Who lives in your randomly generated island?

[Xara]

It’s been a while since I did this, so I wanted to generate a new list to see which villagers I’d get this time!

1. Monique - I’m not the biggest fan of her design, and there are definitely other cat and snooty villagers that I like more, but I’d be open to having her! I’m trying to not judge villagers solely on their appearances anymore, as I’ve had a lot of villagers that I’ve enjoyed and grown to love despite initially not being a fan of their appearances. I’m sure Monique would be lovely to have around!

2. Maggie - I really like Maggie! I adore the normal villagers, and Maggie has such a cute design! She’s always given me kind gardener vibes, haha; I think her and Leif would be good friends! I’ve never had Maggie before, so I would definitely be okay with having her!

3. Celia - Another normal villager that I really like, but have never had! She actually would have been my first normal villager in New Horizons if I hadn’t decided to let RNG choose instead. She has such a pretty design, I wouldn’t mind having her at all!

4. Deena - This is starting to look like an accurate villager lineup for me, since I almost never have less than 3 normal villagers at a time, LOL. I just love so many of them! Deena has never been one of my favourites, but I love the ducks, and she’s very cute, so I’d be happy to have her!

5. Agnes - I actually have her on my actual island! She’s one of my favourite villagers, and is so special to me. I’d be more than happy to have her on my randomly generated island as well.

6. Wart Jr. - He’s not one of my favourite villagers design-wise, but I’d be okay with having him and getting to know him!

7. Puck - A cutie!! I think he’s so adorable, but I’ve unfortunately never had him! I would be more than okay with having him! He’s such a cutie, I really like his design!

8. Gwen - Another penguin! Friga is definitely my favourite snooty penguin, but I like Gwen as well! I’d be okay with having her.

9. Blaire - Looks like I’ll be having a normal and snooty dominant island. Blaire is a cutie!

10. Cube - Penguin #3! He’s a nostalgic villager for me as he reminds me of Wild World, the years I spent playing it and my childhood. I wouldn’t mind having him at all! He’s very cute.

Dozer was actually the 5th villager, but I rerolled since he isn’t in New Horizons.

Overall, I wouldn’t mind having this lineup of villagers! There are a few villagers that I’ve never had before, and villagers that I’m not a huge fan of design-wise, but I think that’s more of a reason to have them and get to know them! My biggest complaint is the lack of personality diversity with no peppy, jock or smug villagers, but it’s not like my actual island has much personality diversity, either.

 

[Mistreil]

I kept the non-ACNH villagers in hopes that I'd get one that I like pierre and meow my beloveds and what do you know it was the right thing to do:

1. Ruby: moon bunnies unite!!
2. Marcy: she's certainly a marsupial...? i wouldn't mind, but her design is very... normal to me.
3. Tarou: he's cute! a happy purple wolf! i don't tend to have wolf villaegrs, but i wouldn't mind either
4. Freya: pretty pink wolf! cute cute.
5. Pierre: I love Pierre so much! I wish he existed outside of e+. i can still hope right
6. Daisy: daisy's always super cute!
7. Marshal: my baby boy... L(_ _L) thanks rng for giving me him here at least. i suffered with amiibo card rng
8. Merry: cute! i like her design a lot!
9. Lucha:
10. Derwin: i respect the blue

I'd keep my list - a lot of them are villagers I wouldn't pick naturally, but who I wouldn't mind at all! rng has blessed me on this day.
marshal and pierre are the two villagers i would always want in my town/island/city/etc. so. i will take this win

 

[olliebugge]

lets see!!

1.) goose - he's ... okay. im not the biggest fan of the chicken villagers but i do like birds, so i'm sure i would grow to like him!

2.) gwen - another bird!! honestly i'm not into her design, the colors feel like they clash and i'm not into snooty villagers very much, but hey, i like penguins.

3.) admiral - oh my god bird number three. i don't particularly like admiral.

4.) bubbles - finally, not a bird!! i like the hippo villagers, so while bubbles isn't my favorite, i could live with her.

5.) lyman - i do not like the koalas. that is all i have to say about him. although i like that he looks like a stick of celery.

