Mafia Call the Ships to Port: Game Thread - END GAME - TOWN VICTORY!

[Geoni]

Get ready to be sorry if you've made up your mind Heyden.

Also are you talking about the voting thing from day 1 Kayla? Because that's the only thing I can see being stretched into being 'caught'.

- - - Post Merge - - -

day 2, rather

 

[iLoveYou]

Lols pulling a Panda / Tom ?

Yes that is what I'm talking about. It's not the voting though, it was more than that.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also FYI, my first post today was at 4:23 am I believe, and I was active on the thread until then.

- - - Post Merge - - -

So again, I was active way before you or Amanda showed up.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Active on the thread since then *

 

[Geoni]

Lols pulling a Panda / Tom ?

Yes that is what I'm talking about. It's not the voting though, it was more than that.

Pulling a Panda/Tom?

Also, if it was more than that, ****ing quote it then.

 

[iLoveYou]

Listen, I'm not down for these games. My posts are there for you to read & reply to. At this point you're just making me do your work for you.

& yet you want to talk about people taunting you. Wow.

 

[N e s s]

Will scum finally give me dat sweet release of death this night since I'm confirmed

Because this is a win in my book

- - - Post Merge - - -

Just an FYI Dad is getting my second vote because I don't think he isn't scum it's prob iLoveYou ^^

 

[Geoni]

It's not about me 'making you do work for me', it's about you arguing that I was 'caught' alongside Amanda, and when you can't even point out the post number nevertheless quote what I appear to be missing, you're avoiding it because you need to fish it out. And if you're repeating yourself? Your argument shows up one more time and if it's a good argument, repetition = reinforcement. But if it's bad? Bad reinforcement.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Will scum finally give me dat sweet release of death this night since I'm confirmed

Because this is a win in my book

- - - Post Merge - - -

Just an FYI Dad is getting my second vote because I don't think he isn't scum it's prob iLoveYou ^^

Change my name to iLoveYouNess

 

[iLoveYou]

It's not about me 'making you do work for me', it's about you arguing that I was 'caught' alongside Amanda, and when you can't even point out the post number nevertheless quote what I appear to be missing, you're avoiding it because you need to fish it out. And if you're repeating yourself? Your argument shows up one more time and if it's a good argument, repetition = reinforcement. But if it's bad? Bad reinforcement.

- - - Post Merge - - -



Change my name to iLoveYouNess

You're avoiding making any defences when I clearly put out posts for you. This is wasting time but I guess the night phase is the phase you least have to worry about right ?

 

[N e s s]

Dad why don't you want a second vote

 

[Geoni]

You're avoiding making any defences when I clearly put out posts for you. This is wasting time but I guess the night phase is the phase you least have to worry about right ?

I'm legit looking back and the only other thing I can think of is the thing about lynching Punchy but if you want to say that's me being caught it's laughable. And not only that, it had nothing to do with Amanda either, and you lumped her in with the 'caught' statement. And if you need me to repeat why I voted for Punchy, it's because I saw what he did as a slip and even early on I thought that he was making that statement about his playstyle because a) he's blue or b) he's mafia. His behavior during his lynchday made me lean towards the latter.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Dad why don't you want a second vote

I just said I'll love you if you do.

 

[Antonio]

Didn't the majority vote for punchy?

 

[iLoveYou]

You guys aren't going to believe me when I say this but I agree with glow. This was gamethrowing. What Punchy did severely handicapped town and just made this game much easier for mafia to win by voting for himself and not being completely forward in what would happen if he was lynched with the information he had. I should have trusted my gut on this because since day 1 I believed that Punchy was acting the way he was acting because he was a blue.

Also lets think before we get no-lynch happy because they'll just pick off the most universally townread people. That's what I would do in their position right now.

Going to look back on how people aligned with Punchy yet again but I am just on break. Bbl.

As much as I kind of geek out about how Tina put the Lightkeeper role in tbt somehow (changed to be unique however), it was most certainly in the wrong hands.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I mean, I'm trying not to be super hard on you because you are still relatively new to this and it's only lightly gamethrowy since this doesn't automatically make us lose, but just learn from this and move on.

