Mafia TBT Scummies Awards 2019: Game Thread - Endgame

[Heyden]

if this cop check is legit
then Tina is town
she PM'd me before she knew it
and said Sensei trusted her super fast this time aroun'

Why is she PMing you but not posting lol
Also one of the mods check Biancas activity bc she loves avoiding the thread thanks

 

[unravel]

I dont even see tina around wtf

 

[SensaiGallade]

You could be an “unaware” something (I remember this from improbable mafia), but at the same time I’m just assuming that mafia wouldn’t have a day action to do to Sensai’s result as mafia. I also don’t understand why you investigated him that early in the game.

If I'm actually being honest, me coming back as red from being investigated makes sense if I consider my flavour text.

To add onto me trusting Tina "super fast", what I meant by that was I personally felt like I could trust her by gut instinct, and it was risky because she has yet to post.

 

[Geoni]

If I'm actually being honest, me coming back as red from being investigated makes sense if I consider my flavour text.

To add onto me trusting Tina "super fast", what I meant by that was I personally felt like I could trust her by gut instinct, and it was risky because she has yet to post.

what gut read was to be had
only 50 minutes into the game
gutreading someone with no posts is bad
you might as well have just picked a name

 

[SensaiGallade]

what gut read was to be had
only 50 minutes into the game
gutreading someone with no posts is bad
you might as well have just picked a name

Thats fair but there's no changing anything now. I would rather try and reach out to people rather than not. It is a PM game after all.

 

[Chris]

Tina PM?d you? Why isn?t she in the thread?

Why is she PMing you but not posting lol
Also one of the mods check Biancas activity bc she loves avoiding the thread thanks

Dad asked me to confirm if Justin can access user private messages (due to Kallie?s post in the voting thread) ? and to anyone concerned the answer is no, he does not have that power. That was before I had even come online for the day and when I logged in sort of gave him a running commentary of my thoughts (regarding a PM I received from Sensai then the thread itself) as I was catching up.

Regarding Sensai, I found it suss he sent me a PM 50 minutes after the game started saying that he felt I was ?one of the only people he could trust.? That read strange to me as I hadn?t posted yet - he had no reason to trust me. I could be a third party axe wielding murderer for all he knew. Someone blindly trusting me when I?ve done nothing to earn said trust rubs me the wrong way. After talking to Dad about it I was rethinking it (prob best not to explain why right now because I?m essentially giving him an easy excuse if I do) but if Waffles is genuine though then maybe my initial reaction was right.

As for Waffles claim originally I would give absolutely 0% weight. But the tone of this post reads genuine imo - and I like that there was some thought put into if an inspection result could be accurate rather than ?FOLLOW ME I?M RIGHT!!?.

I agree with this and plus i inspected him red like i said from the first post im a day cop and i know u guys wont believe this.

Anyway I have a fweling that this is the same as where someone inspects and return red but theyre actually town was it improsomething mafia (a meme inbalance game) i think it was punchy or farobi as cop but whenever they inspect its mafia idk

- - - Post Merge - - -

What I mean is the inspection is possible return in a opposite role

Although I do have a few Qs. I feel I already know the answers but I like to see if what I think a players mentality is lines up with what I believe it is.

I am already reading Sensai as scum so few posts in lol, I know it's a meme game but D1 lynch ez

Not to mention I just inspect him 30 mins ago and he returned redNot to mention I just inspect him 30 mins ago and he returned red

So?
Why inspect Sensai?
Why straight-up out your role instead of just saying you were suspicious of him?

---

Other general thoughts I?m still thinking through?


Post Restrictions
? Justin/Dad post restrictions I believe 100%.
? Toads I?m unsure of. It doesn?t sound believable but given that this game uses a 24/24 clock then it isn?t totally unrealistic either.
? Daniel?s rubs me the wrong way entirely. Why is he posting using the text colour and Japanese-style emojis that Natty uses in her signature? And why did Natty?s opening post in this game say ?I love Daniel? before any of this even happened? I thought at first that perhaps Natty had cursed Daniel, but the time between her saying this and the amount of posts he made before adopting this posting style debunks that. Also the fact that Natty has implied having a different role in one of her posts would suggest that being able to ?curse? someone is not her ability. It did make me wonder if someone else has a role that can pick another players posting restriction and did this to try and force a link between Daniel and Natty as their posts toward each other in the thread have been friendly, but if so I?m surprised Natty didn?t comment on it ? she just responded normally while other people were questioning Daniel?s new post style. Half-think it?s made up. Half think it?s strange. Don't trust Natty or Daniel but I don?t think they?re teamed either.

