Mafia Call the Ships to Port: Game Thread - END GAME - TOWN VICTORY!

[Heyden]

WHERE IS KAREN?????

 

[iLoveYou]

Im down with sheeping idrc

If you're Town, you really need to be helping us find mafia and not just sheeping our votes. You helped with Tom and I think you can provide good feedback into who we should be going after. Right now we only have TWO chances to lynch wrong or we lose. Sheeping shouldn't be an option.

- - - Post Merge - - -

By the looks of it town is going to lose. If the rest of maf team is glow/Evan/Vanessa/some newer player I shrugged off then I'm gonna be annoyed but hey whatever. Nobody listens to Dad.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Might think deeper into Trundle depending on how horrible this reads list is gonna be but the points glow makes I feel the same way about.

The people on your list who I think may be hiding mafia are Vampnessa and Evan. Literally the people sheeping votes are making me nervous. They're way too okay wih hopping from person to person instead of providing advice and perspective on players.

 

[Heyden]

Karen ur doing more harm than good rn u kind of wasted 24 hours if my time and others

Also does anyone else get super dyslexic when evan and amandas users are next to each other or is it just me lmao

 

[iLoveYou]

Def the last two scums are in amanda/kermit/vanessa/ryu imo

anyone on board for a glow mass vote now? we can get karen later but I am pretty near certain glow is scum now

- - - Post Merge - - -

honestly think she's cracking

should we nl today?? considering only one townie went down, it may be best...ik we have a while to decide and I'm all for a karen or glow lynch atm but we may want to think about NLing

I'm down for a trundle lynch

So let me guess Evan, now you're down to lynch Kermit again ? You're playing very opportunistic and going with what other players are saying for our last two lives left in this game.

- - - Post Merge - - -

How can you say "definitely the last two scums are in" and then suddenly be okay with a Trundle lynch ?

 

[Ghostkid]

If you're Town, you really need to be helping us find mafia and not just sheeping our votes. You helped with Tom and I think you can provide good feedback into who we should be going after. Right now we only have TWO chances to lynch wrong or we lose. Sheeping shouldn't be an option.

- - - Post Merge - - -



The people on your list who I think may be hiding mafia are Vampnessa and Evan. Literally the people sheeping votes are making me nervous. They're way too okay wih hopping from person to person instead of providing advice and perspective on players.

Ive been explaining y i think Kermit is mafia for days now.

 

[amazonevan19]

Ugh stuff came up and I didn’t get to do my ILY examination. Guess I can do so at work

Also, I have been providing plenty of analysis of my own, so while I have flipped between people and sometimes followed thread opinions, the statement that I “always go along with the thread” is simply not true

Something of note is that Amanda came out strongly in favor of kammm. Definite buddying if they’re on the same team, and her whole analysis was essentially “Kam is new so give her a pass.” No I’m sorry, I can’t give a new scummy person a pass just because they are new

 

[Ghostkid]

Ugh stuff came up and I didn’t get to do my ILY examination. Guess I can do so at work

Also, I have been providing plenty of analysis of my own, so while I have flipped between people and sometimes followed thread opinions, the statement that I “always go along with the thread” is simply not true

Something of note is that Amanda came out strongly in favor of kammm. Definite buddying if they’re on the same team, and her whole analysis was essentially “Kam is new so give her a pass.” No I’m sorry, I can’t give a new scummy person a pass just because they are new

So ur implying they are a mafia duo?

 

[amazonevan19]

So let me guess Evan, now you're down to lynch Kermit again ? You're playing very opportunistic and going with what other players are saying for our last two lives left in this game.

- - - Post Merge - - -

How can you say "definitely the last two scums are in" and then suddenly be okay with a Trundle lynch ?

I actually then clarified that there’s probably three scums left and added Trundle

From what I’ve seen of trundle after that, he is still likely scum to me but is really trying he’s to appear town. I don’t like voting blue claims until they’ve claimed so no I won’t be switching to Karen for now.

- - - Post Merge - - -

So ur implying they are a mafia duo?

Possibly, though my Amanda read is more PoE than actual scumminess cuz I feel Amanda has been fairly town like this game. Though I’m sure she can change up what she did last game

 

[Ghostkid]

Wait whats PoE again i checked the encyclopedia but it wasnt there

 

[iLoveYou]

Ive been explaining y i think Kermit is mafia for days now.

Then WHY did you vote Trundle just because people switched ???????