This is fake. This is damage control. This is after you and Amanda told people not to vote for No Lynch. This is after you said to self-vote if anything. If this was your gut feeling why didn't you speak up in the thread to give a different perspective. I understand that the Punchy lynch was most likely to happen but if enough of us stood against it, it could have gotten players to reconsider it. Instead you were busy spreading the word of " no voting for no lynch guys ". Along with Amanda. You yourself said the mafia will make bold moves when they see an opportunity and this was a HUGE game-changing opportunity for you guys.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Its not about you voting for Punchy. Its about HOW you went about conducting his lynch with Amanda to ensure he was lynched while appearing pro-Town for voting on him and " sacrificing " yourself in the eyes of all players. Its about how you two cared so much about players voting No Lynch which would mess up the plans right ? Its about you promoting people to self-vote and then turning around saying we should look at the players who self-voted. Its contradicting.

- - - Post Merge - - -

There are literally Town players who got modkilled and you guys actually think Dad getting spared was a coincidence ? No. Its because that would have destroyed the entire mafia team that day.

 

[Geoni]

How could mafia know what Punchy had when it came to the lighthouse thing that would lead to town losing with two mislynches? You're making this argument as if mafia could have known that is what it would lead to when in fact mafia doesn't even have a role cop if we're going to remind ourselves of what glow revealed. I guess you could argue role cop is the ??? but lol, atm this seems like you are trying to make it seem like at that time, being anti-no-lynch was being anti-town when in fact no lynching wasn't helpful at the time, not until after the lighthouse went out.

Also I never self-voted nor did I promote self-voting. A lot of what you're trying to argue here never happened. Like...lol, glad you're tripping up on the facts because you're trying to rewrite a narrative of me being partnered with Amanda and both of us having led the lynch against Punchy. Vanessa and Evan were the largest voices in the Punchy lynch, which is why I suspected both, and especially suspected Evan after he came off as opportunistic with the Trundle lynch as well.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also if all three of us were on the team that day (only 2/3 were), why would we choose not to vote if it led to a modkill, especially 3/5 mafia. That would severely reduce a team's KP and if it was planned, it would require us to ask Tina if she'd modkill us if we didn't vote in a qt and if she gave three mafia players a pass to do so while modkilling town, that'd be pretty impartial hosting, and Tina isn't known for that.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'm loving this argument though. Keep it coming Kayla.

 

[iLoveYou]

How could mafia know what Punchy had when it came to the lighthouse thing that would lead to town losing with two mislynches? You're making this argument as if mafia could have known that is what it would lead to when in fact mafia doesn't even have a role cop if we're going to remind ourselves of what glow revealed. I guess you could argue role cop is the ??? but lol, atm this seems like you are trying to make it seem like at that time, being anti-no-lynch was being anti-town when in fact no lynching wasn't helpful at the time, not until after the lighthouse went out.

Also I never self-voted nor did I promote self-voting. A lot of what you're trying to argue here never happened. Like...lol, glad you're tripping up on the facts because you're trying to rewrite a narrative of me being partnered with Amanda and both of us having led the lynch against Punchy. Vanessa and Evan were the largest voices in the Punchy lynch, which is why I suspected both, and especially suspected Evan after he came off as opportunistic with the Trundle lynch as well.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also if all three of us were on the team that day (only 2/3 were), why would we choose not to vote if it led to a modkill, especially 3/5 mafia. That would severely reduce a team's KP and if it was planned, it would require us to ask Tina if she'd modkill us if we didn't vote in a qt and if she gave three mafia players a pass to do so while modkilling town, that'd be pretty impartial hosting, and Tina isn't known for that.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'm loving this argument though. Keep it coming Kayla.

Because you guys already had a time bomb role on your team lmao. Are you serious ? Its so obvious how the mafia would know that its a similar time bomb when you guys literally had the role yourselves with the same title. I am not saying that you knew how many mislynches in particular, I am saying you and Amanda already knew it would cause a mislynch because you two had the information in front of you. You two saw people doing no lynch and you wanted to prevent more people from switching because that was your game-changing opportunity. Bold. Move.

You actually did tell people to self-vote rather than no lynch and I'm pretty sure I quoted that. Why self-vote or even no lynch instead of saying your gut feeling ? You literally said your gut feeling was that he was blue yet you didn't stand up and say something. Only once he flipped blue for damage control. I'm not saying you led the lynch, I'm saying you were conducting the lynch while it was in progress to ensure No Lynch would not gain the majority over Punchy. Two people had wanted to vote No Lynch.

You said you FORGOT to vote not that you chose not to. I never said it was planned that you three decided not to vote.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Literally your post started with REEEEEEEEEE I FORGOT TO VOTE

- - - Post Merge - - -

So what was she supposed to do ? Let 3 / 4 mafia get modkilled ? Lmao

 

[Ghostkid]

ILY vs Dad
Town vs mafia or MAFIA VS MAFIA :eyes: #DadisactuallyMom

 

[iLoveYou]

Why did you stand up for Karen potentially being blue but not Punchy ?

