Mafia The Battle of the Nobles- Endgame

[toadsworthy]

atm punchy and toad, not gonna give up evan either but itll prob be between the other two, off the top of my head itll prob be punchy but i still want time to think

so literally I have to choose between myself or the town lean I've had since the start.... thats a terrible position to be in. I mean if I'm picking between me and punchy, I obviously pick punchy. But I hope you think long and hard about it. What changed you from thinking punchy was town at the start of the day.

 

[illunie]

wait im scumreading toads bc of dolby and dolby thought that the maf team was specifically punchy / toads i think, so if punchys town thats good for toads i think? lemme reread dolbys case

- - - Post Merge - - -

so literally I have to choose between myself or the town lean I've had since the start.... thats a terrible position to be in. I mean if I'm picking between me and punchy, I obviously pick punchy. But I hope you think long and hard about it. What changed you from thinking punchy was town at the start of the day.

i still think punchys town but i dont think im ever gonna convince the rest of town, and we have a bunch of mls to work with, it might make sense to flip punchy just to be sure

 

[Damniel]

Temporarily locked for rule breaking issues, will open when I figure a solution

 

[Heyden]

It wasn't rlly active hunting it was more a passive thought which is obv not allowed but it's not that serious and not alignment indicative so if you want him /out just replace him imo. just my 2 cents

 

[toadsworthy]

why can't we talk about kingmaker identity anyway? is that in most kingmaker set ups?

 

[Damniel]

Temptations has been removed from the game breaking the following rule:

Things to Keep in Mind:
— This is a semi-open setup. Not all roles stated in the third post will be used. Quoting PMs from me is against the rules, but quoting details from the roles post is fine.
— Discussion of the identity of the kingmaker is strictly prohibited (i.e. guessing who it is, asking them to claim, or claiming yourself). Any rule breakers will be quickly modkilled.

Since it is early in the game and all players are active, I will be first looking for a replacement before modkilling. If I cannot replace by the end of Day Three, the slot will be modkilled.

The slot cannot be executed or have any actions performed on for the time being.

 

[Heyden]

i had a heart attack i thought he got modkilled and was blue lmao

 

[N e s s]

antonio_irl

 

[toadsworthy]

wellllll, on that note I'm going to sleep

- - - Post Merge - - -

antonio_irl

best game over music by far

 

[Damniel]

why can't we talk about kingmaker identity anyway? is that in most kingmaker set ups?

I know I deleted the mechanics part before Day One started, but it's to prevent easy townclearing. The mechanics section may not be there now (I take responsibility for that) but it's been a rule that was stated well before the game started. If anyone had an issue with the rule, it should have been voted by WotC

 

[amazonevan19]

damn I have a lot to catch up on. I did see Dolby and Trundle are RIP and that rune is hesitating on axing Punchy, which I find sus but she has her reasons I suppose.

Will try to make a better post with more thoughts after a gaming session with a friend, but I really REALLY want Punchy gone to help us solve this game.

We really do need to consider who's scum if Punchy is town though - I see a lot of people are just going "Punchy = scum then woot, Punchy = town then we give up." No, if Punchy is town, there has to be other things tying Jacob's other scummates to Jacob. We can't be lazy and count our eggs before they're hatched.

 

[illunie]

Temptations has been removed from the game breaking the following rule:



Since it is early in the game and all players are active, I will be first looking for a replacement before modkilling. If I cannot replace by the end of Day Three, the slot will be modkilled.

The slot cannot be executed or have any actions performed on for the time being.

god can u pls stop flexing on me ik u created the universe and ur kinda a big deal but like cmon dude not rn

 

[Chele]

antonio_irl

I shouldn’t have laughed at this

Also at this point in the game I’m just waiting for 24 hours to exucute

- - - Post Merge - - -

Execute* I think I should take a break tbh

 

[Damniel]

Dedenne2 will be replacing Temptations, welcome!

 

[dedenne]

hi im gonna spend the rest of my life reading up

 

[Heyden]

I shouldn’t have laughed at this

Also at this point in the game I’m just waiting for 24 hours to exucute

- - - Post Merge - - -

Execute* I think I should take a break tbh

me too idk what to say cos I've been anticipating Punchy's alignment for 36 hours

hi im gonna spend the rest of my life reading up

good luck and thank u

 

[Chele]

hi im gonna spend the rest of my life reading up

Omg it’s Dedenne <3

Welcome. Maybe just read on what has happened around EoN up until now. Jacob got lynched as mafia and Dolby and Trundle got killed during the night, Dolby’s death being a reason to silence him by the Mafia and Trundle’s being that he was confirmed town. Now, we want to lynch the scummy Punchy. You may wanna look into his posts.

- - - Post Merge - - -

me too idk what to say cos I've been anticipating Punchy's alignment for 36 hours

Would you want a Toads execution if Punchy flipped scum?

 

[amazonevan19]

If punchy flips scum I think obv lynch toads next, they're WAY too buddy-buddy.

Not entirely sure why kingmaker picked rune but they're not the worst choice. I'm really not liking their not following majority...but if we don't have many MLs then kingmaker exists for a reason, to potentially override a bad decision from the broader playerbase.

Who did Jacob townread again? Why aren't we looking into them more?

 

[amazonevan19]

welcome dedenne, have fun speedreading

 

[unravel]

If punchy flips scum I think obv lynch toads next, they're WAY too buddy-buddy.

Not entirely sure why kingmaker picked rune but they're not the worst choice. I'm really not liking their not following majority...but if we don't have many MLs then kingmaker exists for a reason, to potentially override a bad decision from the broader playerbase.

Who did Jacob townread again? Why aren't we looking into them more?

Chele
Ness
Bianca
Antonio
Mog
Unravel
Trundle

I don't really have thoughts on anyone else

Jacob's list from last night. Note the Chele, Ness, and Bianca town leans. I think there is a good chance one of those three is mafia.

Going to repost again just click me to redirect the source