Mafia The Battle of the Nobles- Endgame

[toadsworthy]

And if punchy flips town, you’re gonna all see what I’ve seen and be like oh yeah, punchy is town

 

[Heyden]

Exactly. If punchy flips scum, I'm going to be more suspicious of those who immediately jump on toads than toads himself

Yeh Toads is an easy bw following this, but I think it’ll be a townled BW considering most ppl I townread scumread toads so, idk I won’t rlly be suspicious of those that jump on him.

 

[cornimer]

I have a hunch Ness is scum but I haven?t bothered making a case yet. If you look at Ness? post filter before EoD1 he?s not really taking a side in Jacob/Punchy until Jacob reaches majority in the last minute.
Not to mention his last minute change after mog decided to change to punchy... hmmmmm

I definitely think both Ness and Evan are kind of sitting in the background and should be looked into. I'm almost certain one of them is scum at this point

- - - Post Merge - - -

Yeh Toads is an easy bw following this, but I think it’ll be a townled BW considering most ppl I townread scumread toads so, idk I won’t rlly be suspicious of those that jump on him.

I think mog is town but the others, idk

Chele will def look good if punchy flips scum

 

[mogyay]

If punchy is scum I don't know if that necessarily means Toads is scum
Why would he so obviously continue to defend Punchy...that just makes him look sus. I think as scum he would know to just go for the bus at this point, unless scum is just REALLY concerned with keeping members alive at the cost of making other members look bad. Idk how great of a strategy that is though, it might get them through the day but it won't get them the win.
Also Toads will be the EASIEST wagon to jump on after Punchy flips scum. He might be being set up so that after scum loses Punchy, Toads is a guaranteed lynch and scum doesn't have to worry about losing another member.
Obviously I don't agree with Toads not wanting to get rid of Punchy. It's very anti-productive for town. But Toads as town is not one to go with the consensus or back off his opinion, as I've said before. I mean back in Caxnival he literally lead like 3 mislynches in a row and was still town. He's often wrong, but that doesnt mean he is scum.

TLR I'm weary of lynching Toads without question after Punchy because it's super easy for scum to frame and pull off

nah, toad has made it VERY clear how he feels about punchy and not lynching him, he made his feelings very clear and pretty early on. him backtracking would be very obvious and even more scummy. may as well ride the train out and receive town points for it, he kinda has to. i suspect he knows him going all out defending punchy will net him town points regardless of how punchy actually flips. if punchy should flip town i might rethink my feelings on toad but as of now i am getting far too many scum vibes from both toad and punchy

also not exactly framing toad if punchy is scum.. like, we as a majority of town would be lynching punchy, i imagine mafia wouldn't have much to do with it (in saying that obviously one mafia member should just be on the we need to lynch punchy thought), so i don't really see how it's mafia actively framing toad, it's just toad being wrong

- - - Post Merge - - -

well i can tell u rn i'm absolutely going to jump on toad if punchy should flip. why are we disregarding everything dolby said lol

- - - Post Merge - - -

should flip mafia****

 

[toadsworthy]

Fuchsia mafia for focused scum punchy

 

[cornimer]

also not exactly framing toad if punchy is scum.. like, we as a majority of town would be lynching punchy, i imagine mafia wouldn't have much to do with it (in saying that obviously one mafia member should just be on the we need to lynch punchy thought), so i don't really see how it's mafia actively framing toad, it's just toad being wrong

- - - Post Merge - - -

well i can tell u rn i'm absolutely going to jump on toad if punchy should flip. why are we disregarding everything dolby said lol

- - - Post Merge - - -

should flip mafia****

Yeah I know scum can't make toads be wrong, but the Dolby kill could've been meant to frame him so it would then be even easier to push a mislynch on Toad. Like they could think, "oh toads is making himself look pretty bad, let's make it look like he was trying to silence Dolby to make him look worse and then advocate to lynch him"
I've townleaned you the whole game and that probably won't change if you go after toads but anyone else, I'll definitely be watching.

 

[unravel]

I'm checking related to Punchy, people who are both scum/townleaning him in a odd way or whatever and I found this

Ness is very very high mafia if Jacob is scum

This post has two things wrong with it. The first reason being that he takes a COMPLETE turnaround and susses Mog now. This is what he's trying to do when he pockets Mog. At the last minute of EoD, he wants to be like 'OMG no Mog is scum!' so that people try to lynch her instead and not link her to Punchy since he 'changed his mind'. The second thing that is wrong with this is that he is shifting the blame onto Ness if Jacob is scum. If Punchy flips mafia, then Ness should be clear in all honesty.

I think this is what Punchy mean't

I'm reading Jacob's meta from the last game he was scum in Legend of Zelda mafia and I don't see a correlation between there and here, I'm seriously kinda wondering if they're both town

God help me if I'm wrong, but I'm switching to Punchy again

Alrighty that's a relief, Jacob was starting to scare me, so before I get called scum for that just know that I was panicking.

Punchy is town, his and Jacobs's interactions pretty much guarantee it.

Ness only appears on EoD, only against either Punchy and Jacob alone but he is purely against Punchy, I think this is the reason why Punchy wanted him to be dead idk?????

