Mafia The Battle of the Nobles- Endgame

[Dolby]

Looks at win condition
Look at avatar

All hail Eternal President ruler Vanessa

 

[N e s s]

Im just gonna merge these RQS

What is your timezone and how active will you be?
CST and pretty active
Preferred pronouns and/or nicknames?
He/him and please type my username as Ness
Do you prefer being town or mafia?
Mafia
Guess the scum team:
Trundle, Jacob, Chele, Biancasbotique
Who would you fearkill N1?
Dolby, Toadsworthy, Jacob
Who can best read you/who can you read the best?
I can probably read Punchy, heyden, Rune and Evan the best. Toadsworthy can probably read me better than anyone here.
Do you think it's fair to read people based off their RQS answers?
Yeah some of these answers will be good to look back on later on in the game. The Guess-maf question might help later and maybe the fearkill one.

 

[Dolby]

Q1 - Preferred pronouns:
He/Him/Dear Leader
Q2 - Do you prefer playing as town or mafia?:
Mafia
Q3 - Do you think it's fair to read people off their RQS answers?:
There are very few situations where it's useful. Generally, no because it has pertinance, however I probably could point to a couple of instances where maf ****ed up big in the RQS. Pretty non-committal I know, but it's rarely relevant
Q4 - What are indicators of someone (any random person) being scum in your opinion?:
Tbh, lowkey don't like that Ness and Toads were pushing for Vanessa to make the RQS. This defenetly applies more to Toads (100% a committed null rn before he blows up on me tbc) but its kinda sucking up to the King already and I don't like it because it's capitulating to the king completely running the thing. Tbh, it's somewhat gut but that's how I can best articulate it
Q5 - Guess scumteam right now:
Of the 6-7 people who have posted I'd select Runeraider (kinda remember a lazy entrance from her back in APM when she was scum) and Toads/Ness as the people that I like the least at this point. There isn't much the I like, but a push for king to make RQS is something that I'm somewhat against. Frankly, if I got 1/3 from this, I'd be more than happy

- - - Post Merge - - -

Brb, gonna grab dinner

 

[Jacob]

What is your timezone and how active will you be? EST, and idk, classes start again tomorrow
Preferred pronouns and/or nicknames? he him
Do you prefer being town or mafia? mafia always
Guess the scum team: mog definitely idk who else tho
Who would you fearkill N1?Dolby
Who can best read you/who can you read the best? probs dolby. I can't read anyone

- - - Post Merge - - -

Do you think it's fair to read people off their RQS answers?: sometimes they can be telling I think but its more useful just to get people talking tbh

What are indicators of someone (any random person) being scum in your opinion?: I rely heavily on reading posts' wording usually

 

[Antonio]

What is your timezone and how active will you be? EST and classes begin on Tuesday but I am known to procrastinate so I will mostly be here.
Preferred pronouns and/or nicknames? He/him and Y'all can call me Antonio.
Do you prefer being town or mafia? Mafia because I love lying.
Guess the scum team: How many are there? I need to go check the main post before I go any further. :/
Who would you fear kill N1? Dolby, if he's playing. I wouldn't have guessed he was scum last game by the way he went for Dad.
Who can best read you/who can you read the best? I am horrible at reading so I don't know. .-. Also, not 100% aware who knows me best to read me but in the last game, the majority thought I was scum until I made an oppsie and I was modkilled. I was a townie in that game.

Anyways, I'm going to figure out how to setup this printer. If anyone wants to help me, private message me. I'll send my discord information but I think I left my cord at my mom's house. I think I did.

