Mafia TBT Newbie Mini Mafia (Game Over)

[f11]

R.I.P

 

[Farobi]

u guys make me cri. i'll post my cases later i guess ._.

 

[NikkiNikki]

i cierd ebery thime

 

[Kildor]

****. And I thought I was right. /cri gif

I just woke up, I'll be posting my opinions later.

 

[hanzy]

Right. Now that all our stupid mistakes are out the way, let's stop being complete newbs please. Still sad to see kyuby go, but now town has answers and hopefully we can just stop wasting our energy on the wrong people now.

I just woke up in a no nonsense mood today after last night. xD

 

[Kildor]

Right. Now that all our stupid mistakes are out the way, let's stop being complete newbs please. Still sad to see kyuby go, but now town has answers and hopefully we can just stop wasting our energy on the wrong people now.

I just woke up in a no nonsense mood today after last night. xD

What do you expect from Newbie Mafia? We're all bound to make newbie mistakes, sadly.

 

[hanzy]

I don't mean to sound rude or anything btw. That message refers to me aswell.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I KNOW! I'm a complete newbie at mafia aswell! I've clearly made big mistakes in this game aswell. I was just saying, I don't think there can be room for any more.

I'm just trying to get my act together.

 

[Qwerty111]

Man, Poor Kyuby RIP. Ugh, I hate screwing up the game like this. We can't afford to lose like this. I know it's TBT Newbie Mini Mafia but we can't afford mistakes now.

 

[NikkiNikki]

Yeah no more mistake hopefully tonight a mafia dies

 

[Kildor]

Yeah no more mistake hopefully tonight a mafia dies

That's suspicious. "Hopefully tonight a mafia dies ."

Can you please explain what you mean by that?

 

[NikkiNikki]

Its night time and I am hoping a blue does the right thing because cookingosaka died because of a blue's action right?

- - - Post Merge - - -

I believe we should investigate does who said "not all roles are taken" which caused the confusion on voting for Kuyby. I have said before that all roles were taken, so I am a bit suspicious of Kildor

I've been thinking about this for awhile, it is possible that certain roles do not appear. So that's why anyone can claim Jay Leno, and look innocent.

Obviously no one claimed the role because Kuyby was actually Jay Leno. But due to kilor questioning also Qwerty,Jewna,Fireninja agreeing (and Kuyby weird postings) lead to the confusion. I felt for it as well but after seeing kuyby's final postings I immediately went back to my original vote. However, at the time there were some who were watching the thread, so I believe the ones who was just watching the thread and didn't change their vote might be mafia.

 

[Kildor]

Its night time and I am hoping a blue does the right thing because cookingosaka died because of a blue's action right?

- - - Post Merge - - -

I believe we should investigate does who said "not all roles are taken" which caused the confusion on voting for Kuyby. I have said before that all roles were taken, so I am a bit suspicious of Kildor



Obviously no one claimed the role because Kuyby was actually Jay Leno. But due to kilor questioning also Qwerty,Jewna,Fireninja agreeing (and Kuyby weird postings) lead to the confusion. I felt for it as well but after seeing kuyby's final postings I immediately went back to my original vote. However, at the time there were some who were watching the thread, so I believe the ones who was just watching the thread and didn't change their vote might be mafia.

What are you talking about? I never question FireNinja, Jenwa, or Qwerty at all. Please quote if I did. And it is a fact, that certain roles do not appear. And I wasn't really the first one who said about the "certain roles do not appear rule". It was gnoxiam's post that made me say that, ( you can see that I quoted gnoxiam's post.)

And the thing you said about the death of Okasan is suspicious. How do you know that it was an action of a blue who killed Okasan? We don't know who killed him.
If you have evidence of this, quote it.

 

[Qwerty111]

Its night time and I am hoping a blue does the right thing because cookingosaka died because of a blue's action right?

- - - Post Merge - - -

I believe we should investigate does who said "not all roles are taken" which caused the confusion on voting for Kuyby. I have said before that all roles were taken, so I am a bit suspicious of Kildor



Obviously no one claimed the role because Kuyby was actually Jay Leno. But due to kilor questioning also Qwerty,Jewna,Fireninja agreeing (and Kuyby weird postings) lead to the confusion. I felt for it as well but after seeing kuyby's final postings I immediately went back to my original vote. However, at the time there were some who were watching the thread, so I believe the ones who was just watching the thread and didn't change their vote might be mafia.

I don't think there is 6 mafia dearie. I just read the op and it is 4 Mafia. Kyuby was doing "I told you so" but we were never sure if he was telling the truth or not. So I stuck with my vote.

 

[Farobi]

THIS MESSAGE IS TO SK: I know you could care less about the discussion on Town vs Mafia - but if you shoot Town tonight, factor along with Mafia KP kills, Mafia will outnumber Town and Town will automatically lose. Mafia know each other, and can vote against you tomorrow, so you have no chances of winning unless you hit scum tonight. With that said, please consider gnoixaim for your kill. You have nothing to lose and plenty to gain. I'm still confident she's scum.

Here's my case.

Ive noticed them agree with each other a lot. Maybe they're Masons?

