• Guest, you're invited to help build our new TBT time capsule! It contains three parts, with some of its elements planned to open in 2029 and others not until the distant future of 2034. Get started in 2024 Community Time Capsule: Blueprints.

Mafia Wrath of the Egyptian Gods - Kingmaker (Game Thread) Endgame

Status
Not open for further replies.
It's not. Which is why I really hope you don't get King'd. You're so horribly wrong on me that I am hesitant to trust your judgement on others either.

I doubt I'll get made king. While it's fairly obvious I'm town, most people don't trust my judgment and stated they want to king either a newbie or someone who'd have very obviously tells anyway.

- - - Post Merge - - -

It's not. Which is why I really hope you don't get King'd. You're so horribly wrong on me that I am hesitant to trust your judgement on others either.

Also, I can't be "horribly wrong" on you. I'm either right or I'm wrong. Implying anything otherwise is AtE :)
 
I doubt I'll get made king. While it's fairly obvious I'm town, most people don't trust my judgment and stated they want to king either a newbie or someone who'd have very obviously tells anyway.

As someone you've misread, I would say they're very right not to trust your judgement.
 
tbh, everyone believes my claim the most... and you should know a survivor wants to lynch mafia just as much as any town member sooooo

- - - Post Merge - - -

My gut feeling is Evan is not scum in this game, like oher games. Ive seen him in only one other mafia role in Franchise wars

can you come up with any valid reasoning? because I'm not in your intestines and I can't see your gut
 
ugh y'all campaigning already, and this cycle isn't even over

tbh if kingmaker legit doesn't know who to pick, toads may not be all that bad of an idea. He did pledge to vote for who wins the popular vote (unlike the Electoral College LUL) after all.

That depends on if we all choose to believe the survivor claim (which I and most of town seemingly do), and if kingmaker can't trust ANYONE. Which, at this point, they should have some solid town reads anyway.

So under only one extreme circumstance should the survivor be made king IMO.
 
tina's tone is good tho, and there's a noticeable difference in her attentiveness to the thread compared to that one game where she was maf.

i don't mean activity when i say attentive, i mean like you can tell she's actively taking part in moving discussion forward whereas when she was mafia she would just analyze and react to everything that everyone else was doing

not that only reacting and not generating is a scumtell in and of itself, i just mean there's clear differences in her approach this game. this is something so minor that i don't think she'd adapt to fake it in her scumplay

- - - Post Merge - - -

ugh y'all campaigning already, and this cycle isn't even over

tbh if kingmaker legit doesn't know who to pick, toads may not be all that bad of an idea. He did pledge to vote for who wins the popular vote (unlike the Electoral College LUL) after all.

That depends on if we all choose to believe the survivor claim (which I and most of town seemingly do), and if kingmaker can't trust ANYONE. Which, at this point, they should have some solid town reads anyway.

So under only one extreme circumstance should the survivor be made king IMO.

only mafia would align with a self proclaimed third party

who do you think it's easier to win with? town or mafia? he could be hostile for christs sakes
 
tina's tone is good tho, and there's a noticeable difference in her attentiveness to the thread compared to that one game where she was maf.

i don't mean activity when i say attentive, i mean like you can tell she's actively taking part in moving discussion forward whereas when she was mafia she would just analyze and react to everything that everyone else was doing

not that only reacting and not generating is a scumtell in and of itself, i just mean there's clear differences in her approach this game. this is something so minor that i don't think she'd adapt to fake it in her scumplay

- - - Post Merge - - -



only mafia would align with a self proclaimed third party

who do you think it's easier to win with? town or mafia? he could be hostile for christs sakes

That's because she's already been hard pressed. I highly doubt she would be so attentive if I hadn't called her out so early.
 
grudges are out of style

wPoqvw6.gif
 
That's because she's already been hard pressed. I highly doubt she would be so attentive if I hadn't called her out so early.

Oh please you know if I were scum I wouldn't even be acknowledging your posts D1.

I'm playing the game because I wanna be here. I got the role I wanted and I'm happy to play. I hate being scum it's not exactly a secret.
 
Okay, so I’ve read up.
My thoughts on Tom have changed a bit. This was the one post that concerned me;
smh i try and pull the wagon off you and not only are you not giving me the reactions I’m looking for, but you suss me for that?
I’m actually not sure what’s going on here. It’s either that Tom is trying to pocket Panda, Panda is scum mates with Tom or that Panda is Scum and rejecting Tom. I’m kind of thinking that Tom is actually trying to pocket Panda, because for no exact reason he goes ahead and says:
The lynch is your choice, do or don’t it’ll be popcorn either way.
We go ahead and ask him what his theories about Panda is, but he doesn’t explain it at all, just leaving us with the words “You will know eventually”. I’ve had one possible outcome come into my head, but I highly doubt the outcome is true because there’s no evidence to support it. Also, I’ve read up on Caxnival Mafia, on Panda's posts, and her tone actually feels the same, but I don’t know, it’s only day 1 and things she has said further into the Caxnival game has different content, so I’ll look at her content for Day 2 if she’s still living and see about that.
 
Oh please you know if I were scum I wouldn't even be acknowledging your posts D1.

I'm playing the game because I wanna be here. I got the role I wanted and I'm happy to play. I hate being scum it's not exactly a secret.

