Mafia The Real Housewives of Mafia - Town Wins

[amazonevan19]

hey wait guys if we're going by mafiascum's interpretations, then we've got some rethinking to do when it comes to Arsonist.

https://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Arsonist

I've seen the same variation of the jailer Dad got on here before, but if this is true Arson might be a town role here. But priming and stuff rules out the first definition - it's either the TOS variation, I guess the maf variation, or the mafscum variation.

Oh damn

Arsonist, if you’re Town, you better as hell pm Farobi pronto

- - - Post Merge - - -

Well feel free to pm him if you’re scum too

 

[SensaiGallade]

Oh damn

Arsonist, if you’re Town, you better as hell pm Farobi pronto

- - - Post Merge - - -

Well feel free to pm him if you’re scum too

Honestly I hope doc has protected Farobi cause he's a valuable asset to us if he isn't lying about his role, which i doubt.

 

[Dolby]

Quite possible. If i've missed something with these two having beef or something, its not unusual for mafia team members to buss each other to make themselves look good. I can't say the same about Dedenne and Waffles hence why it was a cross between Dedenne and Chele. If Dedenne is not scum then it could possibly be Chele.

I mean
Do you really think that Waffles would put two of her teammates as her ONLY susses after that last lynch?

 

[SensaiGallade]

I mean
Do you really think that Waffles would put two of her teammates as her ONLY susses after that last lynch?

If its any way to make herself look good then yes, but I can see your point of view.

 

[PandaDarling]

i don't like posting reads/list at night, but i know i have had little content, and im sorry about that, my life is a bit hectic rn do to Christmas and other circumstances, feel free to PM me or address me here for additional information.

Town Leans:
Farobi
Dad
AmazonEvan19
Arstotzkan
Glow

Nulls:
Dolby
Ness
Mogyay
SensaiGallade
ITookYourWaffles

Scum Leans:
VanessaMay18
Zendel
Dedenne2
Heyden
Chele
Endless

 

[Heyden]

Townread
Evan - obv town
Farobi - detective
Zendel - townreading
Panda - think she's town tbh
Glow - blue
Dolby - highly doubt hes scum or tp based on early game behaviour

Null
Dad - still can't wrap my head around his claim something just doesn't sit right with me
Chele - don't know why she's townread when she hasn't done anything towny imo
Waffles - null town cos she's usually obv as maf
Ness - null ish idk

Scumlean
Sensai - could see him on scum team but idk about lynching him
Mog - havent iso'd but posts feel fillery
Vanessa - sort of torn but i can't wrap my head around to tr her
Endless - poe says it's him or kat, maybe both
Kat - ^
Dedenne - done nothing all game, my weakest sus though

Not a great list but I'm using notes on my phone so hey

- - - Post Merge - - -

also no way in hell arsonist is town, don't give them ideas for a claim lmao

 

[Arstotzkan]

So arsonists are primarily third party but they can also be mafia? So I know about that now.

Need to look into Heyden even more because I was under the assumption that there could only be scum arsonists.

This makes me immensely uncomfortable. For someone who re-read the entire thread, he should have seen all of the arsonist talk, and when looking up the Arsonist role, all definitions listed them as 3rd party or town. None mafia. This feels like he's trying to fake the clear Punchy did.

Spoiler

@Sensai in general my mind is still wrapping around him tbh, I thought the "Asking questions" thing felt townish but hm if thats his scum meta that's concerning.

Tho for a question for you mdude: Why is Vanessa such a hard town read for you? Also how do you feel about Dad's Jailer claim?

 

[moonford]

i don't like posting reads/list at night, but i know i have had little content, and im sorry about that, my life is a bit hectic rn do to Christmas and other circumstances, feel free to PM me or address me here for additional information.

Town Leans:
Farobi
Dad
AmazonEvan19
Arstotzkan
Glow

Nulls:
Dolby
Ness
Mogyay
SensaiGallade
ITookYourWaffles

Scum Leans:
VanessaMay18
Zendel
Dedenne2
Heyden
Chele
Endless

Why do you have 6 scum leans?

 

[SensaiGallade]

This makes me immensely uncomfortable. For someone who re-read the entire thread, he should have seen all of the arsonist talk, and when looking up the Arsonist role, all definitions listed them as 3rd party or town. None mafia. This feels like he's trying to fake the clear Punchy did.

Spoiler

@Sensai in general my mind is still wrapping around him tbh, I thought the "Asking questions" thing felt townish but hm if thats his scum meta that's concerning.

Tho for a question for you mdude: Why is Vanessa such a hard town read for you? Also how do you feel about Dad's Jailer claim?

If I'm completely honest, I'm so confused about Dad's jailer claim and the whole sitatuation surrounding it. My only reason for townleaning him for it is because it was in a moment that was crucial and from my experience of being on the line of lynch, I had to claim to gain the trust of everyone else and explain my actions.

As for the "asking questions" thing, thats nothing new. I didn't just ask people to question me in Alola, I generally do ask for questions or stay around for a while whenever I post a read or give my input on a situation so I can gather peoples views.

