Mafia The Quest for King - Mafia | Game Thread | GAME OVER

I think everyone should super read into these 5 players to find the 1 wolf that's at least in there. I'm going to put aside my Tessa tinfoil for a bit and read into the other 4 since I think this is the safest strategy
 
I think everyone should super read into these 5 players to find the 1 wolf that's at least in there. I'm going to put aside my Tessa tinfoil for a bit and read into the other 4 since I think this is the safest strategy
Considering you and I started that wagon, I'd feel more inclined about the other three on it. I'd think it's obvious that you and I aren't teamed with Tessa.
 
If I may put something forward that bothered me about Tessa earlier today.




Why say "we" can block the king kill? Who is this referring to?

i was referring to trents question to to Chandler
Post automatically merged:

AUTOCORRECT gosh to trundler, which I then responded to. Let me find the receipts.
Post automatically merged:

If I may put something forward that bothered me about Tessa earlier today.




Why say "we" can block the king kill? Who is this referring to?
'Ello, 'ello, hola! Ciao and Bonjour! Question for the voice in the sky, one which I don't fully expect an answer from: If a protective type role is in the game, can they theoretically prevent the king kill?
Post automatically merged:

block it meaning the protective could prevent the kill
Post automatically merged:

Ness' Explanation and Apology on Recent Controversies​

fr though in my eyes you're completely cleared. once you revealed the mechanics of your role, I figured out how your actions connected to your thinking
Post automatically merged:

Ness' Explanation and Apology on Recent Controversies​

fr though in my eyes you're completely cleared. once you revealed the mechanics of your role, I figured out how your actions connected to your thinking
Post automatically merged:

I really don't know why that posted twice mods help
Post automatically merged:

im not reading all that sorry that happend or im glad for you
Post automatically merged:

make an ukelele song next time
NOOOO MY JOKE WAS TOO LATE
Post automatically merged:

I mean, there is a slightly insane way to test that. You would have to kid me. By doing so I would have then proceed to immediately kill Ness. I, being town, know that this would do a lot to help people figure out the eventual Mafia team. It would deal with his role claim and take me off the board
no nuh uh

if you're town and ness is def town thats just a bad idea
Post automatically merged:

i had an impression she would kill oath or gabby i dont think it's unlikely for trent to think the same way? unless he said he also thought it was obvious
i feel like it was pretty clear i was going to kill chris, i mentioned on multiple occasions about how i wouldn't kill gabby lol
 
Last edited:
what the heck is this

let me phrase my current thoughts

first of all when ness claimed pr i was convinced he was softing cop. i figured that was why there was a push on oath, and also this line:
I’l lead you down the path that rocks. Oh MAMA! Let’s rock n roll!!
Post automatically merged:


Cop out response but I wouldn’t kill you honestly. I get the impression you’re town but it’s my paranoia and I’ve had an impression that you’re lower on the totem pole than Jacob/Annika, atleast mentally.
my gut tells me ness was planning on claiming cop and then accidentally killed the cop, but that hero claim looks super real unfortunately. it’s probably not worth pursuing but i am writing my thoughts. jester ness actually makes too much sense on second thought

secondly trent being cop makes this seem like a soft
Checking in during my break, just to say @Geoni better vote before they leave again otherwise they're wall posting for no reason

Also you know what vote for me, I want to kill Dan. I think that would actually be the most useful going into Day 3 given Dan's interacted with just about everyone
i was thinking during the night and i just hate all of geoni’s recent lines?? i haven’t reread them but they seem purposely triggering esp quoting stuff from d1 and treating it like current material

can we elect a king twice in a row

i’m too tired to read deeply it’s midnight here but if i sleep i’ll forget to write this stuff down
 
yes im reading the entire thing again. yes i dont have a job

Oh baby! YES! Our alliance is sealed!
is this still up ness

which is why we shouldn't pick universal trs to be king. picking someone indecisive gives us alot more info imo
i still think we should choose king from someone iffy though it would be funny (we can afford mistakes early on, they would actually prove useful??)


yes but also group discussion for a kill is super important bc if we vote mafia and they kill some townie and they're like "oh we didnt discuss anyone at all as a group first so i went with my gut and i was wrong" then we failed and got no info
we'd be banking off of only one person's read and no
interesting to note that the text is italic is a response to a ribbit posts that makes the exact point that tessa is making in bold