- - - Post Merge - - -

I actually then clarified that there’s probably three scums left and added Trundle

From what I’ve seen of trundle after that, he is still likely scum to me but is really trying he’s to appear town. I don’t like voting blue claims until they’ve claimed so no I won’t be switching to Karen for now.

- - - Post Merge - - -



Possibly, though my Amanda read is more PoE than actual scumminess cuz I feel Amanda has been fairly town like this game. Though I’m sure she can change up what she did last game

Ya I know you eventually corrected yourself on how many mafia people are left in the game but it doesn't look right that you posted 4 potential scum leans and suddenly you go off of them onto Glow and Trundle. I need to check back if you added Trundle & why.

 

[Ghostkid]

Then WHY did you vote Trundle just because people switched ???????

When i get stressed and frustrated i make rash decisions

 

[iLoveYou]

Trundle is being pretty lazy and rn I?ve kinda had it with excuses. Glow has had rl **** and has still managed to post maybe two times more than him

Ya I saw this post Evan but I wasn't sure what to make of it because still it was generally what everyone else was saying.

 

[amazonevan19]

Ya I saw this post Evan but I wasn't sure what to make of it because still it was generally what everyone else was saying.

I have been vascillating on sussing Trundle for a while but have provided other reasoning in prior phases. And now he just voted kammm so I’m a little worried. Though from what I’ve read his kam read is a bit reliant on my ISO’s reasoning, and that may qualify under my prediction that people would just sheep it

 

[EpicGamer12]

I have been vascillating on sussing Trundle for a while but have provided other reasoning in prior phases. And now he just voted kammm so I’m a little worried. Though from what I’ve read his kam read is a bit reliant on my ISO’s reasoning, and that may qualify under my prediction that people would just sheep it

If I'm honest I don't read 90% of your posts, I actually do remember reading Heyden's read on Kammm though.

 

[amazonevan19]

If I'm honest I don't read 90% of your posts, I actually do remember reading Heyden's read on Kammm though.

So you didn’t read or skim my Kam post and so you’re sheeping Heyden instead?

Not much better tbh

 

[cornimer]

If Vampnessa doesn't post soon, can we make a note that she is being kinda quiet during this time ? Sorry if you're just busy but I saw you on the thread and then you left.

Yeah I know I'm sorry I'm trying to catch up

 

[EpicGamer12]

So you didn’t read or skim my Kam post and so you’re sheeping Heyden instead?

Not much better tbh

I skim most posts but I don't recall anything from you on Kammm lol

 

[amazonevan19]

I skim most posts but I don't recall anything from you on Kammm lol

not exactly sure how you missed this

- - - Post Merge - - -

ily has 11 pages in this game R I P

just gonna look into her tom interactions/mentions atm

 

[N e s s]

Meh trundle is probably Town. If I'm wrong about this I'm going to hate myself but I feel as if scum!Trundle would freak the hell out by now like he usually does

- - - Post Merge - - -

His tone is also really genuine too so ifk

 

[amazonevan19]

That actually crossed my mind too about Tom. All he did so far was post a meme and help a nub player out. I can't even comment further than that on him because that is all he provided us with.

Ness I will happily reply to your post in the morning ( my time ).

first ILY mention of Tom, replying to rune who noted his memey posts and helping one noob player

So besides Tom not posting much, Trundle clearing people as Town too quickly without providing good reasons and too many players falling silent but still viewing the thread .. I wanted to bring this post up super quickly as well:

second mention, noting inactivity

Kammm also just simply agreed with one of my bigger posts and disappeared after that. When her & Tom are doing that, I feel like they're using me as a shield to cover themselves in the thread.

third mention, notably also tossing kam into the inactive bucket

Tom

He hasn't been posting much at all and amongst the few times he did, he only posted to agree with me. Looking back, I think he was using me as a "shield" in the sense that he stood behind my words without making a post on his own opinions. So essentially I think he found a way to try to blend into the crowd as Runeraider, and others, have mentioned. Even when people keep calling him out on it, he hasn't responded. I feel like he needs to be kept an eye on, especially with the way he votes & reason for voting.

pretty decent analysis, though noticeably isn't hard scumreading him. None of these posts are; they're just noting inactivity

The other posts are just passing mentions

So where is the anti-Tom warrior here? I don't think ILY is scum, at least not yet, but she is unconfirmed and PoE has to keep including her as a possibility.

Something I did see was that Trundle hard scumleaned tom in post 115. 115! That's ridiculously early even for Trundle bussing standards