• Guest, you're invited to help build our new TBT time capsule! It contains three parts, with some of its elements planned to open in 2029 and others not until the distant future of 2034. Get started in 2024 Community Time Capsule: Blueprints.

Mafia TBT Mafia XV: The Siren's Call (Game Over/Mafia & Third Party Win!)

My eyes are rolling out of my head.

It's obvious to me that town is being spoon-fed by town. Of course mafia would try and deflect attention onto harmless third parties, so as to keep attention of themselves and get one of us lynched. That will be much more evident once one of us is killed. :rolleyes:
 
No, because as I said we count towards town's numbers. From my knowledge after PMing Tinaa, we leave the game after collecting the diamonds. If we don't collect the diamonds but town wins, we still don't win, but we count towards your numbers. We are not against you, we are helping you the best we can. We easily COULD have sat back all game, but we didn't.

No, you couldn't - You had to pretend to be town because otherwise people would be suspicious of you, and you'd eventually get lynched. You went in to this game with a scum mindset right from the beginning. Your goal was to deceive and lie your way through the game, and I assume that originally you had not intended to claim either, but did so when put under the scope.

If you are telling the truth about being removed from the game once all the diamonds are collected, and nothing else negative happens to town in the same process, and the game simply continues on as if you were never really a part of it, then you guys collecting the diamonds would essentially be a disaster for town either way. We'd lose three votes and three people counting towards towns numbers (if you aren't still lying to us..) instantly. That doesn't make you very pro-town. In fact, if it comes down to the end of the line, you might even decide to go "Okay Mafia, we'll side with you!" because you're annoyed at town mistrusting you all game long, even though it's our only logical choice.
 
You thieves are not a team you're competing against each other, if what you say about the role is true.

...smh

- - - Post Merge - - -

The more the thieves are against the idea of it, the more I want to see one of them die.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I still don't think this is three people making a lie due to the consequences of one of them dying, but still.
 
You thieves are not a team you're competing against each other, if what you say about the role is true.

...smh

- - - Post Merge - - -

The more the thieves are against the idea of it, the more I want to see one of them die.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I still don't think this is three people making a lie due to the consequences of one of them dying, but still.

And the more all of you want to kill one of us, the less I want to contribute at all. :lemon:
 
Us winning only hurts you because it puts us out of the game. If you start killing off our team, we aren't going to help you any more.

Oh boy, threats. We really don't have a reason to trust you, and threats aren't really getting you anywhere with us either. Regardless of if you stop talking to town, killed off, or reach your objective, we're going to lose players counted towards town regardless. If we have a DT, I think at least one of them should be inspected, because killing them off would be a waste of vig shots/lynches if they're simply useless third parties. I don't see a valid way they could side with mafia in a no PM game aside from being anti-town and interfering with due process.

- - - Post Merge - - -

And the more all of you want to kill one of us, the less I want to contribute at all. :lemon:

yeah, good idea. Give town a reason to trust you even less.
 
DT died Alice, I doubt we have another one. Unless we have a jack of all trades.

- - - Post Merge - - -

If I were a thief I would be contributing a bunch and stabbing another thief's back by supporting this vig shot idea.
 
Why should we even attempt to help either side? It's apparent both sides want to get rid of one of us.
 
DT died Alice, I doubt we have another one. Unless we have a jack of all trades.

- - - Post Merge - - -

If I were a thief I would be contributing a bunch and stabbing another thief's back by supporting this vig shot idea.

I've been in main mafia games with two DT's. So it's not out of the question that we might have another. But yeah, there's also the possibility of a jack.
 
Why should we even attempt to help either side? It's apparent both sides want to get rid of one of us.

Well after all the lies can you blame us? If you guys just came out with that from the get go you'd be in less of mess right now.
 
Well after all the lies can you blame us? If you guys just came out with that from the get go you'd be in less of mess right now.

Right. As if all of you would go a long with three people claiming they're third parties trying to steal items. Mhmm, I can see it now. We'd still be under suspicion.
 
DT died Alice, I doubt we have another one. Unless we have a jack of all trades.

- - - Post Merge - - -

If I were a thief I would be contributing a bunch and stabbing another thief's back by supporting this vig shot idea.

They said they work together, not against each other.
 
Right. As if all of you would go a long with three people claiming they're third parties trying to steal items. Mhmm, I can see it now. We'd still be under suspicion.
Not all of us went along with your original thief claim to begin with, but at least you guys wouldn't be viewed with complete and total suspicion of every player not in your thief cult.
 
We have been informed that we are not getting removed from the game if we win, she changed it.
 
Back
Top