...im choosing to unpack this d2
tessa noticed shiny's soft

It’s just a bit frustrating to have to prod you to give more detailed reads
Post automatically merged:


I don’t really give townslips over mechanics. It’s a bit too messy in a closed setup. I’ve seen both sides do it
Post automatically merged:


Do you have any thoughts on the game
Post automatically merged:


Is there a particular reason why you specifically pointed out shiny and me on our thoughts as king? Other players have expressed their desires on wanting/not wanting to be king, so interested to hear if you think their motives are innocent or not
Post automatically merged:

I can see a world where Annika is town. But excluding the super quiet people (Gabby, Geoni and Chris), I see town in Annika the least. I’ll need to think about Jacob a bit more. I also need to reread Ribbit because I’m not really getting the slimy vibes Ness was getting from their bus theory (even though I don’t think that was bussing)
i will own up to it, ok? idk what i was on yesterday, these two could never be teamed

So, if you voted Arstotzkan as a joke, are you going to unvote them before you go to work? I wouldn't want to leave for work leaving the game with only a joke vote.
i see that kat / oath cant be a team

I don't understand. What's the point of pointing these three people out for posting first but not looking into their posts? This kind of feels like a good way to throw them under the bus later if you need to idk.

It was a joke :) I was clear that if I become king, the kill would be something I wanted to discuss with everyone in my later posts.


Can you expand on this?

Currently I feel pretty solid about Volt and Ness as trs. I don't think Annika is as maffy as they're made out to be as well.



I can imagine it doesn't. That would ruin the whole point of two vote changes imo.


yes but also its good to look into everything even d1. what bothers me about chris' interaction with my post most isn't their interpretation of it, but the previous statements saying that he wouldn't look into early d1 posts bc they don't matter, and then soon after analyzing an early d1 post that in my opinion clearly didn't matter. just a little contradictory to me.
Post automatically merged:


were you initially aware that we only had 2 vote changes?
tessa goes on chris p hard here

i’m sorry i might have to drop out coz i’ve been too busy irl to do much here :’)


what do you mean by this? like kill them with king power or vote them for king?

as for electing a king i think i’ve settled on trent the paladin for having unique positions on the game. again i’ve only skimmed a bit on what ive missed so if someone could update me if there was anything important that would be appreciated.
i still cant understand why ribbit wanted trent as king

imo think it does matter a bit because it does allow mafia to kill town but i can see where you're coming from tbh since if mafia gets it, it puts them in a position where if they do kill a town it potentially looks bad for them so kinda risky, but usually it's hard to tell if they kill someone in the consensus process of elimination pool so eh
redudant comment

im continuing my campaign for king:
why you should vote for me!
-power to the people. i think it's in towns best interest to discuss who we want to take down together, just like a regular elim. leaving it up to just one person doesn't allow for ideas to bounce off of one another. and voting someone for king just to see what they'll do doesn't really get us anywhere, because a miskill could be town that we then tunnel, a mafkill could mean a double kill bc we didn't discuss, and either is kind of confusing for all of us. i think the cons outweigh the pros in this. we can't really afford to give mafia two kills. plus i have bad judgement so i wanna talk it through everyobe

- i wont kill an ia. as much as i would love to take down geoni and be right about it... i'm all for giving them a chance to speak. i think whoever becomes king should be very careful to not target someone who seems suspicious because of lack of substance. its a poor move in my opinion.

if we can follow these ideas with another person as king, thats also good! it doesn't matter who is king if we as a towncore are able to decide things together. it then puts mafia in the worst spot they could be if they're king- having to listen to the town.
contraditory to the first post of her i quoted

honestly this seems a lil weird to me since it's directed specifically at shiny, maybe a bit pockety, but at the same time I think persuading someone to vote them as king at the start of day 1 is kinda ballsy play for a wolf so meh
redudant again

Would you be shocked if I said I’m kind of on board with Oath?
hesitancy to declare his intention makes sense with ness strategy to take oath down with him

that sounds kind of rude tho, didn't they say they didn't want to be king?