 

[Heyden]

1. What is your timezone and how active will you be? AEST +11 very active
2. Preferred pronouns and/or nicknames? He/him and Hayden/Heyden idc
3. Do you prefer being town or mafia? Mafia as long as my team is good lol
4. Guess the scum team: Dolby, Bianca, Toads, Rune
5. Who would you fearkill N1? Ness, Dolby
6. Who can best read you/who can you read the best? I can read mog, unravel, tae, trundle I think. I have a very hard time reading jacob and ness usually. People who can read me best, idk I think toads was the only person last game who pinned me down initially.
7. Do you think it's fair to read people off their RQS answers? Yes, people say awkward things as scum
8. What are indicators of someone (any random person) being scum in your opinion?:
Inconsistent reads is a big one

[B]1. What is your timezone and how active will you be?[/B]
[B]2. Preferred pronouns and/or nicknames?[/B]
[B]3. Do you prefer being town or mafia?[/B]
[B]4. Guess the scum team:[/B]
[B]5. Who would you fearkill N1?[/B]
[B]6. Who can best read you/who can you read the best?[/B]
[B]7. Do you think it's fair to read people off their RQS answers?[/B]
[B]8. What are indicators of someone (any random person) being scum in your opinion?:[/B]

 

[N e s s]

Oh wait I forgot to do Vanessa's indicator question

Personally I see Trundle as the most suspicious at this point in time. His check in post is a bit shady to me due to his history.

I'm not one to do a traditional check in post but meta pretty much forces me to.

This implies that he is actively conscious about the way he is appearing in thread. Pretty much nobody is going to pay attention to someone's meta whether or not they do a check in, so it appears as though Trundle wants to look good early.

 

[Antonio]

Oh, another question.

Do you think it's fair to read people based off their RQS answers? If the only thing you got for susing a person is there reqs then that really isn't much. It all depends on the situtation, really. I always thought reqs was used as a way to get the game started, tbh.

 

[illunie]

everyones just making up their own rqs so i guess im just stealing the most recent one

1. What is your timezone and how active will you be? AEDT and as active as i feel like while still being useful, depends on if i feel like i can do smth or not i guess, prob will end up being fairly active tho
2. Preferred pronouns and/or nicknames? she/her and rune
3. Do you prefer being town or mafia? town bc reading ppl and metagaming is my one talent lol, i suck so hard as maf it feels good to have a chance at winning
4. Guess the scum team: john wick from fortnite (idk atm i cant rly remember how to read anyone so im kinda riding blind atm)
5. Who would you fearkill N1? dolby or oath bc theyre old and spooky
6. Who can best read you/who can you read the best? i think im rly easy to read so everyone i guess, and as i said before i cant rly remember ppls metagame so ur guess is as good as mine as to who ill be able to read
7. Do you think it's fair to read people off their RQS answers? i mean its the start of the game so im not gonna place any major importance on them but every bit of information helps build a strong case imo, just prob not an excellent idea to make it as a foundation rather than a single point in a list of many against or for a person
8. What are indicators of someone (any random person) being scum in your opinion?: uhh dolby i guess bc literally everyone is gonna make a lazy entrance imo so picking on someone for that feels super weak, but only bc i have to pick someone and it also made me feel warm and fuzzy inside so like who cares

 

[amazonevan19]

1. What is your timezone and how active will you be?
PST, fairly active though I tend to forget about games sometimes

2. Preferred pronouns and/or nicknames?
He/him and Evan is fine

3. Do you prefer being town or mafia?
I'm growing more and more to firmly like town the best. Although it's fun conspiring with good mafia partners, I enjoy having a sense of mystery about a game and finding "whodunnit." Despite me being hard on myself, I actually seem to have a decent mafia smeller at times.

4. Guess the scum team:
lol

5. Who would you fearkill N1?
Dolby or Ness

6. Who can best read you/who can you read the best?
Dolby can usually read me well though he didn't last game; Vanessa usually gets me right from what I remember too.

7. Do you think it's fair to read people off their RQS answers?
I think RQS only help once we know a couple of alignments. Like once a scum dies, we can go back to their RQS and maybe try to gather clues based on what they said. But generally speaking, the only time RQS are ever AI is when someone scumslips in them, and that's not very common.

8. What are indicators of someone (any random person) being scum in your opinion?:
Not showing up in the thread, going after someone/tunnelling someone I trust, being overly defensive, power role fishing, buddying

 

[Antonio]

Ah, I missed one. xD
What are indicators of someone (any random person) being scum in your opinion? Well, idk. Usually, if someone goes with the flow rather than sticking with their gut, don't provide good arguements/counter arguements, or lack fact in their statements. It all depends on a situation, really.

