Mafia The Murder of Woodpines Oregon - Game Thread - Endgame

[dedenne]

Ok I've finished reading, got a few statements

1. I have some doubts about Bianca's theory as I believe in the sign up thread Ness did say he was randomly generating them.(who was whatever role) So she could be with people not on that list or she is just town. I know that was like 20 pages ago but I don't recall anyone saying they were randomly generated.

Um what else was I gonna say...Ok onto the reads

Evan - honestly I don't think I've seen scum Evan , and he is acting like town that I've seen from previous games so slight tl.

Vanessa- good contributions, I still can't tell the difference between scum and town Vanessa but for now tl.

Punchy- noticed a change of style, not as much **** posting, don't want to sus him because of this alone but I see a really big change from the last time I played with him. Null/slight sl

Toads- getting annoyed at placeholders (can't believe I wasted my time reading that argument) , was the first to comment on Punchy's change. Not much substantial but rn he's a tl from me.

Farobi- umm I really don't have much to say. Null.

Amanda- okish reads I think but null.

Locket- came to defend. Stopped getting sussed. Left. Her reads were a bit dusty wasn't as she stated many times but I don't have much to go off here. Null/slight sl.

Antonio- acting like Punchy when he started out, posting random stuff etc. His confusion in places in genuine so he's probably my strongest tl.

Bianca- active, giving comments, she's not posting random stuff but she still seems like town Bianca. Also perfect impression of locket lol. Tl.

Seroja- seems genuine, I don't have much else to say. Slight tl.

Glow- maybe a few more posts? Null.

Rune- joining in with the discussion and making some valid points, tl.

Dedenne2- has terrible reads, town leans everyone, I think we should lynch her.

Panda- not many posts. Null.

Waffles- acting like town Waffles, slight tl.

Sorry a of them are town leans apart from like 3, these are bound to change but I needed to give reads before it was let's lynch Dedenne part 1p

- - - Post Merge - - -

10*

OH GOD DAMNIT I FORGOT THE COLOUR SMH

 

[amanda1983]

finally home from work and im gonna put together i general reads list and address a couple things before i get ready to go out, i will try to check in on the thread throughout the night but as time passes im sure my intoxication level will increase... rip.

Amazonevan19 - i dont know if its just the way i read Evan but he always seems too "agreeable" with everyone.
Vampnessa - not sure
PunchyDaHufflepuff - not sure
Toadsworthy - unusually inactive, but i think he was been busy irl, but theres like a 75% chance he's always mafia ha.
Farobi - something feels off about him but i always find him suspicious.
Amanda1983 - always helpful and active, town lean.
Locket- welcome back please be active.
Antonio - welcome to mafia, seems newbie town so far.
Biancasbotque - i just can't even.
Seroja - town leaning.
glow - i remember her laying low more as town on D1 cause she always gets killed N1 her activity rn makes me feel a little off about her.
Runeraider - have we played together before ?
Dedenne2- you keep posting but not reads when you said you would.
ITookYourWaffles - not sure


Ness can i get the player names linked to their post in the OP please

-- snip --
Short summary reads for now
Amazonevan19 - unsure; contributes a bit; agreed some points
Vampnessa - sounds like genuinely town to me and her post isnt that force-y
PunchyDaHufflepuff - not sure
Toadsworthy - He's always scum
Farobi - Am I the only one who thinks theres def something off about him?
Amanda1983 - always helpful and active, town lean.
Locket- null
Antonio - newbie/townlean
Biancasbotque - I just wanna kill myself...
Seroja - town leaning.
glow - unsure
Panda - summary contribute; unsure lean for now
Runeraider - He seems really different from before kind of townleaning him
Dedenne2- always posting but a bit contribution

Soooo ITYW, could you clarify your reads post when you come back please?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Could we please get clickable names in the OP? And the EoD/N clock in D1 post? Thanks

- - - Post Merge - - -

EBWOP : Could we please get clickable names in the OP? And the EoD/N clock in D1 post? Thanks

 

[PunchyTheCat]

why would a town even need to have a mo other than scumhunt or something slightly more complicated like baiting, idk what ur trying to say here

What's an MO? Still reading the thread btw

- - - Post Merge - - -

yeah, I use the mighty lemon liberally when ****posting

I don't literally think amanda is scum because of pocketing with likes lmao

- - - Post Merge - - -



yeah but the RQs were pretty bad

Fergrfgherfyjghjvejknfewgojrwuyweuidewfui
I
Tried

- - - Post Merge - - -

Ok so I'm really not a fan of toads comparing Waffles to a dog, and wasting a lot of our time arguing with us. I will make my reads today. Yeah, everyone sussing me has pretty valid points. Antonio is so obviously town. The only reasoning I can think of about Lockets thought process is that he is Jester, and he's doing something that he knows that he will be lynched for.

