Mafia TBT Mafia XIII: XCOM: Enemy Within (End Game - Town Wins!)

[toastia]

~@ ShinySandwich - And to add to this:
If you don't start contributing soon, don't think your scum buddies can keep you safe. I'm on to you. BANG!

Why not you? You've added nothing to this game so far. The fact that others may also have contributed poorly is irrelevant - You're useless to town right now and a complete liability to the game. Your only redeeming quality is IF you are a Blue role and you are using your action cleverly at night - But you could also be scum floating under the radar, and we would never get a read on you. And if you are a green role, you add zero value.

You are not the only one doing this, but you are ONE of the players that do, and your name just came to mind first - And your excuse is incredibly poor. I am disappoint.

I really think we should keep the pointless spamming to a minimum - It serves as a distraction and it's getting really old by now.

~@ Aerious - I do not think paying attention to how the roles work makes Oath2Order seem like he's EXALT - He did not say anything about the third party that isn't openly stated in the first post of the thread and then reconfirmed by the host. Besides, we will know if Oath2Order is scum after the night is over regardless - If Dolby gets killed, Oath did it. That is the natural order of things.

And there is still numerous people who aren't contributing at all - Not even with pointless posts. ShinySandwich comes to mind right away. They've barely said ten words since the game started. And I don't think they are the only one. Furthermore, MewMew was very positive about working together with me in a previous game, yet this time around they have not responded to the PM I sent, and they have not spoken much in the thread either. (At least not about serious matters.)

Finally, make good use of your last wills - But remember that EXALT has a role that can spy on them, and sometimes even fiddle with them. Only share what is necessary for town to make progress - And if you can, add something to it that proves your last will is legit.

Could you share the defense Shiny gave you with us? Or if it's already buried somewhere in the thread, point it out? If it's the latter it makes me feel lazy to ask you to do that, but frigging kermit memes and petty arguments man.

I'll save you the trouble, Sataric.

 

[Geoni]

If it was, wouldn't she have specified who it was in her will? It wouldn't make sense to include 2 and leave one out, would it?

It might just be that she was not suspicious of the others she PM'd? I dunno. The best we can do is work with what we have.

 

[Sid2125]

If it was, wouldn't she have specified who it was in her will? It wouldn't make sense to include 2 and leave one out, would it?

Someone asked earlier how many times they can change their will and it was once a night. maybe MissNoodle sent it in with those two and then talked with a third person after sending it in. so that third person is excluded from her will.

 

[radical6]

...

Thanks.

maybe that is what oath is banking on. there are few more effective tactics than a smart player using a dumb tactic to throw people off. oath also being so open with the conversation with noodle could also just be a tactic so that we believe his innocence.

Yeah, but I told him I was a doctor in Mean Girls. He didn't think about killing me at all. I don't think he really puts blues on his priority list when he's scum. He knew a couple of blues in Mean Girls, but he never killed any of them. Though I didn't look back in other games he played as scum, but his priority seems to be the strongish players or at least players who go after him.

 

[Superpenguin]

Could you share the defense Shiny gave you with us? Or if it's already buried somewhere in the thread, point it out? If it's the latter it makes me feel lazy to ask you to do that, but frigging kermit memes and petty arguments man.

All you have to do is go to the OP and click ShinySandwich's name and search through her posts until you find her defense. Literally the kermit memes don't provide any blockade for that especially since Shiny didn't spam anything to fill her recent posts search.

 

[toastia]

Someone asked earlier how many times they can change their will and it was once a night. maybe MissNoodle sent it in with those two and then talked with a third person after sending it in. so that third person is excluded from her will.

Maybe..

 

[CookingOkasan]

Could you share the defense Shiny gave you with us? Or if it's already buried somewhere in the thread, point it out? If it's the latter it makes me feel lazy to ask you to do that, but frigging kermit memes and petty arguments man.

y'know the names in the OP link back to all their posts, right?

 

[Stevey Queen]

Oath is pretty sus in my book. Noodle flat out shared her role with him and she's dead now. But idk. I see what you all mean about killing her right away seems off.

I need to see Capellas convo with noodle before I can come up with any further judgments

 

[Sataric]

Could you share the defense Shiny gave you with us? Or if it's already buried somewhere in the thread, point it out? If it's the latter it makes me feel lazy to ask you to do that, but frigging kermit memes and petty arguments man.

Certainly. Here is a recap of our conversation:

I really think we should keep the pointless spamming to a minimum - It serves as a distraction and it's getting really old by now.

~@ Aerious - I do not think paying attention to how the roles work makes Oath2Order seem like he's EXALT - He did not say anything about the third party that isn't openly stated in the first post of the thread and then reconfirmed by the host. Besides, we will know if Oath2Order is scum after the night is over regardless - If Dolby gets killed, Oath did it. That is the natural order of things.

