voltairenism
the mac propaganda representative
not reading all that
Mafia Among Us Mafia Game Thread (Town Win!)
- Thread starter Damniel
- Start date
EpicGamer12
Senior Member
this is funny because I'm now thinking that Betsy and ribbit could both be town while annika is mafia. I wish I was in the thread earlier to say it before people started sussing me + annika (because she is pocketing me) but oh well. Her posts are literally just too spot on to me.
Post automatically merged:
noob town lock
ribbitribbon
Kappore kappore!
rereading i can’t tell if you’re blatantly pocketing new players or some secret third independent role that wins by tring every noob 
ok this post made me question trundle a bit. because i am suspicious of mog and unravel and like. there’s no normal universe where mafia calls out two mafia. i’ll have to rethink my worldview a bit. could unravel just be maf and that’s what i’m more reading into with the bus thing? i will go thru unravel next
let me stew on this for a bit
problem i have with this is it kind of parallels what you did with unravel and seems like an easy excuse to pull out of reads, especially if they’re your partners
dang
ok this post made me question trundle a bit. because i am suspicious of mog and unravel and like. there’s no normal universe where mafia calls out two mafia. i’ll have to rethink my worldview a bit. could unravel just be maf and that’s what i’m more reading into with the bus thing? i will go thru unravel next
i think you talked about zinnia much more than you implied you did
again ik you said you were convinced by dolby but you give no prior indication of this. it’s believable but convienent
lol
let me stew on this for a bit
EpicGamer12
Senior Member
i always bus when i'm mafia but i'm not mafia
Post automatically merged:
im just good at reading noob towns
ribbitribbon
Kappore kappore!
more work to respond toPhew, a lot to go through. It's quite hard to gather my thoughts and focus with the amount of posts being made. I'm honestly surprised that there were no killings.
For those of you that mentioned my takes not being all that great, do keep in mind that this is still my first mafia game on TBT and I'm a bit excited to participate. I realize that some of my posts received mixed reactions, but now that we made it to D2, I wanted to make it clear that I'm trying not to rush my thoughts and and formulate some reads that a lot of you will hopefully agree with. I feel like I'm beginning to grasp a better understanding of the other users' habits at this point. Anyway, from what I could gather after the first couple hours into D2, I wanted to give my reads, with more to come (by the way, this post took way too long to make and I probably missed many of the newest posts; I'll get to them later):
Explained opinions
Obvious/not-so-strong opinions
- Trundle: My mind is so mixed on him at the moment, but I'm still leaning towards town and here's why:
- Looking at his EOD1, I could tell he was starting to panic about the Zinnia votes. While I was fully convinced (and later proven wrong) that Zinnia was a wolf, I didn't want to suddenly jump on another bandwagon as quickly as I did with Mog previously. I personally didn't think Unravel's posts at the time was enough evidence for me to want to change my vote.
- If anything, I think he's trying his best to maintain a good town read of himself, and simply wants to get reactions out of others. He'd honestly be more of a town read from others if it weren't for the EOD1 panicking. In my opinion, a wolf would rarely act so crazily like that.
- annika: I'm mixed with her. From what I could tell, I think she is doing a very good job of maintaining composure and not letting others bother her groove, but there have been a couple D2 posts that made me question her legitimacy.
- Post #808 is a good example. Why would she vote for someone solely because of someone else telling her to?
- Earlier in post #782, she indirectly mentioned to Dolby that she doubted Trundle to be town, yet admitted in #808 that she went with Trundle's pushing for Unravel anyway.
- In short, I can sort of sense that she's giving off slight wolf vibes, though I'm going to remain null of her for now.
- voltairenism: I've agreed with volt's take on Zinnia. They had every right to question Zinnia's quiet actions when Zinnia was still in the game; unfortunately, she did not flip red, so I'll have to look at their other reads. At this time, volt is slight town.
- They mentioned Trundle being mafia because of his willingness to randomly push player votes. Post #548 brought up a valid point about Trundle possibly starting a wagon to eliminate the more active poster (Unravel over Zinnia). He began to panic when he realized not everyone was on board, and Zinnia was ultimately eliminated. Could this mean Trundle is actually mafia and Unravel is town? I'm not entirely sure because of my own thoughts on Trundle specifically, but volt gets my pass for valid possibility points.
