Yeah, currently what going though my head is Glow/Rune vs Waffles/Vanessa/Toads. Which, again, is why I’m so conflicted on Rune. Glow kinda just validated my earlier stance that they were linked, but on the other hand I really doubt he’d be so aggressive in being pro-Rune by quoting me there if they were teammates
Mafia American Politics Mafia - Game Over - Town Wins!
- Thread starter EpicGamer12
- Start date
dude it?s still a waste of a vest
it?s better to have two people vested rather than one with two
i wouldn?t be surprised if there was strongarm which renders multiple vests literally useless
- - - Post Merge - - -
oh you had no vest to begin w/
i see now
glow, deadass, this is the worst i have ever seen from you. Have you even read my claim post? I literally cannot tell.
If I was NOT elected, I would not be a 2-Shot Veteran. You don't seem to understand this with your reference of "Its better to have 2 people vested instead of 1 with 2". If there was a strong-arm, then that would make my role (and even the president itself) LITERALLY. WORTHLESS. It stated that if i'm elected I would gain 2 bulletproof vests, so I highly doubt Trundle would make a scum role that would just screw me over.
My briefly generalized thoughts:
Town
Dolby - Claimed mason
PunchyDaHufflepuff - Claimed mason
Townlean
Tina - She just genuinely feels like she is trying to figure things out. I like that. She's not like how she played as scum in BOTW where she was just incredibly vague and quiet with practically everything she would say.
Byngo - This is mostly because I feel that although she has been way too on my side, she has the typical town byngo attitude. Whenever she's mafia she tends to be much more reserved and shy to post, and I'm not sensing that from her. Its generally pretty easy for me to read Byngo.
Heyden - I kinda liked how he continued to question the possibility of me being scum. I dunno, it was refreshing to see that he didn't sheep and just straight up think I'm confirmed town. While he hasn't provided enough content as of yet, I like what he's done so far. It feels more authentic then how he formulated his posts in RHOM where he based everything off of his scum partners.
Biancasbotique: The fact that she asked Trundle if he was Canadian to try and get more information on me is incredibly weak play from her, but I see town mindset from it. Also claimed Omarosa as her role name, which I don't know what to make of but given the context of Omarosa I somewhat want to give points for it.
Dad - While I am townleaning him, there is just something about him that rubs me the wrong way. I can't exactly explain why I feel this way, but he just doesn't feel like how he did in RHOM. Only thing that I genuinely like is the fact that he wanted a Dolby presidency over mine because in reference to what Dolby said, the landslide win seems as though Scum preferred to have me be president then Dolby. I can see him doing this as scum in an attempt to seem town later, but other than that I like it. I just need to see more content from him first and then he'll probably be a full on town lean.
Locket - Theres just something that feels honest about them. Weak sure, but I dunno. This is a pretty weak read, so thats why she's at the bottom.
Null
Hikari - They just haven't done enough stuff for me to be able to ping a read on them, but I don't know. Would Trundle be so evil to give a returning player after like 5 years a scum role? Its weak sure, but thats just a general little thought I had. If they had more content then they would probably be higher then Locket in terms of towniness, but other than that I have nothing to work with them.
glow - I don't know what to think of her so far. She isn't following scum meta, but I've just noticed that she called out Toadsworthy for using the "I'll use everyone's opinion idea" and not Evan. A small detail that she could have just overlooked, given that toads was the focus of the thread at that point, but still worth mentioning. She just hasn't done anything specifically town imo. Another post I sorta disliked was this:
I feel as if the logic is flawed. No matter what kind of blue I may have been, there was still a good reason for me to want to be the president because protection on a blue role would be highly valuable. Sure, if I had been cop or something roleblocker would just destroy the plan, but why should that discredit the fact that I'm blue? It doesn't make sense to me. Other than she'll probably be more town later depending on her future content, just a few things about her that make me uncomfortable.
