Mafia Call the Ships to Port: Game Thread - END GAME - TOWN VICTORY!

[Geoni]

*posts multiple pages worth of content in a single case against a person*

"I guess I wooouldn't be against a lynch on Evan."

Honestly I feel the same as someone else said they felt about Evan in that they just felt very uncertain about him. I think it was Dolby. And reading through Rune's post here, I think the source of that is how Evan seemed to take a stance against FireNinja and yet he said something very against the vibe that he was building into a campaign against FireNinja: he mentioned that FireNinja didn't play like this when they were both mafia together and doesn't see him making a sudden vote and clinging to it reflects his meta. So all in all it feels wishywashy. Interestingly both he and FireNinja aligned on voting Ryumia.

 

[illunie]

*posts multiple pages worth of content in a single case against a person*

"I guess I wooouldn't be against a lynch on Evan."

Honestly I feel the same as someone else said they felt about Evan in that they just felt very uncertain about him. I think it was Dolby. And reading through Rune's post here, I think the source of that is how Evan seemed to take a stance against FireNinja and yet he said something very against the vibe that he was building into a campaign against FireNinja: he mentioned that FireNinja didn't play like this when they were both mafia together and doesn't see him making a sudden vote and clinging to it reflects his meta. So all in all it feels wishywashy. Interestingly both he and FireNinja aligned on voting Ryumia.

its probably bc i was much more sure about it before and commited to doing it, then when i read over everything i became less sure in my read. i definitely still think hes scum rn, but i can see how he could be just a town doing some really questionable things, maybe even a tp connected to gig in some way. idk im just really unsure, im still glad i did it tho

 

[Geoni]

Even though you like it Rune, I actually kinda dislike Evan's point about glow, if only because it seems like a repeat of what I already said. Not that I don't appreciate someone finally looking at glow other than Dolby.

- - - Post Merge - - -

its probably bc i was much more sure about it before and commited to doing it, then when i read over everything i became less sure in my read. i definitely still think hes scum rn, but i can see how he could be just a town doing some really questionable things, maybe even a tp connected to gig in some way. idk im just really unsure, im still glad i did it tho

I feel like Evan is one of those people whose color will be more obvious once certain people flip.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also his disagreement with my read of Toads vs Ness was interesting in that he seemed to point out that Ness was self-contradictory when it came to Punchy but sided with Ness in that exchange just because it seemed like he was winning it and Toad's points were pushy?

- - - Post Merge - - -

But yeah I will be curious to see his response to your case.

 

[dedenne]

I played so bad this game, I never had the time.

And @toads I didn't mean lynch, I voted myself. remember last game lol. or whatever game it was

 

[illunie]

I played so bad this game, I never had the time.

And @toads I didn't mean lynch, I voted myself. remember last game lol. or whatever game it was

hey dont beat urself up, everyone has irl things to take care of sometimes

 

[Geoni]

Looking back at Mog and I am starting to townread her a little less. Not a scumread just yet but I don't like how she was suddenly active near the end of day when a convenient lynch was on the table. Out of the people who voted Dedenne she bothers me the most but also I recall her being kinda coasty when killing TP in RHOM.

Recollecting my thoughts on 23 players is a headache.

 

[EpicGamer12]

I'm going to have to catch up after work, I can't just stare at the thread all day. See y'all in 8ish hours

 

[PunchyTheCat]

Ugh hold on I think Rune is town, can't reread his ISO yet

 

[Antonio]

I'll like to point out that I have been super depressed in the last few days and hasn't been in the mood to do much. I have been crying and could really need a hug. I didn't expect this to happen so I apologize for my lack of posting. Anyways, I am currently at page 18 (I can catch up, relax) and I realized that people are calling me out due to me saying I would state my opinion after school. It's passed after school. Again, I'm sorry! I'm not trying to go under the radar or not post anything because I'm scared. I'm aware of how people think inactives are mafia and I'm smart enough to carefully word my statements or choose my actions to not seem like mafia.

That being said, I'll try to post my scum reads during 2ND-3RD period. If you have questions, feel free to ask me. Thx. :/

P.S. My homepage is the forums.

