Who is the best new horizons villager?

[Bulbadragon]

Megan. I love the bear villagers and her design is so cute, especially her smile. I also really like her house. I was super happy when I found her on a mystery island.

I'm surprised that currently Dom is winning the poll, because I thought for sure it would be Raymond. Also, I think his eyes are kinda creepy honestly.

 

[ForgottenT]

Sherb: Looks so weird to me, not a fan.
Cyd: I don't even know what to say about him, I don't like him.
Dom: Looks like a baby, I do not like him at all.
Raymond: Good design, but I don't particularly like him, I'd say he's A tier, but not quite dreamie.
Judy: I did not like her at first, I actually passed her up around 5 times on nook island trips, before I met her in someone elses town and I fell for her, and decided to get her next time she showed up, and she did not long after, and have been a part of my island since.
Megan: I like her, but she's not a dreamie.
Reneigh: The only horse I like, I doubt I'd ever invite her to my island, but I like her design a lot.

 

[S.J.]

I want to try hunting for Megan on Mystery island tours, but there's so many villagers, I wonder if it will be worth the time!

Edit: and I don't know that I'll ever have enough NMTs

 

[mermaidshelf]

I actually didn't like ANY of them when the game dropped but one of my starter villagers was Megan and I found Sherb randomly on a Mystery Island. Didn't expect to love Sherb so much that I kept him as my lazy (My boy Bob whom I've had in almost every game was dethroned. Lucky shares my bday and yet Sherb emerged victorious.) I was also watching a lot of ACNH meme vids on Youtube and that's when I fell in love with Dom, even though I thought he was ugly before. I eventually let Megan move out but it was hard to let her go. I gave her to someone who really wanted her so I'm happy that she's out there somewhere.

 

[Nefarious]

Voted Cyd, because I think he looks really cool. I'm still searching for him, but I know when I do, it's going to be difficult to let him go haha.
I also really like Dom, his face is really meme-able. I enjoyed having him while he was still living on my island. 10/10, would invite him again.

 

[Moritz]

I want to try hunting for Megan on Mystery island tours, but there's so many villagers, I wonder if it will be worth the time!

Edit: and I don't know that I'll ever have enough NMTs

Shes the second best villager I've ever had so certainly worth the time in my eyes.
As for if you will have the tickets...

If you dont mind time travel, the campsite method is pretty great. I got Megan, Judy, and dom that way.

 

[Halloqueen]

Tough call between Audie and Reneigh since I really like both of their character designs, but I think I'm going to go with Reneigh because I like her house more.

Raymond is third behind them. He has an overall sleek and pleasant design, the business attire suits him and the heterochromatic eyes are a nice touch. His house's interior design is also really nicely put together and he's a Smug, which is my favorite male villager personality. Just a really quality villager.

After them, I'd probably say Sherb fourth, Cyd fifth, Dom sixth, Judy seventh, Megan eighth.

I really love Judy's color scheme, but I'm not a fan of the sparkly eyes. I really like the contrast of her surprised expression though. If her default eyes were different, she'd probably be fourth.

 

[sleepydreepy]

Voted for Judy! I got her thinking I'd not like her and give her away to someone else but I ended up getting really attached to her! Her design isn't my style at all but I've come to love it, plus she sings all the time and its super cute