- - - Post Merge - - -

@Locket who would you lynch if you had to lynch some1 rn?

 

[dedenne]

Toads wasn't comparing just waffles to a dog, he was saying generally iirc

 

[toadsworthy]

Tbh Locket so far just seems like last game... where she was town. The only reason she was sussed in the last game too was because we made her a target, otherwise she probably would've been fine

All Bianca has pointed out is that Locket has a set pattern of how she acts, and that she is doing that pattern again.

- - - Post Merge - - -

@punchy
so you are upset about my arguing, yet specifically do things you know will cause more conflict...

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'm actually pretty certain Punchy is mafia, so I'm voting for him
I work at 12 today and will be there until very late, so I'm voting now

 

[cornimer]

20 new pages? It's a spirit of Dolby miracle!

 

[PunchyTheCat]

@punchy
so you are upset about my arguing, yet specifically do things you know will cause more conflict...

I'm actually pretty certain Punchy is mafia, so I'm voting for him

you're voting me on something that was obviously meant as a joke. Oh yeah and also improvement.

 

[toadsworthy]

you're voting me on something that was obviously meant as a joke. Oh yeah and also improvement.

1. You said I'm wasting time with arguing and voting myself. But then proceed to just placeholder vote yourself. You did it to be an ******* and you confirmed it

2. My vote is aside form all of that. Your posts now sound fake and strained, you have notable changes to posts and tone. There is improvement and there is completely different play styles due to scum stress. I see the latter

 

[Locket]

I just felt it was not necessary to talk about it further becuase I am not really annoyed with Locket. Sure ..she sussing me all the time is like eh...but in general I chuckle when she does that

to be honest i almost always sus you

anyway imma finish reading

 

[cornimer]

Quick reads

Amazoneevan19 - His tone seems like other games where he was town and I like some of the things he said in his reads but that isn't enough to strongly townlean him this early in the game.
PunchyDaHufflepuff As everyone has pointed out, his tone seems much different and iirc he has said some confusing and contradictory things (which I don't have time to specifically find right now. However this is also a veeeeery easy wagon for scum to latch onto so I'm hesitant to vote Punchy. I think people also sussed him for having a different tone in RHOM but he was town in that game.
Toadsworthy - I should honestly be banned from townreading toads after last game but his tone seems very genuine and he seems more aggressive like I remember him being in Caxnival when he lead three incorrect lynches. The placeholder vote convo admittedly derailed us from scumhunting for like 10 pages but like I agree that placeholder votes are confusing and not a good tactic, and he was clearly trying to make a statement which I doubt he would do as scum (even though his whole tactic last game was "do things I seemingly wouldn't do as scum.", this just feels different)
Farobi Idk he gave me weird vibes at the beginning of the game, I need to ISO him at some point before I make any conclusions about him though
Amanda1983 - I need to read her other games so I have something to go off but I haven't had time yet
Locket - The main thing that bothered me about Locket was her scumlean on Antonio. I don't understand where it came from and if she is scum, he would be a really easy target for her. I feel like apologizing for subpar reads is something she does every game. But again this is such an easy scumwagon ahhhh
Antonio - Seems pretty noob town so far but I wouldn't 100% town lock him just yet
Biancasbotque - Her tone and ideas seem like town Bianca to me
Seroja - very natural tone, good contributions, she seems to be considering things from multiple angles which I like
glow - Her few posts didn't really make me feel either way about her
Runeraider - He seems pretty different from last game so lots of townpoints there, but I feel like he's gotten involved in a lot of non-scumhunting related circles (eg KP speculation, toads vs waffles) which is the only thing that makes me feel eh.
Dedenne2 - "I needed to give reads before it was let's lynch Dedenne part 10" I literally LOL'd. Well good job on getting a reads list up. I think her tone seems very town and she hasn't acted very different from the games when she was town. The only thing I noticed is that she seems more active but I don't think that alone is enough to raise any flags.
PandaDarling - I always find Panda super scummy but I mean she hasn't done anything different from all the other games where I sussed her and she was town BUT I also don't want to write her off and then she's actually scum this time. So just null for now.
ITookYourWaffles - people are saying she seems different from last game but idk I don't see it that much? I feel like she is just repeating what other people say which I feel like she did a lot last game.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Oh Seroja was supposed to be half green half grey not half black half grey

- - - Post Merge - - -

And the beginning of Evan was supposed to be green too SMH

- - - Post Merge - - -

Those turned out a lot less short than I planned

 

[dedenne]

20 new pages? It's a spirit of Dolby miracle!

