Mafia The Murder of Woodpines Oregon - Game Thread - Endgame

[toadsworthy]

##VOTE PUNCHYDAHUFFLEPUFF
Placeholder

alright you got my attention, you clearly wanted to piss me off... so here I am
what was your intention with this after everything we talked about hm? you just wanted to anger me, piss off

 

[toadsworthy]

We all perfectly know that's a joke.

its not a very good one, you aren't funny at all... no one is laughing, have some grace and etiquette because right now you just look like a fool

- - - Post Merge - - -

post glitch

 

[PunchyTheCat]

omfg why didnt rune protect himself? well ****t

I need to gather my thoughts, this nightkill's making me losing motivation smh.

I'm going to look into locket, farobi, dedenne and evan. I chose these people based on how they were completely silent on N1 and because evan said so

punchy is still not in the clear, however, he's probably just town as usual anyway.

- - - Post Merge - - -

for god's sake punchy why tf did you make a placeholder despite all that debate we went through yesterday?? honestly if you're really town you're gonna waste another day of us discussing about whether or not to lynch you again.

We all perfectly know that's a joke.

 

[amanda1983]

Oh for ****s sake...

RIP Vanessa and Runeraider.

I'm used to Doc role, but not Watcher - what role/s might be on Mafia to balance out Watcher?

- - - Post Merge - - -

EBWOP : Oh duh, Role Blocker. I knew that.

So if Mafia has a Role Blocker, that could explain why Runeraider died. Assuming he could save himself as Doc which iirc is not always the case but is generally how it works. Hmm. Would Mafia RB really target Rune though? Why him over any other player?

Hmm. Time to read back through Rune's posts.

- - - Post Merge - - -

We all perfectly know that's a joke.

COULD WE PLEASE *NOT* CONTINUE THIS ASTOUNDINGLY ANTI-TOWN CONDUCT? On all sides. Let's be better than please and thank you.

 

[Biancasbotique]

I still dont get what Watcher or Tracker does. Those two roles are so confusing to me, and I dont even try to understand it sorry.

- - - Post Merge - - -

why is rune so positive that he will die?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Is Evan scummy at all. He keeps saying his scummy self as a joke, but what if he is really serious about it...

- - - Post Merge - - -

For some reason, because of Vanessa's death, I kinda want to clear toads of being sus because how could he as scum. I'd be surprised if toads is scum and he allowed Vanessa to die early.

- - - Post Merge - - -

and yes btw @ Vanessa and Rune

- - - Post Merge - - -

Let's lynch Farobi next?

 

[Locket]

Okay, so we are down to 11 players. 3 of which are mafia. Mafia has 2kp.

I'm gonna read through some posts & do some reads.

 

[toadsworthy]

Watcher can see who visits a player at night

 

[amanda1983]

Toads - who do you think the Mafia team is rn?

 

[PandaDarling]

Wow, we’re screwed, I’ll be home from work shortly.

 

[Locket]

Evan - Slight town lean, posts seem legit. Could be smart play but I doubt it.
Punchy - Slight scum lean. The reaction to getting almost lynched was kinda over the top. I feel like in a way it was similar to glow.
Toads - Slight scum lean. Most of it is gut feeling. Some posts also give off a scum-feel. (#696 (might be because he was genuinely curious,) #635 to name a couple)
Farobi - Unsure. Some posts come off as scum, and others are town feel.
Amanda - Slight town lean. Posts come off pretty legitimate to me.
Antonio - Doesn't post a lot of helpful stuff?
Bianca - Has some town posts, also have scum posts. Can't get a clear read.
Seroja - Getting mixed feelings, but more scum than town.
Dedenne - Slight town read. I feel like she is playing as more town.
Panda - Very slight town. Feels pretty legit, but not sure.

 

[toadsworthy]

Toads - who do you think the Mafia team is rn?

I stand by seroja/punchy, maybe you or Panda for third? not antonio, evan, or bianca rn

- - - Post Merge - - -

Evan - Slight town lean, posts seem legit. Could be smart play but I doubt it.
Punchy - Slight scum lean. The reaction to getting almost lynched was kinda over the top. I feel like in a way it was similar to glow.
Toads - Slight scum lean. Most of it is gut feeling. Some posts also give off a scum-feel. (#696 (might be because he was genuinely curious,) #635 to name a couple)
Farobi - Unsure. Some posts come off as scum, and others are town feel.
Amanda - Slight town lean. Posts come off pretty legitimate to me.
Antonio - Doesn't post a lot of helpful stuff?
Bianca - Has some town posts, also have scum posts. Can't get a clear read.
Seroja - Getting mixed feelings, but more scum than town.
Dedenne - Slight town read. I feel like she is playing as more town.
Panda - Very slight town. Feels pretty legit, but not sure.

you think me and punchy could be on a team?

 

[amanda1983]

Seroja is Town Locked for me. I'm more confident of her being Town than anyone else.

---

Those NKs have thrown my work-in-progress reads completely for a loop. I'll be starting from scratch later today.

 

[dedenne]

Oh well that happened...

Damn that's really bad

 

[amazonevan19]

**** NOOOOOOOO

****

NO

toads, you made me legit lol with your quoting joke on punchy

now I'm reading for real. Town's probably ****ed though

- - - Post Merge - - -

gonna place my vote on that mofo farobi, though I'd be fine with punchy dying too

farobi is way to ****ing quiet rn and that's scum farobi meta 101

 

[Farobi]

Man, those kills are super disheartening. RIP Rune and Vanessa.

