In the following list I've highlighted those I'm quite sure are town. These are the "if they flip scum I'll eat a hat" type reads for me right now.
Vampnessa
Trundle
Kammm
N e s s
Ghostkid
Heyden
amazonevan19
Ryumia
Antonio
iLoveYou
KermitTea
PandaDarling
amanda1983
Dad
FireNinja1
glow
Vampnessa - Scumlean - or I wouldn't necessarily say scumlean but I just can't tell with Vanessa. Last time I played with Vanessa where she was mafia, she completely bamboozled me (RHOM, worth a read).
Notable Post:
I'm sheeping everyone because I'm too busy to make my own cases which is why I signed up for replacements and didn't just /in in the first place
I never really left the Dolby wagon I still sussed him I just eventually agreed Tom was a better candidate for that day
@rune
Kammm - Hard to get a read on a mildly inactive, however there are some interesting patterns in her posts. If you read her posts, you will probably quickly realize that all of her posts are focusing on new/noob players. Namely Antonio, Ryumia, Punchy, and at one point seemed to be defending Tom after Ghostkid put Tom as a mafia read. This is a bit alarming because, out of all the people being sussed at the time, why choose to refute Ghostkid's read on Tom of all people? Definite scum lean for me.
Notable Post: (post#246)
What triggered a "gut feeling" that Tom is mafia? I've seen a few other people say he's possible scum as well, but I think we need more posts from him before we can start saying he's sus.
Ryumia - As I've mentioned before, I am terrible with reading noob players, however I've been getting town vibes from Ryumia most of the game despite how annoying her posts are to read. I feel like if she was mafia, they would be telling her what to post instead of "I am still looking for clues" 50 times.
Antonio - Attempted to hijack the thread in order to ask opinions on his web design skills. Would a mafia do that? I honestly don't think so lol, but aside from that he seems pretty overwhelmed with the amount of players in the game. TL for me, but I couldn't say for sure. I can't compare anything from him to previous games unfortunately since he only has 1.
iLoveYou - Honestly, her posts have been so much filler and re-iterating what other people say. They've been vocal though, it's so hard to nail down whether or not iLoveYou is scum. One thing I definitely do remember from her is that she is an incredibly adept scum player, and can blend in very well. I'm gonna scumlean but I'd appreciate if someone else could provide analysis where I am lacking.
KermitTea - Voting results from D2
mogyay/Kermitea (1)
glow
PunchyDaHufflepuff
iLoveYou
Tom
Can someone read into this? Tom is such a troll when he knows he's going down. I don't think we should lynch Karen today based on the vague wordings of posts we've seen, but if nothing comes up tomorrow that "proves" her as town should be an easy lynch.
PandaDarling - Her reads are pretty bad imo, and I'm not saying that just because she scum leans me.
these are all leans as of right now:
Vampnessa - nothing about Vanessa says scum to me she seems transparent in her post.
Runeraider - i feel like rune raider is genuinely and actively help us scum hunt and was practically the only person to give Punchy the benefit of the doubt about there weird veteran bomb role.
Kammm -
Ness - he is reminding me completely of his town meta, his emotional back and forth with Toad feels like the town Ness that i know and love.
Amanda -
ILoveYou - first game playing with her, she seems helpful to town but also a bit opprotunistist if that makes sense ? she pushes conversation in a productive way with is good, but haven't seen much actual opinion.
Heyden - seems to be acting his normal town self, but he always seems a bit sus to me so i dont want to exactly town lean him just yet
Evan - i need more from you please.
Dad - up un til recently you have been doing the same this as Glow, so i look forward to hearing more from you and getting a better read on you.
Glow - wish she would post more, she comes in every so often to say a few words then disappears again for the most part.
Ryumia -
Antonio - always seems sus to me, but im starting to learn that, the might just be his personality so not gonna scum lean him yet.
Kermit - the last minute unvote of Punchy seems off to me, then the very vague "i have somethingg to do tonight" i feel like is just a fake soft claim.
Fireninja - at first seemed to come in the thread just to be disruptive and as the game has progressed has kinda faded into the background, maybe starting to feel nervous about standing out as the playlist shrinks ?
GhostKid - i feel like ghosted could be newbie scum slipping under the radar.
Trundle - has been saying far too little for my liking, iirc he use to be more vocal and determined to help scum hunt, but this game he seems t one laying back and letting everything happen around him.
I can look back and develop these more, if i survive tonight, but if i don't please don't let the people that have been popping in and out of the thread just skate by undetected, i believe there's at least one if not more mafia in the people with minimal activity. i love you all and good luck.
2 of her town reads have no reasoning. I can't really make anything out of Panda in any game though so, again, someone else please look.
amanda1983 - I'll get back to this
Dad
glow
Doing a double whammy on these two. If both of these are town, it makes me think iLoveYou or Vanessa must be mafia. glow has been making amazing reads all game like normal, but how is she still alive if her reads really are all that good? Devolves into WIFOM in this case with what I think the mafia is doing vs what they want me to think they're doing. Dad recently decided he finally agrees with glow on her post about me, honestly looks like an appeasement. If I had to guess, glow/Dad is town vs town, or town vs mafia. I think Dad wants to stay on town's good side as long as possible if he is mafia, which explains why he would agree with glow on that post.
Anyway that was a terrible analysis of Dad/glow and I apologize, I'm just going to post it now so I can start looking at Amanda's other games and finish off the reads.
Final Thoughts:
If Ness is still alive tomorrow it
could be worthwhile to confirm him by asking bodyguard to claim. It just depends on who dies. I think we are believing him a bit too easily but I do think he has been giving off town vibes most of the game.