 

[PandaDarling]

Why do you have 6 scum leans?

cause those are the people i wanna look into and have an off feeling about, im not saying the are all scum... 6 would be unbalanced obviously.

 

[Dolby]

If I'm completely honest, I'm so confused about Dad's jailer claim and the whole sitatuation surrounding it. My only reason for townleaning him for it is because it was in a moment that was crucial and from my experience of being on the line of lynch, I had to claim to gain the trust of everyone else and explain my actions.

As for the "asking questions" thing, thats nothing new. I didn't just ask people to question me in Alola, I generally do ask for questions or stay around for a while whenever I post a read or give my input on a situation so I can gather peoples views.

Tbh, your past three posts have had good tone (even though I disagree on waffles team possibilities) so I'm feeling conflicted

- - - Post Merge - - -

This makes me immensely uncomfortable. For someone who re-read the entire thread, he should have seen all of the arsonist talk, and when looking up the Arsonist role, all definitions listed them as 3rd party or town. None mafia. This feels like he's trying to fake the clear Punchy did.

Spoiler

@Sensai in general my mind is still wrapping around him tbh, I thought the "Asking questions" thing felt townish but hm if thats his scum meta that's concerning.

Tho for a question for you mdude: Why is Vanessa such a hard town read for you? Also how do you feel about Dad's Jailer claim?

Endless mentioned the possibility of maf arsonist extensively

 

[Arstotzkan]

Tbh my brain's a little fried to do an entire revamped reads list, especially regarding Dolby and glow I need to figure out wtf is going on with them, but:

Endless: I see no realistic world here where Abe is scum here after this line:

Everyone claim in PM to Farobi - Farobi, don't share the claims with anyone you can't strongly identify as town.

There is one exception, which I've PM'd to Farobi, but like if that doesn't happen, I'm having a VERY hard time trying to ration why scum would say this. "Immense town cred!" ok, but town cred at what cost? The systematic destruction of your entire team and likely yourself in due time? Abe has experienced the power of strong trust circles first hand. These things are powerful as **** lemme tell you.
Mog: me no likey.

Yeah i apologise for boarding the evan train but i didn't know what else to do. Who even suspected punchy tho? Not that I was dead certain but i def agreed that his town slip prob meant he was town

This makes no sense from a town perspective to post. Scum perspective? Avoiding blame. But like rationally there's nothing? I'm aware little content is typical for her meta, but she's posted literally nothing. like good lord. Also popping in EoD at the last second after not posting at all is REALLY sketch to me.

 

[SensaiGallade]

Okay, Its getting late for me so I'm gonna stay around for a while on mobile then go to bed.

 

[Arstotzkan]

Endless mentioned the possibility of maf arsonist extensively

That's exactly my point mdude. He must have read thread to know maf arso, and Arso is explained within thread Im pretty sure, so not knowing yet reading thread is contradictory

 

[Heyden]

I think that's a pretty garbage reason to townread Endless @Kat, I literally said the same thing a page before. You do realise that there's probably scum in the godfathers, so who do you think it is?

 

[Arstotzkan]

I think that's a pretty garbage reason to townread Endless @Kat, I literally said the same thing a page before. You do realise that there's probably scum in the godfathers, so who do you think it is?

o lmao missed you posting that. I think there is **** ton of cred for being the first person to mention it, so move that read onto you

To answer your question tho, I think glow as of now. The amount of effort she put into her last post is crazy for scum, but her case on Dolby is utter horse **** and her PM with me last night made me feel ehhhhhhhhhhh (it was titled "And the sad thing is" before she mentioned she TRed me. It kinda gave me taunting vibes). I really need to ISO Abe and Dolby so this is subject to change, since while she had ****ing terrible logic in that case so is Dad in general this game so I don't feel comfortable dinging someone purely on bad logic, but I'm TRing everyone else atm. If not glow tho, I'd say Abe, then Dolby.

 

[Heyden]

I'm obviously feeling something no one else is with Dad's claim but whatever, I'll sleep over it. I doubt it's Glow or Dolby, and I don't know whether it's really between you and endless cos at this point it's just PoE for me and I'm praying toads didn't troll us and put a team of noobs.

 

[Arstotzkan]

I'm obviously feeling something no one else is with Dad's claim but whatever, I'll sleep over it. I doubt it's Glow or Dolby, and I don't know whether it's really between you and endless cos at this point it's just PoE for me and I'm praying toads didn't troll us and put a team of noobs.

Ironically, Abe actually mentioned something very similar in that Dad isn't clear

 

[Heyden]

Ironically, Abe actually mentioned something very similar in that Dad isn't clear

Ya, and I said it before him too. Ofc I'll just watch tonights actions and pray I don't get crisped.

- - - Post Merge - - -

actually you're right idk if that's just a coincidence or if he's sheeping me rn eh

 

[Arstotzkan]

Ya, and I said it before him too. Ofc I'll just watch tonights actions and pray I don't get crisped.

- - - Post Merge - - -

actually you're right idk if that's just a coincidence or if he's sheeping me rn eh

What's your opinion on Abe rn? I know POE **** but why null or scumlean?