Mafia The Battle of the Nobles- Endgame

[amazonevan19]

Slightest of TRs on Antonio and Rune for latching on to my RQ answer; it was lazy play and it's hard to see scum trying to get me over this. Could also be opportunistic scum but seriously? This early on? Nahh I doubt it

 

[illunie]

This is the first red flag I've noticed so far. I understand not reading opening posts before diving into the thread because the game just started and it's exciting, but why not check the main post if the question requires you to know the player list, and he explicitly acknowledged the need to read the post to know the amount of mafia. basically dodge this question purposefully

Also, dolby's name was mentioned in a post or two before the rqs were even posted, so I kinda doubt he didn't know dolby was in the game

i kinda didnt read the main post before doing rqs either so i dont think thats a scumtell in and of itself, just antonio being his regular goof self. have u played with antonio before?

 

[Antonio]

I mean, there could've been a better response rather than just "lol", right? You also explained why it was a useless question after being confronted so why couldn't you just have explained it within the reqs. I mean, you say you are too lazy to explain it within reqs but you weren't lazy to explain it once rune questioned you.

 

[Jacob]

i kinda didnt read the main post before doing rqs either so i dont think thats a scumtell in and of itself, just antonio being his regular goof self. have u played with antonio before?

I have but mostly like a year or two ago, one recent game

 

[amazonevan19]

i kinda didnt read the main post before doing rqs either so i dont think thats a scumtell in and of itself, just antonio being his regular goof self. have u played with antonio before?

This. Antonio dumbtells all the time. Hell, I've posted about people not in the game before, on both this website and another mafia forum, just because I assumed they were in when they weren't.

 

[illunie]

Slightest of TRs on Antonio and Rune for latching on to my RQ answer; it was lazy play and it's hard to see scum trying to get me over this. Could also be opportunistic scum but seriously? This early on? Nahh I doubt it

i didnt latch on i asked a question when u didnt give enough information lol, y r u perceiving it as an attack on ur reputation as town

 

[amazonevan19]

I mean, there could've been a better response rather than just "lol", right? You also explained why it was a useless question after being confronted so why couldn't you just have explained it within the reqs. I mean, you say you are too lazy to explain it within reqs but you weren't lazy to explain it once rune questioned you.

I didn't think anyone would get on my case over it, so I just wanted to dismiss the question quickly since I didn't see any use for it. And now that I'm forced to explain, I did.

 

[illunie]

Because not answering/not including it would look sus too. I was answering all the questions and like I just told Antonio, I was too lazy to type my reasoning and I didn't want to get into a long back and forth over the usefulness of the question.

and y exactly do u care about not looking sus

 

[amazonevan19]

i didnt latch on i asked a question when u didnt give enough information lol, y r u perceiving it as an attack on ur reputation as town

?? I don't see it as an attack on my towniness though. Yes, you jumped on my answer, but didn't explicitly turn it against me. At least not yet

 

[Heyden]

This is the first red flag I've noticed so far. I understand not reading opening posts before diving into the thread because the game just started and it's exciting, but why not check the main post if the question requires you to know the player list, and he explicitly acknowledged the need to read the post to know the amount of mafia. basically dodge this question purposefully

Also, dolby's name was mentioned in a post or two before the rqs were even posted, so I kinda doubt he didn't know dolby was in the game

That's exactly what I was thinking, but honestly every game I play with Antonio he's not very attentive so imo it's not really indicative of anything, even though it should be considering he's play 10+ games already.

Rn I think Evan is kinda town, I feel scum evan wouldn't be that stupid to bring attention to himself bc he's kind of an easily lynchable person (people aren't really hesitant to lynch him, unlike dolby, ness, toads, jacob, etc), and as scum would he not just save the trouble and name 4 different people?

Also Chele's RQS when she answered the RQS question, idk how to feel about that. Most people answer the fearkill from a mafia POV but she answered from a town POV which is interesting.

- - - Post Merge - - -

he's played*
ignore my grammar

 

[Antonio]

This is the first red flag I've noticed so far. I understand not reading opening posts before diving into the thread because the game just started and it's exciting, but why not check the main post if the question requires you to know the player list, and he explicitly acknowledged the need to read the post to know the amount of mafia. basically dodge this question purposefully

Also, dolby's name was mentioned in a post or two before the rqs were even posted, so I kinda doubt he didn't know dolby was in the game

I'm too busy multitasking with this printer but after posting, I didn't see the roles listed on the main post so I don't know how many mafias there are. Unless I missed it. Also, I haven't check the day post yet, because this printer is irrating me. Basically, I'm busy doing other things so I'm just skimming around and such.