That's literally what I thought

 

[Locket]

idk even as town I make wishy washy statements as well. and imo locket isn't a strong maf player (?) and somehow I don't think her being unsure isn't really that deep. I have never played with them before though so I have no idea how she usually act as town.

going on tone alone she's giving me town vibes.

i have played caxnival and american politics so if you wanna go and read a few of my posts there you can (i was town both games)

Okay evan, I kinda agree that Locket might have this as her town M.O....This is me acting like Locket:

(go inactive for awhile)

Bianca: Vote ##Locket

Locket suddenly appears and defends herself.

Locket gets sussed. Tries to defend herself.

Then somehow she gets saved. we lynch someone else.

Then locket turns out to be town anyway.

LOL

but she is known to appear only when being sussed, thats pretty much her M.O.

Locket- came to defend. Stopped getting sussed. Left. Her reads were a bit dusty wasn't as she stated many times but I don't have much to go off here. Null/slight sl.

that's how i've played in caxnival and politics iirc
yesterday i only had about an hour from when i got home from being out all day and then going to bed

@Locket who would you lynch if you had to lynch some1 rn?

i have no idea right now
antonio isn't really a good option for me and i'm starting to doubt my reads about that

i'll go back and read through some people and their posts then see who the best lynch candidate is

- - - Post Merge - - -

@punchy - what games have you been in? i want to read some of your other games

 

[PunchyTheCat]

i have played caxnival and american politics so if you wanna go and read a few of my posts there you can (i was town both games)







that's how i've played in caxnival and politics iirc
yesterday i only had about an hour from when i got home from being out all day and then going to bed



i have no idea right now
antonio isn't really a good option for me and i'm starting to doubt my reads about that

i'll go back and read through some people and their posts then see who the best lynch candidate is

- - - Post Merge - - -

@punchy - what games have you been in? i want to read some of your other games

Every game since Generic Mafia (shyna is basically worthless that game sucks for my meta)

 

[N e s s]

Vote Count 1.0
Less than 8 hours remaining

ITookYourWaffles-1
ITookYourWaffles
Toadsworthy

Locket-1
Biancasbotique

glow-1
Antonio

PunchyDaHufflepuff-1
PunchyDaHufflepuff
Toadsworthy

Not Voting-11
Amazonevan19
Vampnessa
PunchyDaHufflepuff
Farobi
Amanda1983
Locket
Seroja
glow
Runeraider
Dedenne2
PandaDarling

---

Currently, due to being the first to reach 1 vote (Outclasses Waffles due to 2 votes), PunchyDaHufflepuff is currently set to be lynched. You have less than 8 hours remaining to select a lynch.

Post filters coming soon btw.

 

[PunchyTheCat]

Ahh we need to do something.

 

[unravel]

Its 3 30 AM here and I just woke up
You know I'm fine with punchy lynch cuz of his post quality which is kinda off for me he used to be meme-y ish now he's more like trying to take the game seriously (+ a lil bit of contributions which is kinda odd for me imo)

- - - Post Merge - - -

Gonna go back to sleep sayonara

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also I just knew its 8 hours before EoD rip

 

[Biancasbotique]

@Ness...can you explain why Punchy is set to be lynched with one vote as opposed to waffles who did have the early vote on herself?i dont understand what you mean by outclassed?

 

[PunchyTheCat]

speculation time
- two mafia but set 2kp per night
- three mafia with some strongman-like character
- three mafia with fluctuating kp every night

I'm leaning more towards the first one cause that's what popped in my head right away. Also no mention of a third killer party, so it seems like a town v mafia which is pretty relieving

Ok so not really sure on this post, I don't like it, I don't know why. No mention of third killer party? How does that relate to anything? There could totally be a SK! There's no reason behind putting that in, I really don't like that part.

 

[N e s s]

@Ness...can you explain why Punchy is set to be lynched with one vote as opposed to waffles who did have the early vote on herself?i dont understand what you mean by outclassed?

Actually you're right, Waffles is set to be lynched. I saw that punchy voted himself and then toads voted him, but I forgot Punchy unvoted on the same post.

 

[dedenne]

Ok so not really sure on this post, I don't like it, I don't know why. No mention of third killer party? How does that relate to anything? There could totally be a SK! There's no reason behind putting that in, I really don't like that part.

ok this post sounds the most forced tbh. that's it, I'm voting punchy