Jacob - Less suspicious of him than earlier. His ISO isn't lining up with his scum meta, he tends to act a lot more sophisticated as mafia, and so far I kinda feel like that this isn't scum Jacob. He's barely out of suspicions though.
General suspicions (no specific order here)
Toadsworthy - a bit less suspicious of him after everything that has happened, but I'm still weary of him.
ITookYourWaffles - I still just can't get over this. It feels as if she is just posting for the sake of posting and is agreeing with suspicions on her in an attempt to get approval. I did kinda like her reads list, but other than that she hasn't done much this game.
Runeraider - Liked his content earlier, but now I have a few gripes with him.
VanessaMay18 - There are several aspects of her that I kinda like, but admittedly I'm getting very tired so from this point on I will elaborate more on the further reads later.
Amazonevan19 - He just isn't doing enough stuff, which is getting to be a little bit concerning. One thing did ping me as a little off:
This is basically the only thing I dislike about evan so far. I have a few ideas what this means, but one of them is that he didn't want the responsibility of being mayor; therefore was trying to avoid it. That and he mentions basically the same idea that Toadsworthy had planned on using the presidency in that he would just sheep everyone else's opinions.
I'm not confident most of these being correct in complete honesty. If I had to guess, I would speculate that Dad/Locket/Bianca reads are incorrect, and most of my suspicions being incorrect at this moment. When I have time to sit down and do a proper analysis then I'll most likely change most of these. Anyway i'm tired so i'm hitting the sack.
Town
Dolby - Claimed mason
PunchyDaHufflepuff - Claimed mason
Townlean
Tina - She just genuinely feels like she is trying to figure things out. I like that. She's not like how she played as scum in BOTW where she was just incredibly vague and quiet with practically everything she would say.
Byngo - This is mostly because I feel that although she has been way too on my side, she has the typical town byngo attitude. Whenever she's mafia she tends to be much more reserved and shy to post, and I'm not sensing that from her. Its generally pretty easy for me to read Byngo.
Heyden - I kinda liked how he continued to question the possibility of me being scum. I dunno, it was refreshing to see that he didn't sheep and just straight up think I'm confirmed town. While he hasn't provided enough content as of yet, I like what he's done so far. It feels more authentic then how he formulated his posts in RHOM where he based everything off of his scum partners.
Biancasbotique: The fact that she asked Trundle if he was Canadian to try and get more information on me is incredibly weak play from her, but I see town mindset from it. Also claimed Omarosa as her role name, which I don't know what to make of but given the context of Omarosa I somewhat want to give points for it.
Dad - While I am townleaning him, there is just something about him that rubs me the wrong way. I can't exactly explain why I feel this way, but he just doesn't feel like how he did in RHOM. Only thing that I genuinely like is the fact that he wanted a Dolby presidency over mine because in reference to what Dolby said, the landslide win seems as though Scum preferred to have me be president then Dolby. I can see him doing this as scum in an attempt to seem town later, but other than that I like it. I just need to see more content from him first and then he'll probably be a full on town lean.
Locket - Theres just something that feels honest about them. Weak sure, but I dunno. This is a pretty weak read, so thats why she's at the bottom.
Null
Hikari - They just haven't done enough stuff for me to be able to ping a read on them, but I don't know. Would Trundle be so evil to give a returning player after like 5 years a scum role? Its weak sure, but thats just a general little thought I had. If they had more content then they would probably be higher then Locket in terms of towniness, but other than that I have nothing to work with them.
glow - I don't know what to think of her so far. She isn't following scum meta, but I've just noticed that she called out Toadsworthy for using the "I'll use everyone's opinion idea" and not Evan. A small detail that she could have just overlooked, given that toads was the focus of the thread at that point, but still worth mentioning. She just hasn't done anything specifically town imo. Another post I sorta disliked was this:
I feel as if the logic is flawed. No matter what kind of blue I may have been, there was still a good reason for me to want to be the president because protection on a blue role would be highly valuable. Sure, if I had been cop or something roleblocker would just destroy the plan, but why should that discredit the fact that I'm blue? It doesn't make sense to me. Other than she'll probably be more town later depending on her future content, just a few things about her that make me uncomfortable.