I'm gonna go check the day post right now, actually.

 

[amazonevan19]

and y exactly do u care about not looking sus

Would rather not die, thank you very much.

Seriously, all I did was copy paste and go through the list of questions, and when I got to 3 I was just like "this is dumb" so I put "lol." That's all I thought. I didn't want to NOT put ANYTHING down, but I also wanted to show I didn't think the question was worth answering.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'm too busy multitasking with this printer but after posting, I didn't see the roles listed on the main post so I don't know how many mafias there are. Unless I missed it. Also, I haven't check the day post yet, because this printer is irrating me. Basically, I'm busy doing other things so I'm just skimming around and such.

I'm gonna go check the day post right now, actually.

there's four scums, per Damniel's day post

 

[Antonio]

Would rather not die, thank you very much.

Seriously, all I did was copy paste and go through the list of questions, and when I got to 3 I was just like "this is dumb" so I put "lol." That's all I thought. I didn't want to NOT put ANYTHING down, but I also wanted to show I didn't think the question was worth answering.

- - - Post Merge - - -



there's four scums, per Damniel's day post

Just saw. I doubt Damniel would pick the same mafia members like last game so anyone ones but Dolby, Dad, and Vanessa. Unless it's random. Idk. .-.

 

[illunie]

Just saw. I doubt Damniel would pick the same mafia members like last game so anyone ones but Dolby, Dad, and Vanessa. Unless it's random. Idk. .-.

end my life we are not metagaming the scum team picks i swear to christ almighty

 

[amazonevan19]

Just saw. I doubt Damniel would pick the same mafia members like last game so anyone ones but Dolby, Dad, and Vanessa. Unless it's random. Idk. .-.

First of all, dad isn't in this game.

Secondly, it probably is (and should) be random.

Thirdly, this is an awful way to scumhunt and we shouldn't do it.

 

[illunie]

i will purposefully crush all of my fingers in a car door before i start guessing the scum team based off of metagame

 

[Dolby]

What is your timezone and how active will you be? EST and classes begin on Tuesday but I am known to procrastinate so I will mostly be here.
Preferred pronouns and/or nicknames? He/him and Y'all can call me Antonio.
Do you prefer being town or mafia? Mafia because I love lying.
Guess the scum team: How many are there? I need to go check the main post before I go any further. :/
Who would you fear kill N1? Dolby, if he's playing. I wouldn't have guessed he was scum last game by the way he went for Dad.
Who can best read you/who can you read the best? I am horrible at reading so I don't know. .-. Also, not 100% aware who knows me best to read me but in the last game, the majority thought I was scum until I made an oppsie and I was modkilled. I was a townie in that game.

Anyways, I'm going to figure out how to setup this printer. If anyone wants to help me, private message me. I'll send my discord information but I think I left my cord at my mom's house. I think I did.

Holy **** is this fake dumbtell extraordinare. An "I love lying" reference, not knowing I'm in the game dispite being in like 1/3 of the posts already, giving no explanation as to why I'd be a fear kill (instead praising my mafia play), and not knowing how many maf there are. Holy ****, this either betrays a blatant not reading of a single post (including the OP), or, I don't even know what

Oh wait I forgot to do Vanessa's indicator question

Personally I see Trundle as the most suspicious at this point in time. His check in post is a bit shady to me due to his history.



This implies that he is actively conscious about the way he is appearing in thread. Pretty much nobody is going to pay attention to someone's meta whether or not they do a check in, so it appears as though Trundle wants to look good early.

Like this from Ness

Just saw. I doubt Damniel would pick the same mafia members like last game so anyone ones but Dolby, Dad, and Vanessa. Unless it's random. Idk. .-.

Lowkey like this despite being a horrendous line of thinking because tbh I don't think Antonio wants to shut off targets by going down this route

- - - Post Merge - - -

Gonna just cast aside the whole of that post of Antonio's being a fake dumbtell because they're clearly inattentive

 

[Antonio]

@Dolby, I said "I love lying" in the last game or something along the lines. It's a neutral statement.

 

[Dolby]

@Dolby, I said "I love lying" in the last game or something along the lines. It's a neutral statement.

i know you said that. I was saying that you felt to self-aware there

 

[illunie]

Gonna just cast aside the whole of that post of Antonio's being a fake dumbtell because they're clearly inattentive

look at what ur doing to ppl antonio