yea i agree with crowning tessa or ness
umm i'm gonna vote tessa rn but will maybe change it later
very weird reasoning for not wanting to crown oath

we dont care about their feelings we want to solve this game
fr though dont be afraid to put people in tough situations regardless of politeness and stuff. we gotta win
tessa is not voting for oath and thinks he could be wolf, why even answer to annikas post

i have volt, tessa, ness, trent and ribbit as townleans so i'm ok with crowning anyone in that group or crowning anyone who won't kill in that group

tessa is also offering to take other people's opinions into consideration which makes voting her feel more comfortable, bc it's more like a standard vote

i don't really have more thoughts besides those, i'm personally fine with policying geoni but i get why people wouldn't want to do that
more than half of the active players as townleans

The oath thought is odd in that (a) you’d both kill and crown him and (b) Oath listed you as one of the people he’d kill
again coherent with ness claim we know now
 
thinking back to the D1 votes, the fact that the Tessa wagon was met with little to no resistance means to me that either (a) Wolves did not feel Tessa would kill any of them or (b) Tessa is mafia

Also I think it's pretty much certain that at least 1 wolf voted for Tessa.
so minus ness it's between you, annika, ribbit, and jacob
i feel uninformed on all four of those but i'm more certain about your vote- as we had talked about it together. i need to look into them though. was i the only one getting mixed vibes from ribbit? at first she was acting strange d1 but then had a pretty strong d2
Post automatically merged:

Ness might be a jester
no not funny
 
finished d1 yipee

k chris you're up
1. only like 3 posts of substance which is not my fav, plus i like very few of his takes here.
1. still no kat receipts, doesnt sit well with me
2.chris whats the overall read with shiny?
3. deepwolf hunting is too soon, tbh. i already had my say about this so i'll spare the details

best take so far

i would be ok with chopping chris. mostly i just wanna hear more. so far i haven't really liked anything i heard. lots of talk without nearly any explanation.
Post automatically merged:


me or dan for pres pls i dont want yall voting ia :(
Post automatically merged:

oath can you please explain the trent vote if you havent already its making me want to chop you
Post automatically merged:

srry i should be pinging @oath2order
ur right u were set on chris. no clue who trent went for then

yeah i did just criticize chris for looking for a deepwolf lol

i guess im just more comfortable with killing oath than electing them as king. i dont really love either option though
dan is right that tessa feels more genuine nearing EoD

weird switch im so confused rn
this posts and the one i quoted at the start of this post shows tessa went back to reevaluate whos in her chopping block. could easily just tunnel chris instead

nah i just saw that we have to vote today

i reread properly and honestly idk what to contribute since it seems all of my opinions come off as maffish so i’m just gonna sheep annika for now;;
barely had any pushback to be so fearful

i'm open to change tbh

though i have just seen shiny is in favour of no elimming which i'm not a fan of so will switch if that's the case tbh
"will switch if thats the case" this post is so awkward haha

oath, chris, and ribbit are my isos tonight.
i just get a little tmi anti town feeling from them who knows.
kat is safe i read through and what bothered me most was actually ness's distancing after i pointed it out
Post automatically merged:


the final 3 eod panic of '22 gives me flashbacks
i actually just hate eod in general. i finally have time to myself and theres only 14 minutes and i've only isoed 3 people
i feel like this is why i wasnt as certain that you would kill chris
Post automatically merged:

comments:
- i like basically every post from dan d1. i even said i tr him just for mindmelt
- im not particularly interested on figuring out ness for now
- trent gave almost nothing to work with
- i pointed out jacob's redudant posts because he doesnt have much content d1 and i think it's interesting that a lot of it is just null things
- thats why a lot of it is abt tessa, bc removing dan, ness and trent, its mostly just her
Post automatically merged:

I'm not gonna give minus points to tessa for killing chris (assuming that was their kill) tbh because I also thought it was an alright kill, I feel like PRs tend to look kinda wolfy to me lol

this was tessa's pool of possible king kills:

"i think chris, annika maybe? i trust volt, ribbit, or oath if i'm feeling really spicy"

chris was town, annika imo is town based on my meta for them (more on this later), oath imo feels towny for how they were so anti being king and also how they were joking about dying felt like they didn't really care about dying which is imo a towny trait

so i think if there are wolves here it'd be in volt and ribbit

could be that both of them are wolves, but if not (and probability dictates they're probably not both wolves) then that's either 4 or 5 town there

given that I think it's likely that at least 1 of the wolves would be voting for tessa yesterday regardless of tessa alignment

voters on tessa: annika, Damniel, N e s s, ribbitribbon, Jacob4

don't think me and annika are wolves so would leave with at least 1 in {Damniel, N e s s, ribbitribbon}

eh that didnt really narrow it down as much as id like to have, but i think it'll be a good approach to find town / mafia in that pool cause i do think it's greater than random chance that pool contains wolves tbh

Out of those I'd probably lean on damniel being the towniest but i havent really substantiated those thoughts in my head rn just kinda gut feels based on the posts ive seen from him
@N e s s idk what to think of this post. do you think theres info to be gathered here?
Post automatically merged:

I didn't sense any WIFOM from Ribbit at all
@Damniel do still think the same way?
 