Other thoughts
? Heyden seems like his normal town self. I like that he?s keen to help even though he?s not sure how in a game like this.
? Jacob?s post bothers me. I like that it looks like he?s trying, but take out all those quotes in the middle that really don?t serve much of a purpose and there?s not as much there as it looks. He?s mislead me before with long posts that look like he?s investigating but in conclusion have nothing useful to provide ? and he kind of even stressed it wasn?t useful himself with the ?Jk, I don?t actually know who could be mafia !!!!!?

 

[radical6]

personally i think theres a chance they could have a weird lovers role but with a twist. ex theyre forced to type like each other.



has sensai played with u before/often??

 

[toadsworthy]

Good morning everyone! It is very true, I am only able to make one post per day period and can talk as much as I would like in thread at night. So please PM me for interactions, and don?t ask me questions in response to this post because I can?t in thread.

Here is a summary of my interactions so far via discord

Byngo is feigning jester by literally asking to be lynched. I?m inclined not to believe it obviously, and not sure if it?s town or scum behavior.

I went to dolby first because inoringwlly planned to answer the RQs and explain myself, but I needed an RQs. I?ve talked to him and he?s actually scum hunting, which Idk why he is taking this so serious.

I asked trundle a really good question about him saying that in is last game he said he was purposely changing his style, and what that meant for this game. And he avoided it. Idk if this is because trundle just always thinks I?m annoying or is just dismissive because he a scummy boy.

Dad is the toadsworthy role which I think could be scum in all honesty or a miller because of my track record. He also has been mostly talking to Me in dm about unrelated things.

Jacob is playing a lot more loosely and idk why if it?s because this is a much looser game or he isn?t scum now

Overall this game is being way too serious and I need more memes please and thank you. If you want to talk to me hmu on discord. I will see you all in the darkness. I can also vote as much as I want, so I may make statements with that too

 

[radical6]

i mean, me and dylan have been talking about unrelated **** but we're good friends so maybe thats why

personally from the times we did talk about mafia i lean towards town for him. hes not being a manipulative little **** that he usually is in PM games and pressuring me to claim

 

[Chris]

personally i think theres a chance they could have a weird lovers role but with a twist. ex theyre forced to type like each other.


has sensai played with u before/often??

Yeah after I hit submit I did consider a third party-esque link where as my original line of thought was more narrow based off the idea "scum wouldn't be this bold". Actually if they were lovers that explains Natty's opening post perfectly and why she says her lynch could have an impact on the game.

I remember playing with Sensai in a KM game about a year ago, but I'm blanking on if there were other times.

Good morning everyone! It is very true, I am only able to make one post per day period and can talk as much as I would like in thread at night. So please PM me for interactions, and don?t ask me questions in response to this post because I can?t in thread.

Here is a summary of my interactions so far via discord

Byngo is feigning jester by literally asking to be lynched. I?m inclined not to believe it obviously, and not sure if it?s town or scum behavior.

I went to dolby first because inoringwlly planned to answer the RQs and explain myself, but I needed an RQs. I?ve talked to him and he?s actually scum hunting, which Idk why he is taking this so serious.

I asked trundle a really good question about him saying that in is last game he said he was purposely changing his style, and what that meant for this game. And he avoided it. Idk if this is because trundle just always thinks I?m annoying or is just dismissive because he a scummy boy.

Dad is the toadsworthy role which I think could be scum in all honesty or a miller because of my track record. He also has been mostly talking to Me in dm about unrelated things.

Jacob is playing a lot more loosely and idk why if it?s because this is a much looser game or he isn?t scum now

Overall this game is being way too serious and I need more memes please and thank you. If you want to talk to me hmu on discord. I will see you all in the darkness. I can also vote as much as I want, so I may make statements with that too

Ohh, I didn't know the detail about free reign at night. That seems more plausible (I thought it was once per 24hr).
Liking this post useful reads - ty for using your one post wisely.