 

[glow]

scumread me harder daddy

since when does hayden post so srs

 

[Kamzitty]

I'm going through all the pages last night rn. Just wanna say, some of you guys made me feel like absolute **** about the mislynch. It was day 1 and there are A LOT of people to keep track of.. idk if you guys expect to get a perfect lynch everyday or what, but that seems hella unreasonable to me and this is my first game so please cut me some slack. If all mafia games are like this, where we call people stupid etc for making mistakes, then I don't want to be a part of it. I expected everyone to come together as a team to discuss the mislynch and what we could have done better, rather than make others feel bad purposefully.
I would like to address the whole "sheeping"/bandwagon thing that multiple people called the lynch last night.
First off.. only 4 people voted dedenne, how is that a bandwagon? Isn't a bandwagon where a TON of people all agree to the same thing because it's the easiest?? Most people didn't switch their vote to dedenne and went with their own opinions, and I respect that. But I had my own reason to vote dedenne,which I posted and will put again below.
I'm not sure what sheeping is exactly, but it sounds like following along with what other people are doing, similar to bandwagoning. If so I would like to ask why people assume I was doing that?? I was the first person to call out dedenne for being sus, and she immediately defended herself but still never posted any reads like she promised so I found that uber sus. I didn't even realize other people were voting for her because I placed my vote based off that fact since time was running out, and I had to go and make dinner.
Just needed to get that out,because reading those posts from last night honestly hurt and I really am trying my best. I just feel like some of you guys were kinda harsh. I'm going to finish going through the pages now and try to post something of actual importance.
Also @antonio thank you for the update and I hope you're ok.

 

[glow]

it's ok Kam ur honestly obv town

did someone sus u? i will devour them

 

[Kamzitty]

scumread me harder daddy

since when does hayden post so srs

it's ok Kam ur honestly obv town

did someone sus u? i will devour them

LMAO no if somebody sussed me I would defend myself,, it just irked me how some people reacted to the mislynch last night. ;/ Like, I'm just as disappointed as everybody else, but I don't think it's ok to say it was stupid lol.

 

[N e s s]

LMAO no if somebody sussed me I would defend myself,, it just irked me how some people reacted to the mislynch last night. ;/ Like, I'm just as disappointed as everybody else, but I don't think it's ok to say it was stupid lol.

"Some people"

Sorry I upset you but I hold true to the fact it was a dumb lynch, it isn't anything against you as a person nor do I think you were the sole reason for the lynch. The entire player list was split on votes and I personally think that everyone who was on the Dedenne lynch is townish.

 

[Kamzitty]

"Some people"

Sorry I upset you but I hold true to the fact it was a dumb lynch, it isn't anything against you as a person nor do I think you were the sole reason for the lynch. The entire player list was split on votes and I personally think that everyone who was on the Dedenne lynch is townish.

Although you weren't the only person who acted like the dedenne lynch was dumb, the "I don't think it's ok to say it was stupid" comment was referring to your posts yes lol.
I'm not necessarily upset I just found that an odd way for people to react because I thought the game of mafia was a learning experience, and bashing on people's lynch choices just doesn't seem right. Ig I was just expecting some reflective discussion rather than comments like 'ya that was dumb. this game sux. ugh bandwagons!!!' etc
But what's done is done and I'm ready to move on

I found rune's iso on Evan very interesting and rune made some good points, such as how Evan has contradicted himself several times. I would like to hear a defense/explanation from him tho cus I'm still unsure if all that makes him scum or not, because I know I've contradicted myself at times as well because opinions can change.

 

[iLoveYou]

A few posts caught my eye:

so can we vote dedenne since they softclaimed VT or mafia

- - - Post Merge - - -

or jester

Doesn't VT stand for Veteran ? Why would you want to lynch a potential Veteran in this game ? They're here to absorb mafia hits.

If VT does in fact still stand for Veteran, then I think the people who bandwagoned onto Dedenne2 thought they could take the opportunity to get a potential Veteran out of the game. Assuming they jumped on Glow's comment here.

