Mafia Wrath of the Egyptian Gods - Kingmaker (Game Thread) Endgame
- Thread starter N e s s
- Start date
- Status
Biancasbotique
Sweet Feather
This doesn't make sense...We have a survivor and a SK? Seriously?
Heyden got hit? by Sk or mafia? If there is no SK or town roleblocker, Heyden you are lying!
If there is a town roleblocker, you should be the one who is coming out so you can say who is mafia and doctor can protect you
- - - Post Merge - - -
well after night 2 is over....so we can lynch mafia..
I can accept there is a town blocker but two third parties?
Heyden got hit? by Sk or mafia? If there is no SK or town roleblocker, Heyden you are lying!
If there is a town roleblocker, you should be the one who is coming out so you can say who is mafia and doctor can protect you
- - - Post Merge - - -
well after night 2 is over....so we can lynch mafia..
I can accept there is a town blocker but two third parties?
toadsworthy
Tangsworthy
yeah where'd you pull out a town role blocker from?
Biancasbotique
Sweet Feather
well its just suspicious you are doing a campaign for doctor to save you
- - - Post Merge - - -
i dont believe there is an SK for real!
so the only hit that is possible is from mafia and heyden is alive now because townblocker blocked mafia who hit heyden..
unless its all factional kill
- - - Post Merge - - -
okay..nevermind...if its a strong-arm kill , Heyden will be dead now..
so the question is either we believe we have an SK or Heyden is lying about being shot
- - - Post Merge - - -
i dont believe there is an SK for real!
so the only hit that is possible is from mafia and heyden is alive now because townblocker blocked mafia who hit heyden..
unless its all factional kill
- - - Post Merge - - -
okay..nevermind...if its a strong-arm kill , Heyden will be dead now..
so the question is either we believe we have an SK or Heyden is lying about being shot
It's okay. I don't think any of us will hold this against you.
Biancasbotique
Sweet Feather
geez nevermind
Biancasbotique
Sweet Feather
So he can have a license to say to the doctor "save me" so we lose that protection
- - - Post Merge - - -
Its just a wild idea I had when I saw Heyden insisted that he get protected
should have lynched him then
VanessaMay18
KermitTea
Tae
PandaDarling
F11
My suggestions for King. I would throw hayden in there but, I already know he would lynch Waffles. His play wouldn't actually reveal much.
I wanted people who aren't heavily town or scum read, Newbies, or any one who can easily mask the fact that they are mafia as King. I would prefer none of the Godfathers at this point get Kinged.
The biggest issue is that the players that fit this agenda are the ones who are generally more quiet (Not Tae or Vanessa as much). Maybe it'll force them to participate, but it could also end up with just an inactive King.
I think the best fit for king would actually be Tae, but I'm ok with any of the five
KermitTea
Tae
PandaDarling
F11
My suggestions for King. I would throw hayden in there but, I already know he would lynch Waffles. His play wouldn't actually reveal much.
I wanted people who aren't heavily town or scum read, Newbies, or any one who can easily mask the fact that they are mafia as King. I would prefer none of the Godfathers at this point get Kinged.
The biggest issue is that the players that fit this agenda are the ones who are generally more quiet (Not Tae or Vanessa as much). Maybe it'll force them to participate, but it could also end up with just an inactive King.
I think the best fit for king would actually be Tae, but I'm ok with any of the five
caught up a little
-- don't like how everyone is immediately onto lynch waffles tomorrow train. I just went through waffle's filter and I'm on the fence about their alignment. the so-called tom defense that I can tell is 1 color reads post way earlier and then another one where they say they don't know where the tom sus came from. I honestly doubt that (good) scum would stick their foot out like that and attempt to save town, but then there is also a small contradiction where waffles says "I'm more interested with Tina vs Tom than Trundle vs Ryumia" which I interpreted as: "I want to settle Tina vs Tom over Trundle vs Ryumia", in which case lynching Tom would definitely solve that.
-- Jacob, don't blame yourself, I was pretty certain that Tom would be scum as well. rip.
- - - Post Merge - - -
-- I'm leaning towards Sensai as scum.
