Mafia American Politics Mafia - Game Over - Town Wins!

PunchyDaHufflepuff said:
Lol you haven't read the thread yet like at all
Click to expand...

Well I just did, finally. GOOD GOD TBT NEEDS TO BE ****ING FIXED LIKE SERIOUSLY

Anyway. After reading all of that, I think it's safe to say that Punchy/Dolby are definitively linked, are *likely* town, but it'd probably be best to NOT elect EITHER of them, just to prevent something really bad potentially happening. So that brings me back to Ness. Out of all of the candidates I feel he has been the most measured, analytical, and effective player of the bunch, and he deserves to be president the most.

- - - Post Merge - - -

gdi TBT my post disappeared, getting infernal at this garbage website
 
People that I think should post more so I can get an adequate read:
Jacob
Waffles - seen ya lurking buddy.
Dad
Evan
Hikari
Byngo

That's all I can think of off the top of my head...

- - - Post Merge - - -

Oh GLOW. THE INNOCENT CHILD. that's who I was missing.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Oh GLOW. THE INNOCENT CHILD. that's who I was missing.
 
A little confusing but if I read this correctly, Dolby says they're actually masons, while Punchy explains "My winton is for me to get Dolby elected. Dolby's wincon is for him to get me elected. We share a quick topic, one of us need to get elected to win"

There's not really any doubt they can talk outside the thread, and D0 is probably the only possible window for Dolby to create a successful lie to keep both him and punchy from not being elected. I really don't see any actual reason for trusting Dolby over anyone else, and I'd be kinda shocked if they aren't just a third-party team
 
Punchy Cant u see im ****ing reading the thread buddy I had a hard time getting in the thread ffs

I already mention before u guys mention about Dolby and Punchy as partners and dont think they are scum until Dolby kinda pissed at punchy(?) this realized that they are both town I finally know who to nominate i dunno if u guys are cool voting either punchy or dolby as president
 
Jacob said:
A little confusing but if I read this correctly, Dolby says they're actually masons, while Punchy explains "My winton is for me to get Dolby elected. Dolby's wincon is for him to get me elected. We share a quick topic, one of us need to get elected to win"

There's not really any doubt they can talk outside the thread, and D0 is probably the only possible window for Dolby to create a successful lie to keep both him and punchy from not being elected. I really don't see any actual reason for trusting Dolby over anyone else, and I'd be kinda shocked if they aren't just a third-party team
Click to expand...

I think what he means his objective is to get Dolby elected since among the list he TRUST dolby the most and both of them are partner in crime (masons)
 
Jacob said:
A little confusing but if I read this correctly, Dolby says they're actually masons, while Punchy explains "My winton is for me to get Dolby elected. Dolby's wincon is for him to get me elected. We share a quick topic, one of us need to get elected to win"

There's not really any doubt they can talk outside the thread, and D0 is probably the only possible window for Dolby to create a successful lie to keep both him and punchy from not being elected. I really don't see any actual reason for trusting Dolby over anyone else, and I'd be kinda shocked if they aren't just a third-party team
Click to expand...

I think what he means his objective is to get Dolby elected since among the list he TRUST dolby the most and both of them are partner in crime (masons)

- - - Post Merge - - -

Its understandable some of u guys dont trust u just yet cuz role information can manipulate and all after all this game is about manipulating anyway

- - - Post Merge - - -

Its understandable some of u guys dont trust u just yet cuz role information can manipulate and all after all this game is about manipulating anyway
 
ITookYourWaffles said:
Punchy Cant u see im ****ing reading the thread buddy I had a hard time getting in the thread ffs

I already mention before u guys mention about Dolby and Punchy as partners and dont think they are scum until Dolby kinda pissed at punchy(?) this realized that they are both town I finally know who to nominate i dunno if u guys are cool voting either punchy or dolby as president
Click to expand...

why is this reason to vote them though? Glow is right in that neither of them are confirmed. If anything, we should NOT vote them because I fear shady business going on and/or bad consequences if one of them gets voted in
 
amazonevan19 said:
why is this reason to vote them though? Glow is right in that neither of them are confirmed. If anything, we should NOT vote them because I fear shady business going on and/or bad consequences if one of them gets voted in
Click to expand...

When did glow post? Am I not seeing her posts?
 
ITookYourWaffles said:
I think what he means his objective is to get Dolby elected since among the list he TRUST dolby the most and both of them are partner in crime (masons)
Click to expand...

I take it as it's written, he claimed that if Dolby got elected, he would win. Vise-versa. In mafia's most basic form, town wins when mafia (Or hostile roles in all cases) are eliminated. So why Punchy would claim any other role besides one that follows Town's win condition is beyond me, and at the very least not pro-town
 
Let’s be realistic here. I actually think that strategy wise, me and Punchy would be the best options for Eternal President because our alignments are DIRECTLY tied to each other. We’re either town or maf here, and if we were lovers we would have claimed that already. Let’s say that we’re scum. I’ve been intentionally faking a PM link with Lunchy since the first page, and him with me. No way that mafia are doing that THAT early. I understand that you’ll think that Punchy was telling the truth there (in which case, lol), but there’s another benefit to electing one of us. You get what’s effectively a bulletproof innocent child

I do understand the concerns that Punchy was telling the truth and that he broke, but you all should recognize that that wasn’t a clean or true break. For example, if we were what he said that we were, Trundle probably would’ve designed the role that we would be out after the election. Punchy didn’t bring that up because he didn’t think of that aspect of his fakeclaim (if anyone’s wondering, he was going to have us come out as Bernie Sanders and Hillary Clinton), which would inevitably play a part in it
 
Jacob said:
I take it as it's written, he claimed that if Dolby got elected, he would win. Vise-versa. In mafia's most basic form, town wins when mafia (Or hostile roles in all cases) are eliminated. So why Punchy would claim any other role besides one that follows Town's win condition is beyond me, and at the very least not pro-town
Click to expand...

Yeah, I have no ****ing idea what he was doing there. He extended what I told him that “I want to get one of us elected” to a needless extreme

If he was telling the truth though, both of our roles would be eliminated after the election, and I really don’t see Trundle removing two roles on D0

- - - Post Merge - - -

Jacob said:
If you were masons you would be trying to get mafia killed, any OTHER possibility of winning means you are a third party
Click to expand...

Ffs Jacob, first of all that wouldn’t be a Lynched, probably something like a constituent or a campaign manager. But second of all, that’s not his or our win conditions
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

N e s s
Mafia TBT Mafia - Darkest Dungeon (Cancelled)
Replies
15
Views
929
N e s s
N e s s
Damniel
Mafia Among Us Mafia Game Thread (Town Win!)
139 140 141
Replies
3K
Views
102K
unravel
unravel
E
Mafia The Quest for King - Mafia | Game Thread | GAME OVER
89 90 91
Replies
2K
Views
52K
Jacob4
Jacob4
C
Review the Video Game Above You!
Replies
5
Views
170
Midoriya
Midoriya
TN4U
Mafia Redd's Revenge - Game Thread [GAME OVER]
56 57 58
Replies
1K
Views
32K
BetsySundrop
BetsySundrop
Back
Top