- N e s s: I'm going to lean somewhat null on him, maaaaybe more to the wolf side.
- His point about the Ribbit
Zinnia wagon was very understandable (post #691). While my reasoning for joining the Zinnia wagon was more so due to my personal thoughts about Zinnia's posting in general (and volt highlighting it), I couldn't help but notice a post from Betsy that had me scratching my head (post #728). So, you mean to tell me that Ness originally didn't want to vote Unravel, but wanted to do so after the Zinnia ejection? I'm confused.
- Oh, and post #727 is not how you want to prove you're town-aligned and not working with Betsy and Ribbot in disguise. You gotta do better than that.
- Off topic, but coming from an unfortunate victim of two rear-end accidents just over a month-long span this year, PLEASE do not text and drive. I don't want anything bad to happen to you or other drivers.
Ultimately, after Zinnia's ejection on N1, my reads of the potential mafia members right now would be as follows:
- BetsySundrop: They bring up valid points about Trundle, though I honestly cannot see their theory of Trundle and Ribbit working together (mentioned in post #862). They say Trundle is somewhat mafia, while Ribbit is town. I'm conflicted, and I'm null on Betsy as a result.
- ribbitribbon: They are so up-and-down, it's sort of crazy. I personally could not follow their theory in posts #712, #716, and #756. They start off by saying Trundle is heavy mafia, then suddenly back down without proper explanation. I'm sort of leaning wolf on ribbit, and I don't know if I'll be able to change my mind.
- ShinyDungeoneer: So far, we've mostly been on the same page in regards to their reads compared to mine. Post #735 brings up several valid points in their reads, such as ribbit's inconsistency, Trundle's unnecessary wagons, and Dolby's excellent posting. I'm trusting them so far.
- mogyay: Looking back at their posts and giving them a good read over, I really do not understand why I was foolish enough to hop on the wagon when it occurred. Mog is pretty innocent in my eyes.
- unravel: It's understandable that their time zone prevents them from posting a lot; I still would like to see more reads from them in order to make me feel more confident in them.
- FrostyAlmonds: I still view her as super town. She is very defensive, probably more so than what an average mafia member would comfortably act. While I am still unhappy that we can't be on the same page, I somewhat understand her reasonings behind her thoughts on me.
- Dinosaur: Literally made the first post on D2, placing a random vote on D1. I'm not going to say they're a wolf solely because of that, but I'll need to see some action before I can fully trust them.
- radical6: They have more posts than some of the others, but not enough to form an opinion on. I am going to lean more towards town as they clearly don't want to take a lot of risks at this time (post #540 mentions not wanting to vote ribbit out despite ribbit receiving a bulk of the blame), though I'm going to remain cautious.
- lily2816: I honestly believe they are town. I would like to see more confirmation in regards to their own personal reads, but other than that, I wouldn't be suspicious.
- Yoshi155: Very neutral-minded and up-front. As they are also new to mafia without posting a whole lot, I cannot formulate any proper read as of right now.
- Dolby: I'm going to give him bonus points for doing a very good job of being up-front with the other users. While I do have questions about him in regards to how he actually reads certain posts (Betsy's notes being an example), I could definitely trust him as being a mediator for the town.
I'll read more of the thread tomorrow.
- ribbitribbon
- N e s s
- annika
- Dinosaur
adding reading this to my list
EpicGamer12
Senior Member
it's not a wolfy eod you're just bad at reading me
voltairenism
the mac propaganda representative
a wise man said once that bussing was for weak players
also me bussing my mason partner
EpicGamer12
Senior Member
first good unravel post all game but I don't think it's ribbit so it does nothing good for unravel in my eyes
Couple of bold takes. Dunno if I'm seeing the same thing.
EpicGamer12
Senior Member
u didn't, im just saying ur prone to panic plays, and u had a decent sized wagon
ribbitribbon
Kappore kappore!
you have no reason to believe this but that was just last minute wifom in desperation
EpicGamer12
Senior Member
it's ok I still don't think you're mafia anyway
ribbitribbon
Kappore kappore!
if i’m questioning my daystart read though im totally circling back to volt and opening up some dolby thoughts
maybe i will also look at betsy but man there’s a lot on my list
maybe i will also look at betsy but man there’s a lot on my list
voltairenism
the mac propaganda representative
idk how down i am for tinfoiling annika. i think she gets better late game ig so we will solve the slot then
EpicGamer12
Senior Member
I have caught up now.
