On my most recent island hopping trips I've had a list of villagers that I'm hoping to find and its mostly taken between 60-80 NMTs to come across one of those villagers. I quite enjoy island hopping so I allow myself 100NMT to find a villager during a search, taking breaks throughout the day when I'm tired of talking to the dodos. Luckily I've often found a villager I want before ticket 100 but whenever I don't I usually take a risk with the random move in - sometimes it's worked really well but mostly it's been a disaster
Early on in the game though I found both Raymond and Judy on around 20-30NMTs, I'd been looking for Fauna really but I hadn't built up enough Nook Miles for a long search and was running out of tickets so I took them and they've since become firm favourites of mine

Early on in the game though I found both Raymond and Judy on around 20-30NMTs, I'd been looking for Fauna really but I hadn't built up enough Nook Miles for a long search and was running out of tickets so I took them and they've since become firm favourites of mine