If I knew that why would I still think you're scum? Didn't you say I'm your strongest town lean? That doesn't add up. #minislip
 
Reads so far:

1. Trundle - Null read for the most part, like he said, I?m bad at reading him. His posts kind of strike me as townsided, but for the most part none of them have any real substance in my eyes. Most are questions or memey, while the rest kind of just sheep Dolby. Null/town

2. SensaiGallade - With only thirty posts in the game, only two of their posts have any real substance which is incredibly disappointing if I?m honest. http://www.belltreeforums.com/showthread.php?437033-Wrath-of-the-Egyptian-Gods-Kingmaker-(Game-Thread)&p=7672985&viewfull=1#post7672985?]Their reads [/url] and http://www.belltreeforums.com/showthread.php?437033-Wrath-of-the-Egyptian-Gods-Kingmaker-(Game-Thread)&p=7673007&viewfull=1#post7673007?]a small addendum explaining their reads on Zendal/Tina/Tom.[/url] His reads feel kind of forced in my opinion, as if thrown up to appear useful to town. The one thing that strikes me as odd too is how he mimics Tina in saying I?m off, but he can?t place it? Surely if it?s a hard scumlean, you have more than idle Discord conversation to go with this. Not only that, but he flips on Trundle just because Trundle pressed him. Sensai just strikes me as eager to please in this case, with me hard scum leaning him.

3. Amazonevan19 - Reading your posts are legitimately killing me more than this fever, most of them scream word vomit as many of them were merged as if you were rapid fire posting any thought that crossed into your head there. For the most part you seem focused on my play as a survivor, which to be frank is a bad idea. As a survivor I don?t have to care about anything other than not pissing town off. But I?m not a survivor this game, so naturally my MO here has changed. But I?m digressing and merely responding to you now. I just don?t like any of your content, it all feels hollow for the most part. Peek behind the curtain and there?s really nothing there. Throwback to people who complained about Sataric ?fluffing? posts, can I present king fluff here. Null/scum.

4. VanessaMay18 - never played nor really watched them so they?re new to me. There?s nothing really in her posts that strike me as town or mafia either way. I would like to know if you still feel Hayden is kind of scummy? Null.

5. Dolby - Dearest Dolby, how much do I hate reading you? Let me count the ways some other time. Either you?ve gotten easier to read or I just continue getting worse, I'm actually townreading your blue sniping buttocks. That?s kind of it, uhhh ?Hail Eternal Leader?

6. Toadsworthy - Trying to speed reads up at this point because it?s taking me forever, but mostly I have no reason to not immediately trust his claim as survivor but at the same time I don?t understand fully why he didn?t just come out of the gate swinging like that. It makes more sense to me for a good survivor to be upfront about their role instead of sitting on it until pressed, but at the same time this being a kingmaker game throws a wrench in that. What I?m getting at is that at the very least Toad is townsided, because I am assuming greatly that he held off for a little bit to possibly keep the townie target list low?

7. xCleb - Two posts, not gonna bother trying to dissect an RQS or whatever got posted. Null, pending replacement.

8. Biancabotique - Posts aren?t great. I don?t get why they want Ryumia to be inspected and/or kinged if they sussed Zendal so much. That would be like me negging Evan all game but saying I want him kinged. Nullscumlean.

9. ITookYourWaffles - Null scummish, but honestly Im just getting flashbacks to mafia games wayback where Waffles did the same kind of posts but was kind of all over the place alignment wise. I think though that she tended to be quieter as scum and so far, she?s vocal enough so it?s more null than scum.

10. Tom - it?s me hi hello

11. Chick - Im town reading Chick, mostly because the majority of their posts don?t strike me as filler or echoing somebody else?s posts. They stand out on their own here and I would definitely look to Chick as a potential candidate for King in coming days.

12. Byngo/Tae - Null.

13. Heyden - Going back to my first post, I always scumlean Heyden. Heyden is usually the scum player who gets away in later days because nobody is confident enough to lead a lynch on them because of their posts or eventually promised bsd reads. Would recommend vig take Heyden out honestly, practically every other play we can drag information out of in some other way.

14. Tina - Honestly town reading Tina. Not seeing any obvious red flags that I?ve noticed before playing with her as scum.

15. Arstotzkan - Kat strikes me as super guarded this game for some reason, which is making it hard for me to read her. Everything strikes me as townsided, but Im fairly confident Ive said that before with scum Kat as well. Null

(Running out of time, even quicker reads cuz oops)

16. Jacob - Not good at reading Jacob, but most of his post strike me as townsided so far so Im inclined to think he?s town right now.

17. Ryumia - Null, they?re still getting the hang of it

18. Glow - I would probably sheep her to my doom honestly, but I really need to reread her stuff at a later date before firmly town/scum siding. Null

19. PandaDarling - I miss the older, more talkative, gets irritated when sussed Panda. Not digging this current Panda, especially since I?m starting to think I freaked myself out over theories that are just that: theories. I want to town read her, but her unhelpfulness until literally the last couple hours of day has me scum leaning her more than anything rn

20. F11 - kinda like Heyden, dont trust. Would be a good vig shot in my mind if isnt lynched, which based off my last cursory glance through the latest pages isn?t likely now.

Would have preferred to color, flesh out read sbut i need to get ready to take my brother out trick or trreating since nobody else is available. Will try to peek on the thread between houses but no promises
 
If I knew that why would I still think you're scum? Didn't you say I'm your strongest town lean? That doesn't add up. #minislip

You're my strongest town lean because I don't think you'd be this arrogant if you were scum. Just because you're wrong on me doesn't mean I'm going to retaliate on you.
 
@Tom yeah I still feel like Heyden is scummy. They were much more helpful last game when they were town
 
Reads so far:

Putting a mental pin in this to return to tomorrow. On drink #7 I think. But I'm so glad I'm not the only one who has noticed this about Trundle. Although I am tempted to just peg it done as D1? Other aspects have me pinning him as town otherwise.

His posts kind of strike me as townsided, but for the most part none of them have any real substance in my eyes...

Your read on Sensai is also interesting and something I want to look into more.

Kinda skimmed after that point sorry I'm at that point where I need some sleep.

Caught the word "fever" in there. Not feeling well honey? :(
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top