Last edited:
that’s true let me explain that since i didn’t get a chance:


here and other parts of d1 in the back of my mind i thought you kept buddying people, so i threw out your name instead of chris since lowkey all of the people fosing them made me tr him.

feels weird telling it to your face thought because you could just be a genuinely nice person and i’d have no idea 🤷
sorry if i understood wrong but did you vote tessa in hope you could get her to change to ness?

annika
mostly under radar, but would quickly answer whenever pinged so they were active at the time. voted for tessa what wouldnt turn any eyes
also their strongest read on anything was a townlead on ribbit which is justified by that post that is up there bc i cant cut and paste under. i dont think it has much depth and just felt like a plot point cherry picked. more than a couple of people talked abt bussing bc it feels very natural in this setup
after rereading i still agree with this

i explained most of the stuff at the end of your post here:

i voted tessa against my previous thought because i didn’t want to risk a no crown; since i didn’t have time to go and find another king idea in the candidates i sheeped annika and dan since i liked their reasoning for her. also later iirc a few people pointed out my initial theory seemed more like a bandwagon than a bus, and i agree so i dropped it.

also i liked you and trent as candidates because you both seemed to have strong opinions without outing them to the town. i still townread damniel but he outs his reads explicitly and publicly so i don’t see him as an optimal king.
i still feel this was a good post, but feeeeel like this "no elect" point could be a cop out. this is an wild different thought than i had back then but im trying to reboot my brain

it would be a lot of work to quote all of them but here are a few of his posts i liked:


he explicitly stated that he was keeping his reads to himself which i like and discouraged tessa from abiding by popular vote. he also contributes well when he does.
not at this point anymore because two power roles are dead. i don’t think no killing the king power is optimal anymore, if there’s any left we risk losing them
i got tired of this back and forth but i meant to ask if you explicitly wanted a no vote d1. bc thats what voting trent would bring. and some of your posts said you would prefer otherwise
Post automatically merged:

Oath iso yippee
(Also off topic but kat i will answer your questions in due time dw)
#39 weird opener but i wont take much from it. Beginning of day is a lot of humor
#142 early trent-oath interaction. Could be the start of a pocket, especially since trent’s game so far has been null asf. Biggest thing that stood out to me was the “especially since we can’t afford to lose town this early” because it makes no sense. This is the ONLY time that losing town won’t greatly impact us. The agreement to trent’s statement was poorly justified.
#185“I wouldn’t say i’m joke posting”
….






#189 leans a lot more towny for me… i feel like recognizing that one’s take might not be entirely true/justified and then to publicly say that is pretty town-oriented thinking.
Posts that are weird and don’t really contribute to the game at all in a way that is towny: P#223 , P#422 , P#542 (justification and then a quick backoff from the ness hate)
#571 one of two questions so far that is seeming to get answers not about himself.
Oath defending himself posts: P#612, P#625 P#628 (which actually is a bit better because the point stood pretty well) P#649, P#721
P#631 is like a meld of the two questions trying to get answers and questions defending himself. I do like that he’s staying strong in his first take because i feel like he backed off after earlier comments, this time he stuck to it.
P#703 another weird emotional pocket with trent- also oath was hating on meta earlier and pulls up with meta to defend himself? Weird.
P#730 nice a readslist! (with the main trs at the time as town and a few maf without any justification hmmm….)
P#773 actually very bold because if he does flip mafia that would mean good things for town.