Hi I?m awake now

Rune

Bianca and Ness and someone else on my lynch or toads is scum

This is his recent post as of 7:20 PM SGT he wants Ness to be dead this is all i cud think of as of the moment

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'm calling out Punchy regarding Ness suspicion thing thanks

- - - Post Merge - - -

I need your opinions smh

 

[toadsworthy]

nah, toad has made it VERY clear how he feels about punchy and not lynching him, he made his feelings very clear and pretty early on. him backtracking would be very obvious and even more scummy. may as well ride the train out and receive town points for it, he kinda has to. i suspect he knows him going all out defending punchy will net him town points regardless of how punchy actually flips. if punchy should flip town i might rethink my feelings on toad but as of now i am getting far too many scum vibes from both toad and punchy

also not exactly framing toad if punchy is scum.. like, we as a majority of town would be lynching punchy, i imagine mafia wouldn't have much to do with it (in saying that obviously one mafia member should just be on the we need to lynch punchy thought), so i don't really see how it's mafia actively framing toad, it's just toad being wrong

- - - Post Merge - - -

well i can tell u rn i'm absolutely going to jump on toad if punchy should flip. why are we disregarding everything dolby said lol

- - - Post Merge - - -

should flip mafia****

So I'm gonna get scum read no matter what cool. And all you people just yelling about bandwagon to bandwagon are so town?
I can't deny that you have a point about me for sure mog, but I've had plenty of time to make that change very easily by now and if I wanted to stay in town's good graces like scum do to avoid heat I would've thought of a way to do it gracefully by now

 

[unravel]

If some of us cannot afford the Punchy lynch might as well talk about someone related to anti Punchy club, a scenario if ever punchy is really town

 

[mogyay]

i never saw that chelle said that, i thought punchy was joking when he said that he thought i was mafia (although punchy feel free to clarify lol), bc the next message he said king mog and who u trust. regardless like he obv wasn't pushing a lynch on me, i had zero votes. no matter what i feel like i'll be linked to punchy because of his weird 'townlock' and his non stop trust of me, if he's mafia then obviously that's on purpose (or he's trying to pocket me), if he's mafia then it's prob to make me look bad

 

[toadsworthy]

If some of us cannot afford the Punchy lynch might as well talk about someone related to anti Punchy club, a scenario if ever punchy is really town

do you think punchy is scum or town

 

[mogyay]

So I'm gonna get scum read no matter what cool. And all you people just yelling about bandwagon to bandwagon are so town?
I can't deny that you have a point about me for sure mog, but I've had plenty of time to make that change very easily by now and if I wanted to stay in town's good graces like scum do to avoid heat I would've thought of a way to do it gracefully by now

no i said i would rethink how i felt should punchy be town (although prob not), making that change would be much worse and you know it. and look, you could be in town's good graces now bc vanessa and heyden are doubting it so good job toad!!

 

[unravel]

Since 25% think hes scum, 25% think hes town and 50% of us are confused and dunno where to lead right now
If you all think hes really town and/or flips town then we should discuss who is against punchy like Ness or whatever cuz right now I have no leads because no matter wat we will ended up talking about Punchy I got nothing in mind this game is more cancer than any competitive games I play such as league of lesbians

 

[Heyden]

It’s 1am so I have to sleep but once again, there’s no point keeping Punchy alive if we’re just gonna bicket back and forth on his alignment.

 

[unravel]

do you think punchy is scum or town

Like I said few post ago I don't see him as town nor scum imo I'm genuinely confused but part of me wanted to suggest to lynch him because it might lead us somewhere which including alignment who are TL him, punchy's suspicion and people who push him to lynch cuz in the end we will discuss punchy and it's really anti town honestly if we keep talking about punchy we might not finish interrogating who are possible scum players in game right now i think most of us dont have any leads as of the moment

- - - Post Merge - - -

It’s 1am so I have to sleep but once again, there’s no point keeping Punchy alive if we’re just gonna bicket back and forth on his alignment.

^ See

 

[cornimer]

I'm checking related to Punchy, people who are both scum/townleaning him in a odd way or whatever and I found this



I think this is what Punchy mean't





Ness only appears on EoD, only against either Punchy and Jacob alone but he is purely against Punchy, I think this is the reason why Punchy wanted him to be dead idk?????



This is his recent post as of 7:20 PM SGT he wants Ness to be dead this is all i cud think of as of the moment

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'm calling out Punchy regarding Ness suspicion thing thanks

- - - Post Merge - - -

I need your opinions smh

These quotes from Ness make him look really scummy tbh

- - - Post Merge - - -

He was lowkey against a Jacob lynch, voted Jacob but tried to switch off at the last minute, and then was like "oh Jacob was starting to scare me" after he flipped??? If you switched off him he clearly wasnt scaring you that much. Hmmm

 

[unravel]

I have a hunch Ness is scum but I haven?t bothered making a case yet. If you look at Ness? post filter before EoD1 he?s not really taking a side in Jacob/Punchy until Jacob reaches majority in the last minute.
Not to mention his last minute change after mog decided to change to punchy... hmmmmm

I gotchu fam

- - - Post Merge - - -

He was lowkey against a Jacob lynch, voted Jacob but tried to switch off at the last minute, and then was like "oh Jacob was starting to scare me" after he flipped??? If you switched off him he clearly wasnt scaring you that much. Hmmm

I think this is what Heyden is trying to say as well as Punchy but I wanna hear more from Punchy regarding to this I know right now he doesn't feel like playing but at least let it go and play like you play from last game ty Punch.

 

[Biancasbotique]

If there is someone who would know how scum Punchy operates, it would be Vanessa. She is mafia with him in Resistance.

 

[unravel]

That is how the battle of the nobles worked

 

[cornimer]

If there is someone who would know how scum Punchy operates, it would be Vanessa. She is mafia with him in Resistance.

All I remember from resistance is he kept saying Toads/Dolby was a team even though they were the least likely team. He didn't really provide evidence, he just kept insisting, and I think he got townleaned because "he's clearly being sporadic town punchy"

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'll pull up some quotes after my 10:00 class if you want, but I just skimmed the first two pages of his post filter from that game and almost every post is something similar to "Dolby/Toads is obviously the team open your eyes"

- - - Post Merge - - -

I don't find that too unsimillar to how he has pushed for Bianca this game, even though I heavily sussed Bianca day 1 myself.