What's on your collectible wishlist?

[MrBox]

I'm curious!
I like to help people out if I can so I do enjoy seeing people's public's wish list in the marketplace. (Sorry if you got a DM or message from me asking and being nosy lmao. It is not me asking for your collectibles) Especially if they're cool and nice!

What's on YOUR collectible wishlist???

 

[BungoTheElf]

I think the only thing I really have left is the fresh feather, otherwise, I have everything on my list! I think the impostor wands are cool too but they're pretty rare so I don't really count them, also the rainbow star fragment but you have to place top 3 for that...

I'm pretty satisfied with the lineups I have now so I don't have to do any collectible hunting which I'm glad for but I also kinda miss it a little lol

 

[Foreverfox]

I have. Nothing else. On my wish list!! If I had to come up with something, I’d say Pokemon thing, like the pokeball, togepi egg, Eevee egg, and some alternating lemons and perfect peaches to go above my pikachu eggs. What’s on your wishlist?

 

[Briar]

Well, my dream collectibles at the moment are the Enchanted Butterfly Glow Wand

and the Pink Love Potion

. Aside from those, these are some of my other most-wanted collectibles:

 

[mogyay]

I don't really have a Wishlist! I don't really like the collectibles market lol - I like getting collectibles from events but I can't be bothered with them much outside of that

my long term goal is to get my pink potion back home (I don't regret trading it to get a friend something they deserved but I do miss it) but that will probably take a while lol

 

[-Apples-]

Pretty much everything I own now. If I choose to expand my collection again (which I won’t), my most likely ones are:

• Banana
• Red Tulip
• April Birthstone
• Bee Plush
• Hot Balloon
• Hot Chocolate
• Pumpkin Glow Wand
• Green Candy
• Ice Cream Swirl
• Spring Bloom Egg

And if I do have all of those, but still want more, then the following becomes:

• Lemon
• Pink Tulip
• May Birthstone
• Space Whale Plush
• Glam Balloon
• Jingle Doll
• Planet Glow Wand
• Blue Candy
• Blue Rocket Pop
• Pastel Disco Egg

 

[ZeldaCrossing64]

I've gotten most of the collectibles I want, and I'm very happy with my inventory! There's only a couple that I want, those being the Skull Wand and Glam Feather. Also the Pink Candy, but it's not tradable. Those are more long-term goals, though.

 

[Snek]

7 more Snake Figurines. Since it was unique during the event I could only get one anyway so I will be on a mission until I have two rows of snakes

 

[Roxxy]

my long term goal is to get my pink potion back home (I don't regret trading it to get a friend something they deserved but I do miss it) but that will probably take a while lol

Do dates matter?

I have been so lucky thanks to dear friends I have got all of my dream collectables so anymore would be greedy (but silver star wand is beautiful )

 

[mogyay]

Do dates matter?

I have been so lucky thanks to dear friends I have got all of my dream collectables so anymore would be greedy (but silver star wand is beautiful )

love u girl but absolutely don't be getting ideas lol

I promise it's just a long term goal of mine, I don't need one ! I'm very happy with what I have

Post automatically merged: Mar 18, 2025

ROXXY NO LOL I'm sending it back , I love u but no

 

[nightglow]

Right now the only things I have on a wishlist is date trading an aurora egg that I have to complete a line which i have date trading funds for as an incentive for right now and I hope to acquire a glow mushroom of a certain date to complete another line, however I have a lack of funds for that. (it would be nice if dates are done away with for orders of collectibles. It would be nice to have the slots assigned to numbers and the numbers selected on collectible activation)
If anything, I have too many collectibles and since I cannot seem to sell them, I plan on gifting some of them through time. My wishlist will probably grow as events come this year.

 

[MrBox]

I have. Nothing else. On my wish list!! If I had to come up with something, I’d say Pokemon thing, like the pokeball, togepi egg, Eevee egg, and some alternating lemons and perfect peaches to go above my pikachu eggs. What’s on your wishlist?

Honestly- Probably Gourdy, Fresh Feather and Wix and Vax Candies!! >:^D
Mainly a Fresh Feather though just so I can complete something that's been on my mind.. but it's whatever if I don't get one haha

There's something else on my mind but geugk , I do not want to add anything else

 

[Chere.]

Right now some main goals for myself would be the following:

Heart Glow Wand

Pale Wix Candy

Disco Egg


I would say that I prioritize my friends wish lists just a much though, so I'm just gonna include them here:

Celeste Chick Plush

Fresh Feather (points at you Box)

White Star Fragment

Pink Star Fragment


And these are collectibles I'd love but they're event-exclusive prizes so I'm not holding my breath lol:
Rainbow Star Fragment
Dark Candy

Crescent Moon Glow Wand

Also pretty specific, but I've been hoping for future

Galaxy Egg releases so I can date trade one of mine for a lineup I made during the last fair.

