Mafia Call the Ships to Port: Game Thread - END GAME - TOWN VICTORY!

Here's a new quick reads list maybe it will help me decide who to lynch
Vampnessa - sheeping all game, bad ISOs, on the wrong side of pretty much every wagon so far, she's played terribly tbh we should just lynch her....oh wait....but she's #NotMafia
Trundle - honestly really really conflicted. Heyden brought up a lot of good points against him and I lowkey want to lynch him just based on everything Heyden has said. B U T his tone feels super genuine, and if he really wanted to get out of the lynch the easiest thing to do would be to vote Karen but he's voting Kammm instead? Hmm
Kammm - like everyone else I kind of gave her a free pass all game for being new and good but I'd be surprised if at least one of the new players isn't mafia, and at this point idk who else it could be. But if she is in fact scum then she's played a fantastic game. Also Evan brought up some good points against her.
N e s s - I believe that he was hit, if he's pulling something I'll eat...nevermind I really don't want to go down that road again. And he's been really towny all game frankly.
Ghostkid - my kindred spirit who doesn't know what a quicktopic is. (How come I got sussed for it but he didn't?) Everything he says and the way he talks just screams new town.
Heyden - basically the town leader right now which is great, but tbh I really want someone to look into him (I mean I'd volunteer but it's easter this weekend I'l be busy). EVERYONE is townreading him and I think that's a little dangerous. He seems different than the last time he was scum but I believe he's good enough to change it up. Off the top of my head I can't think of anything scummy he has done but I've also never seen him really be a leader before and I can't help but wonder if he's doing what I did in RHOM.
amazonevan19 - I see now he can't really be townleaned for the role PM thing. I'm conflicted on this read as well because his tone has seemed like his regular town self all game but PoE also I agree with others that he has also been very opportunistic whist sussing me for being opportunistic.
Ryumia - just doesn't seem like mafia at all. I'm sure if she was scum, her partners would be telling her to focus more on scumhunting and not do things like trying to figure out why Jacob was killed.
Antonio - I still don't see why he's like super super townread by everyone but I agree he is more likely town than scum at this point
iLoveYou conclusion of my ISO was that she is more likely town based on her extreme bussing of Tom that started on day 1 and she hasn't really done anything wrong this game but I just have a bad gut feeling she could possibly be scum considering who is left, not that I have any points to support that.
KermitTea - Why the heck would she act like this as scum?? There are too many blues and I'm inclined to think one her and glow is lying but like...why would she be so vague and do the whole "33% confirmable" thing and make an encrypted thing saying her role if she was scum. To keep the lynch off of her, ok, fine. But imo it's a bit wild for scum. I agree with everyone else she should just claim at this point and explain why she couldn't do her actions the previous nights (or if she did and they weren't successful or idek.) Sacrifice thing was weird af. I didn't love mog's content either. Her recent actions are the only thing throwing me off from voting for her.
PandaDarling - people are saying she's playing differently from last game but I don't think that's fair because she literally didn't post at all last game. She even said that that's not how she intended to play. Tbh I found it odd that she townleaned me in her readslist because I don't really deserve to be townleaned and I've noticed that usually the people who townread me when everyone else is scumreading me are scum. (See: Oath in Caxnival, Byngo in Detonate to Shyna) But I can't really scumread her on that alone and if anything her content reminds me of games like Caxnival where she was town, but there's too little of it for me to give her a townlean.
amanda1983 - something about her that I can't put my finger on seems different from last game but I'm still not certain about her
Dad - not an impossibility for him to be mafia but I've liked his stances all game and I just don't see scum!Dad spending the entire game tunneling glow.
FireNinja1 - townlock because of Rune
glow - I haven't liked most of her content all game in the sense that I found it scummy (eg: scumreading oath but not Tom). I believe all the talk about "if I was mafia I would do this" could easily be reverse psychology. But like Karen, the one thing throwing me off is that she seems too out there to be scum (unless that's part of the plan too). She's said some pretty anti-town things that seem to obvious and risky for scum to say.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Oh wow that post looks like Evan is my strongest scumlean but he's really not

- - - Post Merge - - -

Uhh so I guess I think scum is within Trundle/glow/KermitTea/Evan/Kammm even though I also see reasons to townlean all of them
oof this game is rough
I really do want Heyden to be looked into though, definitely not for today's lynch but maybe tomorrow
 
Vampnessa
Trundle
Kammm
N e s s
Ghostkid
Heyden
amazonevan19
Ryumia
Antonio
iLoveYou
KermitTea
PandaDarling
amanda1983
Dad
FireNinja1
glow

Here's who's left. Fmpov I can only really 100% cut out FN and Ness from consideration, which obviously leaves a hella big scumpool

Vampnessa
Trundle
Kammm
Ghostkid
Heyden
amazonevan19
Ryumia
Antonio
iLoveYou
KermitTea
PandaDarling
amanda1983
Dad
glow

Let's operate off of some (reasonably safe) assumptions now. GK and Antonio are noob town and Heyden is reflecting town meta. That leaves

Vampnessa
Trundle
Kammm
amazonevan19
Ryumia
iLoveYou
KermitTea
PandaDarling
amanda1983
Dad
Glow

