Mafia The Murder of Woodpines Oregon - Game Thread - Endgame

[amazonevan19]

shes been online for a while so im guessing were gonna see something soon, not to put any pressure on or anything

she liked one of my posts so clearly she is scum trying to pocket me

but yeah I noticed that too; we'll see

 

[Biancasbotique]

I won't be surprised if amanda is scum

 

[illunie]

- Punchy: Only a verrrry slight scumlean due to the stark contrast between his meta and how he's playing now. I'd be ok with lynching him but I don't want to vote for him right now since I need time to evaluate all options.

Punchy would tell us a lot; locket is riskier but we would have good reason to off her too. Getting more comfortable with a Punchy lynch.

im actually not sure if lynching punchy gives us much info because they havent actually done anything yet, unless ur talking about getting info from peoples read on them which i can get behind. punchys probably my best bet rn, but its so meager its probably gonna be subject to a lot of change over the next 24 hrs

 

[Seroja]

@evan, you said waffles was different from last game but which alignment was she in that game and how did she behave differently? I'm sorry I haven't read any mafia games since last year

 

[illunie]

she liked one of my posts so clearly she is scum trying to pocket me

but yeah I noticed that too; we'll see

she liked mine too but i dont know which one because idk where to check so im not sure how far through she is
can u like this one so i can get the notification, u can unlike after

- - - Post Merge - - -

@evan, you said waffles was different from last game but which alignment was she in that game and how did she behave differently? I'm sorry I haven't read any mafia games since last year

she was scum last game, but idk how different she was except being more active and not really giving concrete reads

 

[Biancasbotique]

I don't get why punchy is the best lynch right now. He did tone down a bit in american mafia when everybody knew he is confirmed as town. I see this as just continuation of that.

 

[amazonevan19]

@evan, you said waffles was different from last game but which alignment was she in that game and how did she behave differently? I'm sorry I haven't read any mafia games since last year

she was scum last game, and basically disappeared for a lot of the time, posting inane ramblings when she bothered to be around. Plus her reads lists were like 60% nulls (no joke lmao) and just overall bad.

Here I am seeing her actually trying to form coherent thoughts and be a little bit looser than last game.

- - - Post Merge - - -

im actually not sure if lynching punchy gives us much info because they havent actually done anything yet, unless ur talking about getting info from peoples read on them which i can get behind. punchys probably my best bet rn, but its so meager its probably gonna be subject to a lot of change over the next 24 hrs

that's what I mean. Punchy himself hasn't said all that much that would help us. But quite a few people have offered opinions on punchy.

 

[illunie]

I don't get why punchy is the best lynch right now. He did tone down a bit in american mafia when everybody knew he is confirmed as town. I see this as just continuation of that.

its mostly the best of a bad situation, but i feel like he has actually changed a lot even compared to the 'end' of last game

 

[Seroja]

she liked mine too but i dont know which one because idk where to check so im not sure how far through she is
can u like this one so i can get the notification, u can unlike after

- - - Post Merge - - -



she was scum last game, but idk how different she was except being more active and not really giving concrete reads

you can go on your profile and click on the Like tab. I'm pretty sure evan wasn't saying that seriously so don't take it literally though.

also thanks.

 

[illunie]

you can go on your profile and click on the Like tab. I'm pretty sure evan wasn't saying that seriously so don't take it literally though.

also thanks.

ah kk, i just wanted to have a general idea of where amanda is up to if she is reading through everything

 

[Biancasbotique]

its mostly the best of a bad situation, but i feel like he has actually changed a lot even compared to the 'end' of last game

wasn't he active the first few hours of the day, even making RQs ?

 

[amazonevan19]

she liked mine too but i dont know which one because idk where to check so im not sure how far through she is
can u like this one so i can get the notification, u can unlike after

Pro tip, you can actually see the exact post they liked by clicking on "this post." Like when the notification says "amanda liked this post by amazonevan19 in thread ___," if you click on this post then it goes to what post it was.

The one she liked of mine was the one where I responded to glow, quite a while back today. So she has a ways to go.

 

[illunie]

Pro tip, you can actually see the exact post they liked by clicking on "this post." Like when the notification says "amanda liked this post by amazonevan19 in thread ___," if you click on this post then it goes to what post it was.

