Mafia Call the Ships to Port: Game Thread - END GAME - TOWN VICTORY!

Panda gave Amanda a green colour in her read without even saying why. Amanda replaced Gigalabesh. On the contrary though, she put KermitsTea as orange.
 
what EVEN was the point of claiming third i’m screaming
 
Panda[ Vampnessa - nothing about Vanessa says scum to me she seems transparent in her post. Runeraider - i feel like rune raider is genuinely and actively help us scum hunt and was practically the only person to give Punchy the benefit of the doubt about there weird veteran bomb role. Kammm - Ness - he is reminding me completely of his town meta said:
Hmm the only actually scum (assuming fireninja and ghostkid are both blues) in her scumleans was Kermit. If she put one in null and one in town which is pretty standard I think then scum could easily be Amanda and any one of Kayla/Dad/Heyden (Heyden is the least sus out of these 3 for me)
The spaces separate town, null, and scum leans

- - - Post Merge - - -

CRUD I messed up the quote
Click to expand...
 
Dad said:
Why is everyone buying into this vote and get bombed thing? smfh

To clarify why I voted Punchy after voting glow: I do actually see the 'typo' as a scumslip. This is Punchy's first game as mafia and it comes off as him being nervous when I look back at day 1, which I thought could either be him as a blue or him as mafia, and initially I was on the blue side. Now? This role he is claiming is insane, the defenses seem defeated, and if he's a jester I'll be pissed but also in awe. Also because everyone seems to be self-voting and yet again nobody is going to listen to me about glow nevertheless follow me on lynching her.
Click to expand...

Knowing now that Panda had a similar time bomb to Punchy is bringing light onto why Dad was trying to make us ignore the threat of a bomb. I never understood why he shrugged it off so much and how he was so confident that it was just paranoia / harmless / not real. Also I do need to bring up again how Dad read Punchy as a potential blue .. is he the blue sniper ? Probably.

Notice he seems confident that the bomb is harmless and won't kill us ? Notice he votes for Punchy ? In that moment voting for Punchy would appear more Town because you are willing to "sacrifice" yourself. My guess for why he was trying to play the bomb off as nothing would be to ensure Punchy gets as many votes as possible so he can frame people on either end of the vote that day ( those who voted Punchy & those who self-voted ) should he need to in the future. As well as hide potential mafia players who would vote for Punchy.

Also in a recent post of his ( which for some reason I can't find ) he mentioned that he wanted to look at the players who self-voted in the Punchy lynch. Why would you even want to do that knowing that Punchy literally lied to us about his role / win con / claim ?


Here are more quotes from Dad about lynching Punchy:

Dad said:
Punchy is straight up lurking and communicating through liking people's posts. The chaotic energies emanating off this guy...

Also yeah, if you're paranoid, self-vote don't vote no lynch. That'll create more nights with a 2kp mafia team.

- - - Post Merge - - -

But that's what this is. Paranoia. If I die from voting for Punchy ya'll can put a clown hat on my avatar but for now I'm going to reassert that this is such a silly concern.
Click to expand...

Again encouraging that the time bomb is a silly concern trying to encourage people to vote on Punchy. Why ? So that the mafia team could potentially hide if they wanted to vote out Punchy. Mafia players who voted Punchy = KermitsTea ( although unvoted )& Dad ( because he has to be mafia at this point ). Mafia players who didn't = PandaDarling who was a bomb herself. So I'm actually not sure why she did that but I guess it was in case their bombs were connected somehow ? She probably wanted to play it extra safe that day from all ends.


amanda1983 said:
Uh... Why are people voting "No Lynch" in the voting thread ???
Click to expand...

amanda1983 said:
I really hope so, yep.

And I remembered Punchy declined to self-vote so his NL vote isn't a surprise. Just don't want others to start voting NL, too.
Click to expand...

amanda1983 said:
You're right, yep. I didn't see that, was too focused on the NL thing.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'm going to try sleeping at a civilised time for once. I'll make sure I'm back before EoD. Doubt I'll need to change my vote, all things considered, but I will be here to do so if necessary.

:)
Click to expand...

Ironically, Amanda questions why people are even voting No Lynch. What's wrong ? You guys needed the bomb to explode that day to get into mislynch or lose phase? You guys didn't want people to start discussing other possibilities ? Too focused on the No Lynch thing ?? Dad also mentioned people shouldn't be voting No Lynch that day. I think they were trying to be helpful to Town ( No lynch keeps mafia KP constant as Dad brought up ) while accomplishing their goal of activating a bomb. Had too many people switched to No Lynch then they wouldn't have successfully lynched the bomb from Town's side.
 
Okay Dad is scum

Remaining scum: Dad and Amanda, forgot the other one I mentioned but I have a degree of confidence that's the scum
 
Also I guess Ryumia/Antonio are suspicious too but I have a hard time seeing them a single town, I'll read into these two later
 
Vampnessa said:
Kayla you forgot to bold the most important quote:
Click to expand...

Ya, he was really confident that day. I thought at first its because he plays a lot and would be much more knowledgeable about game mechanics but then even other players like RuneRaider or even yourself Vanessa, wanted to be more careful about things. So he obviously played it up that day and he had good reason to: Punchy was lying. He wouldn't get caught or blamed either way.
 
Tina said:
YAHII82.png

Night Two.​


Night two will end Sunday 25th March 6pm EDT / 2pm PDT and midnight BST.
Note the time has changed for British players due to daylight savings time.

amanda1983, Kermitea, and Dad were spared.
Click to expand...

I guess now we know why they didn't get modkilled that time lols. It would have been the end of the game or left Panda at a serious disadvantage.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

N e s s
Mafia TBT Mafia - Darkest Dungeon (Cancelled)
Replies
15
Views
823
N e s s
N e s s
E
Mafia The Quest for King - Mafia | Game Thread | GAME OVER
89 90 91
Replies
2K
Views
48K
Jacob4
Jacob4
Damniel
Mafia Among Us Mafia Game Thread (Town Win!)
139 140 141
Replies
3K
Views
96K
unravel
unravel
Damniel
Mafia Among Us Mafia - Sign Ups
2
Replies
24
Views
2K
Damniel
Damniel
TN4U
  • Sticky
Mafia Redd's Revenge - Game Thread [GAME OVER]
56 57 58
Replies
1K
Views
29K
BetsySundrop
BetsySundrop
Back
Top