I don't know how to meme sorry to be a disappointment.

 

[unravel]

Ill be half serious and half meme/joking around in game.

 

[EpicGamer12]

what gut read was to be had
only 50 minutes into the game
gutreading someone with no posts is bad
you might as well have just picked a name

this is actually gold, kudos to you sir

- - - Post Merge - - -

I don't think toads realized the entire point of my game play last game if he thought it was worthwhile to ask me that question. If I'm trying to avoid being read by meta why would I specifically tell him how I am going to play this game? He either didn't think it through or he's just trying to be annoying. Either way I was falling asleep when he sent me that so I was going to ignore it even if it was a good question.

BTW everyone ##VOTE: SensaiGallade
We need him out of this game!

 

[radical6]

Jacob is town

huh. what do you mean

also **** whoever was the inspiration behind justin posting in ****ing pt7 font comic sans

 

[EpicGamer12]

huh. what do you mean

also **** whoever was the inspiration behind justin posting in ****ing pt7 font comic sans

It's just obvious, I can tell he is town

- - - Post Merge - - -

Actually I can see him as Third Party too

 

[Damniel]

I’m still in favor of either lynching Mog (for silent and dismissive behavior), or Dolby (for taking the beginning of day one wayyyy too seriously) uwu

- - - Post Merge - - -

I didn’t realize waffles was being serious in their day cop claim. But I guess in this kind of game you can literally claim anything lol OwO

Sensai also has been acting pretty defensive and I’m not a big fan of what they’re posting

Also I haven’t gotten any DMs from anyone so contact me -w-

- - - Post Merge - - -

Whoops I made the first post too small sorry ;-;;;

 

[Jacob]

OK so 2 things,

1- For my vote today I think I'm gonna keep my pool primarily within Sensai (fishy and red inspected) and Dolby (- sheeping Daniel tbh- mostly because of his forcefulness)

While I do think Dolby's directness for content comes from a place thats part of his restrictions in his role, I honestly can only really see that as a scummy role. If he was town and really needed to keep things on track there would probably be a more encouraging tone in his type

And here my thing about Waffle's doctor claim,

Hold it right there Justin, I'm a day cop and obviously this post is purely bias for us players and this is against the mafia rules

The original claim comes in at her first post which I really thought was just a joke - so I'm gonna go out on another limb and say that was part of her role too, that she would have to claim this role on her first post Maybe? Like that's just not natural/something anyone would do that early in the game. So I'm actually really hesitant to believe she's Role cop - I can see her being town (IF she's wrong about this "inspection" due to her not actually being a day cop, she would just obviously be a little scum read which puts her at a huge disadvantage as mafia for something she couldn't really control - that would just be a poor host decision)
Nothing is really lining up as a genuine cop claim or genuine inspection tbh, so I'm probably gonna end up voting dolby unless something more pushes me over the edge for sensai

? Jacob?s post bothers me. I like that it looks like he?s trying, but take out all those quotes in the middle that really don?t serve much of a purpose and there?s not as much there as it looks. He?s mislead me before with long posts that look like he?s investigating but in conclusion have nothing useful to provide ? and he kind of even stressed it wasn?t useful himself with the ?Jk, I don?t actually know who could be mafia !!!!!?

I thought it would be a funny little post to expand widely on the "Guess the mafia!!!" RQS because it typically requires NO effort and we learned from last game that relying on reads that early is laughable. Of course there's nothing useful to provide - up until that post there was hardly much content beyond lightweight player interactions. I'm kinda surprised/interested that u took it so seriously

- - - Post Merge - - -

The original claim comes in at her first post which I really thought was just a joke - so I'm gonna go out on another limb and say that was part of her role too, that she would have to claim this role on her first post Maybe? Like that's just not natural/something anyone would do that early in the game. So I'm actually really hesitant to believe she's Role cop - I can see her being town (IF she's wrong about this "inspection" due to her not actually being a day cop, she would just obviously be a little scum read which puts her at a huge disadvantage as mafia for something she couldn't really control - that would just be a poor host decision)
Nothing is really lining up as a genuine cop claim or genuine inspection tbh, so I'm probably gonna end up voting dolby unless something more pushes me over the edge for sensai

Sorry just wanted to expand on this, I lost my train of thought:

So I'm actually really hesitant to believe she's Role cop - I can see her being town, but it would be a role completely separate of role cop.