Anyways over all take is null-maf leaning. I really want to agree that he’s a townie omgussing but truly i’ve seen just about nothing get done and no wolfhunting from him. Just a lot of spew.
i dont think theres anything particular groundbreaking in this iso. @N e s s did you take anything from this into consideration last night?
Post automatically merged:

Direct quotes first reactions:
@ DeathsChris and Shiny, huh. Interesting. Gut says Shiny was mafia kill, which means they ascribed to the theory that they were too townie in their methods. Might be worth investigating if no one's done so yet.
Common volt maf thoughtsSomeone's gonna have to catch me up on this one; it sounds like some stuff from EoD D1?
"maf not dying w/ a Tessa king"The fact that she went uncontested is less of a condemnation on her wagon and more of a condemnation on the accuracy of Tessa's reads.
"don't think me and annika are wolves":lemon: "the town" (this is a half joke).
tessa pr musingmight be overreacting here but am looking at how only one of the deaths (hers) was mentioned when there was a loss of two PRs last night - you'd think that'd exasperate the concerns rather than just focusing on the one she pointed at
post #505Don't like how the wagon/analysis of the wagon/dan approving the wagon was basically a call/response between Dan and Jacob.
It's nothing I can point to with a solid finger (purely gut/intuition), but I have not gotten anything from Dan that has given me any warm fuzzies all game. idk man.
"because no one had brought this up"tessa I don't get what this is at. and why the bold?
my alignmentyea this says jack and **** about my alignment, my work here is done (y)
"... Did trundle dupe me into playing a Kingmaker game."get ****ed :lemon:
page 30noting 'ribbon sus' to 'ribbon town' without much changing in that regard? Hm. I have had absolutely no ability to read ribbon atm (my brain fogs over whenever they post, nothing against you ribbon I think it's more likely to be my current mindset than anything on your end), but the fact that either the reads are co-existing without questioning one another or the reads are changed with no explaination isn't great. Might be worth looking into later when my eyes aren't bleeding.
Ness talking about suspicion on meYou might have already answered this so forgive me if so, but iirc weren't you on the train of people who said that yesterday's vote went too smoothly? If so, why are Oath and I, two pretty inactive people, on your chopping block first and foremost when theoretically mafia was helping that day end? You're being inconsistent.
post #625I do think the tone shift from afk to immediately focusing on the gun pointed at his face is interesting
"forgettable is mafia read"HARD disagree. It is a mafia tactic that can be deployed, but it is just as much of a mafia tactic to be incredibly rememberable, command the stage, and draw everyone to their line of view and their points. It's just as much of a sketchy action to talk in absolutes.
Towncore strongWhat towncore? There has never been one, based on what I've read. This chat has been going nowhere with people throwing out idle questions and looking at way too small of a picture rather than considering anything significant. I don't think I've seen anyone in this entire thread I feel confident is town at this point, which scares the ever living crap out of me because usually I feel something but all I see here is shuffling around pieces of sand and hoping they make a clear picture.
Ness doubting OathNo ****ing shot, not after he's actually been active enough that a case can be made against him do you back off. Reaction test?
Trent wanting to kill DanCan someone link to me his thoughts on this (or @Trent the Paladin can you recap), must have been in D1.
Tunnel not badBAD. DISLIKE. DISLIKE. that is WAY too much confidence, PARTICULARLY when he said his empathy was getting the better of him earlier.
"everyone and their mother townread me"I can't come up with a refutation for this off the top of my head, I don't remember people scumreading you besides Oath (which feels very omgus to me), but this makes me want to tear my hair out. ****ing christ.
"my vote's on Dan"Didn't you just say Dan wasn't someone you liked as much anymore like 3 pages ago?

Need to still compile my thoughts on people individually but I frankly heavily dislike Ness (for reasons stated) and Dan (more of a vibes, nothing really gave me good vibes in my readback to make my change much of my mind). I know Ness PR claimed and he's going to ***** at me for pushing resistance out but I'd written out **** I thought was sus before he actually revealed that in my defense, and I could easily see Ness claiming a PR as a PR'd mafia (or mafia has a framer on their side) so. Dislike.

I'm not a massive fan of voting anyone for king at the moment, though I apparently need to vote so. Give me a few to actually make a reads list. Just pushing this out ASAP so people have a chance to react to it before EoD in 45 mins
i like this post so much i want to live in it please post a lot today kat
 
Last edited:
@Damniel do still think the same way?
WIFOM no but also that’s NAI bc we just say Trent do that. I am open to discussing the slot tho
Post automatically merged:

