Mafia The Battle of the Nobles- Endgame

[toadsworthy]

you're just being manipulative, you're guilting us for wanting to lynch punchy but not giving any other suggestions about who to lynch? it's beyond weird. this is stupid, it would give info on just about everyone on jacob vs punchy, no one else we can lynch would give us that much information

I just said bianca and chele and gave quick reads about all the people who didn't vote jacob.

 

[Biancasbotique]

I think both mafia and town are quick to hop on Punchy's death. If I am on scum team and Punchy is scum, the faster we get rid of Punchy the better because as long as he is in the game, associations could be made.

and of course, frustrated town just wants him gone.

 

[toadsworthy]

you're just being manipulative, you're guilting us for wanting to lynch punchy but not giving any other suggestions about who to lynch? it's beyond weird. this is stupid, it would give info on just about everyone on jacob vs punchy, no one else we can lynch would give us that much information

you lied essentially or just didn't read what I've been posting and then avoided my question

 

[mogyay]

If I'm scum and punchy is scum... why kill dolby? everyone by now knows what he was thinking, thats not gonna stop you guys from lynching the two of us. But in this world, why would I purposefully put myself in the middle of two of my scummates knowing I can't save one. With a whole game ahead of me, would that really be worth it? Also why would I align myself so closely to punchy and have him start saying that anyone who town reads him should be sus. If I'm going through all the trouble to fight off everyone on him, why allow him to say that.

If I'm scum and punchy is town, still why would I kill dolby? He was saying that I would be cleared if dolby came up town which I would know ahead of time and keep him to make me look better.

none of these scenarios make sense

If punchy is scum, ya'll are still gonna lynch me because of everything dolby said...

- - - Post Merge - - -

LITERALLY EVERYONE WANTS TO JUST OFF PUNCHY SO QUICK, WHY IS THIS NOT A RED FLAG FOR ANYONE ELSE

- - - Post Merge - - -



when has a majority on something ever stopped me from making my opinion known. I strong read evan last game based on my analysis and I have the same feeling about punchy and all of this rn. I mean I literally can't stop you from leading his lynch, but you know I'm coming for your head if I'm right

come for my head then honestly, i'd rather just lynch punchy, i'll deal with all the consequences if he's town

- - - Post Merge - - -

you lied essentially or just didn't read what I've been posting and then avoided my question

now you're calling me a liar? don't stoop this low toad come on. i'll read back what you said now, it's 5am for me

 

[toadsworthy]

come for my head then honestly, i'd rather just lynch punchy, i'll deal with all the consequences if he's town

- - - Post Merge - - -



now you're calling me a liar? don't stoop this low toad come on. i'll read back what you said now, it's 5am for me

I didn't say you are a liar, but saying "I didn't suggest anyone for lynch" is not telling the truth because I just posted reads and ended by saying my two for right now are bianca and chele. I also said that you could've just missed what I read, but I'm a little triggered since dolby straight lied about my drunk posts the other day

 

[mogyay]

you lied essentially or just didn't read what I've been posting and then avoided my question

you're seriously suggesting we lynch bianca and chelle over punchy lmao? like i'm ngl i don't even have a response, chelle's not done anything wrong esp compared to punchy, i'm not gonna respond to that. i've made my feeling clear about bianca and how mafia are using her as a scapegoat, that's my own opinion

 

[toadsworthy]

These are the people who didn't vote for jacob... you could possibly add evan since he joined it last

Punchy - I don't think he is mafia stillllllllllllllllllllllllll, and were left with all the people who literally can't read punchy which is frustrating. He definitely has some weird posts and is bad rn, but like thats just punchy.... typically he is given free reign when not sussed, falls into a lucky PoE and is cleared. Just because he doesn't have that now doesn't mean he is scum. I honestly think he was left by mafia and Dolby was killed to ensure punchy gets lynched... which is fishy to me

Vanessa - killed Jacob, yet didn't vote him. Stands by she was all for a jacob lynch... but didn't vote him. There is nothing really that clears vanessa and she is stepping up to really hammer punchy. She was cool calm and collected as a king, took a back seat most of the day... but when it came down to it her hands really were tied and she had to vote jacob bottom line. That last ditch effort though... if you want to talk about me trying to swerve a lynch onto bianca, you have to take into account that vanessa did a very similar thing.

Heyden - I don't get scum vibes from heyden as much as some of the others. I do have trouble reading you, but your apathy towards punchy right now seems the most genuine. Where as vanessa and chele have gotten new bloodlust

Dolby - I expected most of this day to be me fighting dolby tbh... I was leaning more towards scum for him so this is weird.

Chele - you're rising pretty quick in my scum reads. Good content at first looks like doing analysis, steps aside from EoD madness to not incriminate yourself, puts a vote on punchy and hopes the best for your summate. Like literally I have no idea why were overlooking you so much rn.

