Mafia Call the Ships to Port: Game Thread - END GAME - TOWN VICTORY!

[Ghostkid]

In that case im down for a Karen lynch i believe shes scum

 

[N e s s]

just saying i think it's kinda obvious why Karen unvoted at this point i mean come on now. if anyone else is on the same page as me don't say it but i mean seriously

 

[Ghostkid]

She has to be trying to fly under the radar she cant just come and be like oh i was mentioned by so and so imma act like ive been gone defend my srlf and say im too busy to play the game

 

[glow]

I didn't, it was worth a shot because if someone said "rip ness" they'd be cofirmed town. Albeit now that I know I was hit it's prob a good idea to read back on what people said.

why do you keep twisting every single thing people say in this game, you've 100% scumread like 5 players this entire game and they've all either flipped or been revealed as Town

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'd like a word with whoever gave glow a second vote

what are you even saying

who even have i 100% scumread

 

[Ghostkid]

Im guessing the silence after any of my posts means my opinions are **** and i need to hush

 

[cornimer]

Im guessing the silence after any of my posts means my opinions are **** and i need to hush

Nooo that's not true

 

[glow]

just saying i think it's kinda obvious why Karen unvoted at this point i mean come on now. if anyone else is on the same page as me don't say it but i mean seriously

if karen was blue (which she is definitely softing) why would she say she was fine"sacrificing" herself to begin with?

 

[N e s s]

what are you even saying

who even have i 100% scumread

Oath, Dedenne, Me, Fireninja, Punchy (albeit this one is the most understandable here). 100% is hyperbolic, but all 5 of those players are town and if you stop and think you'll realize I'm not mafia. You can be sus of me all you want but guarantee you're not going to try and lynch me at the end of all this.

tbh i don't feel like dealing with you at this point because IDK if you would be playing so weirdly as scum. If you have half a mind you'll at the very least starting acting like town glow and do more in depth reads than constantly say "wtf [x] is scum omg" without providing an in-depth reason for every player who you remotely feel suspicious about

 

[Ghostkid]

Look Karen i know ur watching and if your town u better come up here and defend urself if u dont people are gonna lynch u idk y u became a replacement but ur doing no better than the last person. Im suprised u havent been mod killed u contributed NOTHING all game ik the little game ur playing. Either if ur town or mafia ur doing a bad job at it for just sitting there im expecting a read list from u soon if not ur lynched and if u happen to be town everyone is gonna be ****** and pretty badly ****** too

 

[N e s s]

if karen was blue (which she is definitely softing) why would she say she was fine"sacrificing" herself to begin with?

if Karen was scum, why would she say she was fine "sacrificing" herself to begin with?
if Karen was blue, why not try and back out of it at the last second?
If Karen claims to have a provable role, why not give her a chance until she claims?

 

[glow]

I still don't think Runeraider is scum

mmmm y u always lyin

legit thought Runeraider was mafia lol, so this was a surprise

- - - Post Merge - - -

once i see who got saved i shall call out the entire mafia team based on my best guessing

FYI if Vanessa is mafia her read on Runeraider is probably just a means to throw a townie under the bus once she dies. ^^

y da **** u lyin

Barebones Reads based on how each person has posted so far this game. Grey means not enough content for me to read properly.

Vanessa
PunchyDaHufflepuff
Trundle
Runeraider
Kammm
Tom
Dolby
N e s s
Ghostkid
Heyden
amazonevan19
Ryumia
Antonio
iLoveYou
mogyay
PandaDarling
Gigalabesh
Jacob
Dad
FireNinja1
glow

Please just ask questions based on my reads rather than making me type out my every thought. Also, fun fact, this is one of my least confident reads lists ever. I think a lot of the mafia are coasting.

