Mafia TBT Mafia XII: Mean Girls (GAME OVER THREE WAY TIE)

Superpenguin said:
She was a Detective, though. At least that's what I thought everyone thought she was.

- - - Post Merge - - -



I actually thought you'd decide to lynch her, or you would at least talk to her more and she'll slip up along the way if I did something like that in my will. I figured no one would take my will seriously considering how i played.
Click to expand...

She did started to slip. I asked for her past inspections and I started to wonder why she never got roleblocked.
 
tsundere said:
She did started to slip. I asked for her past inspections and I started to wonder why she never got roleblocked.
Click to expand...

Yeah, I figured if she was scum she would roll along with getting outted but her inspections she would give back would all be crap and you'd lynch her. But instead you trusted her and Elise was gonna give her a gun. :eek:
 
Superpenguin said:
Yeah, I figured if she was scum she would roll along with getting outted but her inspections she would give back would all be crap and you'd lynch her. But instead you trusted her and Elise was gonna give her a gun. :eek:
Click to expand...

I don't know why I trusted her tbh. I should've stopped. But originally Elise was going to give me the gun. Maybe later in the game if she didn't come back with any inspections then I would've lynched her, but she wasn't my biggest suspicion.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Whatever I did **** this game lmao
 
But still
1) Oath couldn't have been protected from anything. Did you accidentally send him a PM?
2)Why did we have no vigs or JoATs
3)Why the **** did doctors not get PMs back about their protections
4)Aerious why did you lie to me about another doctor and why did you think that Natty protected herself night one
5)Why are there so many townies
6)Why did I believe SP's will when he was trolling the whole game
7)Why.
 
sunshinetea was good mafia.. lmao.

ok i wanted to make a big post about this game but I've forgotten most about it.

sunshinetea and tsundere/Natty for MVP's in each team respectively. nikkinikki was a good cult leader too i thought :}

I just wanted to comment on the hosting. I'm sorry Purpl but you were completely disorganised and clearly hadn't thought a lot of things through. Personally I think the idea of hosting got to your head and you got so caught up trying to be amazing that you didn't do any of the actual important things. It also seemed like you couldn't make many decisions on your own (i've heard about Tina helping you.) and I can't remember who said it (maybe Oath or Natty) but you really needed a co-host. Alice had to make the post links and you kind of had other people do stuff for you, even ending the game was a decision suggested by Tina on behalf of others:

<Tinaa> [16:18:47] <Tinaa> Keep in mind, when I say this I'm not doing it to be mean - but I was asked to message you on behalf of others. The general consensus is that people think that you should end Mean Girls Mafia. The scum team has been leaked - one of the scum team has even been confirmed scum to town because of it. It's only a matter of time before the rest of the team get leaked to town simply to end the game
<Tinaa> faster.
<Tinaa> [16:18:47] <Tinaa> The game has been compromised because of the leak. A lot of people aren't happy and no longer wish to play, even if they haven't said so publicly in the thread. The majority think it'd be for the best if you just chose to end it early rather than leaving it to drag out any longer.

Tina also helped you balance the roles and helped you out a lot this game (seriously why didn't you just make her a co-host lmao)

You were also erratic and didn't really give valid reasons for what you did (flashback to "I HAD MY MOTHEREFFIN REASONS")
Also no timers was kind of annoying. It also seemed a bit meh how you were hounding people and complaining on IRC at the beginning of the game that people didn't have clear inboxes, when you yourself multiple times did not have a clear inbox, which I think led to some kills or something not being sent in but I'm not entirely sure.
Throughout the game you also never updated the playerlist with roles/deaths, no DAY/NIGHT posts (still) and it just overall seemed really unorganised.

As tsundere said - why no vig's or JoATs? I know this was closed and you can do what you want but it just seemed a bit weird to not have any at all. (Also, wtf is a 1 shot gift giver)

Doctor PMing thing was weird and I still don't understand why it was changed in this game?? Why weren't doctors told about their protections?

IMO for the future if you ever do wish to host again I would seriously make sure you will be free for however long you think your game could be, clear your inbox and make sure you actually know what you're doing. I would also recommend making sure you have/are a co-host.
(Finally wtf was up with all the flavour text issues? I mean I know you gave up but start something as you mean to end it.)