IMO: annika this game feels incredibly backbench compared to annika last game. It does not feel like she is actively trying to solve. And if I set her as mafia in my mind, I can tell she is trying to pocket me. If she's town then she has hyper fixated on just one aspect of this game for no reason. Doesn't make sense to me.
annika/unravel are my 2 top suspicions atm. I'm nervous someone I've townlocked in my mind is actually mafia like Dolby or Almonds.
I would fill out the rest of the mafia team with one of (lily/yoshi) and one of (radical6/mogyay) probably?
IMO: annika this game feels incredibly backbench compared to annika last game. It does not feel like she is actively trying to solve. And if I set her as mafia in my mind, I can tell she is trying to pocket me. If she's town then she has hyper fixated on just one aspect of this game for no reason. Doesn't make sense to me.
annika/unravel are my 2 top suspicions atm. I'm nervous someone I've townlocked in my mind is actually mafia like Dolby or Almonds.
I would fill out the rest of the mafia team with one of (lily/yoshi) and one of (radical6/mogyay) probably?
Post automatically merged:
yeah I'm not pushing it for today
Post automatically merged:
i think you are focusing too much on the people who are active and not enough on the people who aren't
Getting the impression you forced a lot of this out for the sake of giving reads. The read on Annika feels super fabricated, like you're pining for a reason to call her suspicious. Lotta of misinformation in what you're saying about me too.Phew, a lot to go through. It's quite hard to gather my thoughts and focus with the amount of posts being made. I'm honestly surprised that there were no killings.
For those of you that mentioned my takes not being all that great, do keep in mind that this is still my first mafia game on TBT and I'm a bit excited to participate. I realize that some of my posts received mixed reactions, but now that we made it to D2, I wanted to make it clear that I'm trying not to rush my thoughts and and formulate some reads that a lot of you will hopefully agree with. I feel like I'm beginning to grasp a better understanding of the other users' habits at this point. Anyway, from what I could gather after the first couple hours into D2, I wanted to give my reads, with more to come (by the way, this post took way too long to make and I probably missed many of the newest posts; I'll get to them later):
Explained opinions
Obvious/not-so-strong opinions
- Trundle: My mind is so mixed on him at the moment, but I'm still leaning towards town and here's why:
- Looking at his EOD1, I could tell he was starting to panic about the Zinnia votes. While I was fully convinced (and later proven wrong) that Zinnia was a wolf, I didn't want to suddenly jump on another bandwagon as quickly as I did with Mog previously. I personally didn't think Unravel's posts at the time was enough evidence for me to want to change my vote.
- If anything, I think he's trying his best to maintain a good town read of himself, and simply wants to get reactions out of others. He'd honestly be more of a town read from others if it weren't for the EOD1 panicking. In my opinion, a wolf would rarely act so crazily like that.
- annika: I'm mixed with her. From what I could tell, I think she is doing a very good job of maintaining composure and not letting others bother her groove, but there have been a couple D2 posts that made me question her legitimacy.
- Post #808 is a good example. Why would she vote for someone solely because of someone else telling her to?
- Earlier in post #782, she indirectly mentioned to Dolby that she doubted Trundle to be town, yet admitted in #808 that she went with Trundle's pushing for Unravel anyway.
- In short, I can sort of sense that she's giving off slight wolf vibes, though I'm going to remain null of her for now.
- voltairenism: I've agreed with volt's take on Zinnia. They had every right to question Zinnia's quiet actions when Zinnia was still in the game; unfortunately, she did not flip red, so I'll have to look at their other reads. At this time, volt is slight town.
- They mentioned Trundle being mafia because of his willingness to randomly push player votes. Post #548 brought up a valid point about Trundle possibly starting a wagon to eliminate the more active poster (Unravel over Zinnia). He began to panic when he realized not everyone was on board, and Zinnia was ultimately eliminated. Could this mean Trundle is actually mafia and Unravel is town? I'm not entirely sure because of my own thoughts on Trundle specifically, but volt gets my pass for valid possibility points.
- N e s s: I'm going to lean somewhat null on him, maaaaybe more to the wolf side.
- His point about the Ribbit
- Oh, and post #727 is not how you want to prove you're town-aligned and not working with Betsy and Ribbot in disguise. You gotta do better than that.
