Mafia Call the Ships to Port: Game Thread - END GAME - TOWN VICTORY!
- Thread starter Chris
- Start date
Okay, how will it punish Town ? Me bored.
PunchyTheCat
Senior Member
I don't even know.
voting myself I guess :/(NOT ADVISED TO DO AS TOWN)
- - - Post Merge - - -
lol I scumslipped again come at me
FireNinja1
inactive: please read "about" tab on profile
Should I stay off the Punchy wagon if there's something about a bomb involved...?
Just hopping on to catch up on breaks and Punchy admitted to being scum? Even so I would like a normal length day if just to have time to discuss day 4's lynch.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Also right off the bat that kinda towntells FireNinja for me. Will explain why later if it isn't obvious.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Also right off the bat that kinda towntells FireNinja for me. Will explain why later if it isn't obvious.
cornimer
grab acorns 'til you're delirious
There's a slight possibility people who vote for him could get exploded by a bomb or something. Some willing sacrifices already voted so if you don't want to take the risk, vote for yourself
FireNinja1
inactive: please read "about" tab on profile
Sounds good.
But basically FireNinja's vote on Punchy and criticism of Punchy feeling the need to say he would be playing differently this game made him scummy and Toads did the same so he may also have been killed over that if it wasn't also a bluesnipe, and it read authentic. I think who interacted with Punchy, defended or sussed him or just ignored his situation day one, needs to be looked into.
But yeah, if we could have an extra day despite a huge majority on Punchy that'd be awesome. Even though I feel like the thread is already dying down because we got a second one, that doesn't mean the scumhunting should stop.
Who do you all think should be lynched after Punchy?
But yeah, if we could have an extra day despite a huge majority on Punchy that'd be awesome. Even though I feel like the thread is already dying down because we got a second one, that doesn't mean the scumhunting should stop.
Who do you all think should be lynched after Punchy?
EpicGamer12
Senior Member
this greatly depends on what punchy flips lol
cornimer
grab acorns 'til you're delirious
ahighiughai that was literally my exact thought lmao
I can see that point about the nightkilling. That being said, with the Tom and Punchy lynches, they're so easy to sheep and get away with it because Tom was universally suspected and Punchy admitted to being scum apparently. That means five days of getting away with sheeping and people not batting an eye at it. And I need that to be kept in mind moving forward.
Anyways, thanks to that google doc I made and kept up with earlier in the game, I have people who took different positions on Punchy vs FireNinja noted. Only mentioning the living ones of course.
Defended Punchy in some capacity:
-Mogyay defended the idea that Punchy's playstyle could change
-Rune was defensive of Punchy if just because he didn't like Toads early on but I still tr Rune so w/e
Didn't defend Punchy but were against FN during that situation:
-Heyden
-Locket
-Evan
Suspected Punchy in some capacity:
-FireNinja
-Trundle suspected both Tom and Trundle as his first suspects
-Ness was kiiinda wishywashy about Punchy but there was more incidents of him calling Punchy out than defending him.
Nulls or highly mixed feelings on Punchy:
-Antonio nullread him
-I was more on Punchy's side in the beginning because I thought he was a blue but on this day I have felt less sure about it due to how many blues have flipped
Need to read back on Panda and Ryumia still but I don't think they took a stance there? Don't recall Kayla, glow, or Gig ever taking any stances on it. Not in my notes anyhow.
I still have a lot of catching up to do but I felt like listing these stances from 1 because I think that is an important day to look back upon in situations like these.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Of the people I just listed I am probably going to move forward considering that alongside glow, 2 out of these 5 could be in the mafia team: mog (Kermit), Evan, Locket (Vanessa), Antonio, and Heyden. Need to look back on how they interacted with Tom, Punchy, and glow though.
Anyways, thanks to that google doc I made and kept up with earlier in the game, I have people who took different positions on Punchy vs FireNinja noted. Only mentioning the living ones of course.
Defended Punchy in some capacity:
-Mogyay defended the idea that Punchy's playstyle could change
-Rune was defensive of Punchy if just because he didn't like Toads early on but I still tr Rune so w/e
Didn't defend Punchy but were against FN during that situation:
-Heyden
-Locket
-Evan
Suspected Punchy in some capacity:
-FireNinja
-Trundle suspected both Tom and Trundle as his first suspects
-Ness was kiiinda wishywashy about Punchy but there was more incidents of him calling Punchy out than defending him.
Nulls or highly mixed feelings on Punchy:
-Antonio nullread him
-I was more on Punchy's side in the beginning because I thought he was a blue but on this day I have felt less sure about it due to how many blues have flipped
Need to read back on Panda and Ryumia still but I don't think they took a stance there? Don't recall Kayla, glow, or Gig ever taking any stances on it. Not in my notes anyhow.
I still have a lot of catching up to do but I felt like listing these stances from 1 because I think that is an important day to look back upon in situations like these.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Of the people I just listed I am probably going to move forward considering that alongside glow, 2 out of these 5 could be in the mafia team: mog (Kermit), Evan, Locket (Vanessa), Antonio, and Heyden. Need to look back on how they interacted with Tom, Punchy, and glow though.
Just for the record I'm starting to townread Trundle less and less than I did. Just because he put Tom and Punchy down as suspects isn't no reason to be seeing him a single Town because he hasn't made a single active push this entire game.
- - - Post Merge - - -
and no, punchy, liking my posts won't change my opinion of you
- - - Post Merge - - -
and no, punchy, liking my posts won't change my opinion of you