~FIN~

edit: oops that's long lmao. and I mean this in no way a personal attack but just some things to keep in mind if you do want to host again in the future. x)
 
Last edited:
VillageDweller said:
sunshinetea was good mafia.. lmao.

ok i wanted to make a big post about this game but I've forgotten most about it.

sunshinetea and tsundere/Natty for MVP's in each team respectively. nikkinikki was a good cult leader too i thought :}

I just wanted to comment on the hosting. I'm sorry Purpl but you were completely disorganised and clearly hadn't thought a lot of things through. Personally I think the idea of hosting got to your head and you got so caught up trying to be amazing that you didn't do any of the actual important things. It also seemed like you couldn't make many decisions on your own (i've heard about Tina helping you.) and I can't remember who said it (maybe Oath or Natty) but you really needed a co-host. Alice had to make the post links and you kind of had other people do stuff for you, even ending the game was a decision suggested by Tina on behalf of others:

<Tinaa> [16:18:47] <Tinaa> Keep in mind, when I say this I'm not doing it to be mean - but I was asked to message you on behalf of others. The general consensus is that people think that you should end Mean Girls Mafia. The scum team has been leaked - one of the scum team has even been confirmed scum to town because of it. It's only a matter of time before the rest of the team get leaked to town simply to end the game
<Tinaa> faster.
<Tinaa> [16:18:47] <Tinaa> The game has been compromised because of the leak. A lot of people aren't happy and no longer wish to play, even if they haven't said so publicly in the thread. The majority think it'd be for the best if you just chose to end it early rather than leaving it to drag out any longer.

Tina also helped you balance the roles and helped you out a lot this game (seriously why didn't you just make her a co-host lmao)

You were also erratic and didn't really give valid reasons for what you did (flashback to "I HAD MY MOTHEREFFIN REASONS")
Also no timers was kind of annoying. It also seemed a bit meh how you were hounding people and complaining on IRC at the beginning of the game that people didn't have clear inboxes, when you yourself multiple times did not have a clear inbox, which I think led to some kills or something not being sent in but I'm not entirely sure.
Throughout the game you also never updated the playerlist with roles/deaths, no DAY/NIGHT posts (still) and it just overall seemed really unorganised.

As tsundere said - why no vig's or JoATs? I know this was closed and you can do what you want but it just seemed a bit weird to not have any at all. (Also, wtf is a 1 shot gift giver)

Doctor PMing thing was weird and I still don't understand why it was changed in this game?? Why weren't doctors told about their protections?

IMO for the future if you ever do wish to host again I would seriously make sure you will be free for however long you think your game could be, clear your inbox and make sure you actually know what you're doing. I would also recommend making sure you have/are a co-host.
(Finally wtf was up with all the flavour text issues? I mean I know you gave up but start something as you mean to end it.)

~FIN~

edit: oops that's long lmao. and I mean this in no way a personal attack but just some things to keep in mind if you do want to host again in the future. x)
Click to expand...

edit 2: this is a good round up of what you should consider (and to all people who want to host in the future) http://www.belltreeforums.com/showthread.php?135506-Official-TBT-Mafia-General-Thread-Guide-Hosting-History&p=3310232&viewfull=1#post3310232

- - - Post Merge - - -

JNO i meant to edit and not quote i cry );
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

N e s s
Mafia TBT Mafia - Darkest Dungeon (Cancelled)
Replies
15
Views
881
N e s s
N e s s
Chronos314_XD
Review the Video Game Above You!
Replies
5
Views
128
Midoriya
Midoriya
E
Mafia The Quest for King - Mafia | Game Thread | GAME OVER
89 90 91
Replies
2K
Views
50K
Jacob4
Jacob4
Damniel
Mafia Among Us Mafia Game Thread (Town Win!)
139 140 141
Replies
3K
Views
99K
unravel
unravel
Damniel
Mafia Among Us Mafia - Sign Ups
2
Replies
24
Views
2K
Damniel
Damniel
Back
Top