Mafia TBT Mafia VII: Animal Crossing [Game Over/Town Win]

[Kaiaa]

To let everyone know: I will be inactive most of the day today 8-4pm or 5pm. I'll be at work/school during those times.

 

[Kaiaa]

Do you think that it's possible to bury it with the shovel and perhaps it will do something?

I haven't bought the watercooler but unless it says you can bury it you can't.

 

[Dolby]

Didn't say that you could bury it, so it must be 100% useless

 

[Truffle]

Oh okay, thanks!

 

[Lithia]

I'll also be inactive from now until 5pm, because of school.

 

[Farobi]

Honestly I don't know if we should play it safe the first day and lynch Makkine. There are probably seven Mafia players and, if you don't know, that's a lot. Makkine does not seem scummy enough to earn my vote. Yeah, she may not contribute later in the game, but I'd like to give her a chance as this is just her second game. FireNinja1, on the other hand plays Mafia quite a lot actually. Yet within his simple, meager posts he somehow manages to slide by through modkills / being up for lynch, which is equally detrimental to his Town buddies later in the game, proven he is one. I'd like to see both talk more though!

- - - Post Merge - - -

With that said, I'm more up for lynching FireNinja1 than Makkine today. Both are of more-or-less equal quality, so it's not like the change of vote could be of much difference anyway.

 

[KermitTea]

Honestly I don't know if we should play it safe the first day and lynch Makkine. There are probably seven Mafia players and, if you don't know, that's a lot. Makkine does not seem scummy enough to earn my vote. Yeah, she may not contribute later in the game, but I'd like to give her a chance as this is just her second game. FireNinja1, on the other hand plays Mafia quite a lot actually. Yet within his simple, meager posts he somehow manages to slide by through modkills / being up for lynch, which is equally detrimental to his Town buddies later in the game, proven he is one. I'd like to see both talk more though!

- - - Post Merge - - -

With that said, I'm more up for lynching FireNinja1 than Makkine today. Both are of more-or-less equal quality, so it's not like the change of vote could be of much difference anyway.

Here's what was said yesterday

Hey everyone, now that I think about it...it might be a waste to lynch Makkine.

Because tbh if she's not gonna contribute she should end up getting modkilled anyway (assuming the host actually implements modkills)

I disagree, it's a risk we really ought to take. Makkine will never contribute sure, but what if she's red? It'd be much better to get her out of the way than let Jubs deal with her, leave Fireninja or another non-contributor to the modkill.

soo you're saying that if she stays here, she will just contribute to the kp? makes sense i guess , but I'm saying that say someone like FireNinja randomly posts and stuff, meaning that he most likely will not be modkilled because he is "contributing", so we could lynch him instead? idk, but makkine is definitely a safe lynch.

 

[Farobi]

The "What if ______ is red" statement can be applied to anybody in the game really; it's just filler text. What if FireNinja's red? What if you're red? It does not possess any sort of weight at all. I still think Makkine is innocent. FireNinja1 hasn't even posted yet so I can't say much about him, but to me Makkine is just too safe of a target for anyone - Town or Mafia - to vote for.

 

[KermitTea]

The "What if ______ is red" statement can be applied to anybody in the game really; it's just filler text. What if FireNinja's red? What if you're red? It does not possess any sort of weight at all. I still think Makkine is innocent. FireNinja1 hasn't even posted yet so I can't say much about him, but to me Makkine is just too safe of a target for anyone - Town or Mafia - to vote for.

I know -- which is why I'm bring up Tom.
He role claimed early in the game saying that he's town but so far he's been jumping on everyone else.

 

[Cariad]

I know -- which is why I'm bring up Tom.
He role claimed early in the game saying that he's town but so far he's been jumping on everyone else.

Tom made me suspicious too... It is just how he blurted it out and left it...

 

[Byngo]

At first, I did find it odd that he rather quickly role claimed townie. But I realized that is too noob if a mistake for a smart player like Tom to make. I think he would be a little more hush-hush with role claiming, especially publicly. But who knows? o-o

The one I find more odd is how Jeremy almost lashed out at Tom at just the mention of him possibly being mafia.

The "What if ______ is red" statement can be applied to anybody in the game really; it's just filler text. What if FireNinja's red? What if you're red? It does not possess any sort of weight at all. I still think Makkine is innocent. FireNinja1 hasn't even posted yet so I can't say much about him, but to me Makkine is just too safe of a target for anyone - Town or Mafia - to vote for.

I tree with you there. Makkine is an easy target, but then who do you suggest we consider to lynch? o:

 

[Cariad]

Don't know about you, but I havnt seen bellbringergreen yet... They have probably posted though, because no one else has mentioned them.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I have, sorry, I was thinking of the wrong person... Whoops!