And there is still numerous people who aren't contributing at all - Not even with pointless posts. ShinySandwich comes to mind right away. They've barely said ten words since the game started. And I don't think they are the only one. Furthermore, MewMew was very positive about working together with me in a previous game, yet this time around they have not responded to the PM I sent, and they have not spoken much in the thread either. (At least not about serious matters.)

Finally, make good use of your last wills - But remember that EXALT has a role that can spy on them, and sometimes even fiddle with them. Only share what is necessary for town to make progress - And if you can, add something to it that proves your last will is legit.

They replied here super quickly..

There are people who haven't even posted, Why me?

Why not you? You've added nothing to this game so far. The fact that others may also have contributed poorly is irrelevant - You're useless to town right now and a complete liability to the game. Your only redeeming quality is IF you are a Blue role and you are using your action cleverly at night - But you could also be scum floating under the radar, and we would never get a read on you. And if you are a green role, you add zero value.

You are not the only one doing this, but you are ONE of the players that do, and your name just came to mind first - And your excuse is incredibly poor. I am disappoint.

~@ ShinySandwich - And to add to this:
If you don't start contributing soon, don't think your scum buddies can keep you safe. I'm on to you. BANG!

After that, I got no reply, but they've been viewing the thread and posting on TBT otherwise.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Prin was way ahead of me..

 

[8floor]

Yeah, but I told him I was a doctor in Mean Girls. He didn't think about killing me at all. I don't think he really puts blues on his priority list when he's scum. He knew a couple of blues in Mean Girls, but he never killed any of them. Though I didn't look back in other games he played as scum, but his priority seems to be the strongish players or at least players who go after him.

he left us a nice list of all the blues when he quit in that game.
the only reason why we were not shooting down blues in that game is because it was too obvious. i do not think this game follows the same circumstances, necessarily
and noodle was a blue role that mafia reaaaaally wants dead.

 

[Sataric]

Thanks.


Yeah, but I told him I was a doctor in Mean Girls. He didn't think about killing me at all. I don't think he really puts blues on his priority list when he's scum. He knew a couple of blues in Mean Girls, but he never killed any of them. Though I didn't look back in other games he played as scum, but his priority seems to be the strongish players or at least players who go after him.

Yeah, both me and Dolby are still alive. That alone makes me believe that Oath is probably Town.

 

[toastia]

Yeah, both me and Dolby are still alive. That alone makes me believe that Oath is probably Town.

Can't mafia only make one kill per night? Wouldn't that mean he could only target one if he was scum unless he's mafia vig or something?

 

[Superpenguin]

I don't see why "Oath doesn't like killing blues" clears him.

Noodle's role was one which mafia would want completely out of the way. In HP mafia, Karen was a tracker/watcher and I didn't want her alive even though she trusted me and shared a ton of information with me. We decided to just kill her cause the tracker/watchers were too big of a nuissance to the mafia.

 

[radical6]

Can't mafia only make one kill per night? Wouldn't that mean he could only target one if he was scum unless he's mafia vig or something?

Uhhh I'm pretty sure mafia have more than 1 KP....

 

[Superpenguin]

Yeah, both me and Dolby are still alive. That alone makes me believe that Oath is probably Town.

Explain, please.

 

[8floor]

Yeah, both me and Dolby are still alive. That alone makes me believe that Oath is probably Town.

after oath saying in scum chat in the last game that dolby was his only concern for getting called out as scummy, i am sure he would probably not go that route and make himself obvious...

 

[Geoni]

All you have to do is go to the OP and click ShinySandwich's name and search through her posts until you find her defense. Literally the kermit memes don't provide any blockade for that especially since Shiny didn't spam anything to fill her recent posts search.

From doing this I'm going to assume that the defense in question is this?

There are people who haven't even posted, Why me?

Never posted after that post. That was at 5:57 AM according to my clock. She had a lot of activity in Brewster's Cafe during 7:00 AM on my clock. She had the time to do that but not defend herself? Yeah, fos on ShinySandwich.

 

[CookingOkasan]

It's really a shame that Noodle didn't simply pm Fel with role questions... The engineer is definitely a valuable role (especially if theres a chryssalid in the game since the engineer can shut them down to a degree). With so many players and roles, I have no idea why she role claimed such an important blue role on day one to anyone. But hell, I guess that's none of my business. (~not question green so it's okay~)

 

[oath2order]

Explain, please.

I killed them Night One in Mean Girls.

 

[Sataric]

Can't mafia only make one kill per night? Wouldn't that mean he could only target one if he was scum unless he's mafia vig or something?

Well, a Mafia team normally discuss whom they're going to kill together with each other so he would send his minions to kill the other targets he thought would catch on to him, I reckon.

Explain, please.

He killed us both on Night 1 in the Mean Girls Mafia and then sent me a PM taking credit for the kill. He told me straight out that he thought we where the most likely to eventually catch him otherwise, especially if we'd be talking to each other. Dolby has proven that he can normally tell if Oath is scum or blue a few times before, such as in Tom's PoI game when Oath was the detective and got killed Night 1.