Saw*
Post automatically merged:

so minus ness it's between you, annika, ribbit, and jacob
i feel uninformed on all four of those but i'm more certain about your vote- as we had talked about it together. i need to look into them though. was i the only one getting mixed vibes from ribbit? at first she was acting strange d1 but then had a pretty strong d2
Post automatically merged:


no not funny
I’m not so convinced of Ness’s claim but I’m putting that aside for now. Ness shouldn’t be king anymore regardless. I don’t think anyone within the 5 players in the Tessa wagon should be king
Post automatically merged:

reading back on Trent’s posts, I think he either checked a dead person like Chris or Shiny or just got a green check. He wasn’t very vocal on reads D2 and maybe that’s because he didn’t get a groundbreaking check in
 
Last edited:
yeah this is really bad and I feel more and more like wolves are just trying to power themselves to a win rn

I don’t really get the Trent kill, from what I remember no one was really suspecting him that much? Even I would have been a better kill at least then the cop wouldn’t have died

Ness killing Trent and then also saying they were almost gonna kill me looks wolfy fmpov
Post automatically merged:

I’m doubting myself on the believability of ness pr claim but lemme fully catch up
Post automatically merged:

feel like tess and ness need to be under more scrutiny at this point for their king kills especially since they were both on PRs, especially for ness since there could be a mafia investigative role that told them Trent is pr on n1

Ness kill on Trent especially feels weird to me, at least for the tess kill on Chris people were suspecting that slot more so it made more sense, this kill just doesn’t feel logical for town to make
Post automatically merged:

I’m never voting for tess or ness today
Post automatically merged:

Do we know if Trent softed his n1 peek at all on d2? Gonna look through his iso now
 
Last edited:
Do we know if Trent softed his n1 peek at all on d2? Gonna look through his iso now
I don’t think so. That or he either checked me and got green based on this:
Chris flipping tracker however kicked my overthinking into overdrive however, it's not a role that reveals alignments but maybe it helps balance things out IF there's a godfather and more good/evil PRs in the game. What if Dan is godfather, meaning he's essentially going to fly by now that we're out of PRs and it's gonna take too long to realize? But maybe I'm just overthinking things or trusting Chris a bit much or simply just tired because it's bedtime.
But if he did get a green check, to just think I’m godfather and want to kill me is a bit of a stretch
 
Yeah I don’t see anything in his iso suggesting a peek at all

-_-
Post automatically merged:

I don’t think so. That or he either checked me and got green based on this:

But if he did get a green check, to just think I’m godfather and want to kill me is a bit of a stretch
Yeah that does seem a bit of a stretch ngl, if you’re town and he got a green peek on you I doubt his first reaction would be to tinfoil that you’re gf and push you despite mech being in your favour

If anything makes me think he probably didnt peek you regardless of your alignment tbh, if he got a wolf peek on you he probably wouldnt think about tinfoiling gf and he’d push you harder
Post automatically merged:

......
@Jacob4 does this seem real to you
Lmao I think it’s wrong but I wouldn’t say it sounds unreal necessarily, have seen weirder tinfoils from town
 
Last edited:
Hey @Trundle , can we get ISO links to Night 2/Day 3 in the OP?
Noted. Did you double check that you would have gotten a roleblock notification if you were blocked without ability?
@N e s s
Also an additional question: You mentioned in your rationale for your pr claim yesterday that you were worried about being killed. I understand self-preservation for self-preservation's sake, but given your slot is essentially a green with a twist why do you value your life at such a level?
I think everyone should super read into these 5 players to find the 1 wolf that's at least in there. I'm going to put aside my Tessa tinfoil for a bit and read into the other 4 since I think this is the safest strategy
I do not understand the confidence here. Day 1 was a lot of meandering, right? I think it's more likely that a lack of resistance to anything going on with the Kinging process is more indicative that everyone was just way off base, and the identity of the King wouldn't matter because they weren't in danger regardless
 
I do not understand the confidence here. Day 1 was a lot of meandering, right? I think it's more likely that a lack of resistance to anything going on with the Kinging process is more indicative that everyone was just way off base, and the identity of the King wouldn't matter because they weren't in danger regardless
There are 10 players left in the game. 5 of them were on Tessa’s wagon. Do you believe that the entire mafia team are in the other 5?
 