 

[KermitTea]

List of people who haven't posted yet:
Trundle
BlueLeaf
Minties
Lithia
Kuma
Gandalf
Prin
VillageDweller
Kit
puppy
Prof Gallows
TheCreeperHugz
pallycake
FireNinja1
PurplPanda

I'm doing this off memory so correct me if I'm wrong. Just keep these people in mind.

 

[Jeremy]

At first, I did find it odd that he rather quickly role claimed townie. But I realized that is too noob if a mistake for a smart player like Tom to make. I think he would be a little more hush-hush with role claiming, especially publicly. But who knows? o-o

The one I find more odd is how Jeremy almost lashed out at Tom at just the mention of him possibly being mafia.




I tree with you there. Makkine is an easy target, but then who do you suggest we consider to lynch? o:

That is simply because Tom has built a wall of salt between us. Not to mention that he accuses me of the same thing every game for no reason.

 

[Byngo]

That is simply because Tom has built a wall of salt between us. Not to mention that he accuses me of the same thing every game for no reason.

Ohh, I see. I guess I wouldn't know since I don't go on the IRC :3

 

[Jeremy]

Ohh, I see. I guess I wouldn't know since I don't go on the IRC :3

It's from MIV when he offered me an olive branch of friendship after a few disputes in previous games. But as I took that branch, trusting he had turned from his history of mistrust and deceitfulness, I felt the stab of a rusty knife in my upper back. I laid there dying and only one person stood near me. It was Tom, my only ally! He was the only one near me but surely my friend, and a fellow town cop, was not the one to commit this act. "Help me," I shouted in agony. "Who could have done this," he questioned as embracing my bleeding body. I thought I died that day in the arms of an ally. My cop brother on the force! But alas, he was not an ally at all. He was no brother! Because it was his hand, driven by the scum in his mind and the darkness of his heart, that had stabbed me in the back on that fateful night. And I never forgave. And I never forgot.

 

[Cariad]

It's from MIV when he offered me an olive branch of friendship after a few disputes in previous games. But as I took that branch, trusting he had turned from his history of mistrust and deceitfulness, I felt the stab of a rusty knife in my upper back. I laid there dying and only one person stood near me. It was Tom, my only ally! He was the only one near me but surely my friend, and a fellow town cop, was not the one to commit this act. "Help me," I shouted in agony. "Who could have done this," he questioned as embracing my bleeding body. I thought I died that day in the arms of an ally. My cop brother on the force! But alas, he was not an ally at all. He was no brother! Because it was his hand, driven by the scum in his mind and the darkness of his heart, that had stabbed me in the back on that fateful night. And I never forgave. And I never forgot.

Sad story, make me want to cry
honestly

 

[VillageDweller]

List of people who haven't posted yet:
Trundle
BlueLeaf
Minties
Lithia
Kuma
Gandalf
Prin
VillageDweller
Kit
puppy
Prof Gallows
TheCreeperHugz
pallycake
FireNinja1
PurplPanda

I'm doing this off memory so correct me if I'm wrong. Just keep these people in mind.

http://www.belltreeforums.com/misc.php?do=whoposted&t=150171 For reference as this is a new thread for the game, no signup posts here <3
Kuma, Trundle, Kit, Gandalf, TheCreeperHugz and Lithia (and I guess now me?? LEL) have all posted at least once~

Also thank the lord that this wasn't "omg day one sucks!!!!" again thanks to items, making it more interesting <3
sorry for not posting until now, it kind of started while I was asleep and then I had school so ya. But I'm here now!!
I feel kind of bad for Makkine like this buutt it might be similar to PurplPanda in Mini Mafia IV, turned out to be red.. lowering that KP (which we need to 4KP is too op). Also I think KarlaKGB said it like, voting for her should be a wake up call to her to start being more active (or contributive), sadly it doesn't look like it has had much of an effect with only 1 post from her so far :[

i thought FireNinja would have realised by now that he's known for being inactive/uncontributive but clearly it hasn't sunk it to him not posting yet. i mean yeah timezones but still. so far tho FN1 looks like to be on the road to #modkill so yea

also forgot whoever said it but someone said mafia are given vague roles which aren't in the game to claim as: just idk as a warning if it sounds quite vague (or useless?) be suspicious. But don't do anything too drastic as we don't know what's real and what's not :{

 

[Cariad]

I thought I'd seen purplpanda Karen, but I don't really know. I also think gandalf has posted, but I may be wrong.
That's a lot of people who haven't posted, but I guess there is still a while until night.

 

[Jeremy]

Oops I meant mafia VI