Mafia The Battle of the Nobles- Endgame

[toadsworthy]

If that's true , are you saying rune is town since punchy is still here?

Rune is townish because she was on the jacob train like third to vote. She could've done anything else to save her scummate so that makes no sense. Punchy being here is because mafia sure as heck wasn't gonna kill him and something happened to the big or we have no vig

 

[Chele]

Dolby also said that if Punchy comes back town, he would be reading me significantly different. but I don't want punchy to die

I feel dolby gave this game at least a sense of order, and its rapidly descending into chaos

Why don’t you want Punchy dead? His alignment would give us the most information tbh.
And from then on, we could actually lynch with reason.

 

[unravel]

Im not saying toads is town but lynching punchy would lead different us somewhere as i already said few post ago and chele replied to it

 

[Chele]

Rune is townish because she was on the jacob train like third to vote. She could've done anything else to save her scummate so that makes no sense. Punchy being here is because mafia sure as heck wasn't gonna kill him and something happened to the big or we have no vig

You’re sussing me for coasting through EoD, but how about Rune. She participated less than I did.

 

[Biancasbotique]

Okay in all seriousness what is your final decision who do we lynch?

For me I can't scumlean toads yet I'm just waiting for punchy's alignment if punchy is really town then mafia is planning to do chaotic for today and frame toads that would make sense right? Then again there are possible different scenarios in the game

I agree , mafia could be framing toads with Dolby kill. It's a win win for them because Dolby is someone they want to get rid of fast

 

[mogyay]

I agree , mafia could be framing toads with Dolby kill. It's a win win for them because Dolby is someone they want to get rid of fast

or mafia just want us to think it's a frame but it's actually not, sometimes the most obvious scenario is the best one bc no one could believe it could be true

 

[Biancasbotique]

or mafia just want us to think it's a frame but it's actually not, sometimes the most obvious scenario is the best one bc no one could believe it could be true

that's a possibility i agree. I still believe Punchy's alignment will give answers on the strategy of mafia. If Punchy is mafia, then that whole Punchy/Jacob dynamics is a tactic and we can at least deduce what the other two mafia are doing

 

[unravel]

Im not saying toads is town but lynching punchy would lead different us somewhere as i already said few post ago and chele replied to it

Why is there unnecessarily words when I type something ffs

 

[toadsworthy]

Why don’t you want Punchy dead? His alignment would give us the most information tbh.
And from then on, we could actually lynch with reason.

omg
because he is not scummmmmm..... lynching for information is just as dumb as following cracked PoE. Is it really gonna help us overall

 

[mogyay]

omg
because he is not scummmmmm..... lynching for information is just as dumb as following cracked PoE. Is it really gonna help us overall

u were wrong about jacob so.. u should entertain the thought u might b wrong again. yes it will help us, u're working against town

 

[unravel]

or mafia just want us to think it's a frame but it's actually not, sometimes the most obvious scenario is the best one bc no one could believe it could be true

Yeah I would agree to this possibility as well mog you too have a point

 

[Chele]

omg
because he is not scummmmmm..... lynching for information is just as dumb as following cracked PoE. Is it really gonna help us overall

Yes it will help us overall. It?d even help for your reads, if you were town and genuinely thinking that I?m Mafia. If Punchy flipped Town then that?d actually help you lead a lynch on Bianca and I. I don?t know why you?re so against this situation. Plus, I think we have two more days until MYLO.

 

[Biancasbotique]

Yes it will help us overall. It’d even help for your reads, if you were town and genuinely thinking that I’m Mafia. If Punchy flipped Town then that’d actually help you lead a lynch on Bianca and I. I don’t know why you’re so against this situation. Plus, I think we have two more days until MYLO.

yes that will strengthen your case against me . I hope he flips mafia btw but if he is town , I'm goner (maybe)

 

[toadsworthy]

or mafia just want us to think it's a frame but it's actually not, sometimes the most obvious scenario is the best one bc no one could believe it could be true

If I'm scum and punchy is scum... why kill dolby? everyone by now knows what he was thinking, thats not gonna stop you guys from lynching the two of us. But in this world, why would I purposefully put myself in the middle of two of my scummates knowing I can't save one. With a whole game ahead of me, would that really be worth it? Also why would I align myself so closely to punchy and have him start saying that anyone who town reads him should be sus. If I'm going through all the trouble to fight off everyone on him, why allow him to say that.

If I'm scum and punchy is town, still why would I kill dolby? He was saying that I would be cleared if dolby came up town which I would know ahead of time and keep him to make me look better.

none of these scenarios make sense

If punchy is scum, ya'll are still gonna lynch me because of everything dolby said...

- - - Post Merge - - -

LITERALLY EVERYONE WANTS TO JUST OFF PUNCHY SO QUICK, WHY IS THIS NOT A RED FLAG FOR ANYONE ELSE

- - - Post Merge - - -

u were wrong about jacob so.. u should entertain the thought u might b wrong again. yes it will help us, u're working against town

when has a majority on something ever stopped me from making my opinion known. I strong read evan last game based on my analysis and I have the same feeling about punchy and all of this rn. I mean I literally can't stop you from leading his lynch, but you know I'm coming for your head if I'm right

 

[mogyay]

town, please don't let toad guilt you, it's absolutely not a red flag for us to watch to lynch punchy, he is absolutely our best bet at figuring out mafia (regardless if somehow he is town), there is absolutely no one else who comes close to being as scummy as punchy (although couple ppl are getting close now with this) so you don't have to feel bad about it, it's logical, it reveals a lot about alignment, punchy has manipulated us, he has played up to our emotions, when he thought he would die he tried to push a lynch on to bianca

it's a red flag for u not to want us to lynch punchy

 

[toadsworthy]

who does lynching punchy give us information about?

me for one? who else?

 

[Heyden]

Honestly Jacob voted trundle and mog followed right after, if anything scum would AVOID bunching votes together, especially with intent of lynching the town trundle cos that would look bad for the pair of them. The fact that you actually think mog is scum just makes me thing ur even more wrong about punchy being town lol.

 

[Biancasbotique]

Well I think that if we figure out Punchy's alignment and compare it with Jacob, we can literally look at the final hours of day one and see everybody's movements/motivations. no?

 

[mogyay]

who does lynching punchy give us information about?

me for one? who else?

you're just being manipulative, you're guilting us for wanting to lynch punchy but not giving any other suggestions about who to lynch? it's beyond weird. this is stupid, it would give info on just about everyone on jacob vs punchy, no one else we can lynch would give us that much information

 

[N e s s]

To be honest I'm starting to think things aren't adding up so clearly at the moment, something isn't right

- - - Post Merge - - -

Don't get me wrong I kinda feel like Punchy's death is a necessity but I'm starting to think that everything isn't as it seems, Yoads has a point that everyone is being really quick to hop on this