 

[Damniel]

By Toads:
Why is unravel a day cop@with scum inspect and claiming but not voting Sensai then.... and yet Sensai is voting himself. Please post that for me and give me your thoughts on it

I was actually thinking she was joking about the inspect. But she should elaborate on this herself („ಡωಡ„)

 

[Byngo]

mog is prob tp rather than scum

- - - Post Merge - - -

and sensai ploppping a vote on himself while a kind of bandwagon is forming on him says to me he’s prob not town, but not necessarily scum. the pressure on him isn’t that great so maybe he’s a tp that doesn’t care if he’s lynched

but reads don’t matter because i guarantee u there’s gonna be convoluted roles or twists in the game

- - - Post Merge - - -

o i didn’t read the last like 4 pages lol

 

[Dolby]

Regarding Sensai, I found it suss he sent me a PM 50 minutes after the game started saying that he felt I was ?one of the only people he could trust.? That read strange to me as I hadn?t posted yet - he had no reason to trust me. I could be a third party axe wielding murderer for all he knew. Someone blindly trusting me when I?ve done nothing to earn said trust rubs me the wrong way. After talking to Dad about it I was rethinking it (prob best not to explain why right now because I?m essentially giving him an easy excuse if I do) but if Waffles is genuine though then maybe my initial reaction was right.

That is just so bad imo. I can understand trying to form a PM link early game for the sake of a PM group. But "one of the only people I can trust?". That's just nope. It's so pockety

If I'm actually being honest, me coming back as red from being investigated makes sense if I consider my flavour text.

To add onto me trusting Tina "super fast", what I meant by that was I personally felt like I could trust her by gut instinct, and it was risky because she has yet to post.

I actually really dislike the first line about the red inspect bc tbh I don't even think that Unravel inspected you to begin with. Acquising to this real quick makes much more sense for a scumteam member rather than a straight out denial. Kinda reminds me of Improbable mafia when Unravel claimed day cop with a red check on Farobi, but we lynched him because of how he handled himself

I want to say Justin is legit just because I feel the post restrictions are more likely to be on town than scum and besides his super early game he hasn't given me much reason to be that sus of. and there's no way he's faking, even less likely than Dad.

Daniel should be shot by vig tonight. Honestly. His posts are contentless spam. NO VOTES ON HIM THOUGH. I will like he's trying to bait somebody onto him

I?m still in favor of either lynching Mog (for silent and dismissive behavior), or Dolby (for taking the beginning of day one wayyyy too seriously) uwu

- - - Post Merge - - -

I didn?t realize waffles was being serious in their day cop claim. But I guess in this kind of game you can literally claim anything lol OwO

Sensai also has been acting pretty defensive and I?m not a big fan of what they?re posting

Also I haven?t gotten any DMs from anyone so contact me -w-

- - - Post Merge - - -

Whoops I made the first post too small sorry ;-;;;

If you like that Waffle's claim is serious and that Sensai doesn't look good, why are you voting for me over Sensai

And as a btw


GeoniToday at 4:39 AM
Tina is hella towny in my PMs so far btw

- - - Post Merge - - -

For "this is just so bad" im refering to Sensai rather than Tina

 

[unravel]

Let me clarify that I believe my actions is a trap please be be careful what you send an action or whatever cuz this game is similar to Improbable mafia which i cud sense it

- - - Post Merge - - -

Kinda reminds me of Improbable mafia when Unravel claimed day cop with a red check on Farobi, but we lynched him because of how he handled himself

Clarification from Dolby
My role in Improbable mafia 2 was an innocent child I died because there was a plot twist which the host didnt give me that info and its "when a player sents ANY action" ill be dead

- - - Post Merge - - -

And guys the cop joke i claim was bianca's mini game i recall those correctly