty sure it's because they know my role. I've dropped so many hints, it's impossible you can't take a guess. If you tell me: "well why should I believe you" then I will simply ask you "what makes you believe them"? No nights have passed so it's not like anyone got inspected. You are simply choosing to trust them without good reason.

You were going to get me lynched in Mini Mafia 2 even after I directed the Town into getting out 1x Godfather (with your help) + 2x Roleblockers. I was a Miller in that game. That is why I say you will lead Town into making bad lynches. You will still have doubts until the end and waste time lynching those who make pro-Town movements. I could have seriously roleblock + killed my Vigilante instead of having him shoot Kuma the roleblocker from last game. I could have killed SirGanatar to frame Oath2Order last game too. If I were Mafia there is no way I would sacrifice 3/4 of my team on the first 3 days. Yet you were still going to lynch me because I returned Mafia Goon in that game. It's like you couldn't put 2 + 2 together to assume I was the Miller. I don't know if it had anything to do with my "Miller/Mafia hunt" but yeah. No Mafia player would be crazy enough to sacrifice thwir whole team.

This is why I say you need to think things through more carefully. This is why the Town should not follow you. You are too willing to make bad lynches just to figure out if others are Mafia.

 

[Blu Rose]

Blu Rose, painful. If you try and pick at me for TRYING to be rational then so be it. You're only doing it because she's not highlighted you. If it was you, it would be a different story. In doing so you've mo laced yourself on the radar in my opinion.

What? I wasn't trying to be offensive...

Also, iLoveYou...

You say that SP is too willing to make bad lynches, but you voted me the first day.

Now, I will shush, unless if I am addressed in someone's post and I feel the need to respond.