I haven't been very active in the thread due to real life things but let me explain myself. My initial vote on Bianca on Day 1 was on the basis that I was not comfortable with how everyone was set on Punchy and how easily scum could hide behind this, so I tried to divert it to bianca to see how others would react. I switched off of bianca because no one would listen to my say and my vote would end up being useless, so i decided to switch last minute on waffles because (1) i just read 2 hours worth of content in the thread for 10 MINUTES so i had to skim some parts (2) i was already under the guise of glow knowing what she was talking about when she seemed so /set/ on waffles (3) town panic and the freaking time constraints. People were telling me to vote for waffles at the last 5 minutes of the game and that was too much pressure for me I almost had no time to think about it. I was pretty upset w myself knowing that I was the final reason of waffles's death (like i should've known better i knew her longer than some of your ages lol??) but whats done is done so i'll try to look forward now.

amazonevan19 - I can see his tunneling on Seroja earlier very town-like, but his core idea behind it is pretty faulty. Null.

PunchyDaHufflepuff - I'm not against his lynch, but the vig could've shot him instead why is he still around lmao. His gameplay has those obv scum and bleeding town moments that I can't really wrap my head around on. I regret 100% in making waffles die and leaving you around. null, scum lean.

toads - Slightly cautious around him. Him being one of the capable leaders of town and not acting much like it leaves a bad taste. scum lean. Other stuff too which i can quote l@er.

Amanda - She's new so I can't use meta on her but so far her posts don't stand out much despite its length which is concerning. like fluff. null, scum lean.

Locket - eh, it's possible she's scum but some of our reads are aligned so i could see a possible town-Locket here.

Antonio - not reading too much into this guy cuz how lol. i guess he seems genuine enough so town lean.

Bianca - I'll try to reset my outlook on bianca. my gut says she is scum but she looked better in the recent pages so im gonna back off her for now. null.

Seroja - town

dedenne - ehhh, null.

Panda - Voted for me so obv scum. But yeah, im leaning panda as scum because her reasoning on voting for me is actually balls.

I'll make a separate post on connections i find later cause i kinda rushed this. One of punchy or toads is probably mafia, and if not im thinking either amanda or panda as other possible lynches.

 

[Seroja]

Evan - Slight town lean, posts seem legit. Could be smart play but I doubt it.
Punchy - Slight scum lean. The reaction to getting almost lynched was kinda over the top. I feel like in a way it was similar to glow.
Toads - Slight scum lean. Most of it is gut feeling. Some posts also give off a scum-feel. (#696 (might be because he was genuinely curious,) #635 to name a couple)
Farobi - Unsure. Some posts come off as scum, and others are town feel.
Amanda - Slight town lean. Posts come off pretty legitimate to me.
Antonio - Doesn't post a lot of helpful stuff?
Bianca - Has some town posts, also have scum posts. Can't get a clear read.
Seroja - Getting mixed feelings, but more scum than town.
Dedenne - Slight town read. I feel like she is playing as more town.
Panda - Very slight town. Feels pretty legit, but not sure.

well how about that? apparently you're part of the team toads

btw locket, you can't just stay quiet for like 90% of this game and come in here with this half-assed list. at least tell me why you're having mixed feelings about me. why do you think that it's possible for me, punchy and toads to be in one scum team? you gotta expand on your reads more, give me something to work with.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Oh well that happened...

Damn that's really bad

I feel like you're town (just going by tone because you haven't really contributed much so far) so please put in a lil bit more effort thank you.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I stand by seroja/punchy, maybe you or Panda for third? not antonio, evan, or bianca rn

toads, was my vote on glow the only reason for your sus on me? cos you said it was uncharacteristic of me to do that. what other reasons do you have?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Seroja is Town Locked for me. I'm more confident of her being Town than anyone else.

---

Those NKs have thrown my work-in-progress reads completely for a loop. I'll be starting from scratch later today.

how can you be so confident that I'm town that you'd town-lock me? I would have gone for a strong town read (like with vanessa) at most unless they're 100% clear.

- - - Post Merge - - -

why is rune so positive that he will die?

Is Evan scummy at all. He keeps saying his scummy self as a joke, but what if he is really serious about it...

I had two thoughts about evan and his reaction test on me and I'm still thinking about it. I'm hoping he's town but can't let my guard down.

For some reason, because of Vanessa's death, I kinda want to clear toads of being sus because how could he as scum. I'd be surprised if toads is scum and he allowed Vanessa to die early.

explain this

- - - Post Merge - - -

ebwop: oh forgot to type under the quote about rune. I was also wondering the same thing.

- - - Post Merge - - -

also for the record I feel like punchy is easy scum prey.

 

[Farobi]

also for the record I feel like punchy is easy scum prey.

I would be inclined to agree with this but there are still some factors that i considered re punchy:

1) Punchy is town and you're correct in scum using him as a scapegoat candidate for lynch.
2) Punchy is mafia and scum are in the position to set themselves up to appear more town-aligned basing on how he flipped.

I feel that a punchy lynch would be all the more confusing and beneficial to mafia in this case actually, and considering how one of the investigative role is dead i'm really not sure this risk is worth it and that we should at least consider other candidates (aside from myself imbeciles). i'll have to re-read the interactions of people with punchy in the thread but right now im totally down with a toads lynch and how he's set really mostly set on punchy and playing almost mostly on emotion.

 

[PunchyTheCat]

I'm lowkey fine with my lynch, I understand that it would help town, even though it's a ML

 

[Seroja]

I'm lowkey fine with my lynch, I understand that it would help town, even though it's a ML

ok so as town you're just gonna act scummier so that we can waste yet another day on a mislynch? yeah, sounds like a plan alright.

 

[PunchyTheCat]

ok so as town you're just gonna act scummier so that we can waste yet another day on a mislynch? yeah, sounds like a plan alright.

No, not the point. Reading people like Amanda, Evan and Toads after my death is the point. I'm also fine with a Farobi lynch