i still cant understand why ribbit wanted trent as king
i’m gonna be completely honest with you, i didn’t see trent wanted to no kill the king power d1. a quick iso of him i still can’t find it. no i didn’t want that i liked his d1 from what i saw of it

sorry if i understood wrong but did you vote tessa in hope you could get her to change to ness?
no, i voted tessa because it looked like no chance of a trent king so i looked at who other people were voting. however i was nervous about her killing chris so i threw that out there
tessa noticed shiny's soft
this is the most solid evidence anyone has against anyone rn don’t let go of it
There are 10 players left in the game. 5 of them were on Tessa’s wagon. Do you believe that the entire mafia team are in the other 5?
this is so hypocritical
1. i agree with artso
2. you voted for tesaa

it might be more useful to look into why people voted tessa if you’re going to go that hard on it
 
this is so hypocritical
1. i agree with artso
2. you voted for tesaa

it might be more useful to look into why people voted tessa if you’re going to go that hard on it
I’m not saying that voting for Tessa was inherently mafia. I’m saying that mathematically it’s very unlikely there are no mafia who voted for Tessa. I think each player who voted for her requires scrutiny (I know that includes myself). I find it hard to believe the wagon is completely pure
 
I’m not saying that voting for Tessa was inherently mafia. I’m saying that mathematically it’s very unlikely there are no mafia who voted for Tessa. I think each player who voted for her requires scrutiny (I know that includes myself). I find it hard to believe the wagon is completely pure
rereading everyone had reasons for voting tessa across multiple posts:
>you and ness simply townread tessa
>me and jacob switched after seeing our choices for king weren’t going to go through

i’m still looking for annika’s one moment
Post automatically merged:

>annika wanted tessa or ness
 
i’m gonna be completely honest with you, i didn’t see trent wanted to no kill the king power d1. a quick iso of him i still can’t find it. no i didn’t want that i liked his d1 from what i saw of it


no, i voted tessa because it looked like no chance of a trent king so i looked at who other people were voting. however i was nervous about her killing chris so i threw that out there

this is the most solid evidence anyone has against anyone rn don’t let go of it

this is so hypocritical
1. i agree with artso
2. you voted for tesaa

it might be more useful to look into why people voted tessa if you’re going to go that hard on it
be so fr
I enjoy stirring the pot, please vote me. :)


If anything I'm anti-bloodshed day one! Do not confuse me with Dan, someone advocating for shoving someone down the mountain! After day one, then the pock knife comes out!


OH YEAH, WHAT'S UP MAFIOSOS AND MAFIASAS AND MAFINBYS? I'm here throwing my hat into the day one ring, make me king! But TomTrent, why should we do that? I'm glad you asked peasant! If made king, I will do one of two things, heavily weighted in the no island removal category while the tiny less weighted side of me thinks it'd be funny if I just chose someone at random (like say Oath) and had them mad at me the rest of the game for their early demise. But TrentTom, that's not compelling! To that I say what else do you want? At most we fish for information about our opponents by removing a night kill, at worst you all dislike me as we go into day two! But Tom the Warrior, this is a closed setup we should be fishing for information anyways? What are you, my boss? It's day one I'm here to relax before we all hunch over and ummmm ackthully each other and bring out the crayola coloring list of yarn theories.

Truly, voting for I, Trent the Paladin, would be good for us all! And selfishly allow me to actually play one of these rps I sign up for but then get cast off day one for the wrong thing of "why should we evict someone day one when nothing has happened other than last hour panic?". With hearts full of love for your fellow Toad, vote me. xoxo <3

It's important to commit to the bit, voting for a king who just eagerly votes for what the majority wants might as well be no king at all. "it was the will of the people, you can't fault me for getting the ejection of X player wrong!" wrong, rip bozo.

Like I said, I intend on no elimination night one if made king. Boring? Sure. Could I spice it up by giving into the devil in me and just random voting someone? Sure, but I'm not likely to do that. If we're going to elect "Yes men", I would prefer to get removed because why even play kingmaker.
Post automatically merged:

i have progressed in the sense yesterday i thought everyone was town and today i think everyone is mafia. growth
Post automatically merged:

WIFOM no but also that’s NAI bc we just say Trent do that. I am open to discussing the slot tho
i disagree, i think ribbit's vote is the best clue we have on their alignment. trent just did a frustated unvote
 
Last edited:
I think everyone should super read into these 5 players to find the 1 wolf that's at least in there. I'm going to put aside my Tessa tinfoil for a bit and read into the other 4 since I think this is the safest strategy
i think it’s you
Post automatically merged:

i think you want us to focus on that group because everyone there besides you is town, and you’re the least likely to be killed if we focus there

daniel + geoni + 1
maybe
 
Back
Top