Antonio - so jacob's first post was scum reading you for like RQS stuff. I don't know why he would try to suspect his summate right off the bat, so that gives you a bye for right now

Bianca - nothing has changed about my read on you. You are very scummy this game, totally not town bianca

I have scum vibes from vanessa, but my candidates for lynch rn are Chele and Bianca tbh

Here

- - - Post Merge - - -

you're seriously suggesting we lynch bianca and chelle over punchy lmao? like i'm ngl i don't even have a response, chelle's not done anything wrong esp compared to punchy, i'm not gonna respond to that. i've made my feeling clear about bianca and how mafia are using her as a scapegoat, that's my own opinion

bianca is a scapegoat for mafia, but literally 80% or more of this place wants punchy dead rn

- - - Post Merge - - -

you're seriously suggesting we lynch bianca and chelle over punchy lmao? like i'm ngl i don't even have a response, chelle's not done anything wrong esp compared to punchy, i'm not gonna respond to that. i've made my feeling clear about bianca and how mafia are using her as a scapegoat, that's my own opinion

bianca is a scapegoat for mafia, but literally 80% or more of this place wants punchy dead rn

 

[mogyay]

ok sorry i actually did miss that out somehow, i'll read it now but i really don't agree with either of those people

 

[toadsworthy]

that was a weird percentage, but first I wrote all and I knew that wasn't true so I just picked 80

 

[mogyay]

Here

- - - Post Merge - - -



bianca is a scapegoat for mafia, but literally 80% or more of this place wants punchy dead rn

- - - Post Merge - - -



bianca is a scapegoat for mafia, but literally 80% or more of this place wants punchy dead rn

yes because punchy is probably mafia based on his behaviour while to me bianca isn't. the people who all want punchy lynched are town to me (hayden, chelle, waffle) so natually i don't think there's any bandwagon going on. i see it with bianca though

 

[Antonio]

I can't sleep so I'm gonna state my input and then go offline again.

I have stated my reasons on why I think punchy is town however I can see the reasons why this game isn't gonna move forward unless punchy is lynched even though there could be other people who are scum. I'm conflicted, tbh. Vanessa (or was it dad/Dolby), didn't you say last game that me voting for myself was idiotic because you didn't want a day 1 casualty? It's day 2 and is it worth a possible town lynch? I can see some pros and cons.

I still believe that Punchy has a blue role or is even the kingmaker himself. Him not claiming a blue role but rather town could be him not completely claiming because he didn't want to be lynched during night by mafia. Yes, he claimed blue role before but that is old meta and it is risky to claim blue role.

 

[mogyay]

no matter what we do it's gonna be a risk, we may as well make it a calculated risk that we can benefit from. on that i'm going to sleep because it's 5am and i hate my life, i'll be here tomorrow

 

[Antonio]

crap, I forgot about not talking about king maker.

 

[N e s s]

I still believe that Punchy has a blue role or is even the kingmaker himself. Him not claiming a blue role but rather town could be him not completely claiming because he didn't want to be lynched during night by mafia. Yes, he claimed blue role before but that is old meta and it is risky to claim blue role.

Did you even read the rules at all you nincompoop, you're literally not supposed to speculate on the identity of the Kingmaker gdi now unless Daniel is feeling generous you're getting modkilled

 

[Antonio]

ignore that bit and change it to "Punchy has a blue role". I can't edit it :/

- - - Post Merge - - -

Did you even read the rules at all you nincompoop, you're literally not supposed to speculate on the identity of the Kingmaker gdi now unless Daniel is feeling generous you're getting modkilled

It was mistake, I swear. It's midnight and I got ****ty memory.

 

[Chele]

who does lynching punchy give us information about?

me for one? who else?

It’d give info about Chele, you, Bianca, Heyden, Mog, Ness and more. And from PoE, we could get the rest of the scumteam.

Also if you really refuse for a Punchy lynch, the what would ANY other lynch give you?
Lynching either me or Bianca wouldn’t lead you anywhere. If we lynched Punchy, many people would be cleared and it’d actually benefit town a lot.

 

[Antonio]

I have stated last game that my memory is poor. Just ignore that bit, plz.

 

[illunie]

Rune who?s your lynch pool

atm punchy and toad, not gonna give up evan either but itll prob be between the other two, off the top of my head itll prob be punchy but i still want time to think

 

[toadsworthy]

It’d give info about Chele, you, Bianca, Heyden, Mog, Ness and more. And from PoE, we could get the rest of the scumteam.

Also if you really refuse for a Punchy lynch, the what would ANY other lynch give you?
Lynching either me or Bianca wouldn’t lead you anywhere. If we lynched Punchy, many people would be cleared and it’d actually benefit town a lot.

Just everything about lynching punchy feels so wrong, I won't vote for him at all... but I mean ya'll aren't gonna comprehend what I'm saying, believe any of the logic I'v brought up about him. None of you have played with punchy, so you are just falling into what he does.

 

[Antonio]

I'm going offline. I just feel so stupid for forgetting everything. ;-;

- - - Post Merge - - -

Just everything about lynching punchy feels so wrong, I won't vote for him at all... but I mean ya'll aren't gonna comprehend what I'm saying, believe any of the logic I'v brought up about him. None of you have played with punchy, so you are just falling into what he does.

Many of the people susing punchy has played with him.