Y would we think she was scum?
Mafia Call the Ships to Port: Game Thread - END GAME - TOWN VICTORY!
- Thread starter Chris
- Start date
Y would we think she was scum?
I can if you want ? I'm Sana the Parrot Trainer (Townie).
amazonevan19
DLELELEWOOOOP
she claimed vt awhile ago iirc
Octopus catcher sounds a little fake
- - - Post Merge - - -
Parrot trainer
Octopus catcher
Alter boy
One of these is not like the other
Initially I thought Kermit was a traitor hit but now I'm thinking it was within the team, because it wouldn't take the KP down to 1, what would take the KP down to 1 is losing one more team member that day which they did. No, it seemed like Kermit was very lynch-prone even after Trundle got lynched instead, and so that vote on you, and the kill within the team, and how Tina answered the question that she did allow inter-team kills, says to me that there was a potential for her being used to make you specifically seem less suspect with the vote and people like me look more suspect, especially since glow was very anti-Kermit, more obvious town at that point, and I'd been hard on her most of the game.
Again you understand how Tom used to be but he isn't that way anymore. He had a long streak of either being mafia a good 4-5 times in a row or something, and when he was town, he got N1'd or sometimes lynched D1 very often, and I think it sorta broke him into not giving as many reads as a player. Coming in after a long haitus away from forum mafia, Tom probably wasn't very confident as scum, thus I can see him allowing himself to be fodder. But given how you stuck to the no lynch or lynch inactive thing for the first day as well as not liking Tom because you expect him to be stronger even though myself and others explained both tbt's meta and Tom's meta has changed and how it has changed, it suggests to me a sense of self-awareness I was worried about but didn't dwell on because I didn't think someone making a long-time return to be that strong of an actor but actually, going in fresh, I think that probably helped with both the acting and sensing who was blue. But I also don't think it may have been intentional that you were going after blues but more likely that Toads was killed because it made Ness look bad, Oath was killed because it made glow look bad, and you saw my potential to lead against both of them.
"What basis do I have to go on to say a role like that would never exist?" Is this referring to Punchy's? And the worry that anyone who voted Punchy would be killed? Because if so here's the basis: it's way too overpowered and could near autowin the game for mafia had something like that been given to Tom for example.
And no you clearly seemed to argue that I was planting seeds of doubt to 'put you in this situation' or something of that wording. Of course mentioning that I could have also been doing it with others is a fair means to backtrack on that.
- - - Post Merge - - -
tbh if I'm ranking it for myself right now it would be Kayla > Amanda > Ryumia > Antonio > Heyden. I feel pretty confident about Antonio and Heyden being town and Kayla/Amanda being a team. Ryumia could be mafia if she's coasting by with using irl excuses and acting disinterested. But my thing here is I don't think she's experienced enough to act disinterested here because in thread her posts don't suggest that she's disinterested but her activity off the thread as was pointed out earlier in the game shows it wasn't always her top priority on tbt.
Dad, why would mafia focus on making kills to make other players look bad instead of focusing on killing blues that would hurt their game ? It was clear the mafia was blue sniping. There were so many other kills they could have made if that's what you're arguing. How about Punchy vs. FireNinja1 for example ?
- - - Post Merge - - -
And if that's what you're arguing then explain the Kate kill and which player that would have made look bad ?
- - - Post Merge - - -
And if that's what you're arguing then explain the Kate kill and which player that would have made look bad ?
Really and truly, day 1 seems like the only one where I can see it as bluesniping because out of everyone those weren't the people I was expecting to see dead. But I'm not going to consider Dolby a bluesnipe because he could not only be a fearkill because he's seen as a strong player, but he also died shortly after scumreading a lot of townies so it would look bad on said townies, and not only that but he was townread by most people even though they still aired that they felt like he could be scum if only because he's seen as good enough to fake town that good.
Tbh, I can hardly even think of what kind of indicators Toads gave to come off as blue because he was very much at the forefront of an argument between himself and Ness and he also took a harsh stance on FireNinja. Oath? Sure, he was quiet, and that could have been an indicator, but I'm not dismissing that it could have been what I said before about it making glow look bad.
Tbh, I can hardly even think of what kind of indicators Toads gave to come off as blue because he was very much at the forefront of an argument between himself and Ness and he also took a harsh stance on FireNinja. Oath? Sure, he was quiet, and that could have been an indicator, but I'm not dismissing that it could have been what I said before about it making glow look bad.
FireNinja1
inactive: please read "about" tab on profile
Guys, scum have safe claims, stop wasting your time.
Antonio
✦ Any Pronouns ✦
Lil Sebastian from parks and rec <3
Anyways these names are weird. I'm Neilin the Castle Servant (Townie). What is a castle servant even doing on a boat?
On the note of FN vs Punchy? I think mafia would be able to tell they're both unstable enough to be lynched, either one of them, and they just kill the one who looks clearer the following night, not that night. If there was nothing better on the table to kill.
And kate? Could have been a mafia kill or a vig shot, but there were only 3 kills that night, and I see mafia as having had 3kp that night, so either she was a bluesnipe based on not wanting to say too much in the thread as a new player who has a role of responsibility or Oath thought she was scum and shot her and for some reason one of the mafia kills didn't go through.
amazonevan19
DLELELEWOOOOP
what if the last two are dad/kayla and they've been arguing this whole time as an elaborate form of distancing L M A O
Yeah I don't recall anyone claiming to be hit or lose a life or anything D2 so that's why even back when it happened I theorized kate was a bluesnipe based on how she might have been holding back to not bring too much attention on herself and that's why she seemed inactive.
amazonevan19
DLELELEWOOOOP
if Amanda hasn't claimed yet I'm just gonna park my votes on her at this point
I really thought she claimed some generic VT tho...brb gonna check
I really thought she claimed some generic VT tho...brb gonna check