- Off topic, but coming from an unfortunate victim of two rear-end accidents just over a month-long span this year, PLEASE do not text and drive. I don't want anything bad to happen to you or other drivers.
Ultimately, after Zinnia's ejection on N1, my reads of the potential mafia members right now would be as follows:
- BetsySundrop: They bring up valid points about Trundle, though I honestly cannot see their theory of Trundle and Ribbit working together (mentioned in post #862). They say Trundle is somewhat mafia, while Ribbit is town. I'm conflicted, and I'm null on Betsy as a result.
- ribbitribbon: They are so up-and-down, it's sort of crazy. I personally could not follow their theory in posts #712, #716, and #756. They start off by saying Trundle is heavy mafia, then suddenly back down without proper explanation. I'm sort of leaning wolf on ribbit, and I don't know if I'll be able to change my mind.
- ShinyDungeoneer: So far, we've mostly been on the same page in regards to their reads compared to mine. Post #735 brings up several valid points in their reads, such as ribbit's inconsistency, Trundle's unnecessary wagons, and Dolby's excellent posting. I'm trusting them so far.
- mogyay: Looking back at their posts and giving them a good read over, I really do not understand why I was foolish enough to hop on the wagon when it occurred. Mog is pretty innocent in my eyes.
- unravel: It's understandable that their time zone prevents them from posting a lot; I still would like to see more reads from them in order to make me feel more confident in them.
- FrostyAlmonds: I still view her as super town. She is very defensive, probably more so than what an average mafia member would comfortably act. While I am still unhappy that we can't be on the same page, I somewhat understand her reasonings behind her thoughts on me.
- Dinosaur: Literally made the first post on D2, placing a random vote on D1. I'm not going to say they're a wolf solely because of that, but I'll need to see some action before I can fully trust them.
- radical6: They have more posts than some of the others, but not enough to form an opinion on. I am going to lean more towards town as they clearly don't want to take a lot of risks at this time (post #540 mentions not wanting to vote ribbit out despite ribbit receiving a bulk of the blame), though I'm going to remain cautious.
- lily2816: I honestly believe they are town. I would like to see more confirmation in regards to their own personal reads, but other than that, I wouldn't be suspicious.
- Yoshi155: Very neutral-minded and up-front. As they are also new to mafia without posting a whole lot, I cannot formulate any proper read as of right now.
- Dolby: I'm going to give him bonus points for doing a very good job of being up-front with the other users. While I do have questions about him in regards to how he actually reads certain posts (Betsy's notes being an example), I could definitely trust him as being a mediator for the town.
I'll read more of the thread tomorrow.
- ribbitribbon
- N e s s
- annika
- Dinosaur
Also lol at saying "the town" under Dolby's read.
voltairenism
the mac propaganda representative
ehhh i overall dont enjoy the blame-y vibes. she had a hand on killing zinnia but negates responsability bc "if i was here i would totally be able to tell she was town". cant blame someone for living in another part of the world tho
So, you're both saying don't look at face value, look into covert/ deepwolfiness?
I dunno if i can do that without getting trapped in a circular nightmare. I mean, i can do it, but you're gonna get walls that lead to nowhere and nobody wants to read. (Also, trundle eod was on the surface much the same as previous wolves I've seen, so...if the fangs fit?
)But putting trundle aside, and to address the spotlight point- i kinda disagree. There are 4 wolves. They will most likely bus at some point. With so many, they have a bit more leeway and can take more chances and stand out some. Then the partner(s) can bus.
It's why no matter who flips red, nobody is clear based on it, but maybe connections can be seen?
If I were looking for a deepwolf, I'd look at frosty or dolby. Someone who is super active, not making mistakes, townread by most. The problem with that is - there's nothing to point to, and it's extremely risky to vote off really strong players just in case they may be wolfing. So I vote off the absent/most sus. This is probably why I end up tunneling town a lot. There's mistakes to point to.
The point is - all i have to go on is surface. When i try to see patterns/teams, i get nowhere. Maybe after there's a red flip, patterns will be more clear?
EpicGamer12
Senior Member
yeah I re-read it and completely changed my mind lol
Post automatically merged:
ie i skimmed it the first time and just assumed it was a good post but then it wasn't
Post automatically merged:
i skim 90% of posts guys