 

[mogyay]

my Wishlist is complete as lovely @Roxxy sent me a love potion tysm I love u and don't deserve such kindness

thanks for making this thread mrbox, didn't realise today was the day I'd finally get my lovely potion back - dreams do come true kids

I promise to try and fulfil some wishes as thanks

 

[MrBox]

my Wishlist is complete as lovely @Roxxy sent me a love potion tysm I love u and don't deserve such kindness

thanks for making this thread mrbox, didn't realise today was the day I'd finally get my lovely potion back - dreams do come true kids

I promise to try and fulfil some wishes as thanks

Ah?! Roxxy beat me to it!!!!!! When I gave up on my hunt I was going to gift mine to you cause you have been especially kind to me !!

 

[mogyay]

Ah?! Roxxy beat me to it!!!!!! When I gave up on my hunt I was going to gift mine to you cause you have been especially kind to me !!

everyone is too kind to meee that is so sweet of u to think of me !!! YOU'RE THE TOO KIND ONE - LET'S GET U A FRESH FEATHER

 

[-Blue-]

I know this is probably for ones that exist, but I really want an orange pumpkin kitty to go along with the ghost and shadow? kitty collectibles. Maybe instead of a sheet over their head it's a pumpkin head with a sheet body.

It would be cool if the shop showed all the collectibles even if they were out of stock. Half the times I don't even know which ones exist. The crow plush is cute. I ended up doing my math wrong and was like 1 coin short so if it comes back for this Halloween I'll probably get it.

 

[MrBox]

everyone is too kind to meee that is so sweet of u to think of me !!! YOU'RE THE TOO KIND ONE - LET'S GET U A FRESH FEATHER

IT IS OK.. it will come if it wants to

 

[cornimer]

The only collectible on my wishlist that I've never owned is a Rainbow Feather, but unfortunately that's pretty unattainable. I'm really happy with my current lineup though!

 

[Halloqueen]

I enjoy coming up with different lineups I want to build and, as new collectibles are introduced over time, my wishlist is thus always changing as I develop new concepts and new stuff provides new possibilities.

Currently:

- 2 Crystal Balls for a lineup.

- A 2014 or 2016 White Feather to date trade for my current 2024 one for lineup purposes. The date for this depends on...

- Pavé Purple Feather, Yellow Feather, and Red Feather, in that order, for a feather line with my Black Feather and White Feather. Green too, but lower priority.

- A Key Lime Pie since I like to bake, I have a few baked goods lineups and it's one of the only baked good collectibles I don't have, aside from the Half-Eaten Cupcake.

- A Rainbow Heart Balloon since I love it and it would be great for a lineup I have.

- A bunch of Perfect Apples.

- Spirit Candy: Pale Wix. I like collecting all of the candy collectibles and have all of them except for this one, Pink, and Dark.

- A Butterfly Glow Wand since I kinda warmed up to it and think it would be cool for a lineup. Lower priority.

- Pink Heart Glow Wand and Cyan Heart Glow Wand. I was never really on the Glow Wand train until the Pumpkin Glow Wand and Skull Glow Wand came out and I got them, then I got more interested in the others. Still didn't really care about the Flower/Heart/Star trio until the Impostors brought out the Cyan Heart, and now I like the contrast of the two Hearts and think it would be cool to own one of each Heart. Way too expensive though, and I rather focus on other, more affordable and attainable hunts.

---

There are also things that are event rewards, are unable to be traded and that I don't expect to ever acquire:

- Golden Easter Egg. I've loved it since my first Easter Egg Hunt here on the forums and love it even more now that it's animated. I'm fond of the more simplistic Easter Egg collectibles that look like something you can make at home. Unfortunately, I never solve all of the hints in a given hunt and, now that any ties are decided by who found what egg faster, I'm fairly certain I'll never own this. Would absolutely love it though.

- Pink Candy. I've missed my chance twice with bad guesses in Count Inside the Bottle events.

- Dark Candy. This predates the Pink Candy as an event reward. Would be cool for completion purposes.

- Shooting Star. Amazing for lineups that incorporate Night Sky Scenery.

- Crescent Moon Glow Wand. I'm a sucker for RGB color changing stuff.

---

I think that's everything currently. Might come up with other neat lineup ideas as I, hopefully, gradually knock out current hunts.