Assuming 4 scum are left, this gives us a 4/11 chance of randomly hitting scum. (4/10 eliminating me cuz I'm obvtown Kappa but I'm keeping myself in for objectivity's sake.) I AM NOT SUGGESTING RANDOM LYNCH, just noting this for the sake of observation. A hard look at each of the above and how they relate to each other is warranted imo
 
Honestly I was surprised that so many people were sus'ing Tom yet no Vigilantes thought to get him out of the game. I believe it was actually Dolby who posted saying that it didn't matter if we lynched Tom another day because his play would become obvious ovwr time, so I did follow his lead a bit on Day One. I do admit that. Of course there was a possibility that Tom was a quiet blue but when Oath and Kate died Night One it wasn't adding up why the mafia didn't see Tom as a potential blue player for a kill Night One too. Instead they went for Kate ( no one claimed a hit so there's no way Oath shot her at that point ). Which is why essentially I went hard on him.

I know that's a bit irrelevant but I think someone made an ISO on me and wanted to know why I didn't votw Tom Day One if I'm correct ? I think it was Vampnessa actually.

But anyways, I would really be surprised if Kammm is mafia. I'm looking into all the ISO's of her right now.
 
I'm not going to be on at EoD but I'll place a vote within the next three hours

- - - Post Merge - - -

iLoveYou said:
I know that's a bit irrelevant but I think someone made an ISO on me and wanted to know why I didn't votw Tom Day One if I'm correct ? I think it was Vampnessa actually.
yes that was me

- - - Post Merge - - -

that seems like a very random time to bring that up but thank you for answering

- - - Post Merge - - -

Oh nvm I see Evan was bringing up you and Tom ok that's not random then
 
Why is ILY getting the rep that she hardcore sussed tom day 1 when I literally just posted evidence showing she only slightly sussed him, if we're being generous with the definition of sus??
 
I'm not going to be on at EoD but I'll place a vote within the next three hours

- - - Post Merge - - -

yes that was me

- - - Post Merge - - -

that seems like a very random time to bring that up but thank you for answering

Well I had intentions to get back to you on that but the thread shifts so fast it's hard to stay on track sometimes. Evan's post reminded me that I still owed an answer for that.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Why is ILY getting the rep that she hardcore sussed tom day 1 when I literally just posted evidence showing she only slightly sussed him, if we're being generous with the definition of sus??

I definitely didn't sus him hardcore Day One. It was impossible to becausw of how little he posted and what he was giving us to work with. I agree with you on that point.
 
Why is ILY getting the rep that she hardcore sussed tom day 1 when I literally just posted evidence showing she only slightly sussed him, if we're being generous with the definition of sus??

Well ok it wasn't very hardcore on D1 but she was one of the first ones to bring him up (after Rune I think) and that's pretty risky if they were scummates because Tom had a valuable role.
 
Well ok it wasn't very hardcore on D1 but she was one of the first ones to bring him up (after Rune I think) and that's pretty risky if they were scummates because Tom had a valuable role.

true

we'd also have to semiclear trundle on that basis then

like I said earlier, I'm not sussing ily over it or blaming her for not "hardcore sussing" Tom d1; I just wanted to look into why everyone said she did, and it turns out to be another exaggeration akin to the praise of Kammm

- - - Post Merge - - -

Vampnessa
Trundle
Kammm
amazonevan19
Ryumia
iLoveYou
KermitTea
PandaDarling
amanda1983
Dad
Glow

out of the remaining people I don't townlock, these are roughly my opinions. Green = townlean points, orange = scumlean points, red = scumlock, gray = null points

- - - Post Merge - - -

voting kammm as she a strong scumlean atm and I also want to test trundle, cuz he also voted kammm and her flip will help my read on him

- - - Post Merge - - -

*is a strong
 
Im gonna take a guess just a guess mind u...thats probs not gonna help but im gonna put it out there...and i have no reasoning for putting these people here cuz its just a guess...
I belive that
Kammmm...idk how many m's there are
Trundle
Kermit
Amanda
And glow might be part of the mafia crusaders

- - - Post Merge - - -

Or at least some of them i know theres only 3 mafia left

- - - Post Merge - - -

4*
 
I was debating between Kammm and Karen but decided to just vote for Karen. I won't be here at EoD to switch my vote but if she actually claims something believable switch off of her. Right now I'm just not buying it though.
 
I’m on my lunch break... I need to figure out who I wanna vote for now, I work until 4pm pst which is EOD. Rip.
 
Voting for Trundle my lunch is nearly over, and I don’t know if I’m confident with Kermit soft claiming, if I have missed something I’m sorry I’ll try to check back before EoD.
 
hello karen, earth to karen, can you hear me karen

If she keeps avoiding us, do you guys still want to risk the lynch ? I think if she was a double voter role ( like some people mentioned as a possibility) she would have easily claimed it by now to save herself and us from eventually losing the game. The only other option looks like Kammm or Glow. There's always No Lynch too worst case scenario ?
 
Worst case scenario is that shes town with a blue role...
 
Back
Top