The one she liked of mine was the one where I responded to glow, quite a while back today. So she has a ways to go.

yeah ik, i just couldnt find the page with the likes, but ive got it now

 

[amazonevan19]

you can go on your profile and click on the Like tab. I'm pretty sure evan wasn't saying that seriously so don't take it literally though.

also thanks.

yeah, I use the mighty lemon liberally when ****posting

I don't literally think amanda is scum because of pocketing with likes lmao

- - - Post Merge - - -

wasn't he active the first few hours of the day, even making RQs ?

yeah but the RQs were pretty bad

 

[illunie]

i feel like there needs to be a designated joke font for that, id feel kinda sad if i needed to use it tho

 

[Biancasbotique]

Runeraider, I think the only time liking a post was an issue when someone who got lynched or died suddenly like a surviving player's post. Everybody was like oh why did he like if he is out of the game....As it turns out, that person is a ghost ha ha

 

[illunie]

wasn't he active the first few hours of the day, even making RQs ?

idk if those rqs were exactly a shining beacon of town activity

- - - Post Merge - - -

Runeraider, I think the only time liking a post was an issue when someone who got lynched or died suddenly like a surviving player's post. Everybody was like oh why did he like if he is out of the game....As it turns out, that person is a ghost ha ha

ye ik, i just wanted to know where amanda was up to in reading through

 

[amanda1983]

-- snip --

I haven't yet read any games in-depth from like June last year and the last game played, so theres a bunch of players here I don't know much about yet. I'll make sure to look them up before I make a full reads post.

For now, I'll only comment on players I'm familiar with.

Initial thoughts :

glow - active and engaged, asking questions (Farobi RE 3rd party comment), contributing info (roles), and opinions (KP discussion). I'm comfortable putting her as my top Town Lean rn.

Toads - active and engaged, contributing to discussions openly and in a generally calm and relaxed manner. He seems very much like the Town!Toads I'm used to, and nothing like the Mafia!Toads so far. Town Lean.

Seroja - I'll wait til there's more from her before I comment

Panda - as with Seroja

---

I was going to hold off on commenting on other players until I've read up on them, but I realised it's better if I just put my first impressions done now, so here they are real quick :
-- snip --

-- snip --

---

You skipped 4 players can you give opinions on them?
Your post are wishy washy can you elaborate them pls?



Are you really sure? its too early tbh and sometimes they pretend to act clueless and took advantage. This is his first game and yes he sounds really genuinely town but too early to jump on?

---

-- snip --

Okay so clearly my formatting wasn't as clear as it could have been lol. Apologies for the confusion. Hopefully this post clears things up. Please let me know if not, I'm always happy to answer questions.



My initial thoughts on the four players NOT in the numbered list were near the start of that post. Initially I was only going to comment on those four that I remember playing with. This was due to RL concerns as well as my need to read up on previous games, as it was roughly 3am - 4am during that span of time I wrote the main part of the post (the first time), and I hadn't been to sleep yet for very good reasons (not really). But given we needed to generate reads and a viable lynch candidate ASAP, I decided it was best to post what I had about everyone else even without any background info. Obviously they were not detailed reads, any of them, but given the stage of the game I didn't have that much to work with.

Anyway. I'll elaborate on my reads later this evening and post them ASAP. (My day was taken up with surprise family stuff.)

---

RE Antonio : no, I'm not really sure, I never am until the game has ended haha! But in addition to everything prior, he played just fine after my "Town Lock" post which means he's freakishly good IMHO if he's actually scum. No jitters or cockiness or weird silliness. So unless or until something new comes through or is raised, I'm happy to leave him in my personal "Town" category.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Oh **** my life.

I'll catch up. I swear. Sorry. Just have RL things to do as well, so I'll reading as I move.

 

[illunie]

Oh **** my life.

I'll catch up. I swear. Sorry. Just have RL things to do as well, so I'll reading as I move.

dw theres probably like 5 pages u can skip where we went back and forth over toad and waffles and reached 0 conclusion

 

[unravel]

Calm your **** guys Toads isnt ****ing salty he is just explaining **** about my voting thats it and he isnt comparing amateurs to animals you guys need to calm down get some fresh air and reread the statement slowly.

Reason why I'm voting self because I seriously thought its 12 mins before EoN hence I vote myself as placeholder

##VOTE: ITookYourWaffles

I slowly townleaning toads I seriously don't think he will stick on me and point it out for a stupid reason he find my placeholder alarming which I really understand his pov