Mafia A Summer Fling- Mafia Win!

[nintendofan85]

Can you read the rules instead of yapping around

Can you send me a link to them, please?

 

[dedenne]

Can you send me a link to them, please?

arent u supposed to read them before u play *thinks violently*

 

[nintendofan85]

arent u supposed to read them before u play *thinks violently*

If I read them, it was a long time ago.

Like I said, the only other time I played mafia on here was over three years ago.

 

[dedenne]

If I read them, it was a long time ago.

Like I said, the only other time I played mafia on here was over three years ago.

fair enough but if u forgot theyre literally stickied for u to tead

- - - Post Merge - - -

read

 

[Jacob]

Posting at end of phase in case I die

From this, nobody can put sus on us for just voting incorrectly, as we actually did something in the game.

While I do understand your perspective on activity, it's strange to me that you think mislynching even though you participated warrants a pass on being suss'ed. Regardless of the team you're on, EVERYBODY is expected to participate and do something for this game. At the very least I'd think a member of the mafia would be a little bit attentive to making sure they remain active in a game like this. Your logic here is a little flawed- and definitely comes across as you trying to hand out your activity in a slower game as a reason for people to town read you. Everyone including Daniel appreciates the activity of those who are putting in the effort (I again apologize for my own inactivity), but you absolutely can be suss'ed for joining in on a mislynch if there is good evidence. I personally am not trying to actually scum read you based on who you voted or why, but your mindset is alarmingly self aware

It was all a matter of RNG, no joke.

This also rubs me the wrong way due to the fact that pretty much everyone since the moment RNG voting was brought up in this game has been saying "Let's NOT random vote because it gives no info." I don't think any mafia member would be ballsy enough to RNG vote after everyone's warnings, but the fact that it looks like you aren't reading in depth enough looks to me like you're coasting, and missed everyone's warnings. I.e. You don't need to read during the day to search for mafia, and you voted a random player in order to stay off of a mislynch train to appear less scummy.

Following this, should Nintendofan die tonight and flips red, I town-lean Kirbyz.


End of Night 1 list for me. Leans aren't heavy, but in case I die please refer back to this:

Chele
Nintendofan85 (connected: Kirbyz)

Sorry it's short, these are the only observations that I feel confident enough in to call my own

 

[Damniel]

Day Two

toadsworthy has died. He was a 1-shot vigilante.

mogyay has died. She was a Townie

Day Two has started and will end in 48 hours on July 28th 6PM EST.

Due to inactivity, Kirbyz has been removed from the game and has been replaced by Byngo, welcome!
​

 

[Chele]

Welcome Byngo!
And UGHGHGH. I made this post as I was reading through the thread and before I knew about the deaths. There's no point deleting my whole post so just so answer questions and my response on things, here it is:

Spoiler: Text

-

I hope you're taking into account that I meant randomized = lynch with little reasoning. I explained this to Kallie earlier.
I guess you could take it that way, but the reason I am trying to reason a lot is because I want to provide discussion at the least and settle for a lynch candidate.
And sure, your comment was little but the meaning behind it (popping in and declaring that one of us were scum) was a big deal, because the 'bandwagon idea' was meaningless, as only three had voted. The 'over-dramatic' part isn't new to me, to be honest. I recall using the same term "you have no right to say that". Read this part (the battle of the nobles) where I was Town. I still use the same 'overdramatic' approach. That's just my play I guess.

That feeling when you?ve slept and there?s like SO many more pages to read up on. I hate timezones.

Spoiler: Wall of text

How does Antonio?s RQ?s involve fluff? There?s literally nothing that seems fillery or forced. It?s just him talking about his playstyle, pronouns and personal opinion on what happened in other games. Also, I don?t think that he?s even shading players. This is a bad case to make, especially on his RQ?s.

Yes, he is uncoordinated but look into his playstyle and look at his previous posts. He even mentioned Dad in one of his posts and didn?t think that Dolby was playing. This means that he is just inattentive. Just wait until he posts more then you could make a judgement.

Majority of people are going for Antonio just for his RQ?s. I feel like this is just a very easy bandwagon because so many other people have just been saying stuff about him and I?m pretty sure that I have proved him to be ignorant towards the game. Obviously he didn?t read the OP or just skimmed through the posts, but that?s not AI at all. You have no right to even sus him over one post (which is his first post). Also I?m not just aiming this at you, Mog.



It is sorta filler to just comment on something which feels ?weird? and not even feel sus about it? It?s just the damn RQ?s and an OP, there?s no point even making a case off of it.

First of all, can we just count how many players have already declared that the RQ?s and Evan?s refusal aren?t AI? I don?t see how Heyden only stands out to you for that reason. Second, he?s only made two posts so far (aside from the RQ?s), so how does meta and the way only one of the posts that you?ve quoted make it look ?good?? Third, reading into something carefully could also be a Mafia tactic so that they could sus many people based on little things. How does reading into only one question from Dolby?s RQ?s form a reason to clear Heyden for you?

HOW? How is her content AI? Why wouldn?t she defend you as scum? Elaborate please.

How was I overcautious? Also, it is a valid point to shrug off Vanessa. Dolby came into the game saying ?yo toads and ness are sucking up to vanessa using the RQ?s? and obviously that?s a very wrong sus. You can?t just sus somebody for asking for RQ?s from Vanessa. As well as that, many other people asked for the RQ?s. And yeah, I always use paragraphs and reasoning to state my points? Again, I?m confused as to why you?re only targeting Ness and I in this. What happened to Toads, Antonio and Evan? I?m pretty sure I defended way more people as well. Ness never defended me.

