I just re-read everything, I wish I had been here for end of day because the kcat lynch was dumb. I mean they were new, yes, said they would check in each hour, but how many new people that join mafia do you actually know that add a lot to the game. Chele had suggested a randomized lynch, waffles said it was dumb, and kcat agreed. Nothing about that seems suspicious.... except that she like kinda didn't elaborate, but she was also very new.
Kallie I don't scum read for it really at this point because she generated the discussion first. It could've been easier as a prominent player to just lay back and let someone else say something and go from there. Kallie is cunning enough to lead a day 1 lynch as a mafia, but I don't think that is a smart play on her end given how dead this was.
Dedenne is always pretty apathetic and minimal, so like nothing from her posts stand out to me. It is still very sus and I scum lean her for it, but nothing she has said really strikes out. It was a bad vote, and dedenne is kinda owning it.
Chele however seems to want to overexplain her vote to us a lot. the OMGUS from my little comment was a lot, and to say I am just "irrational" and "can't say that" is dramatic to the point where I get suspicious.
chele said:
Jay - She answered RQ's, and also answered an activity question but then went away. The "agree" thing seems to be a push, but at the same time I don't really know how to react considering that she's new to Mafia and has little experience. Something else to consider is that she said that she would pop in about every hour of the day, however, she's made 3 posts (including RQs). I need clarification from her but for now, she is my #1 lynch candidate.
I mean you did word it different from Kallie I guess, but saying you had your own "reasoning" to vote someone who only had 2 posts, one of which was two words is stretching it. Also you wanted to nail her down for saying she was gonna check in, but Mog also said she was going to be off for a whole day and didn't say one single post. Also your saying that Kcat made a "push," but idk what that means, she wasn't trying to push anything, she was agreeing with Waffles that a randomized lynch was a bad idea before it got started.
The only thing helping Chele is that she voted 2nd which if she was scum would have no reason to vote onto a bandwagon she knows is for a town person and could've easily blended in. I see it more of bad town play and weak analysis and eagerness to find a lynch candidate than overwhelmingly scummy.
Chele can you tell me the last like few games you were in and your alignment?
I guess Dedenne looks more sus from that perspective, but still... nothing about Dedenne really piques my interest. I do want to hear Mog, Jacob, and everyone else's perspective of the events from day 1 without people saying "omg it was boring." There is definitely enough to go off of