 

[Chele]

Hi.
What is your timezone and how active will you be?
GMT +13 and I’ll probably be very active. However, I may have nobody to talk to whenever I’m active since nobody is online during my time.
Preferred pronouns and/or nicknames?
She/her.
Do you prefer being town or mafia?
Town, because I feel less-pressured and I’m not good as Mafia.
Guess the scum team:
Evan, Tae, Temptations and Rune. This is purely a guess.
Who would you fearkill N1?
Waffles (unravel), because I struggle to read her the most. Her meta also tells a twisted story.
Who can best read you/who can you read the best?
I think that Dolby could read me in 1 second because of how bad I am, and maybe Bianca? Bianca learnt to never trust me again after one of the games lol. I guess the only person I could read well is Punchy, because of how obvious he is at times.
Do you think it's fair to read people off their RQS answers?
No, I don’t. RQ’s are just questions that are asked to drum up conversation, and nobody could know or expect what is to happen in the game. You shouldn’t be read off of RQ’s since they are not alignment indicative at all, and your perspective could change at any time during the game.
What are indicators of someone (any random person) being scum in your opinion?
Meta is something that I barely refer to, but I’d say their reads and the way they act around specific players.

 

[illunie]

4. Guess the scum team:
lol

explain pls, y no answer

 

[Antonio]

Oh, a fresh face. Welcome, chele!

 

[amazonevan19]

explain pls, y no answer

there's no reason for me to guess. It's picking names out of a hat. In fact, I will actually use random.org to make a list right now.

toadsworthy, tae, mogyay, and unravel

Was that helpful? No. That's why I didn't answer it.

 

[Antonio]

there's no reason for me to guess. It's picking names out of a hat. In fact, I will actually use random.org to make a list right now.

toadsworthy, tae, mogyay, and unravel

Was that helpful? No. That's why I didn't answer it.

Why didn't you state that it was a useless question then? "lol" seemed very vague and like you didn't want to answer that question.

 

[Dolby]

6. Who can best read you/who can you read the best?
Dolby can usually read me well though he didn't last game; Vanessa usually gets me right from what I remember too.

you do realize I was maf last game right? Lol

 

[illunie]

there's no reason for me to guess. It's picking names out of a hat. In fact, I will actually use random.org to make a list right now.

toadsworthy, tae, mogyay, and unravel

Was that helpful? No. That's why I didn't answer it.

y even include the question if ur not gonna answer it, like either make a point in ur post about y u dont like the question or dont include it at all, unless ur worried about being called up about not answering the question or smth?

 

[amazonevan19]

Why didn't you state that it was a useless question then? "lol" seemed very vague and like you didn't want to answer that question.

Because I was too lazy to either do random.org like I just did, or get into a protracted battle over why I feel it's a useless question.

Since both have/are happening now, I should've just said it was up front.

@Dolby

Still a misread. Kappa

- - - Post Merge - - -

y even include the question if ur not gonna answer it, like either make a point in ur post about y u dont like the question or dont include it at all, unless ur worried about being called up about not answering the question or smth?

Because not answering/not including it would look sus too. I was answering all the questions and like I just told Antonio, I was too lazy to type my reasoning and I didn't want to get into a long back and forth over the usefulness of the question.

 

[Jacob]

Guess the scum team: How many are there? I need to go check the main post before I go any further. :/
Who would you fear kill N1? Dolby, if he's playing. I wouldn't have guessed he was scum last game by the way he went for Dad.

This is the first red flag I've noticed so far. I understand not reading opening posts before diving into the thread because the game just started and it's exciting, but why not check the main post if the question requires you to know the player list, and he explicitly acknowledged the need to read the post to know the amount of mafia. basically dodge this question purposefully

Also, dolby's name was mentioned in a post or two before the rqs were even posted, so I kinda doubt he didn't know dolby was in the game