You think they are Masons just for agreeing a lot? As Town, we should care less if they are indeed Masons. We also especially shouldn't announce possible Blue roles publicly for fear Mafia might catch up. There was no reason to bring this point up if you're Town. However, it did make much more sense to me when I scum-read that post.

ccemuka also hasn't been mentioned in any of gnoixaim's cases, despite him being a very fitting candidate for "not posting much / repeating what everyone said" etc.

Anyways, here are some users that haven't posted much/repeating/etc.etc.etc.:

Spoiler

Qwerty111: Posts only here and there. And they're bandwagoning along/repeating things (oh yeah, like me right???) 7 posts total
Beardo: Here they are agreeing to Hanzy and FireNinja (+ randomly posting pictures)
NikkiNikki: Again, she as well is stating the obvious and repeating/agreeing what others have said.
And then there is Hanzy, I know they have been contributing - but the fact they switched their vote so quickly seems suspicious to me. Especially when they were so "pro-kyuby" lynch vs. Purpl.

Spoiler

Kyuby- a person who posts the bare minimum but still has good posts. I don't necessarily think he should be lynched for that.
Beardo- A newbie. My eyebrows went up when they said they were to lazy to read things and almost automatically have a suspicion on Static.
staticistic1114- a player that gets their personality mixed with the game. I guess, I'll let the off topic-ness go, but voting for a person with no reason or evidence beside, their avatar?, that really suspicious to me?
Purplpanda- Usaually more vocal but he seems quiter since it is a no pm game. But, I guess personal stuff was happening in you're life.
Qwerty111- An inactive that I'd like to hear more from.

^ One of some posts where ccemuka also has fit the criteria of gnoixaim's possible suspicion list.

Another thing:

Whoops, forgot to mention - those 4 are on my suspicions list.
Qwerty, Beardo, Nikki, and Hanzy.

Kyuby also hasn't been in gnoixaim's suspicion list early Day 2. Looking like Mafia made it on the spot to divert attention, no? Town would usually retain suspicions on some people if they had any, but it's really interesting to see that you weren't very particular on Kyuby at that time of the day, gnoixaim.

OK. There are still more of my thoughts I'd like to point off:

But, I don't think that's really worth a lynch vote. It's day 2 and one of our best players has died, it's a total dead end. And I don't think she was dodging evidence more like showing how there are other players who hasn't really contributed anything.

ccemuka giving a rather baseless defenese for gnoixaim. Reviewing his earlier posts, he usually follows the flow. I don't think I remember him defending someone actually.

No one since we don't have the proper evidence but maybe some more thing will be found out later today.

Look over here fellows! Proposing a No Lynch when there was a 7:4 Town-Mafia ratio! If that doesn't look a bit at all scummy to you guys, then I don't know what does.

I know there'll be a bunch of "scum shouldn't defend each other publicly it's stupid!" comments but they can. No one else looks as scummy as these guys right here.

Another person I suggest to keep an eye on is Kildor. Parity cop should try to inspect him. VIGILANTE PLEASE SHOOT CCEMUKA.

 

[Qwerty111]

I am annoyed with the lack of blue action. Come on blues!

 

[NikkiNikki]

06-13-2014, 04:52 PM #526

I've been thinking about this for awhile, it is possible that certain roles do not appear. So that's why anyone can claim Jay Leno, and look innocent.

Sorry, i just woke up. Then we should be more suspicious on gnoixaim as shes the lead of the confusion.

I don't have evidence, but i was questioning it because I don't really understand much of night time.

 

[f11]

[
Look over here fellows! Proposing a No Lynch when there was a 7:4 Town-Mafia ratio! If that doesn't look a bit at all scummy to you guys, then I don't know what does.

I know there'll be a bunch of "scum shouldn't defend each other publicly it's stupid!" comments but they can. No one else looks as scummy as these guys right here.

Another person I suggest to keep an eye on is Kildor. Parity cop should try to inspect him. VIGILANTE PLEASE SHOOT CCEMUKA.

I never said no lynch. I said we should wait until more evidence comes up.

 

[NikkiNikki]

I don't think there is 6 mafia dearie. I just read the op and it is 4 Mafia. Kyuby was doing "I told you so" but we were never sure if he was telling the truth or not. So I stuck with my vote.

I know there are 4, but among does 6 could be mafia.

 

[Farobi]

I never said no lynch. I said we should wait until more evidence comes up.

It's not easy for evidence to pop up out of the blue, and we can all use old posts as evidence. The way you word it also seems like "oh, I'm just gonna go along with whoever gets lynched today".

 

[f11]

It's not easy for evidence to pop up out of the blue, and we can all use old posts as evidence. The way you word it also seems like "oh, I'm just gonna go along with whoever gets lynched today".

But like you said up their in your long post is that I'm a go with the flow type of person. Then the thing with Gnoxiam happened. Lynch her for "bandwagoning" This whole game people were bandwagoning and not contributing. Many people, I'm look at you, Beardo have contributed less than others. Anyways, I was about to vote Gnoxiam but Marii made that post about Kyuby. Check the voting thread please. Notice how NikkiNikki tried to vote no lynch. Even I wanted to, which I did not, I couldn't have voted no lynch. Kill me at night and You'll have a 6:4 ratio.