trashpedia
🌟🌊
Alice is defo underrated and I’m surprised that she’s considered middle to low tier
Villagers you think deserve a little more love
- Thread starter oiwa
- Start date
meggtheegg
strawbaby she/her
Bree and Hazel deserve so much more love!!! They're so cute
Cheri makes me melt she's so adorable. I don't get her rating at all. But then, the only Tier 1 villager I think is cute is Molly so my tastes are out of sync.
I think Agnes is underrated. She’s a pig and all but I think she’s still pretty cool. Another villager I think is underrated is Rod. I guess he has the same problem as Agnes in which he is a mouse which many people don’t really like.
I looked through the tiers for all the villagers I've had in NL and now in NH (which is not all that many, I get attached quickly and don't like to let them leave--except Merry, boo Merry).
Jambette deserves more love. Her design is...ugh...but she's a sweetheart. Seconding Celia as well, she's so sweet! She was in one of my NL villages, and she was the first island villager I found and now she's on my island.
The second I found was Filbert, who is also one of my NL villagers turned NH villagers. Poncho is cute, even if jocks are uniformly annoying.
Wart, Jr. is my favorite. I like Tom, too, but not as much as Wart who has that cute little smile! I think Eloise is adorable, and Pecan is super sassy, so I don't get why they aren't more popular. I like Papi, too, he usually makes me laugh.
Out of all the 20 or so villagers I've had, somehow Kyle was the highest in tier 3. I do like Kyle (he's a big softy under that leather jacket), but IMO I have much better villagers!
Jambette deserves more love. Her design is...ugh...but she's a sweetheart. Seconding Celia as well, she's so sweet! She was in one of my NL villages, and she was the first island villager I found and now she's on my island.
The second I found was Filbert, who is also one of my NL villagers turned NH villagers. Poncho is cute, even if jocks are uniformly annoying.
Wart, Jr. is my favorite. I like Tom, too, but not as much as Wart who has that cute little smile! I think Eloise is adorable, and Pecan is super sassy, so I don't get why they aren't more popular. I like Papi, too, he usually makes me laugh.
Out of all the 20 or so villagers I've had, somehow Kyle was the highest in tier 3. I do like Kyle (he's a big softy under that leather jacket), but IMO I have much better villagers!
TheCelestial11
Senior Member
Carmen, Leonardo and Huck are amongst my all time favorites and I'm kind of sad they never get love.
Other lower tier villagers that need more love are Bertha, Candi, Tasha, Olive, Sprocket, Cole, Piper, Portia and Sylvana.
Other lower tier villagers that need more love are Bertha, Candi, Tasha, Olive, Sprocket, Cole, Piper, Portia and Sylvana.
Yesssss Doc love! I love him, he's a cutie and he and I share a birthday!
Other than Doc, I really love Gaston too. He was one of my first villagers in Wild World and man was he one of my best friends in the game.
I also think Bangle, Kidd, and Walt deserve more love!
(Editing to add Rowan and Tybalt. Honestly all the tigers deserve love, even Claudia)
Last edited:
Yessss I came here to say this. I was first mad I got him as a random move in, but the first day he became my favorite! I love this penguin.
Omg I actually had Agnes in my New Leaf Town and she was great. Don’t think Rod is underrated, because he’s actually in Tier 4, which is higher than People expect from Mouse Villagers. Just the problem that Jocks are mostly not that interesting and then people end up with Bam, Poncho, Kid Cat, etc.
I guess most Bears, Lions, Tiger and Kangaroos are underrated. Maybe people just don’t like Big Animals somehow?
Like Leopold looks like a cute Librarian Type (His Japanese Name is Teacher), Rooney has the Boxer Theme, Rowan is like a sleepy Tony the Tiger and Curt or Pinky are also adorable in their own ways. Just to name some of them.
Also yeah, Birds are also not that liked, but I adore Jacques, Midge, Piper and ofc Jay (Why is he Bottom of the Barrel?).
I also like Tashas Design. She is a Squirrel, but looks like a Skunk. That’s a neat combination. Sadly overshadowed by Peanut, etc.
I personally think that all species have some good designs, but I can understand that not every villager can be picked. It’s just one Island after all and you have to pick 10 Villagers.
Also what’s with the Hype about Cat Villagers. I have Mitzi in my Town and while I think she is a great Villager, I would not like a Town full of Cats or cutesy Villagers all over the place. I guess everyone has a different opinion, but that’s just me.
Last edited:
I think a lot of people love Kiki
YES! I had her in a mystery island yesterday TOO! And I was shook to see she was Tier 6. She's actually what inspired me to make the thread. Pink cute monkey with blush? Where can you go wrong.
Alice is actually my 2nd or 3rd favorite villager, and I love her to pieces. I've always been shocked at not seeing her higher up in the tiers. I was hoping someone would reply to this thread with Alice ;w; she was one of my dream villagers in New Leaf and someone gave her away to me! I was so happy.
peachmilke
sproutling
deirdre is super cute esp with her new horizons model idk why ppl love deer so much but sleep on her )): i also thought blanche would be higher tier'ed than she was these two are definitely my favorite villagers and ive had a blast having them in NH so far
itangerine
mocha ✧ she/they
I have yet to recruit more villagers but from my current island I'd say Genji. He's not ugly but I don't see much of him compared to others !! He was one of my first villagers and I've quickly grew obsessed with this silly sport obsessed furball.
here's a genji eating a lollipop for your daily needs
here's a genji eating a lollipop for your daily needs
Similar threads