6.) faith - oh god another koala. fun fact, faith was actually my starting villager on my current island, and i actually have her amiibo! i guess this is just her way of haunting me.

7.) monty - i've had monty before and he's... alright. i like the monkeys, i do, it's just that his design is a little dull for my taste. but hey, i like his house!!

8.) erik - finally a villager i like! i had erik for awhile on my current island and while i eventually let him move out, he was a cool guy and i'd be happy to have him again.

9.) peggy - also a villager i've had before! i hate her hair.

10.) cephlabot - !!!!!! love he

anyways most of these villagers i'm not a big fan of. i wouldn't mind letting most of them go except for erik and cephlabot.

 

[Snek]

1. Big Top
2. Phil
3. Admiral
4. Marlo
5. Wendy
6. Hans
7. O'Hare
8. Beau
9. Shino
10. Lopez

I got a good batch. One of them, Phil, is already on my real island. Randomly generated a lot of smugs, not thats a bad thing because I really like smugs.

 

[QueenCobra]

Gayle
Mac
Buzz
Flip
Pompom
Anchovy
Renee
Fauna
Cobb
Hippeux

Honestly I love all of them in different ways. It all works out lol.

 

[wuppytime]

HMM seems fun!!

- victoria
- bettina
- BOW!!!!!!!!!
- goose
- medli
- chops
- viché
- chadder
- phoebe
- curly

i would take this lot for bow alone, tbh. i'm not like. in love with anyone else on this list!! never had viché though so that'd be cool!

 

[Croconaw]

I may have done this before, but this is my list for 2024:

Pango
Tammy
Lyman
Limberg
Alfonso
Viche
Ribbot
Dozer
Gen
Frank

The only one I like even remotely is Alfonso. I didn’t get any dogs either. How disappointing. It’s safe to say I’m not a fan of this lineup.

 

[micat]

Peggy, Broccolo, Marcie, Etoile, Flip, Big Top, Rhonda, Becky, Quinn, Cobb

The first half of villagers I think I would like, but the second half (after Big Top), I’m not sure what to think of since I’ve never seen them before.
Also I thought it was funny that I got a bunch of villagers exclusive to Animal Crossing or Animal Forest e+ at first,, I had no idea there were more than a couple, and some of them seem really cool

 

[pottercrossing]

I got:

• Jacob
• Shino
• Monty
• Sheldon
• Olaf
• Marshal
• Robin
• Pinky
• Frett
• Piper

I'd keep Shino and Marshal and kick off all the others tbh, I'm not a fan of most of these guys.

 

[MrBox]

1. Winnie- I like her design actually, although I didn't feel anything for her when she was on my island
2. Bruce- Never had him on my island but he looks very cool! I'd probably grow attached if I had him in any of my AC games
3. Flip- Cute!
4. Tutu- I like her design! Never had her in any of my games though
5. Genji- I love Genji!! Otaku..
6. Walt- Walt looks very cool! Have a few friends who like him!
7. Blaire- Very cute !!
8. Bubbles- Also very cute!!!
9. Teddy- I like him! He was on my sister's island before
10. Jitters- Ahhhhh this villager. I like his deranged look but would probably feel unsettled if I had to keep interacting with him

 

[~Kilza~]

I was curious to see who I ended up with. I got 3 villagers who weren't a part of NH (Meow, Jane, Tiara), so I just re-rolled for them so that way I ended up with villagers I could actually get in NH:

1. Greta - Snooty mouse
2. Kitt - Normal kangaroo
3. Bree - Snooty mouse
4. Molly - Normal duck
5. Benedict - Lazy chicken
6. Shep - Smug dog
7. Apple - Peppy hamster
8. Ursala - Big sister bear
9. Tammy - Big sister bear cub
10. Ellie - Normal elephant

Ellie's the only one I've actually had before. But I definitely don't like this, since there's very little personality variety, and somehow two snooty mice to boot. I think I'd only keep Ellie, Bree, Benedict, Shep, Apple, and Ursala, then re-roll the rest.