Jacob - Less suspicious of him than earlier. His ISO isn't lining up with his scum meta, he tends to act a lot more sophisticated as mafia, and so far I kinda feel like that this isn't scum Jacob. He's barely out of suspicions though.
General suspicions (no specific order here)
Toadsworthy - a bit less suspicious of him after everything that has happened, but I'm still weary of him.
ITookYourWaffles - I still just can't get over this. It feels as if she is just posting for the sake of posting and is agreeing with suspicions on her in an attempt to get approval. I did kinda like her reads list, but other than that she hasn't done much this game.
Runeraider - Liked his content earlier, but now I have a few gripes with him.
VanessaMay18 - There are several aspects of her that I kinda like, but admittedly I'm getting very tired so from this point on I will elaborate more on the further reads later.
Amazonevan19 - He just isn't doing enough stuff, which is getting to be a little bit concerning. One thing did ping me as a little off:
Amazonevan19 said:
This is basically the only thing I dislike about evan so far. I have a few ideas what this means, but one of them is that he didn't want the responsibility of being mayor; therefore was trying to avoid it. That and he mentions basically the same idea that Toadsworthy had planned on using the presidency in that he would just sheep everyone else's opinions.
I'm not confident most of these being correct in complete honesty. If I had to guess, I would speculate that Dad/Locket/Bianca reads are incorrect, and most of my suspicions being incorrect at this moment. When I have time to sit down and do a proper analysis then I'll most likely change most of these. Anyway i'm tired so i'm hitting the sack.
This is just you joking right? I have my qualms about the veteran thing but damn.
they arent actually confirmed yet, its just very likely. noones completely confirmed yet
- - - Post Merge - - -
being sus of people for simply questioning someone is a really bad idea imo, until one of them dies or we get a cop read the possibilities of punchy and dolby being scum is there, no matter how remote it may be
Okay but dude...they're masons. Mason claims = Absolute. I just can not see how you can in anyway question Punchy's alignment over him posting incessantly when thats basically all he's done all game.
dad am i really that forgettable
yes
first of all, while he has been posting randomly he hasnt been doing it as aggressively as this, its mostly been random garbage. secondly, it definitely isnt absolute since we havent gotten any definitive information about their role from trundle through day or night posts. its about as absolute as your role being confirmed, its very like theyre telling the truth but not completely confirmed.
finally, i still believe both dolby and punchy to be town as they claim, like how i believe your claims to be true. but i dont think they shouldnt be held up to scrutiny just because their claims are believable. i wouldnt put it past dolby to create an elaborate fake call like this based off of what ive heard about his level of play. this sort of mentality seems ultimately detrimental to town if were gonna just accept everything a person says with no thought after they make a believable claim
just want to reiterate so its harder for me to be misconstrued- i believe dolby and punchys claims and believe they are masons like they say. but we really shouldnt jump on people for questioning them, and we shouldnt take them as confirmed town as of right now.
I'm reading back to fish out some stuff for you Byngo and I am distracted by how Locket had been railing against Bianca for small things like her use of the word shapeshifter but more jarringly, Locket accusing Bianca of having lackluster reads with not enough sentences is hypocritical because a lot of their posts are just a few sentences.
But onto the note on people excusing the other people, I am saying this because of Toads just excusing Evan and giving him more time when, if this were a normal 48 hour game, Evan would have posted in more often by now. I am having to look further back because I recall people just carelessly accepting Dolby and Punchy or Ness as town when it wasn't as obvious as it is now.
But onto the note on people excusing the other people, I am saying this because of Toads just excusing Evan and giving him more time when, if this were a normal 48 hour game, Evan would have posted in more often by now. I am having to look further back because I recall people just carelessly accepting Dolby and Punchy or Ness as town when it wasn't as obvious as it is now.
Biancasbotique
Sweet Feather
amazonevan19