MMMM OH MY GOD
STOP ****ING LYIN

- - - Post Merge - - -

Oath, Dedenne, Me, Fireninja, Punchy (albeit this one is the most understandable here). 100% is hyperbolic, but all 5 of those players are town and if you stop and think you'll realize I'm not mafia. You can be sus of me all you want but guarantee you're not going to try and lynch me at the end of all this.

tbh i don't feel like dealing with you at this point because IDK if you would be playing so weirdly as scum. If you have half a mind you'll at the very least starting acting like town glow and do more in depth reads than constantly say "wtf [x] is scum omg" without providing an in-depth reason for every player who you remotely feel suspicious about

i never scumread punchy? i was 1 out of the 2 people that believed his claim. he "confirmed" himself as mafia fmpov. ofc i voted him after he lied about his pm.

i was clearly indecisive about dedenne. but i would happily lynch anyone that self votes in that manner 10 out of 10 times with no regrets if they flip town. town shouldn't self like that. it's LITERALLY against your wincon.

just gonna ignore all that rude **** you just said but anyway can u chill pls. 1st i never even sus'd you. 2nd literally all i said was i didn't believe what you said was true, it's clear i was still processing what was happening in my posts following that, and after that i thought i made it clear that i think mafia just played suboptimal

- - - Post Merge - - -

there's a lot of reason for the way i've been playing this game, i don't really feel the need to explain it because if i tell people then it'll become obvious what i'm doing in future games.

i've drastically changed the way i read people. i read a lot into pattern and behavior and i put no weight into meta. like i'll admit that my reads suffer because of this but it's how i want to play, and i think it'll make me a better player in the long run

 

[Heyden]

Detective, Vig, Vig, Veteran, Bodyguard, Neighbour, Vote Gifter + Karen's role? Unless Karen is BG or Vote Gifter? I know this sounds scum motivated but I'd rather her say yes or no to whether she's the vote gifter or bodyguard bc those are the only 2 confirmable roles right now, and I hate hate hate how everyone's giving her a free pass.

I'm probably gonna move my vote to Trundle, but srsly Karen pls

 

[N e s s]

i never scumread punchy? i was 1 out of the 2 people that believed his claim. he "confirmed" himself as mafia fmpov. ofc i voted him after he lied about his pm.

i was clearly indecisive about dedenne. but i would happily lynch anyone that self votes in that manner 10 out of 10 times with no regrets if they flip town. town shouldn't self like that. it's LITERALLY against your wincon.

just gonna ignore all that rude **** you just said but anyway can u chill pls. 1st i never even sus'd you. 2nd literally all i said was i didn't believe what you said was true, it's clear i was still processing what was happening in my posts following that, and after that i thought i made it clear that i think mafia just played suboptimal

1. I'm gonna say it again that you being "indecisive" about Dedenne, who you clearly asked for recognition if it was okay to lynch her, was sus af.
2. If you clearly say "Ness is lying" and "I don't believe Ness for a second", it's pretty easily assumable you're suspicious of me otherwise you wouldn't say that.
3. I'm sorry for being rude, I was getting frustrated. I didn't mean it and I don't want to make this toads 2.0, but please at least start going into more detail with your reads, it's frustrating to see you say "lets lynch X" or "omg X is so suspicious" when you provide barely any evidence for it.

 

[Ghostkid]

Detective, Vig, Vig, Veteran, Bodyguard, Neighbour, Vote Gifter + Karen's role? Unless Karen is BG or Vote Gifter? I know this sounds scum motivated but I'd rather her say yes or no to whether she's the vote gifter or bodyguard bc those are the only 2 confirmable roles right now, and I hate hate hate how everyone's giving her a free pass.

I'm probably gonna move my vote to Trundle, but srsly Karen pls

I hate thst too i hope she comes to her senses

 

[amazonevan19]

I'm down for a trundle lynch

 

[FireNinja1]

I'm down for a trundle lynch

Seconded.

 

[amanda1983]

if doctor outs they won?t die (since there?s bg)

if doctor gets roleblocked it?s good for us, we don?t want saves because if mafias smart they would only make 1 kill a night

- - - Post Merge - - -



cracking how l o l

Still catching up but WHY do you keeping giving Mafia advice / ideas like this??

 

[Ghostkid]

Y are we voting trundle?

 

[Heyden]

Actually lol, reading back I think I know what Karen based on a huge assumption that could easily be wrong but I'll take my chances.

Trundle lynch it is ayyy

- - - Post Merge - - -

actually I retract the Kermit statement but I still want to lynch Trundle anyway

 

[Ghostkid]

Fine whatever.(i swearcu all are voting trundle to spite me)
Ok im getting off.
One more thing if anyone wants to you all can call me gavin or gav if its easier for you.