• Guest, you're invited to help build our new TBT time capsule! It contains three parts, with some of its elements planned to open in 2029 and others not until the distant future of 2034. Get started in 2024 Community Time Capsule: Blueprints.

Mafia TBT Newbie Mafia: Steven Universe Mafia [END - Town + Shiida Win!]

Status
Not open for further replies.
The Jack of All Trades was Enchilada and replaced by Locket. Xerolin's was the Vigilante and replaced by Sparro. I think it is most likely that Xerolin was the one who shot Kirby because Enchilada wasn't even playing the game.
 
The Jack of All Trades was Enchilada and replaced by Locket. Xerolin's was the Vigilante and replaced by Sparro. I think it is most likely that Xerolin was the one who shot Kirby because Enchilada wasn't even playing the game.

i'm so sorry you're totally right. unless of course there's 2 jack of all trades, unlikely but i suppose we can't rule it out
 
I don't think it's likely at all. We only have 8 players left, 2 of which are mafia. 1 claimed third party and that left only 5 town players. Joat is rare in itself I think. Having two of them in a small list of players is an overkill I would think.
 
As far as roles/player allignments are concerned, the game should be 100% fair. I'm sincerely sorry if you feel like it's not, but if you think something was unfair so far, feel free to PM me or Crys about it.
 
It's okay Jacob. I think we meant the circumstances of this game is not fair for town. It just so happened that the people who are not really into playing this game got the most important roles. Thanks you two for doing your best to make this game happen ^^
 
It's okay Jacob. I think we meant the circumstances of this game is not fair for town. It just so happened that the people who are not really into playing this game got the most important roles. Thanks you two for doing your best to make this game happen ^^

yeah, i guess that's downside of noob mafia sigh, for some people it's to test the waters and if they don't like the waters then they just give up and unfortunately for us that seems to be most of town..
 
yeah, i guess that's downside of noob mafia sigh, for some people it's to test the waters and if they don't like the waters then they just give up and unfortunately for us that seems to be most of town..

It is really peaving that people sign up not to play, I am super busy and I am still trying to get information in. Main person who I want to see more from is Qwerty, come on, you show up to vote and barely try, you only seem to be digging into Shiida our third party, come on! I have a feeling we are going to loose another valuable townie today, tbh I am going to put this out there, I was shot N1 but lived through so there is that.
 
It is really peaving that people sign up not to play, I am super busy and I am still trying to get information in. Main person who I want to see more from is Qwerty, come on, you show up to vote and barely try, you only seem to be digging into Shiida our third party, come on! I have a feeling we are going to loose another valuable townie today, tbh I am going to put this out there, I was shot N1 but lived through so there is that.

i want to hear from them too! i've wanted to from day one and it's so annoying they're still not replying!

how come you're only claiming now and not night one?
 
This is my farewell post

I was left without internet for this morning, leaving me unable to vote.

I didn't mean to not vote, and wish I was able to continue playing.

I was still very new, and didn't know exactly how things worked that well. I will probably browse this thread more to get the feel of it all, but I will not be posting.
 
Probably so that there wouldn't be a huge target on their head.

but they shot her.. so surely they already think she's a target? claiming you've been shot on day two would have confirmed to us that you were town, i don't really understand why you've waited this long to claim. you've gone 2 days without giving town important information that could have helped us, i guess it would have been helpful.
 
@Luca, I was not trying to push a lynch on mog at all. I was just asking her some questions to determine her alignment. If you noticed, I questioned a lot of different people whenever I see some discrepancies in their posts and I waited for their answers.

Anyways, if you have any questions for me, please go ahead.

yes, I know; I just found some of her behavior a bit odd, like how she's worded a few of her posts

and yes, actually, I do have a question for you.
right now, at this very moment, who do you think the two scum are, and why? (I'd appreciate some proof, like any certain posts that may have given you such feelings)

I'm also suspicious of mogyay but I don't really know what to ask either of them. I'm not sure if Locket is avoiding us or just inactive.

@Lucanosa
I'm glad you've caught up and I'm looking forward to seeing your cases.

- - - Post Merge - - -

@Cadbberry
You posted near the end of D2 that Moonbrink was posting on other threads but you didn't vote.
May I ask why?

I've caught up with today's posts, and I'll be working on and posting my cases later tonight.
the clock is the key.

I'm feeling this .

Anyway, inb4 Lucanosa comes in and call us all out for ****lynching again. He did not place a vote. I am seeing a pattern here.

