You do realize there are four mafia... right? Four isn't enough to reach majority. And they would always be comfortable lynching someone not on their team. And please direct me to where I said you were naming someone who isn't a candidate. Quote it, preferably.
Doesn't it say in the OP that we don't know how many of each role there are and that not all the roles will necessarily be used in this game?
There's not actually, if you see the post I made the last page purpl is trying to convince everyone to vote for me, and since seems like people will only follow that "the most experienced" people will says Its almost impossible to get votes out of me right now, you might vote for me if you wish =), I already did vote for myself, btw, dont you think that if I was mafia then people will actually start to point to someone else direction to get the votes for that person and not me? =) You're welcome
- - - Post Merge - - -
*Will only follow what "
Like others have said before, I don't think your bolded statement is a good argument. I'm agreeing with what Jennwa said regarding this quote. And if you had read the brief guide that Karla had quoted earlier, from the first Mafia game, you'd know that it wouldn't really be a good idea for scum to defend their own teammates like this. This just seems like too flimsy of an argument for me to ignore. I have quite a few reasons to suspect you right now: this statement, on top of your hidden mode, your jumping on
hanzy when you were initially suspected.
True, hm.. That does seem scummy although what does that change? She does use hidden mode, and she was being honest about it.
Let's think about this for a second here, why would she announce it when she obviously knows that she will be suspected? Wouldn't a scummy hide about their hidden mode?
Don't fall for the trap! Heh. But, to be honest, I can't help but suspect you, just a little bit. You seem quick to bandwagon, and you even subtly tried to deflect attention away from Kyuby, who is arguably the most suspected, by agreeing with other suspicions toward Purpl... possibly a very subtle way to defend a scum-mate? I could be totally wrong, but that's just a bit of speculation from me that I'd like to throw out there.
That's literally the stupidest idea I've ever heard. Whenever a scummate is about to get lynched, they're scum mates normally vote for them to get suspicion off of their back.
Also, *if I were
Subjunctive mood of verbs.
I'd say it depends, really! I know you are more experienced with Mafia than I am, but still--I wouldn't say it's necessarily
normal for scum to hop onto the bandwagon, if a team-mate is about to be lynched, just to save their own hides... Teamwork is really important for the mafia alignment! I'm not even sure if this really needs to be said, but your post implies that you somehow believe otherwise, so I'll say it anyway--depending on the importance of the role, I think it's possible to somehow strategically defend your scum-mates, even if doing could cast suspicion on you.
Well, you have my vote now. That was the weakest defense I've heard this whole game.
I have to somewhat agree that Purpl's argument wasn't a very convincing one. However, I still feel like there isn't really solid reasoning for me to suspect Purpl more than Kyuby.
My vote goes to Kyuby for the aforementioned reasons.
For now, I'm going to vote for myself as a placeholder.
