what's the rarest bug/fish you've caught so far?

Joined
Nov 2, 2016
Posts
4,927
Bells
2,796
Island
Alyse
Lost Star Fragment 004.MB
Moon Bunny
Blue Rocket Pop
Ocean Pearl
Oarfish Head
Oarfish Body
Oarfish Body
Oarfish Tail
Silver Moon Jellyfish
Red Super Star Trophy
Snow Bunny
Bloodshot Potion
today i caught an oarfish using bait and a sturgeon. haven't found any rare bugs yet, the rarest ones i've found are emperor butterflies and tarantulas which are pretty common at night.
 
:D.... Football fish. I caught 3 in a row.. Maybe not so impressive, but it made me happy. Is it bad their appearance was kind of jarring to me in this game though? I felt a pang of disappointment. I miss their teeth, but I love the detail everywhere else, and I love the new tank. It's cute you can click the tank to shut the esca on/off.. Hm.

Goldfish tank I was mad about. No more goldfish bowl. New one is pretty, but looks more like outdoor decor so that's where it is..
 
I got the coelacanth or something like that today. I was really going for that one so I was quite happy. Although the red snapper isn't rare or very profitable, its still my fave fish to catch after the sharks (even though I still haven't seen a shark.) The red snapper looks beautiful imo.
 
Coelacanth, sturgeon, oarfish, and football fish.

I agree the football fish look weird in this game. I suppose it’s realistic that a deep sea fish would look like a deflated football out of the water but I prefer their old scary look! Now they’re just sad.

I had a heart attack when I pulled the oarfish out. It just kept coming and coming...
 
Last edited:
Football fish
 
The Football/Angler Fish isn't really that rare, as I keep on finding them every time I fish at night.

Funnily enough, my first rare fish was the Coelacanth. Then I found a Sturgeon while hunting for a rare island with the nook miles ticket.
 
i've caught a coelacanth and a tarantula!

although i have fainted many many times to tarantulas already :( over ten times by now.. on my own island and islands i visited with my nook miles tickets!
 
I've gotten 3 sturgeon fish so far, but nothing as impressive as an oarfish or coelacanth. :(
 
Football fish/sturgeon - considering I never managed to catch either in the years I had my NL town, catching them both on my second day was a pleasant surprise lmao
 
There are 3 fish I've only caught once - Tuna (this only appears near the peer), Coelacanth and Sturgeon (mouth of river). These are my 3 rarest.

I thought the Tarantula would be pretty rare but I've caught 6 of them.
 
I’ve gotten an oarfish. Anddd maybe the peacock butter fly, mantis, and tarantula for bugs.
 
Got an Oarfish after grinding for a while yesterday, and I got lucky enough to have rain for a few hours this morning and go a coelacanth! As for bugs, I think Tarantula is my rarest. I also got a mole cricket early on which I hated getting in New Leaf so I'm happy about that.
 
i don't know about rare, but my fav bug so far is the orchid mantis. its design is just so beautiful!
 
I've caught two Oarfish so far... I feel like I play for hours and don't see any extra large fish though, am I doing something wrong?
 
I got a sturgeon yesterday and caught an oarfish about an hour ago! I didn't realise they were rare so reading this has made me happy lol
 
I'm not really sure what counts as rare...

I caught a tarantula....I also caught an Orchid Mantis. Don't know if that's rare but it looked cool.
 
Back
Top