I call any townie lynch a ****lynch lol it's just my word for a mislynch.
tbqh, I never really suspected Sparro of being scum, and more like scared/busy town, and when he flipped blue, it confirmed it. what's bothering me now though is how someone (person A) brings up someone else (person B) as possibly sus and then everyone bandwagons and because most of the players here are new, the reads are all over the place (which is to be expected), and the bandwagons are literally running us all over. like.... esphas's death was different (the esphas effect is what I'll call it I guess), but even tho they seemed scummy, moon and sparro's deaths were via bandwagon. someone posted their suspicions because of a few sketchy posts and no one tried to argue about how they are or aren't what the claims said they were. and the only person who really fought for their safety from fear of lynching was rosetti.
I'm starting to suspect if some of the people who I've thought were town are actually scum....
while I'm working on my reads/cases I'll also be going over everyone's posts along with the meta of the few players on here who aren't newbies.
 
the clock is the key.


What is this supposed to mean? You go inactive for almost 24 hours and you didn't vote, now you get on here saying this ****.

I call any townie lynch a ****lynch lol it's just my word for a mislynch.
tbqh, I never really suspected Sparro of being scum, and more like scared/busy town, and when he flipped blue, it confirmed it. what's bothering me now though is how someone (person A) brings up someone else (person B) as possibly sus and then everyone bandwagons and because most of the players here are new, the reads are all over the place (which is to be expected), and the bandwagons are literally running us all over. like.... esphas's death was different (the esphas effect is what I'll call it I guess), but even tho they seemed scummy, moon and sparro's deaths were via bandwagon. someone posted their suspicions because of a few sketchy posts and no one tried to argue about how they are or aren't what the claims said they were. and the only person who really fought for their safety from fear of lynching was rosetti.
I'm starting to suspect if some of the people who I've thought were town are actually scum....
while I'm working on my reads/cases I'll also be going over everyone's posts along with the meta of the few players on here who aren't newbies.

If you believed Sparro was innocent then why didn't you vote? Also I believe that Esphas was lynched partially due to bandwagon and partially due to inexperience in mafia.
 
What is this supposed to mean? You go inactive for almost 24 hours and you didn't vote, now you get on here saying this ****.

timing is key with mafia
you say something at the wrong time and your head will be on the chopping block.

also I said before I don't have all day to come on and read, post, etc.
like, I have a lot of things I need to finish by the end of the summer for college so I can't waste all of my time questioning and pushing people, especially when it's giving little in terms of results seeing how quiet the thread is.

If you believed Sparro was innocent then why didn't you vote? Also I believe that Esphas was lynched partially due to bandwagon and partially due to inexperience in mafia.

first off, I didn't vote because like I said I wasn't sure on his alignment, plus even if I did vote it wouldn't have saved him considering everyone ran him over w/ the bandwagon, and a #NOVOTE would've done literally nothing. the only thing that would've saved him was a case protecting him, or he himself speaking up, and I read him as null then so I wouldn't have made a case just to save him at that time.
second, eshpas's lynch was from a bandwagon, but he got the bandwagon pushed really hard on him because he posted some really sketchy things just to get the game going.... someone else called it the esphas effect I believe. there's ways to get the game going.... and then there's the esphas effect aka what he did. that's why I said that. and like I said, all of the lynches so far are from bandwagons, no one is defending theirself and no one is defending others. plus being inactive isn't making finding scum any easier.
 
timing is key with mafia
you say something at the wrong time and your head will be on the chopping block.

also I said before I don't have all day to come on and read, post, etc.
like, I have a lot of things I need to finish by the end of the summer for college so I can't waste all of my time questioning and pushing people, especially when it's giving little in terms of results seeing how quiet the thread is.



first off, I didn't vote because like I said I wasn't sure on his alignment, plus even if I did vote it wouldn't have saved him considering everyone ran him over w/ the bandwagon, and a #NOVOTE would've done literally nothing. the only thing that would've saved him was a case protecting him, or he himself speaking up, and I read him as null then so I wouldn't have made a case just to save him at that time.
second, eshpas's lynch was from a bandwagon, but he got the bandwagon pushed really hard on him because he posted some really sketchy things just to get the game going.... someone else called it the esphas effect I believe. there's ways to get the game going.... and then there's the esphas effect aka what he did. that's why I said that. and like I said, all of the lynches so far are from bandwagons, no one is defending theirself and no one is defending others. plus being inactive isn't making finding scum any easier.
I am aware that posting at the wrong time could have a negative effect. Hence why I said I would not be posting reads tonight. I thought that was a really odd thing for you to say.
On the D3 lynching, I agree that a no lynch would not have helped Sparro, but that is the second time you failed to vote.
 
but they shot her.. so surely they already think she's a target? claiming you've been shot on day two would have confirmed to us that you were town, i don't really understand why you've waited this long to claim. you've gone 2 days without giving town important information that could have helped us, i guess it would have been helpful.

I meant to but I was fearful of a target on my head, as Cass said. I also dont know if it woulda helped since I think Kirby targeted me for being someone he played with before and then Kirby died leaving me back to square one. I was trying to piece together why they shot me and I think it was just due to experience, the only people I questioned were all townie except for Kirby and the unconfirmed Rosetti. It may have been because I was on the right track with Kirby, who was scum, or maybe Rosetti?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top