Mafia Wrath of the Egyptian Gods - Kingmaker (Game Thread) Endgame

Status
Not open for further replies.
First and foremost, I am actually sick and taking a day off work, I may go to hospital again this evening. Yeah, I always get sick. So as I was reading the thread here is what I picked up;

I’m not sure how to react to Tina's behaviour now. Tina's reasoning for Tom really feels off. “They didn’t seem like *you* as a person” is highly confusing me, I’m taking it that it’s not a gut feeling and she’s judging by Tom's normal behaviour. Also, she acted quite aggressive in her post tone when she was replying to Trundle's question, I think she mentioned something about being aggressive in her RQ's as well. Well, back to the point of Tom. I don’t really see anything scummy in Tom's behaviour though, but I’m just going to take note of this and leave it here because you could say that Tina has had maybe a bit more experience with Tom in games, so I'll leave this be for now.

But later on through the thread, I see her getting aggressive and getting quite frustrated that people keep on sussing her for inactivity since she’s in a different Timezone, and I could get that. Also, looking back at her scum play in BoTW, it seemed very different to her play now, where in BOTW she was using quite some AtE to react to things. Like, in one post in BOTW I clearly remember she said “People are sussing me :sad face:”. In all honesty, I don’t think I could read Tina well. So I’m going to put her as null.

I’m actually slightly believing Toads' claim. People are questioning why he claimed so early, but it is believable for him to claim early because most of the people (including me) were sussing him, and you could see where Toads was coming from because he was like, the only scumlean option we had early then. And plus, do you guys really believe that Toads was scum and he’d claim survivor that early in a game? If he was scum and being sussed like this, he’d probably claim to be a Townie or something according to his safe claims. Definitely not a third party survivor.

@ Tina, my only un-nooby scum play was in Bowie's FNAF Mafia, in which I actually had to out because I was sick in hospital. ;(
Also, I’m going to make a reads list.
 
Didnt think glow was but you dont think Heyden either?

@Heyden confirm/deny? And if youre implying hostile 3rd party, why are you being cryptic about it?

If we're going solely off of rolename, it reminds me of a role we have on Azuri called Lovers. Usually its set up at the beginning of the game but there's a varient where Lover is a BN and they choose someone to be their partner. Theoretically speaking, its possible for Toads to be that and he's hiding his role in case he chooses to fall in love with scum, but I highly doubt that role's even seen the light of day on here so I'd wager its Surv, plus you could make the argument that love knows no bounds in war so it could go either way. Its odd for a Surv, but the only other thing I see it being is a mafian safeclaim, and Toads being mafia here would be ridiculous.

At home finally, gonna try to sort out some of my thoughts

I don't read Heyden's posts
 
I don't read Heyden's posts
giphy.gif
Why not tho?
 
It's not how you would play, so what? I've seen other claim 3rd party survivor and other non hostile roles and it work for them that's why

who and when have you seen that happen?
 
Also, if you want to know Waffles' pronouns, look at the tag section.
I only just realised xD.
 
who and when have you seen that happen?

Tom did it in death by design.... he claimed survivor day 1 and then got to coast on it. F11 in the last game didn't claim it ever (props to you for that) and got killed eventually. I had a bunch of people come at me for different reasons, and I tried to deal with it last night. But I didn't like where I stood this morning, so I figured it would be in my best interest to just claim
 
Wasn't thinking blue, lover's possible maybe idk I still can't pull myself together to trust Toads for what he claims.

Ftr I think my 'effort' is always brought up as a scumread reason, but I've honestly never had a game where I believe I was remotely helpful D1 in lynching scum, unless pushed to do so.
 
In the history of replacements, replacements tend to be critical roles either mafia or blue

- - - Post Merge - - -

If I am townie, and I need replaced...I'll just get modkilled. That's what I am thinking...
 
idk what a lover is either, but reading up on it from mafiawiki, I don't have any quick topics or was told of any person being connected to me... so unless I'm fully unaware then idk what to tell you other than don't lynch me
 
In the history of replacements, replacements tend to be critical roles either mafia or blue

- - - Post Merge - - -

If I am townie, and I need replaced...I'll just get modkilled. That's what I am thinking...

I’ll have you know that I replaced Mog.
 
I posted my reads list and said it was from mobile because that is why I didn't elaborate on them. Whenever I make an reads list, I always draft it in word and then copypaste it here. I don't like posting giant reads from a phone lol. But for my reads list earlier, I was about to head someplace and wanted to get my thoughts out there.

probably going to elaborate further on all of my reads later on, but glow said I scumread her after she sr'd me, which isn't exactly accurate. I expressed doubts about her before she did that, yeah I didn't formally sr but I was still trying to feel people out and posted issues I had with her playstyle. So what she's implying is that I'm just sussing her for sussing me, which is incorrect.

As for why I townread cleb and heyden, I felt cleb didn't have anything to hide with his posts (though he hasn't been here too much), and I thought heyden was playing like he usually did as town. But with his cryptic "I have anti town thoughts" post, I'm tempted to move him to null.

Dolby is in null because for the thousandth time, him being the king does not confirm him in any way, and he's also realllllly good at appearing town as any alignment. I also didn't look at dolby's reads when making my own - I read them earlier and then wrote my own later on, and they happen to have a lot of similarities.

However, the past couple of games he's been much easier to read as being anti town. Right now, under a kingmaker setup, I'm having a harder time pinning him down.
 
Evan, what do you think of Tina. Also, what about Cleb’s 1 Post makes you want to townlean him
 
uhm wut

replacements have recently been mainly scum, but I think it was rather mixed on which roles they were before I played. Someone replacing isn't a surefire way to tell alignment, it just means they can't play anymore and replace out instead of purposefully getting modkilled, which ruins the fun
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top