Also noteworthy to look back upon.
Mafia Call the Ships to Port: Game Thread - END GAME - TOWN VICTORY!
- Thread starter Chris
- Start date
Also noteworthy to look back upon.
idk, i feel like at that point he knew he was probably gonna get lynched so he mightve just straight up fabricated it, id take anything from that with a handful of salt imo
- - - Post Merge - - -
o that was when dolby was still alive, nvm then thought it was more recent, still wouldnt fully believe it tho
Pointing this out as well. If Punchy flips red this looks awfully defensive of him. If he flips town, I think that's a valid thing to hold against Vanessa.
- - - Post Merge - - -
My thought as well as I catch up on this bomb shenanigans.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Curious as to why you didn't say this earlier when Dolby died.
This is a super important point to be bringing up. I think its possible that all of our reads being posted at night are giving the mafia ways to strategize a kill. If we post "oh I suspect this person" and they're Town then obviously they won't die in hopes of a mislynch ? It can explain why some of us are still in the game and honestly I think the night posts are starting to be more important than ever now.
do u want us all to be completely silent then? not trying to be rude or anything (it probably comes off like that) im genuinly curious if thats what u think
Oh... I see. :0 Thanks for bringing it up.
Another post to think about if Punchy flips red. In regards to where mog and Kermit align
o was it? i was gonna say that but i wanted to wait until start of d4 to try and save evan lol
amazonevan19
DLELELEWOOOOP
definitely, but I was intending it more to be a point of question against Vanessa then a defense of Punchy. It was that one point Vanessa brought up that bothered me
amanda1983
Senior Member
Ya that's one reason* I've been hesitant to put up reads since we've reached agreement on Punchy's lynch. At this stage we're in a good position to enter D4 - and it seems like Mafia gains more than Town does by us generating further content before then. Which is, I'm aware, scummy of me to be saying as I haven't given my reads on everyone yet. But frankly I'd rather take that heat than hand Mafia extra info to work with for NKs etc.
I'm not saying we should all shut up and just stop playing until D4 starts. I am just explaining my PoV and how I'll be approaching things until then.
*other reason : there's so many players and variables to consider (which I personally generally enjoy the challenge of but I've struggled this time more than I expected to likely due to how + when I replaced in).. the sheer volume of content to consider has been a bit overwhelming. Again, I'm aware that it's scummy of me to be even saying this. I am not trying to excuse how I've played til now, it has not been helpful for Town at all for my slot to have given so little input. I intend to do better, and for me that means being as forthcoming as possible whilst keeping timing (for NKs) in mind.
I hope that makes sense, PLEASE ask questions if not or you just want further info.
I'm honestly not sure what's the best way to deal with night phases. There are pros & cons to discussion at night and I can see why it would benefit us. Maybe we can do a sort of "last will" system where players who feel they will die for any reason, should be posting reads ( no one should agree or disagree until the next Day ) ? I don't know. It was so much easier when Town was able to PM each other because we used to be able to coordinate ourselves as privately as the mafia.
amanda1983
Senior Member
We can have them ready to go just before EoN, when Mafia won't have time to change their actions easily?
Obviously not everyone will be able to be online close to EoN, but hopefully the better players / those with reason to think they'll be NKd can do so.
I think that's what we used to do anyway, I don't recall everyone just posting their reads during Night phases unless a) they're new and haven't been told not to yet, or b) there was specific reason to do so (irl conflicts, strategy to confuse Mafia, etc).
If everyone is posting reads its probably easier for the mafia to make kills that will blend with general opinions. If one / a few people are making reads then it will look too obvious if the mafia is basing their kills off of that one person.
amanda1983
Senior Member
Dammit I keep forgetting to refresh.
- - - Post Merge - - -
EBWOP : * before posting.
- - - Post Merge - - -
EBWOP : * before posting.
@this and Vanessa finding me sus over that moment: I wasn't caught up at all and had just read the deaths and the last page. Idk why you think I would have read all that is going on with Punchy and not talk about it at all. And I was getting a reaction from Kayla there because another person questioned her.
As for keeping my vote on glow, I will probably change to Punchy but I wanted to establish that glow was hella sus up to that point for me.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Nah I also clearly see you are reaction testing with it. That doesn't mean I can't take it out of context because it's still pretty weird at a level of expectation but you said you were trying different things out so idc. If Punchy flips town why shouldn't I think back on it though? Not that that is what is going to happen.
- - - Post Merge - - -
I would love for someone to explain to me why Evan is obvious town because as of page 210ish I'm still not seeing it.