- - - Post Merge - - -
I suppose I shoud elaborate my suspicion
gut feeling which stems from some similarities from their previous scum game (def a while back) that i subconsciously noticed as I was going through their filter
i can't pinpoint what it is, but it reminds me of their scum play
- - - Post Merge - - -
With tom / heyden:
Must've missed something but how do you know tom didn't shoot heyden? tom didn't go after heyden, meaning that he is obviously in some agreement with heyden's claim of getting shot. If tom didn't shoot heyden then he would've either gone after heyden or pushed heavily for the possibility of SK (didn't check tom's filter yet to see if he did any of these). Tbh heyden is pseudo confirmed at this point.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Also to add to my last theory. If tom hadn't used his shot yet, he could've easily claimed and proved himself, yes? So the only reason why he wouldn't logically claim is because his shot has been used.
-- don't like how everyone is immediately onto lynch waffles tomorrow train. I just went through waffle's filter and I'm on the fence about their alignment. the so-called tom defense that I can tell is 1 color reads post way earlier and then another one where they say they don't know where the tom sus came from. I honestly doubt that (good) scum would stick their foot out like that and attempt to save town, but then there is also a small contradiction where waffles says "I'm more interested with Tina vs Tom than Trundle vs Ryumia" which I interpreted as: "I want to settle Tina vs Tom over Trundle vs Ryumia", in which case lynching Tom would definitely solve that.
-- Jacob, don't blame yourself, I was pretty certain that Tom would be scum as well. rip.
- - - Post Merge - - -
-- I'm leaning towards Sensai as scum.
- - - Post Merge - - -
I suppose I shoud elaborate my suspicion
gut feeling which stems from some similarities from their previous scum game (def a while back) that i subconsciously noticed as I was going through their filter
i can't pinpoint what it is, but it reminds me of their scum play
- - - Post Merge - - -
With tom / heyden:
Must've missed something but how do you know tom didn't shoot heyden? tom didn't go after heyden, meaning that he is obviously in some agreement with heyden's claim of getting shot. If tom didn't shoot heyden then he would've either gone after heyden or pushed heavily for the possibility of SK (didn't check tom's filter yet to see if he did any of these). Tbh heyden is pseudo confirmed at this point.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Also to add to my last theory. If tom hadn't used his shot yet, he could've easily claimed and proved himself, yes? So the only reason why he wouldn't logically claim is because his shot has been used.
toadsworthy
Tangsworthy
Kermit, thoughts on me
cornimer
grab acorns 'til you're delirious
Well that was a lot to catch up on. Some freeflow thoughts before I sleep:
-Call me crazy but against all logic I still think toads is survivor. Which makes Heyden's claim of being shot and saved questionable...but someone probably would've came out if he was lying. So maybe 2 vigs, or some other weird role that we're not even thinking of? I mean last game there were kinda two vigs. (Also Heyden's post about his wincon what even)
-I still want waffles lynched next, 100%.
-Bianca has posted some Truly Bizarre things tonight and idk how I feel about her anymore.
-Tom why didn't u claim
-I thought I had more thoughts but I guess not. If anyone has questions just ask me
-Oh and as I said earlier suss on Sensai has gone up now because him going from scumreading to townreading Tom kinda looks like a too-hard attempt to go against the status quo.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Oh, I want Tina for Queen next. I know that crowning an experienced player is risky but I townlean her very strongly, and I am not confident on any of the less experienced players being town.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Nobody's here well I'm going to sleep but I'll respond to anything in the morning
-Call me crazy but against all logic I still think toads is survivor. Which makes Heyden's claim of being shot and saved questionable...but someone probably would've came out if he was lying. So maybe 2 vigs, or some other weird role that we're not even thinking of? I mean last game there were kinda two vigs. (Also Heyden's post about his wincon what even)
-I still want waffles lynched next, 100%.
-Bianca has posted some Truly Bizarre things tonight and idk how I feel about her anymore.
-Tom why didn't u claim
-I thought I had more thoughts but I guess not. If anyone has questions just ask me
-Oh and as I said earlier suss on Sensai has gone up now because him going from scumreading to townreading Tom kinda looks like a too-hard attempt to go against the status quo.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Oh, I want Tina for Queen next. I know that crowning an experienced player is risky but I townlean her very strongly, and I am not confident on any of the less experienced players being town.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Nobody's here
well I'm going to sleep but I'll respond to anything in the morning
toadsworthy
Tangsworthy
absolutely no Tina crowned
I scum read her
I scum read her
- Status
