So for all of these I both Ranked them, the traditional way in terms of how much I like them/ how likely I would be to invite them to my island and Rated them out of 10, which seems to be the new things. All opinions are my own and not meant to make anyone feel and about their villagers. The great thing about having 400 villagers is seeing what different taste everyone has. Thanks for sharing everyone!
here are mine (it's an all-cat island!)
raymond
punchy
kabuki
katt
lolly
felicity
ankha
tangy
merry
kiki
i don't have a jock... i just like the peppies and normals too much
1. Kiki - 8/10 - love Kiki, she’s cute, she’s just a bit quirky, and she’s simple yet stands out among the normals. I had her previously and gave her to a friend who still has her. She’s one I would consider inviting back though.
2. Kabuki - 10/10 - I know I ranked him higher than Kiki, who I rated higher. And it is because when I had him, through great island hopping luck early on, I expected to keep him forever. Unfortunately I just didn’t really click with him, which now realize is probably cause the cranky voice bothers me. However, I still think his design is one of the best in the game. He’s gorgeous and perfect.
3. Tangy - 7/10 - I don’t really like food villagers much. But she is an exception. She’s so cute and her house is one of my favorites in the game.
4. Merry - 7/10 - adorable. Love her little fangs and silly baby face.
5. Felicity - 6/10 - she’s super cute, though for whatever reason I find her slightly less exciting than some of the other peppy cats. Still really great though and feel if I ever had her on my island her ranking might go up.
6. Raymond - 5/10 - he’s a solid villager. Obviously much beloved. I have him now on my second island and though he is definitely not permanent, or my favorite smug, he has charm. I really dislike his house interior, even though I understand the reason for it.
7. Lolly - 5/10 - cute, nothing against her. She’s not my favorite but wouldn’t hate having her around.
8. Ankha - 5/10 - the first snooty I ever came across. She’s neat and I like her pouty face. Her level of theming is a bit to heavy for me. I would feel like she did not fit in.
9. Punchy - 5/10 - I feel bad he is so low on the list. I like him, primarily because I associate him with the lovely
@Dunquixote! I have never given him enough of a chance I think, because there are so many cats I like. But I probably should.
10. Katt - 3/5 - it seems strange, even to me, considering how much I love and adore Tabby, but I have never found Katt’s design appealing. I think it is that her eyes look like glasses pretending to be eyes. However, I would like to giver her a chance to win me over, as I have a soft spot for a loveable weirdo.
Gonna put my current line up in, though many of them will be leaving over the next few weeks, starting with Blanche, who is currently in boxes. Probably my saddest goodbye so far as I always loved her design, just her house won't fit my new plans :'(
1. Flurry
2. Audie
3. Marshal
4. Raymond
5. Apollo
6. Shari
7. Blanche
8. Marcie
9. Broccolo
10. Bud
I will update my list once all the changes have happened. Quite sad really, as I was fairly settled on that line up. But I need houses that will work and can't build them all a private rural area haha.
1. Flurry - 8/10 - despite having my least favorite color palette, and my original intention to only keep her short term, I grew to really love Flurry. She’s so cute, and of course I love the hamsters and find them one of the most fun species to dress up. I kept her for over a year, and I still may one day bring her back to my island someday. So I guess she really did win me over.
2. Shari - 7/10 - I think she is a great uchi, especially for those who don’t like the abrasive was they have at times. Something about her clueless expression made the uchi personality come off as much more sweet but dense than rough around the edges to me. She’s really cute, and I like her yellow paws.
3. Broccolo - 6/10 - he’s very cute and I like his house. His catchphrase is hilarious and amazing. Of all the mice he is one of the ones I would be most likely to invite.
4. Raymond - 5/10 - also ranked above. Solid, nothing against him.
5. Bud - 5/10 - initially strongly disliked him, because I do not like the villagers with goatees. But I love his colors and his house and the sort of sunshiney beachy vibes, so I have come to like him more.
6. Marshal - 5/10 - I like Raymond a bit more, but these two are fairly similar in my estimation. He’s also solid, decently cute. He has a much much better house interior than Raymond.
7. Blanche - 3/10 - I feel like I should like her, but something about her design just doesn’t work for me. I think it is the eyes. I don’t dislike her though.
8. Marcie - 3/10 - my opinion on kangaroos has improved, but they are still not a favorite species. Marcie is cute but at the same time I feel like something is missing from her face?
9. Audie - 3/10 - not a fan of wolves or the workout hobby or her sunglasses on head. I think her house is wonderful, inside and out, and wish I could give it to a villager I liked better. Her coloring is also nice.
10. Apollo - 1/10 - I don’t know what it is, but I just have a very strong aversion to him. Plus he is a cranky.
My lineup is currently:
Diana
Wolfgang
Raymond
Beau
Whitney
Audie (might have her leave at some point)
Julia (want gone)
Merengue (want gone)
Flo (want gone)
Fang
1. Flo - 7/10 - I think she is both cute and cool, I like her eyes. Would consider inviting her if I ever found her.
2. Beau - 6/10 he is cute but basic to me. I find him a little forgettable, but face to face find him quite cute. (Is it just that my mind is going?)
3. Raymond - 5/10 - as I said above. I have him and he is alright, nothing against him. He’s fairly cute, but has not clicked for me
4. Julia - 5/10 - my friend really loves her. She is cute. I think she should be a peppy instead of a snooty, which would make me like her more
5. Merengue - 3/10 I find her design too sickly sweet and it feels overdone to me. She is still cute-ish though. I do like that they made a rhino into this super cutest cream puff, as they are an underrated species who don’t generally get enough love.
6. Audie - 3/10 - as I said above, not a fan of the wolves or the workout hobby, or default sunglasses on head. Her house is really great though and her color is pretty.
7. Wolfgang - 2/10 - see above regarding wolves. His coloring is nice but cranky is my least favorite personality.
8. Whitney - 2/10 again, wolf, sorry. I really do not like the colorless or winter pastels color palette villagers. Snooty is fairly close to cranky personality wise for me.
9. Fang - 1/10 - sorry, I know he is popular but he would be one of my 10 least favorites
10. Diana - 1/10 - again, sorry. I gave her one because zero seemed mean. She’s one of my least favorites and I really avoid her at all costs. But luckily she’s got tons of fans and doesn’t need me.
so…seems like we have very different taste in villagers
. Which is okay! I hope I didn’t make you feel bad about your choices, because of course you should like who you like! (And my opinions are probably the weird ones…)