 

[amazonevan19]

right as I think dad is starting to make sense, he pulls **** like "ZOMGS AMANDA AND ILY ARE ON AT THE SAME TIME"

like if he's town and doesn't know that just looks hella opportunistic...then I take back everything I said about him being self aware lmao

I'll have to digest the other back and forth arguments but that in particular stood out to me, like honestly wtf dad.

 

[iLoveYou]

The fact that he's pretending not to know how the mafia would know about the time bomb is like he's just trying to pretend that he could never think of that. Ness is Town and he thought of that ?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Dad you're a really good player and there's no reason you wouldn't be able to connect the dots on that.

- - - Post Merge - - -

So stop faking.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also just FYI I can't post too much from this point forward due to work.

 

[Geoni]

Because you guys already had a time bomb role on your team lmao. Are you serious ? Its so obvious how the mafia would know that its a similar time bomb when you guys literally had the role yourselves with the same title. I am not saying that you knew how many mislynches in particular, I am saying you and Amanda already knew it would cause a mislynch because you two had the information in front of you. You two saw people doing no lynch and you wanted to prevent more people from switching because that was your game-changing opportunity. Bold. Move.

What does mafia having a time bomb have to do with us specifically knowing that town had a time bomb nevertheless that it was Punchy of all people? That kinda **** would require a role cop, like I was saying, in order for us to have been specifically trying so hard to make sure Punchy got lynched and that us telling people not to no-lynch was the way to achieve that. And team doesn't. Your only saving grace here is that there was a ??? in that list so you can of course say that was role cop but you're really pushing hard to convince people that somehow Amanda and I are on the team and that we would be able to know this much because you're grasping at straws to make me look sus as possible.

Also I was promoting a Punchy lynch because I thought he was scum based on how he reacted during his lynch day, and I wanted him lynched over no-lynchers or self-voters and I continually said that this is a dumb paranoia people were having that anyone lynching Punchy would die. Also, on the note of giving Punchy a benefit of the doubt with being blue rather than scum, he had a number of days between when I originally sensed he could be blue and when I changed my mind about it. I wanted to see how Kermit would act the following day before I made my decision on her but she died that night.

Also I'm pretty sure it's 5 mafia team but what you're trying to accuse me of is being on a mafia team and actually not reminding my team to make sure they vote and not get modkilled. I normally don't forget to vote as town (have a fantastic track record of that btw) but I for sure don't forget to vote as mafia. Because I know that any loss of KP can be a detriment to whether or not scum can win the game. And I was annoyed with myself that I didn't vote even as town. But I was also having a hectic workweek at that time and my job often requires me to be away from internet for hours if it's busy and there are a lot of incidents going on and I was training a guard that night as well and forgot to get to voting. You're again trying to push this point as it being 'Dad getting caught' so no matter what I say about it the response is going to be 'Tina wouldn't kill a majority of the mafia team one night because a lot of them forgot to vote'.

- - - Post Merge - - -

The fact that he's pretending not to know how the mafia would know about the time bomb is like he's just trying to pretend that he could never think of that. Ness is Town and he thought of that ?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Dad you're a really good player and there's no reason you wouldn't be able to connect the dots on that.

- - - Post Merge - - -

So stop faking.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also just FYI I can't post too much from this point forward due to work.

I'm a good enough player to know that if I were mafia in that situation it would look better to act upon the paranoia and self-vote rather than participate in a lynch like Punchy's given how a great deal of the town saw him as mafia and wouldn't need to go out of my way super hard to be anti-no-lynch or anti-self-voting.

But yeah I have to sleep soon so I'll be away for a while as well, anyways.

- - - Post Merge - - -

right as I think dad is starting to make sense, he pulls **** like "ZOMGS AMANDA AND ILY ARE ON AT THE SAME TIME"

like if he's town and doesn't know that just looks hella opportunistic...then I take back everything I said about him being self aware lmao

I'll have to digest the other back and forth arguments but that in particular stood out to me, like honestly wtf dad.

Opportunism can be used by town as well, especially if they're told they're going to be lynched by a majority of the playerlist, and it seemed like a definitive qt moment.

 

[N e s s]

Can we stop with the text walls

 

[Ghostkid]

Can we stop with the text walls

I agree with ness dad ur not getting out of a lynch...we made up our minds...just give up

- - - Post Merge - - -

30$ FOR A GOD**** GAME ABOUT MARIO PLAYING GOLF TF IS THIS ****