I expected Mog and Jay to come in before EoD. Even then, I didn't want to lynch an inactive as they could've gotten
a replacement or modkilled, and I knew that Jay was lurking. Obviously my reasoning in general was poor due to
this game being so bland.
The last few games I was in was long ago. I think Generic Mafia (my first ever game on this forum) and the Scummies
are the two in which I was Mafia. The rest, I was town-aligned.

To make thing short I kinda didn't like how Chele acts defensive regarding her vote

To be fairly honest, this is my play in most games. Plus, I am always defensive and unafraid to talk, because I did mention my reason.

Chele's tone from previous games seems the same too... although it is a little bit more defensive than the last game

That's because it's been like 6 months since my last Mafia game. Undeniably, things have changed.

usually chele makes massive wallposts if shes mafia. rn i think shes town

To be fairly honest, I sometimes refrained from making massive wallposts in larger games since they were more fast-paced and people wouldn't read over them. It kinda explains the Scummies game, but then again, all I spammed was "vote farley for senate".

-

No, mislynching and not being sus'd is not where I'm trying to get here. I am moreover angry at the people who sus'd us for mislynching straight after because they didn't lynch. There was no good evidence to present against me because the people came onto me were saying "you must be scum because of bandwagon". I am not trying to say "I'm Town because I am active" but instead trying to imply that you can't sus me just solely based off of the vote because people who didn't vote before would just get a free pass themselves.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Well, Mog is gone now. That's an eminently weird decision as people started to sus her for inactivity.
Also, I guess that clears Kirbyz (Byngo) as Town.

 

[radical6]

Not surprised toad died, he also likely shot mog because he predicted he was going to die and used his shot.

How the hell does that clear byngo? What?

 

[toadsworthy]

Omg was I fearkilled N1?

That’s kind of an honor thanks!

Good luck town

 

[Chele]

How the hell does that clear byngo? What?

I was going to say that since Kirbyz was kicked out for inactivity, this means that they weren't active during the night, leading them to be clear since Mafia KP was used. But now that I think about it, it only depends on N2 and how much KP they have then, and a single Mafia member (if more than one) could've just chosen the kills for everybody. Scratch that idea.
Also I don't think that Toad shot Mog, because of all people he sussed me the most. He would've shot me, and not an inactive?

 

[Jacob]

welcome natty <3 rip mog and toad

 

[nintendofan85]

Welcome, new player! I don't believe we've met before, haha.

 

[Byngo]

welcome natty <3 rip mog and toad

how’d u figure out toad was a vig

 

[radical6]

I was going to say that since Kirbyz was kicked out for inactivity, this means that they weren't active during the night, leading them to be clear since Mafia KP was used. But now that I think about it, it only depends on N2 and how much KP they have then, and a single Mafia member (if more than one) could've just chosen the kills for everybody. Scratch that idea.
Also I don't think that Toad shot Mog, because of all people he sussed me the most. He would've shot me, and not an inactive?

What... toad literally said you were good

Shooting an inactive makes more sense anyway because then we dont waste a lynch on them if you have no other options. He didnt seem to voice any other suspicions

Also you do realize that like... any member of the mafia can send in a kill. You just need one member to send it. There is definitely more than 1 in this game. I'm assuming 2-3

Your reasoning is really off

- - - Post Merge - - -

Oh i didnt read the scratch that idea part

- - - Post Merge - - -

Anyway I'm not sure why you thivk toad suspected you when at the end he tr you

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also mafia had no reason to kill mog, but a vig has a reason to shoot mog

 

[Byngo]

im already regretting replacing. i forgot how bad i am at reads

posting thoughts as i read through thread

i almost want to townlock kallie for getting kcwhatever lynched, cuz like there was next to no reason for her to stick her neck out at that point if she were scum. maf like not having to work and even the dumbest player would’ve realized that, with more than half the day gone, meaningful discussion wasn’t gonna happen, so just sit back and relax

don’t particularly care for dedenne n chele magically sus’ing kc after kallie stepped up

 

[Jacob]

how’d u figure out toad was a vig

are you pocketing me scum

 

[Byngo]

no way there’s more than 2 scum

probably no to tp since it’s so small

- - - Post Merge - - -

there’s something that just feels... manufactured? about Chele’s posts but idk

jacob too but we know it’s always my assumption he’s scum

 

[radical6]

no way there’s more than 2 scum

probably no to tp since it’s so small

- - - Post Merge - - -

there’s something that just feels... manufactured? about Chele’s posts but idk

jacob too but we know it’s always my assumption he’s scum

I townread her but her last few posts have me real confused if im honest

 

[unravel]

Small part of me wanna believe Chele is town and was frame because toad died idk... And how is Dedenne and Nintendo connected again?

 

[Chele]

there’s something that just feels... manufactured? about Chele’s posts but idk

I don't know what gives you the manufactured vibe. Maybe because I was trying to generate discussion a lot before, it probably sounded like a reach. And the reads before EoD.

I townread her but her last few posts have me real confused if im honest

I'm honestly confused at myself at this point.
About the Toads thing, he did only very slightly townlean me, he was eminently puzzled at my behaviour and compared it to other games. I don't really believe that he shot Mog. He never mentioned anything about her and we could've just waited until her modkill, since there is no more replacements. Even if he wanted to shoot an inactive, why not Kate?

Honestly my brain is like, dead. I'll take a short break before I get even more flustered.