Very shocked to see she flipped town, especially since no one was defending her when the lynch was on her for more than an hour!!

How did you expect anyone to defend Dedenne2 when there were no solid leads on her at the time ?

B makes no sense, why would mafia push the lynch somewhere else when they knew killing Dedenne was ok

- - - Post Merge - - -

pushing the lynch anywhere would just bring attention to them

One reason they would do this is to cover their tracks for the future would she flip Town. Either they didn't vote ( which I don't believe ) or they voted strategically. I think it's highly unlikely to assume that the entire mafia team would vote one way on the Day One lynch.

About amazonevan19:

Something that I need to bring up again is the fact that he chose to call me out for repetition rather than those constantly repeating Dolby's arguments for content. How can you call out one, but not the others ? It didn't make sense for any of them to be re-hashing the "donuts lynch inactives" arguments considering how past it we already were. So why did you choose to call me out when I was simply responding to what was being put out there by those players who couldn't find anything else to provide to the discussion other than that seemingly pro-Town stance behind a deemed "leaning Town" player ?

Looking back at Mog and I am starting to townread her a little less. Not a scumread just yet but I don't like how she was suddenly active near the end of day when a convenient lynch was on the table. Out of the people who voted Dedenne she bothers me the most but also I recall her being kinda coasty when killing TP in RHOM.

Recollecting my thoughts on 23 players is a headache.

I agree with you very much here, Dad. mogyay is bandwagoning all kinds. I feel like she is looking for moments in this game where she can blend in the most. I'm not comfortable leaning Town on her at all.

Gigglabesh took the time to vote. To me that is alarming. This player is not invested in this game at all in terms discussion, yet they want to stay alive ( not modkilled ) by voting. If other players didn't even bother voting but Gigglabesh did, then there must be a reason. If this continues, this player will slide to the end. I'm hoping that no one will let this player fall under peoples' radars. This player is way too suspicious and the fact that they so easily came here just to vote Antonio

I'm at work so please be patient with me

 

[PunchyTheCat]

VT=Vanilla Townie VT= me

 

[Kamzitty]

"Doesn't VT stand for Veteran ? Why would you want to lynch a potential Veteran in this game ? They're here to absorb mafia hits.

If VT does in fact still stand for Veteran, then I think the people who bandwagoned onto Dedenne2 thought they could take the opportunity to get a potential Veteran out of the game. Assuming they jumped on Glow's comment here."

Just wanna point out that glow posted that comment after I had already put my vote in,and I believe punchy and mog put their vote in before i did, so it wouldn't be possible for anyone to vote based off of Glow's comment. (and tbh I dont see how dedenne soft claimed any of those things so Glow's post doesn't even make sense to me)

 

[PunchyTheCat]

"Doesn't VT stand for Veteran ? Why would you want to lynch a potential Veteran in this game ? They're here to absorb mafia hits.

If VT does in fact still stand for Veteran, then I think the people who bandwagoned onto Dedenne2 thought they could take the opportunity to get a potential Veteran out of the game. Assuming they jumped on Glow's comment here."

Just wanna point out that glow posted that comment after I had already put my vote in,and I believe punchy and mog put their vote in before i did, so it wouldn't be possible for anyone to vote based off of Glow's comment. (and tbh I dont see how dedenne soft claimed any of those things so Glow's post doesn't even make sense to me)

it means Vanilla Townie, what dedenne's role was.

 

[iLoveYou]

"Doesn't VT stand for Veteran ? Why would you want to lynch a potential Veteran in this game ? They're here to absorb mafia hits.

If VT does in fact still stand for Veteran, then I think the people who bandwagoned onto Dedenne2 thought they could take the opportunity to get a potential Veteran out of the game. Assuming they jumped on Glow's comment here."

Just wanna point out that glow posted that comment after I had already put my vote in,and I believe punchy and mog put their vote in before i did, so it wouldn't be possible for anyone to vote based off of Glow's comment. (and tbh I dont see how dedenne soft claimed any of those things so Glow's post doesn't even make sense to me)

Ya please disregard that part of my post because I thought VT was veteran. Apparently it's Vanilla Townie.